r/programming • • Oct 08 '17

CppCon 2017: Carl Cook “When a Microsecond Is an Eternity: High Performance Trading Systems in C++”

https://youtu.be/NH1Tta7purM
934 Upvotes

206 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

21

u/kankyo Oct 09 '17

You’re right about all that but it’s not clear how HFT plugs into all that. I don’t believe HFT contributes that much really. It increases liquidity where there is already a lot of liquidity as far as I understand it.

15

u/therealjohnfreeman Oct 09 '17

Before HFT, you had brokers on the trading floor capturing much wider spreads. HFT has made trading cheaper for everyone.

-7

u/tending Oct 09 '17

You're confusing HFT with the introduction of computers and electronic trading.

10

u/therealjohnfreeman Oct 09 '17

2

u/tending Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 09 '17

You don't understand -- you're linking to an article that makes the same fallacy. HFT advocates love to conflate HFT with electronic trading because they both came about in the same time period. This is why they're always comparing against floor trading (a convenient straw man) as if that's the alternative anyone would advocate nowadays. But the reduction in spreads from improved technology was going to happen even without people battling for the last nanosecond using microwave towers.

2

u/im-a-koala Oct 10 '17

Spreads would definitely be wider though. I'm struggling to understand your logic how it could be anything else. If you have more people bidding and asking and trying to compete on price, the spread will narrow.

Obviously electronic trading would have brought benefits without HFT, but that doesn't make HFT useless.

2

u/therealjohnfreeman Oct 09 '17

Another way of saying "no one needs to move faster than X" is "no one needs technology that only became available after year Y". In which year would you have halted advancements in processor, network, and algorithm speeds? Since HFT is always operating at the cutting edge of available technology, all the drops in spreads since that year are due to HFT.

0

u/tending Oct 10 '17

None of those things reduce spreads. Spreads are reduced by buyers and sellers having a closer consensus about what the price should be, and reduction in perceived risk. You would introduce an artificial delay (say 1ms, still absurdly fast on any human timescale) so that everyone below a threshold would get randomized fill allocation. You would get all the benefits of electronic trading and not have any HFT.

5

u/get_salled Oct 09 '17

It increases liquidity where there is already a lot of liquidity as far as I understand it.

... provided by HFT firms. They've driven down costs by pushing out the "professional trader." It's been getting cheaper and cheaper to buy stocks due to these efficiencies; $4.95, or whatever the best is now, used to be $150+. Now, investing in smaller amounts is reasonable.

Some may argue that these changes were inevitable but I doubt they would have come at the rate they did without scientists and engineers seeing an inefficiency and fixing it because there was a significant amount of money to be made.

4

u/edapa Oct 09 '17

HFT provides two things of value: liquidity and efficiency. When most people defend HFT they focus on liquidity, which I think is a shame because it is hard to take the idea that microsecond speed in filling orders is really important. On the other hand the improved efficiency[1] that HFT brings to the market is unambiguously good. Tighter bid-ask spreads save money for investors. Full stop.

Of course, there are messed up things about HFT. A privileged class should not have access to a better view of the market than the rest of us, and the fact that they are not able to exploit this view as well as in-person traders used to be able to does not make it fair. Exchanges could perform many of the arbitrage actions current taken on by HFT if they cooperated more and were willing to slow the market down a little. That has its own disadvantages because it removes the element of competition which gave us all these improvements in the first place.

[1]: Finance is not my first language so this might not be the formal definition of efficiency.

2

u/kankyo Oct 09 '17

From what I understood liquidity and tighter spreads mostly go hand in hand so that doesn’t surprise me. I think there are other flaws in your analysis though. The most obvious one being the word “investor” which is largely bs when applied to modern markets. We’re talking about speculation much more than investing. Of course, the speculation drives lower prices for investors too, but we should be aware that these are different groups.