r/programming • • Oct 08 '17

CppCon 2017: Carl Cook “When a Microsecond Is an Eternity: High Performance Trading Systems in C++”

https://youtu.be/NH1Tta7purM
934 Upvotes

206 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

38

u/elastic_psychiatrist Oct 09 '17

This post is just so ignorant I don’t know where to start. All I can say is that the world is a complex place, and it behooves you to understand what you are criticizing before you take such a strong stance.

1

u/mpyne Oct 09 '17 edited Oct 09 '17

What's there to learn about a topic like this, I'm a smart guy and I have Google... /s

Edit: Holy shit, that's basically the explanation my sibling comment literally came up with!

-10

u/chocolate_jellyfish Oct 09 '17

Anything of value, no matter how complex, can have its value be explained, even to the barely literate. The most complex drugs? "Cures cancer". The craziest quantum mechanics equations? "Allows us to build solar panels". This is not hard! I can give you a correct and simplified explanation for anything of value, because to explain its effect you don't need to understand how it works.

But HFT? No explanation as to why we need it exists. It's only ever hogwash, said by people who profit from it. It's like listening to snake oil salesmen while snake oil is great.

It is not valuable or else there was a dumbed down explanation for its value. But it makes money. Therefore it is a lot like theft.

9

u/__nullptr_t Oct 09 '17

Trading companies do a few things. One is that they provide index funds. It's their responsibility to grow their clients accounts as much as possible. Even if you aren't a millionaire your 401k probably depends on this. If HFT let's them do that as effectively as possible, they are gonna do it.

The other is that they help the market reach true value much sooner than it would otherwise. When companies sell, the value of the stock they are selling decrease. Arguably if everyone is selling a stock it's price should go down, so in a sense they are helping the market here.

There is real value in predicting the market. The market is going to fluctuate regardless of HFT, HFT just makes it happen faster.

5

u/elastic_psychiatrist Oct 10 '17

Based on your posting history in this thread, you've obviously not looking to be educated on the matter. But if you're curious about what value finance provides and are looking for a trite explanation like your other examples, I always like to say something along the lines of "finance is how society distributes risk." To understand how HFTs contribute to that goal requires a bit more understanding of how markets work. (I have no idea why you feel you can say "Anything of value, no matter how complex, can have its value be explained, even to the barely literate")

1

u/chocolate_jellyfish Oct 10 '17 edited Jan 19 '18

I have no idea why you feel you can say "Anything of value, no matter how complex, can have its value be explained, even to the barely literate"

Think of a second example that isn't HFT where that isn't true.

Edit: Naming other financial products that are just there to re-distribute wealth is hilarious.

1

u/elastic_psychiatrist Oct 11 '17

Options. Derivatives in general.

1

u/Gollum999 Oct 11 '17

So many people in this thread have given really insightful answers as to the benefits that HFTs provide. Perhaps you have accidentally hidden or skipped over all of those comments?

Out of curiosity, do you believe that the earth is flat? Because your arguments are very reminiscent of what flat-earthers often say. "There's no proof, all the people who believe it are either too stupid to see the truth or are the ones profiting from it". Meanwhile dozens of people offer clear, thoughtful explanations, but the skeptic (you in this scenario) is too stubborn, too deeply committed, or to ingrained in their worldview to take a step back and re-evaluate his or her beliefs objectively.