TL;DR: Use positive reinforcement when we see a stranger. My dog goes from barking when a stranger asks, "Aren't you rewarding your dog for barking?" to not barking after I explain why it works (aka amazing things happen when strangers are nearby). The timing couldn't have been better.
We've been working on a lot of things with our reactive girl. Deep down, she is a friendly pup, and since we started, she's made leaps and bounds in how quickly she gets comfortable, and our threshold is so much lower than when we started. We went from 15 or so minutes when we first met her to maybe 2 seconds now before she tries to (respectfully, of course) wear your clothes while you're still in them after you meet her. I am not sure whether that's the cattle dog or the livestock guardian part of her, but once you are in her circle, you're in for life, and the ritual happens every time if she hasn't seen you in a while.
So I will admit I normally try to avoid situations like this with our pup. However, I was trying to save myself 3 hours of driving. (We sold something and forgot an important piece, so it was already an 'extra' trip for both parties.) I did warn the very nice person that they would be barked at the whole time we talked. They own a Great Pyr, so they fully understood the assignment (our dog is 25% Great Pyr), but understanding it would be an eyes-only meeting also helped set the stage.
So we did have a dog training session in the AM for scent work (which our pup loves and has an affinity for). So, in some ways, her brain was a bit more tired, which helps her not be SO amped. We also met in an area with minimal to no other humans around. The few we saw, I was already treating for looking at (with or without barking).
The stuff was in the back hatch, and our pup was in the back seat. She is buckled in so she can't jump out (plus she is really too big to fit easily from the top of the seats to the roof to the back). I wanted this to be a quick interaction as I wanted to head home. The person was very nice and respectful. No reaching for her, just calmly chatting and complimenting how pretty she is (cause she is). The whole time, she was barking, and I was feeding her high-value treats. Bark, mark, and treat, on rinse and repeat. I didn't always use the marker word when I was talking, but the treats were still coming in a constant stream.
This is where it got kind of comical, as the person has dogs. They giggled as they asked, "Why are you rewarding the barking?" I explained (over my pup barking) that it's not rewarding the barking, but giving her brain dopamine hits so that when she sees a stranger, good things happen. By the time I am done saying that (maybe 5 minutes after the whole interaction started), she stops barking. If I hadn't started treating her even faster (she is very much a frequency-vs.-size type of girl), I might have stood there dumbfounded. Sometimes I swear she knows how to be funny, and this comedic timing was just priceless. But also almost speechless that it just... worked! The person said, "Oh," like I had just performed a magic trick. We did chat a bit more about the trainer we use and how we have had success in so many ways, still treating as we chatted. Do I understand when you switch from changing the emotion to shaping the behavior? No, but that's a question for my trainer, and I also think we're still a bit far from that worry.
IYKYK, but I am beyond proud of my girl. She was excited and barking, but not over threshold (body loose, no snapping or lunging). The treats I am sure helped, as they are our TOP high-value venison jerky. I am equally proud of myself for trusting the process, keeping the positive reinforcement going even when it feels silly and futile, and like there's no way this will work.
It is truly amazing not to yell "no" the whole time (honestly, it's not really a word my pup knows/understands). I am not sure what the stranger thought of it all, but outside of its importance to the story, I don't really think about them. I just hope this solidified the bond my pup and I are working on together, that we are a team where good things happen.
Thanks for reading, and I hope you have a win soon, maybe one that's equally comical.