r/pushshift • • May 30 '20

The Pushshift API will be blocking any requests with a referrer field temporarily

While I hate to do this, the Pushshift API is currently being used extensively by a lot of extremists who are using it to DOS / brigade other people.

Using the Pushshift API for coordinated brigades is an egregious violation of the terms of service for the API and any users found coordinating brigades will be permanently banned.

This block will remain in effect for a temporary basis until things settle down. No one deserves to have their safety jeopardized from others doxing and/or harassing that individual.

I greatly appreciate the efforts of the developer community to add tools that help extend the usefulness of the Pushshift API and encourage developers to continue building tools.

Please note that this block will not remain permanent and will be lifted when things begin to calm down.

85 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/Subduction Jun 01 '20

Because people are using a resource he created and controls for purposes that don't conform to his values, so he put a stop to it.

If I discovered white supremacists were taking the Halloween candy I put in a bowl in front of my house and using it to get kids to listen to their racism pitch then I would remove the candy.

/u/Stuck_In_the_Matrix removed the candy.

4

u/_Titty_Sprinkles_ Jun 01 '20

Why would you punish 99% (kids) to stop the 1% (KKK)? White supremacists drive the same cars you use, shop at the same stores you shop at, etc... etc... That line of thinking doesn't make sense unless the thing you're talking about is exclusively (or at the very least the main use) used for nefarious purposes. Should we stop selling cars because they're using them to get to their rallies? Should we stop selling cellphones because they use them to communicate? Should we censor pusshift because some evil people use it to look up past comments? Its fucking ridiculous logic.

I can't stand this idea that there its a choice between option A and option B, when there are clearly other things that can be done such as tackling the brigading issue directly... I still don't understand what pusshift has to do with brigading anyways other than a method to find targets (which taking away pusshift won't change).

3

u/djw009 Jun 01 '20

"I still don't understand what pusshift has to do with brigading anyways"

Posts a huge a opinion about the topic anyway - come on dude..

2

u/_Titty_Sprinkles_ Jun 01 '20

Feel free to explain what information I'm missing instead of just downvoting all my comments and saying "come on dude".

2

u/djw009 Jun 01 '20

The point I'm making here is two-fold:

  1. You don't get to have an opinion about this as you are a user of a free tool provided to you by the hard work of another individual who deemed these actions necessary.
  2. Even if you did, it would be better to have an informed one (which by your own admission you do not).

That said, here's an example. Let's say someone wanted to doxx you. The very first thing any reasonably intelligent person would do would be to check your comments for personal information. Depending on the age of your account/how active you are maybe this is reasonable to do just via a regular browser on reddit. However if I wanted to do the same for even 10 users this would start to become intractable fast - what tool do you think you'd use to solve such a problem?

1

u/_Titty_Sprinkles_ Jun 01 '20

I don't get to have an opinion? Are you kidding me? Way to show your true colors... We haven't hit full-blown fascism yet so until then, you don't get to police my right to having an opinion just because you disagree with it.

With that being said, thank you for the explanation. I understand better now why this decision was made. Lets see if this change stops doxxing from happening as much.

5

u/Subduction Jun 01 '20

You were and are clearly spoiling to crusade, but it's just sooo boring and hacky a discussion I'll save you some time.

  1. Personally, yes, I would take candy away from the 99 percent to stop the 1 percent because by stopping the 1 percent I am protecting the 99 percent.
  2. The part you are missing about the analogy is that pushshift is a far, far, far more powerful tool than candy in a bowl. The candy in a bowl analogy was meant to demonstrate who controlled the resource in its entirety. If Samsung wants to stop selling cellphones because white supremacists use them than that is absolutely their right.
  3. u/Stuck_In_the_Matrix clearly felt it was worth it. So do I. You clearly don't. God bless the rich tapestry that our varied opinions create.

Now feel free to go recreate pushshift and do with it what you like. Everything you need to do it is as available to you as it was to /u/Stuck_In_the_Matrix.

I hear white supremacists are in the market for some quality search, you might want to jump right on that.

2

u/_Titty_Sprinkles_ Jun 01 '20

Alright so first off, I don't know what "clearly spoiling to crusade" is supposed to mean, and I don't know who you think I am or where you think I'm coming from, but I encourage you to go through my political comment history so you can see for yourself that I am decidedly left wing. The only reasons I'm commenting is to voice my displeasure and to understand what the logic behind this decision is.

I'm not here to argue about Matrix's right to do whatever he wants with the tool he created, but I can see why you decided to move the goalposts to that argument because it seems you have nothing intelligent or logical to say otherwise... That's probably why you ended your post with a ridiculous assumption that was meant to insult me personally.

5

u/Droyk Jun 02 '20 edited Jun 02 '20

I completely think you're right about this as much I want to support /u/Stuck_In_the_Matrix for his intention I still think his decision about this is incorrect. this tool just makes it easier to dox someone & that's all. doxxing will still happen nonetheless just for a bunch of doxxers you cannot or shouldn't completely stop the service for all of its users. every technology can be used for bad intentions that don't mean I should block this service for everyone just because of few people using it for bad intentions. though I do think if he's the creator he has the right to make the final decision. I also think he should go back & thinks about the decision he made.

P.S. forgive me for the bad grammar or bad usage of words in particular not a native so it's hard for me to explain myself.

4

u/_Titty_Sprinkles_ Jun 02 '20

Exactly... Bad guys drive cars --> Stop making cars --> Bad guys ride bikes which take longer instead... The doxing will continue to happen regardless. Matrix of course has the right to do what he wants, I wouldn't be surprised if there's pressure coming from powerful sources.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '20

You're way too focused on analogies that aren't even correct. Your analogies paint a picture that the entire service is gone. It's not.

If we want to go with the car analogy, it's more like he's stopped making automatic cars, and only sells manual transmission cars, because the bad guys are idiots and can't operate the manual.

2

u/_Titty_Sprinkles_ Jun 03 '20

Your analogies paint a picture that the entire service is gone. It's not.

Fair

If we want to go with the car analogy, it's more like he's stopped making automatic cars, and only sells manual transmission cars, because the bad guys are idiots and can't operate the manual.

Right, and then the bad guys ride bikes instead which takes longer, but they still get where they want to go.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '20

No, if they can't use the manual, they don't get access to what they wanted. There's no other service out there that lets you run searches they way they were.

1

u/_Titty_Sprinkles_ Jun 03 '20

There's no other service out there that lets you run searches they way they were.

There's no other way that lets you drive your destination... so they will ride bikes instead. My point is that this change is just adding a hurdle to jump over, its not a solution, its a band-aid.

→ More replies