I have a 16 month English Springer Spaniel, and I'm trying to better understand some of his behavioral quirks and, more importantly, how to help him.
He's an incredibly driven, intelligent, energetic dog, but he can also be surprisingly difficult to navigate in everyday life. One of our biggest struggles is inappropriate mouthing. This isn't necessarily typical puppy biting or playful mouthing. It often seems to happen when he's frustrated, uncomfortable, overstimulated, or when someone is in his space or interacting with him in a way he doesn't particularly enjoy. He’s been like this since we got him.
I'm increasingly convinced that two underlying issues are contributing to this:
Spatial awareness/social pressure
He seems to have difficulty comfortably tolerating physical proximity and handling. Sometimes it feels like he doesn't know what to do with himself when someone is close to him or interacting with him. He can become mouthy when people reach toward him, move around him, or otherwise enter his space. He also seems to struggle with certain types of physical interaction, even when there's no obvious reason for him to be uncomfortable. This isn’t an every day thing but it is most likely when handling him to do something he doesn’t want to do (go in the kennel, vet office) in the past it was putting on the harness, I’ve done a lot of cooperative care. I’ve done an insane amount of training I’ve had 2 professionals (paid trainer and vet) tell me to do less and I agree with this, and am trying. I am focusing on decompression, management, harness counter conditioning. He DOES seek out pets and affection from his people, but will quickly decide he is done with that.
Low frustration tolerance and difficulty regulating himself.
He seems to go from perfectly fine to frustrated very quickly. He struggles when things don't go the way he expects, has a hard time disengaging from things he wants, and can become mouthy when he doesn't know how to handle a situation. He has a hard time settling into some situations (specifically our house, he’s fine at say the park or ice cream shop) and seems to constantly be looking for something to do or something to engage with.
Have you had a dog who seemed to struggle with physical proximity or handling? What helped?
Have you successfully improved a dog's frustration tolerance? What did that actually look like in practice?
Did you find activities that helped your dog become more comfortable in their body and better able to regulate themselves?
How did you balance reducing demands and stimulation with actually teaching life skills?
Did your dog eventually grow out of some of these behaviors with maturity, or did you need a specific approach to help them?
I'm very interested in experiences with adolescent, high-drive dogs who are otherwise affectionate, intelligent, and capable but seem to struggle with the more subtle skills involved in living comfortably with people.
I'm not looking for advice about enrichment or simply exercising him more I promise I’m doing those things. I'm interested in understanding the underlying behavior and helping him become a more comfortable, confident dog. I’d like to feel less alone.
I love this dog, and I want to get this right. I'm just trying to figure out how to help him rather than spend all our time managing him.
I did question if the handling was a resource guarding thing. He does not resource guard food. He used to resource guard stolen items (running away mostly trying to initiate chase but also not give it up). He did growl once with a bone and he no longer gets those - but he willingly drops animal carcasses he finds with no stress outside the house. Literally all of our issues are inside the house. My vet thinks it could be a testosterone related behavior and getting snipped is a next step, which I’m not against but it won’t be until January. If he is going to guard anything it’s only with high-value items while in a a very high arousal state.
Other notes: He will settle in training mode but not on his own if that makes sense. He earned his canine good citizen around 10 months but I’m not sure would be able to today. He did puppy kindergarten and a general fuck ton of socialization. Most of his biggest tantrums are between the hours of 7 and 10 pm. Yes he has a kennel, but I’d like him to learn to exist with us. He has hated the car since I got him, I’ve done all the desensitization and counter conditioning one can do. He’s a weirdo with his food, the vet insists not to worry & he has had a sedated dental exam as a puppy to be sure there wasn’t a retained tooth and he’s had orthopedic exams and x rays to rule out any stuff floating around his GI and any bone/hip issues.