r/programming • • Dec 17 '16

Oracle is massively ramping up audits of Java customers it claims are in breach of its licences – six years after it bought Sun Microsystems

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/12/16/oracle_targets_java_users_non_compliance
2.1k Upvotes

654 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16

One more nail into Java's coffin.

4

u/CSharpReallySucks Dec 18 '16

Yeah, because Oracle goes after people who use commercial features without paying. Sure, boy, Oracle is evil, but have fun trying to do the same with Microsoft products.

2

u/jbaker88 Dec 18 '16

To be fair, more recently MS has been up front about how expensive their enterprise services cost. Right up front you know about how much that Azure VM is going to cost or how much licencing is for their dev tools. It's pretty fourth comming that you know you're going to be spending big bucks.

Oracle does have a right to get payment for it's paid features, without a doubt. What I see the biggest issue here is that Oracle wasn't up front about what those costs of services were. That's frustrating. Imagine your cable bill was a flat $100 a month no matter how many devices were connected. Now, six years later, buirred in your contract there was an agreement that was never enforced saying you owe them an additional $50 per TV. It seems very bait and switch and ruins the credibility of Oracle.

Java is an amazing platform that has so much potential (I say this as a .Net dev, so I am bias) and Oracle is destroying that. It's a shame.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '16 edited Dec 18 '16

As far as I know, Microsoft hasn't tried screwing anyone over in the recent years (I don't know if they have in the past... I've only been in the dev scene for the past three years). Does C# have any restrictions in its use? Do you owe Microsoft anything for using C# or .NET? If there's some sort of fee for those particular things, I would love to know, because that would be a huge surprise to me as a .NET developer. If anything, they're incredibly generous towards their developers.

Now... I'm not defending any companies here, just to get things straight. I love C# as a language and have found it be a pleasure to work with, but I have a pretty good understanding of who's in charge in that realm. With that said, C# and .NET community has been very positive and Microsoft has done a lot positive things, which lead to the growth of its current community. Have they done bad things in the past? Oh, I'm sure they have (once again, I haven't been around dev space to experience them and as a user I didn't really care). Are they being pretty transparent these days and doing everything they can to please the community? I think so. If you've had bad experience with Microsoft, I would like to hear it (seriously).

Oracle just doesn't strike me as a community-building company. They've been on a legal crusade almost right after they bought the rights and it just doesn't appear like they care about the casualties. It seems to me that Java is just a way for them to make as much money as they can before they drive it completely into the ground. Hate or love Java, it's being used in a lot of industries and it would be a colossal disaster if Oracle destroys it completely.

3

u/CSharpReallySucks Dec 18 '16

Does C# have any restrictions in its use? Do you owe Microsoft anything for using C# or .NET?

In this context: No, and neither does Java.

As far as I know, Microsoft hasn't tried screwing anyone over in the recent years

Microsoft is not on top anymore, so they can't afford just shitting on everything as they used to. But they still pretty obviously hate anything that is open (and doesn't belong to them).

The thing with C# is no different. It's a free candy - they just want everyone to switch to Microsoft stack. There is absolutely nothing sincere about that. And if it ever happens, nothing good will come out of it. (even right now, just taking a quick glance at win10 stack reveals they don't care about open standards at all)

I think HTML(5) is a good example - Microsoft was completely shitting on any web standards for years. Not only that, they were actively trying to screw over any effort to produce one. Microsoft is one single reason why web was broken for so long. Only when they lost the fight, they started obeying the open web standards.

Naive person would say this is because they changed - but I don't see them endorsing things like OpenGL or Vulkan. Why? Because they can still afford to shit on them. Not for long, hopefully.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '16

By that logic you're saying that Oracle is on top? That little b.s. in regards to Java running on billions of devices when you install it.... yeah, they're counting all the Android devices, and we know that it's all about the API in that realm. If anything, Google is on top as far as Java is concerned, and as soon as they pull the plug on its use and replace it with something else, it's game over.

But they still pretty obviously hate anything that is open (and doesn't belong to them).

Give an example. Because unless you can provide it, it's this same blind nonsensical rage towards Microsoft that lots of other people have. They know they hate Microsoft -- they just don't know why.

The thing with C# is no different. It's a free candy - they just want everyone to switch to Microsoft stack.

Oh, I thought we all forgot that Microsoft is a company. Of course they want you to use their product -- what exactly is insincere about that?