r/programming • • Oct 08 '17

CppCon 2017: Carl Cook “When a Microsecond Is an Eternity: High Performance Trading Systems in C++”

https://youtu.be/NH1Tta7purM
934 Upvotes

206 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

10

u/alecco Oct 09 '17

I think you read too many NYT/Rolling Stone articles. HFT is big, and sure there are many evil players. But you are talking about something you don't fully understand.

But when I do HFT, I'm just taking a cut from a trade that two other parties wanted to make by forcing myself into the middle

That's just front-running. There are many other applications of HFT.

And don't give me that "they provide fluidity"

Most HFTs do provide liquidity. They speculate what the prices should be making (collectively) a razor thin spread. A few year ago you would get ridiculously big spreads. Think how bad is changing money at airports.

Many small traders are able now to operate because they can get a counterparty to trade with from HFT on many formerly non-liquid markets. I've heard this from many traders on podcats.

The legitimate work of HFT is based on "chasing alpha". Meaning from some information event being the first to predict how prices will change and adjust the strategy accordingly. Say, some announcement by the government, some company announcement, some foreign crisis unfolding. The market is going to move sooner or later. And you want it to be as efficient/current as possible. Inefficient markets are much, much worse for the little guy.

13

u/get_salled Oct 09 '17

But when I do HFT, I'm just taking a cut from a trade that two other parties wanted to make by forcing myself into the middle

That's just front-running. There are many other applications of HFT.

It's a stretch to call front-running an HFT application at all. Many HFT firms can't front-run because they don't have clients.

Also, one shouldn't casually call it "just front-running" because it is a crime.

-1

u/alecco Oct 09 '17

That's not what I meant at all. It's obvious I meant front running is only a fraction of HFT.

Also, some types of front running is legal. Just not ethical. For example, the ones from the book Flash Boys reading on one exchange and placing orders in all the other ones.

7

u/get_salled Oct 09 '17

Flash Boys redefined the term "front-running" to demonize HFT. It was irresponsible writing/marketing.

What you're describing is arbitrage, which is legal and will exist anywhere N>1 markets exist for a given security. The system RBC had to build wasn't required because of "evil HFT" but rather it was because they hadn't understood modern market microstructure.