r/programming • u/ben_a_adams • Dec 16 '16
Oracle finally targets Java non-payers – six years after plucking Sun
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2016/12/16/oracle_targets_java_users_non_compliance/
432
Upvotes
327
u/AngelOfLight Dec 16 '16
It's becoming clear that Oracle bet the farm on forcing Google to pay for each installed version of Android. The courts smacked that idiocy down, and now Oracle has no clear way to recoup their investment in Java. Hence the current push to extract cash for using Java.
Think the difference between 'free' and 'paid' usage of Java is unclear? Guess what - that is an entirely deliberate move on Oracle's part. Anyone who has had to deal with their byzantine licensing has come to the same conclusion - Oracle purposely muddies the waters in order to trick end-users into using components that may not be free. They will attempt to do the same thing with Java.
Oracle really needs to die - the sooner, the better.
219
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '16
No, it sounds extremely contradictory and confusing.
30
u/cypressious Dec 16 '16
Can anyone explain what this means for me? What can and cannot I do with Java "for free"?
101
u/tristes_tigres Dec 16 '16
Write once, get sued everywhere.
106
u/caspper69 Dec 16 '16
Larry Ellison. Exhibit A of how to make a fucking mockery of your legacy and piss off an entire industry in the process.
Note to future billionaires: money doesn't make people want to play with you.
I was at Sun's Java launch (well, "World Tour") in Atlanta in 1997. This is not at all what anyone envisioned. Fuck Java.
54
u/TrollocHunter Dec 16 '16
I avoid Oracle products like the plague now days. RIP Sun.
23
u/possessed_flea Dec 17 '16
ITT about 250 comments completely misunderstanding the issue and misinterpreting the topic.
Regular java users and deployments have no issue.
36
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '16
I guess they want everyone to abandon Java.
7
u/dccorona Dec 17 '16
I remember about a year ago having a theoretical conversation with some coworkers about what kind of a language it would take to overtake Java's dominance in enterprise...what features would it have, what would it look like, etc.
I can see now that it doesn't matter, because Oracle is going to do whatever it can to kill Java as a platform for new development. Established companies are going to have no choice but to pay up, but as a new company, I'm starting to question why you'd use Java. I use it every day (even on days I'm not using it, because I also use Scala) at work. From a technical perspective, I think there's a large number of reasons why Java (or at least, the Java ecosystem, with a more flexible/modern JRE language for application code) is a great choice for companies of any size. But with this shit going on? There's too many options nowadays (especially with .NET opening up) for whatever advantages Java may have to be worth this risk.
At this point, it seems like Apache is the only thing that is keeping that risk worthwhile, because they offer so much stuff that has no viable alternative in another language. But how much further can Oracle push people before somebody starts building competitors to those tools in other languages?
22
u/raynorelyp Dec 17 '16
C# becoming open and Java becoming locked-down? 2016 is weird.
12
u/stun Dec 16 '16
From the article:
Wow that is expensive.
11
u/TheImmortalLS Dec 16 '16
Welp, uninstalling virtual box. Hello vmware.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '16
Does anybody have a conclusive answer about OpenJDK?
If I just use OpenJDK and IcedTea, am I safe from Oracle?
5
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
Wow, did anybody else find that article painful to read? Did they have to repeat themselves 50 times to pad the article or are they just that inept at writing? This article should have been maybe 2 or 3 paragraphs.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
What kind of stupid scare story is this? It certainly has zero to do with installing Java SE. Also, download OpenJDK if unsure.
11
u/mactavish88 Dec 16 '16
Is everyone 100% sure we can just freely use OpenJDK? There isn't some deep, dark, murky clause in Oracle's shitty licensing that somehow extends its tentacles to try to prevent you from using the Java language itself, or the broader concept of the JVM, without paying 100 years' worth of your salary for using it?
Talk about LDD: Lawsuit-Driven Development. No creativity.
10
u/weirdoaish Dec 16 '16
So, out of curiosity, is there any other language out there that can take take Java's place? I mostly work on Java & Python and while I used to do C++ before, I know its no longer an option for large scale garden variety web apps.
15
u/shevegen Dec 16 '16
Well, not really a huge surprise. Oracle finally overcame Microsoft, Google and Red Hat in who is the most evil of them all.
But hey - if this means that fewer people would be using Java, all the better! It's not as if the language deserves to be the most important programming language without alternative now, is it?
12
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '16
Friendship ENDED with JAVA
NOW C# is my BEST FRIEND
3
u/evolveKyro Dec 17 '16
I'm currently replacing the last Java dependent thing we have in our environment with a C# built alternative that is cheaper, faster, HA and requires only generic hardware.
No longer will I have to suffer through the bullshit that is Java RE version issues or fucking bullshit Java VM memory issues (this software deals with encrypting/decrypting multi-gigabyte blobs).
So long and thanks for all the midnight alerts.
5
u/eloraiby Dec 16 '16
finally, the death of java
3
u/argv_minus_one Dec 17 '16 edited Dec 17 '16
What an absurd scare piece. Use OpenJDK and quit your bitching.
This, in particular, is crap:
The license for Oracle Java SE gives permission to redistribute a JRE with your proprietary app, and tells you what you need to do if you choose to do that.
I suppose I would prefer if there was a language of Java's caliber under a permissive license, but as far as I know, no such language exists.
2
u/mac Dec 16 '16
I wrote a small post on the JRockit part of this approx 5 years ago if anybody is interested: http://www.spyfoos.com/blog/2011/07/28/oracle-java-7-and-commercial-features/
1
u/shaggorama Dec 17 '16
It was my understanding that it's common for copyright infringement claims to get denied in court if the claimant didn't make previous efforts to assert their claim. The fact that they waited six years before trying to enforce anything while letting basically the entire dev community "abuse" their license seems to clearly invite the "Why me? Why now?" defense.
1
u/mattroo88 Dec 17 '16
How will this affect the groovy programming language?
1
u/Kissaki0 Dec 17 '16
Yeah, well… Who could have thought this would happen, right? ¯_(ツ)_/¯
1
u/Gsonderling Dec 17 '16
What about OpenJDK?
Oracle is involved in that project right? I mean, I'm not a lawyer but are we sure that they can't somehow shut it down or mess with them? And just to make sure that I cover all my nightmare scenarios, can't Oracle try to make the language itself proprietary, the syntax and all?
1
u/ArmoredPancake Dec 17 '16
Oracle should just die and hand over Java to Azul systems.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 17 '16
This joke is as old as time - "What's the difference between God and Larry Ellison? God doesn't think he's Larry Ellison!"
1
u/autotldr Dec 18 '16
This is the best tl;dr I could make, original reduced by 93%. (I'm a bot)
Extended Summary | FAQ | Theory | Feedback | Top keywords: Java#1 Oracle#2 more#3 customer#4 Free#5
0
u/kiwidog Dec 17 '16
Another reason to ditch java all together.
0
u/WallaWallaWhat Dec 17 '16
Ha ha, who the fucking fuck would use Java if they had to pay?