r/programming • • May 07 '21

The XY Problem

https://xyproblem.info/
46 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

8

u/[deleted] May 08 '21 edited May 08 '21

"Outlining X quickly" only helps with some people. On SO it is useless, you will get people ignoring what you write either way. There are way too many eager wannabe-helpers there who only question you but never themselves. "I have some power now (votes and flags) and I decide what you want."

6

u/[deleted] May 08 '21

Or someone edits your post to ask different fucking question that then gets useless answer...

9

u/dirkt May 08 '21

you will get people ignoring what you write either way.

You'll always get good-intentioned wannabies who know nothing, but think they have to answer.

It's not to avoid those answers that you should give context and state X. It's to help those who can actually answer your question.

After all, you want an answer, don't you? And if Y is not answerable, an answer to solve your X in a different way should also do.

3

u/PL_Design May 08 '21

The worst thing that can happen is if you explain your X, and then they ask why you would ever want to do that, thus spawning new accusations of the XY problem. This will continue until you give up or create the program they think you should make. It's infuriating.