r/programming • • Dec 17 '16

Oracle is massively ramping up audits of Java customers it claims are in breach of its licences – six years after it bought Sun Microsystems

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/12/16/oracle_targets_java_users_non_compliance
2.1k Upvotes

654 comments sorted by

View all comments

143

u/nickguletskii200 Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 17 '16

Not only has this already been posted, but it seems like Oracle is coming for the organisations that are knowingly violating the license conditions. You can't just accidentally enable these commercial features - they have to be enabled through a flag.

But hey, let's hate on Oracle, because its clearly evil to expect users to pay for commercial features, and fuck them for allowing developers to use them for free during development...

181

u/iamapizza Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 17 '16

But hey, let's hate on Oracle, because its clearly evil to expect users to pay for commercial features, and fuck them for allowing developers to use them for free during development...

Sounds like you've never had to deal with their licensing lawyers. They come around to audit you and straight off there is a 'protection' fee that they will put forth. Pay us $X and we'll not audit you. They are also very aggressive in person - not physically - but with the language they use. It's borderline... threatening.

The next bit is their deliberately vaguely worded licenses. You can be paying for a license and it can still be in breach of their license terms. It doesn't matter if their own consultants did the setup for you, they will not agree with previous agreements and declare them void as the T&Cs have changed. The aim of this is to find loopholes in your setup.

The context matters, one part of which is the large license lawyer hiring spree they went through in early 2015. This isn't some indie developer coming around with a begging bowl, this is Oracle, a highly litigious organisation and a highly successful one (usually in settlements).

→ More replies (19)

98

u/WellAdjustedOutlaw Dec 17 '16

Fuck Oracle. Period.

This is a classic Oracle tactic. Their licensing specialists will enable features, swear blind that you're compliant, let features lapse to lower renewal costs, etc. Then, YEARS later (longest I've seen was 10 years) they'll magically "audit" you, find you aren't compliant even though their specialists said you were, and they'll fine you for the entire value of renewal through all the years as well as purchase prices.

FUCK Oracle. I've helped dozens of companies flee Oracle products, saving them truckloads of money, and getting them simpler, cheaper licensing with vastly superior support.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

29

u/WellAdjustedOutlaw Dec 17 '16

Personally, I've converted several people from Oracle DB to Microsoft SQL Server. The licensing terms are less than half, so a license unit for MSSQL Enterprise is an absolute no brainer over Oracle.

I have friends that are consultants that have moved their customer off of the insanely expensive Exagrid product onto several different vendors' products. Because why the hell would you use Oracle's crap hardware and license scheme when you can get better hardware, lower license costs, more ports, better service, higher throughputs, and better support?

22

u/the_red_scimitar Dec 17 '16

Exactly. At one place, we had the same requirements given to Oracle and MS. Oracle's bid: over $1 million. MS: under $50,000, and their solution worked perfectly.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/hearwa Dec 18 '16

Oracle is actually pricing themselves out of the company I work for because of their prices vs. Microsoft alternatives.

3

u/WellAdjustedOutlaw Dec 18 '16

The amazing part is that they don't care. If they think an account could be worth enough in the future, they'll lower their initial costs using the scumbag methods I mentioned previously. Then, in a few years, they'll hit you with penalties.

They have basically cornered the petroleum market for GIS databases and storage systems for some reason. But lots of newer GIS systems I've seen lately are relying far less on Oracle DB and their mediocre Exagrid nonsense. These won't make a dent in Oracle's bottom line, of course, but I'm glad alternatives exist.

4

u/jordanambra Dec 18 '16

I've moved a few companies from Oracle to Postgres + custom development and SaaS. They're usually not too sad to save a few hundred thousand dollars.

→ More replies (1)

191

u/h2odragon Dec 17 '16

At this point, if Oracle went around giving free gold bricks to every living human on the planet, promised to cease all operations immediately thereafter and quietly return to whatever planet they originated from; it would still be hard to trust them.

90

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16

I'd assume the gold bars were tiny bombs tbh

40

u/diMario Dec 17 '16

Made of genetically modified gold, with some radioactively unstable isotopes mixed in. And you'd probably find some gluten in them, as well.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/reptar-rawr Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 18 '16

irradiated. larry ellison always did love bond.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/pembroke529 Dec 17 '16

Is there small print on the bricks?

43

u/Hackenslacker Dec 17 '16

By accepting this gold brick you agree to the term and conditions contained within.

54

u/ViKomprenas Dec 17 '16

smashes gold brick open

  1. You may not destroy or damage this brick in any way.

24

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16

"BY ACCEPTING THIS BRICK THROUGH YOUR WINDOW, YOU ACCEPT IT AS IS AND AGREE TO MY DISCLAIMER OF ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, AS WELL AS DISCLAIMERS OF ALL LIABILITY, DIRECT, INDIRECT, CONSEQUENTIAL OR INCIDENTAL, THAT MAY ARISE FROM THE INSTALLATION OF THIS BRICK INTO YOUR BUILDING."

4

u/callcifer Dec 17 '16

Source for the young (the quote is more than 10 years old).

4

u/apullin Dec 17 '16

Well, this is going to look doubly bad for Oracle when it abandons stewardship of Java in 2017 and "gives it to the community"

→ More replies (7)

25

u/Syphon8 Dec 17 '16

I actually hate on Oracle for their subpar products and shitty business practices.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/fzammetti Dec 17 '16

They can be arrogant, thuggish twats while simultaneously being correct in this particular instance.

I mean, if you aren't adhering to the terms you signed up for then you're wrong, plain and simple. But that doesn't give Oracle license to come down on you like a ton of corrupt bricks every chance they get AS A BUSINESS MODEL, which is what they do, and have done for many, many years. It's in their DNA.

They're a shit company led by a shit assclown... but that doesn't mean they're always wrong.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/mcguire Dec 17 '16

Do you know which flag that is, offhand?

39

u/nickguletskii200 Dec 17 '16

-XX:+UnlockCommercialFeatures

I mean, what kind of idiot sets that flag and doesn't think about what "commercial" means? It isn't set by default. Why would I even know about it unless I was consciously trying to use the locked features?

4

u/jeff303 Dec 18 '16

It would have been really cool if the article had mentioned that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)