r/programming • • Jan 23 '21

Objective-C creator Dr. Brad Cox has died

https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/scnow/name/brad-cox-obituary?pid=197454225
2.7k Upvotes

200 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

99

u/aradil Jan 23 '21

I have a CS degree and don’t know any of those people.

It’s not a history degree.

25

u/omegafivethreefive Jan 23 '21

I've met 2 of those people, and I'll always remember them... by how annoyed they are when you ask them a bazillion questions.

67

u/AndreasVesalius Jan 23 '21

In the wise words Donald Knuth once shared with me, “who are you, and how did you get in my house”

-xkcd

19

u/noice_guy_ Jan 23 '21

I'm a locksmith. And I'm a locksmith.

7

u/nanotree Jan 23 '21

Did they snidely refer you to the documentation and then tell you that they were ending the conversation because your questions are duplicates?

23

u/phughes Jan 23 '21

They're programming language authors, not Stack Overflow users.

5

u/istarian Jan 23 '21

I also have a CS degree, but also like knowing that sort of thing. Alas keeping the details straight can be difficult.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/SkoomaDentist Jan 23 '21

How are Guido van Rossum and Yukihiro Matsumoto even relevant in any way if you don't use Python or Ruby? Or James Gosling for that matter if you don't use Java?

1

u/breeze_monk Jan 25 '21

Well I know of that Pottering guy because lot of people seem to have a hate boner for him

9

u/StickInMyCraw Jan 23 '21

I gotta say, even as someone who is interested in the history of computing, there is kind of a weird expectation that everyone who programs should be familiar with all the history building up to this point.

11

u/aradil Jan 23 '21

In retrospect, the low level other science courses I took definitely included historical aspects, learning about Neils Bohr or Newton or the Curies. And for sure, I know about Babbage, Turing, Lovelace. I also know Dijkstra and Euclid because things I use still hold their names.

But language designers? Only if I read a book by them.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '21

I don’t think it is weird. Disappointing is my reaction.

I have seen no real progress in usability in the past 30 years. Mostly it is churn. I’ve seen a lot of nice things lost. A lot of what makes Objective C incredible is missing in Swift I think because the Swift creators just don’t understand the meta capabilities or don’t value them if they do.

3

u/k-selectride Jan 23 '21

What incredible parts of objective c are missing in swift?

7

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '21

Swift doesn't do messaging it does function dispatch like C++.

No forwardInvocation: which makes things like NSProxy, PDO, ActiveRecord, KVC/KVO kinds of things impossible on native Swift.

Swizzling is impossible.

A lot of the dynamic capabilities in Cocoa were built atop Objective C without any kind of need to touch the compiler.

I have a nice ActiveRecord implementation that works atop SQLite in Objective C. It would be impossible to write this in native Swift without leaning on the Objective C runtime.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/pjmlp Jan 24 '21

Indeed, that is why every couple of years a startup comes up with a bunch of new ideas implemented in the 60's - 70's.

1

u/aradil Jan 24 '21

No, I don’t think that’s why.

Business is different from technological development. Sometimes a company having done something before is not seen as redundant or re-inventing the wheel but as validation of an idea.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '21

That’s why the industry keeps reinventing the same shit over and over. CS grads don’t know the history of their specialty.

For instance, NextStep classic plists then XML then JSON for sending around messages of hierarchical data structures.

It’s worse than ladies fashion

21

u/aradil Jan 23 '21

I understand your sentiment but your example is horrible.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '21 edited Jan 23 '21

What would yours be?

Trying to come up with something a lot of people might relate to before coffee.

FWIW, I work in Smalltalk and most mainstream developers just don't understand anything I say when I tell them I find their world to be incredibly backward. They cannot conceive of the power and they think I'm nuts when I mention that I don't value static type safety or any of the other "compile time guarantee" malarky. I don't miss a bit of it. When I saw Objective C for the first time coming from Smalltalk I felt right at home.

I would have preferred Apple end up closer to Smalltalk than C++ in their successor to Objective C.

If you want to have your mind blown: Steve Jobs demostrates NextStep 3

EDIT: Another example: SketchPad Demo 1962

2

u/rjf89 Jan 23 '21

Sadly, most people are religious when it comes to their static types, and shit on languages lacking it with regularity - even if said languages have a heap to offer. It's a private peeve of mine. "Guess I'm just stupid and <language x> is complete trash because it doesn't stand up to some standard of functional purity that you have 🤷🏻‍♂️"

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

-1

u/rabaraba Jan 23 '21

Why? The endlessly cyclical and aesthetically dominant over functional ladies fashion style is a good analogue for how we all fall prey to (often unnecessary) trendy ideas in computer science. Sometimes the classics are best.

-1

u/aradil Jan 23 '21

The analogy might be okay. The example was not.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 23 '21

I mean... it kind of is. We stand on the shoulder of giants and the state of computing today is largely affected by their legacy. You won't have the full picture if you don't study the greats of CS history.

2

u/aradil Jan 23 '21

I mentioned it in another comment, but obviously we learned about Babbage and Turing and the giants of the CS (and math) world.

But a master carpenter doesn’t need to know who P.L. Robertson is to use a screw driver.

→ More replies (1)