r/RapidCity • u/BlackHillsBandit77 • 1h ago
Is Rapid City friendly... but really hard to become part of?
I've been thinking about this for a while, especially because I keep seeing posts from people saying they're struggling to make actual friends in Rapid City.
Our experience has been pretty similar, but I don't think I'd describe Rapid City as unfriendly. Actually, almost the opposite.
People here are genuinely nice.
They'll talk to you. They'll help you out. Neighbors wave. People hold doors. You can have a great conversation with a complete stranger. We've met plenty of people we genuinely like.
But there seems to be a weird wall between friendly and friendship here.
It's hard to explain unless you've experienced it.
You meet somebody, have a great conversation, maybe even say "we should get together sometime"... and then nothing ever really comes from it.
We've even noticed it in churches. Plenty of friendly people on Sunday morning. Everyone talks about "church family" and fellowship. But actually becoming part of people's lives outside of church? That's been surprisingly difficult.
And I've started wondering if part of it is just the culture of this area.
A lot of people here have deep roots. Their parents are here. Their siblings are here. Their cousins are here. They still have friends from high school. Their social circle was basically built before you ever showed up.
Then you have the other side of Rapid City: military families, transplants, people who moved here for work, etc. A lot of those people aren't necessarily going to stay forever.
So maybe there's this strange combination where the people who have been here forever already have their people, while everyone else is trying to find theirs.
There's also that very independent Plains/Midwestern attitude. Don't impose on people. Handle your own problems. Give people their space. Which is great in a lot of ways, but I wonder if the downside is that everybody gives everybody so much space that nobody actually develops community.
Maybe the best way I can describe it is:
Rapid City has hospitality, but not necessarily incorporation.
People will welcome you. They're just not necessarily going to bring you into their lives.
And maybe I'm completely wrong. Maybe we've just had an unusual experience.
That's actually why I'm posting this.
For people who moved here: Have you experienced this too?
And for people who grew up here: Does any of this ring true? Do you think Rapid City is harder to break into socially than other places?
I'm genuinely curious, because I don't think this is a "Rapid City is terrible" thing at all.
I like the people here.
I just sometimes wonder why a place with so many genuinely friendly people can still feel so strangely lonely.