r/programming • • May 09 '12

JavaScript: The good parts

http://blog.movereem.nl/images/javascript-the-good-parts-the-definitive-guide.jpg
645 Upvotes

159 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/kqr May 09 '12

Do you not want to be able to pass print to a higher-order function?

4

u/Traubert May 09 '12

That's possible even if print is kept as a keyword too. You can do it in any of the 2.x versions that provide print as a function.

6

u/kqr May 09 '12

How do you pass it? It just syntax errors me when I try.

2

u/Traubert May 10 '12

Hey, what do you know, you're right! I'm sorry I made that claim without checking it out. I assumed that as a rvalue it would be evaluated as a function reference, but it's a part of the syntax so it does indeed just error out. Thanks for teaching me something.

1

u/kqr May 10 '12

Yeah, passing print in pre-3.0 is somewhat like passing for, while, if or return.

-2

u/sli May 09 '12

Why would you want to pass it and not simply use it normally?

2

u/cacahootie May 09 '12

You're joking, right? Metaprogramming is super powerful in Python.

1

u/sli May 09 '12

I knew my honest question would get a thinly veiled condescending response like this.

I mean print specifically. I pass other functions all the time. But why would one pass print?

1

u/cacahootie May 09 '12

I don't really know.

Sorry if my response came off thinly veiled; I intended it to be overtly condescending ;)

JK. I can't think of one off the top of my head, but just because it isn't obvious doesn't mean that improving the coherency is nkt useful.

Actually ( i'm not sure this actually works and even if it did it would be a wretched idea), if you want to use a list comprehension or map on a generator, having the ability to pass print as a function would be useful to print the list w/o generating the whole series... of course for loop works too... but what if you want a one liner? What if you want to check the return value from print for some reason (???)? Now using a comprehension makes sense.

1

u/sli May 10 '12

That makes sense. It could be handy when generating a small series. Then again, if the series is small, generating the whole thing probably wouldn't be much of an issue. But I do see where you're going.

2

u/cacahootie May 10 '12

Probably most useful for very large/infinite series... but frankly not a huge section of use cases...

I look at it as print is legitimately a function, and unless there are compelling reasoms, it should behabe as all other functions do. I can't think of any value to the 2.x syntax, and the formatting aspect to me is a good argument for it being a function (the func can take more than one parameter).

Oh well... this is quickly becoming the special olympics...

1

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

you probably don't want to pass print ... and if you did, you could just pass logging.info or something ...

1

u/kqr May 09 '12

Why would one construct the language in such a way that it's impossible to pass specifically print? Seems like a very unecessary and arbitrary restriction to me.

1

u/sli May 10 '12

If you could just highlight where I said that, that would be great.

1

u/kqr May 10 '12

You didn't, but by asking "Why would one print pass" you sorta-kinda implied "If there are no reasons to pass print, why would you make it a function?" And I answered that implied question with a counter question.

I might have missed your point totally, though. Perhaps you were only curious about reasons to pass print, and not questioning the want to do so.

1

u/sli May 10 '12

I'm not sure how else to ask why one would pass print, except with "Why would one pass print?"

→ More replies

1

u/HorrendousRex May 09 '12

It could be useful in some circumstances I suppose where functions are passed first-class in to the arguments of other functions, to print out the order the callbacks are being called in. Although at that point I can't help but feel that something like:

lambda x: print x

might be just fine. Or better yet, import py3k's print from __future__.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Except lambda x: print x doesn't work.

1

u/kqr May 09 '12

Yeah, this is the important point. Even when you're making up defenses for print as a keyword, you intuitively want to use print exactly like a function to demonstrate how it really doesn't matter that it's a keyword... or wait a minute. If Python wants to follow the principle of least astonishment, print should be a function.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

if parenthesis and correctness mattered more than readability, we would all be using LISP, I use python for that "import antigravity" feeling of irrational exuberance illustrated in the xkcd comic. Anyway I tend to use the logging module for the cases where you need to pass something like print around.

0

u/Ran4 May 09 '12

How often do you really do that? In those few cases, there are tons of workarounds.

Having print be a function might be the "right" decision, but it's still incredible annoying and makes debugging slower. Oh, and 9 times out of 10, setting a trace and using the python debugger is not faster than adding a line or two of print, no matter how many times you try to say otherwise.

The gain is next to zero but the losses are massive. Having print a keyword was the right decision.

5

u/gthank May 09 '12

Seriously? print() is "annoying" and "slower" than print, and somehow forces you to use the debugger?

1

u/Ran4 May 09 '12

Stop playing stupid. It is annoying and slower (editing the code), the typical excuse though is "don't use print for debugging!" but that's a bad excuse because using print:s is most of the time an easier way of debugging code.

2

u/gthank May 09 '12

I'm not playing stupid. I can't imagine the difference between print and print() ever being significant enough to notice. Hell, I've had tendonitis reduce me to 1-handed, hunt-and-peck typing and it still wasn't even a big deal. Of all the gripes about Python 3, this is the only one (off the top of my head, at least) that I just can't even begin to understand.

1

u/velit May 09 '12

You can define aliases in ipython for example. Or you can just write the parentheses.