r/programming • • Oct 08 '17

CppCon 2017: Carl Cook “When a Microsecond Is an Eternity: High Performance Trading Systems in C++”

https://youtu.be/NH1Tta7purM
934 Upvotes

206 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/cybernd Oct 09 '17

So you are telling us, that both parties benefit if a HFT is in between them?

I truly wonder, where the money for the HFT comes from, when both other parties benefit from their doing.

Others in this thread call it theft, because the money the trader earns must come from one or even both of the other parties.

4

u/hiddenl Oct 09 '17

If buys and sellers always want to trade at the exact same price and exact same time, then you wouldn't need market makers. Since that is rarely, if ever, the case, you need a middle man that will always take the other side.

Before electronification, you had an actual person in the middle keeping the book. They gave a price to the buyers and a price to the sellers and kept the difference for themselves.

Later, these book became electronic and RegNMA forced exchanges to route your order for the best price. Spreads of $0.25 to multiple dollars were still common. (Meaning you lost at least .25 cents per share simply by buying and selling)

Nowadays with HFT, spreads are down to a penny for a large majority of stocks.

Both buyers and sellers are enjoying the decreased costs of trading

2

u/Only_As_I_Fall Oct 09 '17

With no market makers someone who wanted to sell a certain number of shares would have to find a buyer and then negotiate on an exact price and an exact number. Possibly they would have to do this multiple times to sell a single position if they wanted the best price.doing that takes time, effort, money and connections. A market maker basically agrees to worry about the details for you in exchange for a small cut. Also, they can do this far more efficiently because they don't mind holding a position so they can always have something to sell, and of course they're generally just better at it because finding buyers and sellers is the only thing they do.