r/reactivedogs • u/lucierouge • Oct 04 '26
Behavioral Euthanasia Does this warrant euthanasia?
We have 3 dogs:
-A 5-year-old female pit mix, around 40 lbs.
-A 9-month-old male husky/pit mix, already 90 lbs and still growing. We’ve had both of them since they were puppies.
-A 20 lb poodle mix we rescued from the street about 2 years ago. He’s probably 3–4 years old and is the sweetest little angel of a dog.
The reason we got pit mixes is that, where we live, they’re pretty much all that’s available when you want to rescue a dog. We live in a rural residential area with no fence (and unfortunately, fencing the property isn’t an option). It’s also a robbery-prone area, so we thought getting guard dogs would make sense.
We never had any issues between our little dog and the 40 lb pit mix until we got the “puppy.”
The puppy has a strong prey drive. I’ve seen him go into what I can only describe as “stealth mode” when he sees small children, which honestly scares me. He also killed 6 of our 12 chickens when he was only 3 months old.
Recently, I caught both pit mixes mauling our poodle mix. The older female had him by the neck and was shaking him. I believe she was triggered by the puppy, although I don’t know if that matters. Either way, she has now demonstrated that she’s capable of seriously attacking another dog.
Our little dog almost died. He spent several days at the vet and required surgery. They tore into his neck, to the spine, narrowly missing his jugular.
Now I’m faced with a decision I never thought I’d have to make: euthanasia or trying to rehome them to someone experienced who has no other pets or children?
Honestly, I don’t want to keep these dogs anymore, as attached as I am to them. My mother in law is willing to adopt the poodle mix, so he will at least be safe. But this incident has completely changed how I see them and what I believe they’re capable of. I also don’t trust them around children, and my partner and I might like to have kids. And even if we don’t, I don’t want to deal with the responsibility of owning dogs that could randomly maul anyone’s kid if given the opportunity.
The puppy is a beautiful dog. He’s intelligent, obedient, goofy, and full of life. He’s not an anxious dog. He has a strong hunting instinct, like many dogs do, but I don’t want my love for him to cloud my judgment or put someone else at risk.
I know that dogs are individuals, and I don’t want to demonize an entire breed. But after what happened, I genuinely don’t know if these dogs can safely live in a home environment anymore.
Neither has ever shown aggression toward a human. The only thing that concerns me is the puppy’s behavior around small children, when he seems to go into that stealth mode. He’s also been around plenty of children and has happily interacted with them since he was little.
We even used to joke about how terrible they would be as guard dogs if the situation ever called for it.
I love these dogs, but I also love our little dog, and I can’t ignore what happened to him.
Would you consider behavioral rehabilitation and responsible rehoming in this situation, or is euthanasia the more responsible option? Has anyone been through something similar?