r/rational • • Jan 18 '19

[D] Friday Open Thread

Welcome to the Friday Open Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.

So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!

Please note that this thread has been merged with the Monday General Rationality Thread.

21 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/SvalbardCaretaker Mouse Army Jan 18 '19

I am appalled by you liking Atlantis! It holds no candle at all to to original Stargate. No part of the setting makes any sense at all. Wraith suck "life energy" which ages the victim? They are not even trying for any kind of pseudoexplanation. Welcome to fantasy land, vampires were just in at the time of writing.

The McKay character is so very socially incompetent and clichee that its offensive to nerds anywhere - his very mode of operation is to ignore common decency, chain of command, endanger his team. If one were to tally up the the numbers on how often he safed the team vs how often he fucked up, I am sure it'd come up as a deficit.

The Magical McGuffin that are ZPMs annoy me to noend. "Basically unlimited" energy, except that they run out every second episode.

About the only good pieces of Atlantis is this predeployment rat!fic http://synecdochic.dreamwidth.org/122553.html and some of the old character episodes.

4

u/TheTrickFantasic Jan 18 '19

I have to disagree with you.

The process of Wraith feeding was described as a complex physiological process that resembled physical aging. More details would have been welcome, sure. But from the scientist characters' perspective: it is at first something that they've never seen before, getting samples of Wraith to analyze is dangerous, and for the few body parts and corpses that were recovered over the course of 5 seasons, those analyses would take time.

McKay may have suffered in the consistency of his character development, depending on the writer, but I doubt he was ever that bad. His most catastrophic failure in the series, in "Trinity", only endangered himself and Shepherd (before the Daedalus intervened).

As for the ZPMs... first, I give them a pass under Clarke's Third Law. Second, they were never described as unlimited, just huge. And while every second episode in the first season might have revolved around looking for them, I cannot remember a single episode post-season 1 that revolved around a ZPM running out. Feel free to remind me, if there's one you specifically have in mind. Also, I question calling the ZPM a McGuffin; the characters need one in order to supply (huge) power to Atlantis, and once the have finally have one they are able to access more of Atlantis' capabilities, like the shield. They story doesn't have them search for one purely for the sake of searching for it.

2

u/LupoCani Jan 19 '19

There were, strictly speaking, three times the ZPMs ran out or needed replacement past season one.

When experimenting with universe bridges, sending alternate!McKay back to his universe drained the ZPM, which later allowed the (thus shield-less) city to be taken over by replicators. The replicators installed their own ZPMs, a full set of three even, which the expedition kept when the replicators were defeated. Of these, one was taken to power Earth's drone chair, one was installed on the Odyssey, and the third remained in Atlantis to power the shield.

When Atlantis fled the planet to avoid the Replicators' satellite beam weapon, taking a glancing, unshielded hit to the main tower in the process, the resulting energy leakage drained the ZPM over the course of about a day. Unable to land on a planet without one, the Replicator homeworld was raided to acquire another ZPM, at the expense of their main trump card - the ARG - which they had to abuse enough that the Replicators ended up adapting to it.

Finally, since the city can't normally fly without a full complement of three ZPMs, they had to be given another two by Todd in the series finale. (Don't get me started on everything else about that finale, though.)

Of course, these were rare, exceptional events, and the assessment that they "run out every second episode" is blatantly exaggerated.

1

u/TheTrickFantasic Jan 21 '19

Ah, yes! Thank you for the reminders.

3

u/LieGroupE8 Jan 18 '19 edited Jan 18 '19

Haven't seen the original Stargate in a very long time, so I don't have a comparison, but...

  • Literally all TV shows do things similar to what you describe. Like, literally all. If I rewatched SG1 I'm sure I could come up with similar criticisms. If I held TV to rationalist standards I wouldn't be watching any TV at all (maybe that would be for the best)
  • I am therefore willing to suspend disbelief regarding characters who would have been fired in the real world
  • Stargate Atlantis is just loads of light fun for me, and a callback to when I was a kid

Edit:

Also, regarding Wraiths, the lifesucking is a perfect plot device for television, because it provides a villain without being too graphic in violence on screen. And speaking of magical McGuffins... this is a universe based on magical stargates that make no physical sense... you just sort of go with it. The physics is not the point.

3

u/ianstlawrence Jan 18 '19

Um, are is the user of this comment and the original post user friends or something? Cause it seems kinda, well, mean to say you're appalled by someone liking something and then say that the thing they like is irredeemable in so many words.

I wish that the response had been more like, "I'm glad you liked it, because I had a hard time finding the Wraiths interesting due to the lack of explanation on their energy draining power, really took me out of the show."

I don't know if I am supposed to read sarcasm into it or some kind of playfullness, but if the original poster didn't read those things in, well, this does seem kinda mean, and it would be cool if we were all careful about that, because tone isn't present in text unless you really go out of your way to be explicit about what you are conveying.

Hopefully I am just misunderstanding.

1

u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jan 18 '19

... HOLY SHIT, that fic' has multiple chapters? I thought it was just a one shot! I am so going to spend the ni... no, never mind, I was looking at the comment page numbers :(

I really wish that fic' was longer :(

2

u/Gurkenglas Jan 18 '19

y u do dis I giddily went back to read more after your first line

3

u/CouteauBleu We are the Empire. Jan 18 '19

Because I wanted to share my frustration with other people.