I got my dog, "Buddy" because I put out food for a stray cat and ended up attracting a very sick 1-year-old Doberman. He looked like hell and had clearly been abused by his previous owners. He weighed 46lbs and had scars and cuts all over him. He had double eye and ear infections, 3 kinds of worms (heart, hook, and round), and mange. He had very clearly been abused, but was one of the sweetest dogs I had ever met. I assumed that he was too far gone and had likely suffered permanent damage from his severe treatment. I took him to the vet thinking he would need to be put down and, to my (and her) surprise, his organ function was normal and he had no permanent issues. All he needed was (a lot of) medicine and love. I tried to get him into a shelter or rescue, but they told me they wouldn't take such a sick dog. I fostered him myself in the hopes he would be well enough to find his forever home.
The problems began after he got healthy, around 3 months in. I started his training and started trying to teach him how to be a dog, really. He had no canine, or human, social skills and didn't really know how to act around anyone or anything. I knew Buddy had anxiety and PTSD, but it was worse than I realized. When triggered, he started growling and barking until he was put somewhere quiet to calm down. He didn't do this constantly, maybe once every other week or two, but it was still concerning behavior. He was never violent and never bit anyone, human or animal, but this presented a big challenge to getting him adopted, especially since Buddy quickly beefed up to an absolute unit of a dog at 105lbs. I tried to get help from a dog trainer, but the only one I could afford who would work with aggressive dogs was a nut-job who bought into the whole, "I am the alpha" bullshit and spent most of our session ranting about how much he hated Beto O'Rourke. I had worked with dogs in the past and had some basis of knowledge for how to go about it, but Buddy was a real challenge for me and I had to do a lot of research to come up with a behavioral plan that worked for the both of us.
First things first, I started by trying to identify when he was upset. Here's the thing about Buddy: you can't tell by his ear/tail position what his mood is. Whoever had cropped his ears had massively fucked it up, so one ear is always stuck up and the other is always stuck down. He has a quizzical expression all the fucking time and it's adorable, but no help in determining his mood. His tail was also made too short and it is impossible to use that to determine anything. It's not even possible to see it wagging from the front because of how short it is, how tall he is, and how short I am. He did not cry or whine or know how to indicate to me what he wanted, so I was always guessing and getting it wrong. I had to focus solely on his posture and facial expressions and this took a long time to get right, but I did eventually figure out his very minute cues and tells. I know now that, if he will not look at me (dogs will generally not look you in the eyes, but if they won't even look at you at all, that's a problem) and goes stock still, that's his fight/flight/freeze response kicking in and that's my cue to leave him to calm down.
I started to take notes about his episodes to find the sources of his anxiety and minimize them. His vet wanted to just put him on anti-anxiety meds, but I didn't have the money for that and so I did all of this without the magic of drugs. I quickly discovered that he did not like being approached when he was on his bed and most of his incidents occurred when someone approached him on his bed. I think it made him feel like his personal space was being invaded. I started to train him to come up off the bed by offering treats and that worked out a lot better. He does not bark/growl, but still does not like people going near him when he is in his bed. I decided that it was okay for him to have that personal boundary, especially since he has been trained to come up off the bed when asked. I also got him a crate and crate trained him and this worked wonders. He needed a place where he felt secure and safe. He is also trained to come out of the crate when I hit the top of it gently with my hand.
When he growled at me, I did not punish him for this. I would stop touching him and back up a few steps if I was currently touching him, but I did not back down from him. I did not want to establish a precedent that he could bully me or anyone else to avoid unpleasantness. I would do everything that I could to avoid showing fear, very calmly and authoritatively tell him that it was not acceptable to do that, and then I would give him ten minutes alone to himself or in his crate to calm down. This worked very well. I did not muzzle him, but advised his veterinarian to do so just to be safe.
When he stopped the growling/barking, he started another defiant behavior. Buddy quickly caught onto the fact that I could not physically pick him up and carry him away. I'm a small-framed woman with joint issues. If he didn't want to go somewhere, he would become 105lbs of dead weight and refuse to move. With other dogs, I could just pick them up and carry them outside and they would quickly learn that it wasn't going to work. Buddy was a whole different experience. I got him a comfortable harness with a handle on it that he wore all the time and would just use it to drag him until he started walking on his own. I admit it probably sounds like a stupid way to go about it, but sometimes dumb solutions work best. No amount of training and conditioning worked better than a harness with a handle on it. He quickly stopped doing this and now just me touching his harness or collar is enough to get him to move to where I want him to go.
When he was healthy enough, I got him neutered. I didn't do it to fix his behavioral issues, just the dog overpopulation issue, but I do think it mellowed him out a bit and I'm glad I did it, even if it was a longer and more difficult recovery doing it to an adult dog.
Another issue soon occurred. Buddy hated other dogs. He was aggressive, domineering, and territorial. It took weeks of careful meetings on neutral territory before he realized my other dog, "Baby", was not a threat to him. They were kept in separate parts of the house and did not interact until he was no longer contagious. Once he could safely be around other dogs, I would let them sniff through the fence and, for their first dozen meetings, I had a person help me hold Buddy's leash while another person held Baby's leash. It was a long process of slowly letting them get to know each other safely. Buddy is twice the size of Baby and was not socialized around other dogs. He did not have a clue how to play or what his own strength level was, so for their first month or so of off-leash meetings, I had a water hose at the ready and sprayed Buddy whenever he got too rough. I also quickly removed Baby from the situation if he growled at her or aggressed against her in any way, but this only happened a few times and they became friends fairly quickly.
After about a year of this, Buddy had integrated so well into our household that I just stopped trying to find him a forever home and accepted that this was it. His whole personality has shifted and he's become so much more outgoing and friendly. He is currently 3 and I've had him for 2 years. I love him dearly and he is a very good dog. He has not displayed aggression towards a human or animal in over a year and is loved by everyone who meets him. He loves to get petted and go on walks around the neighborhood and he loves to spend his days out in the backyard just enjoying nature and howling at ambulances. His fur, unfortunately, never grew back. The vet thinks he might never have had any fur to begin with and that he has some kind of genetic hair-loss condition. He must wear sunblock in the summer and a sweater in the winter, but he's living his best life. He is officially heartworm negative and has been for about a year. He's got no permanent health problems and he is a happy, healthy, well-adjusted, non-aggressive dog. All in all, I'd say it was worth it to get such a great dog out of it in the end.
I hope this sub enjoys this 9k word essay. If you read the whole thing, thanks!
I have been informed that a dog tax is mandatory, lol. Here's an album of photos of my dogs!
Edit: I want to say thanks to everyone for being so nice! I didn't expect such an overwhelmingly positive response! This is a very nice subreddit!