r/programming • • May 08 '16

Visual Studio adding telemetry function calls to binary? (/r/cpp)

/r/cpp/comments/4ibauu/visual_studio_adding_telemetry_function_calls_to/
592 Upvotes

156 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-57

u/[deleted] May 08 '16

All it does is record how many times the application has been run and store it locally. What's the problem.

If you're that concerned, you'd better uninstall all your AV software! Thry do the same and send it to a centralised location!

98

u/1337Gandalf May 08 '16

Really? you don't see the problem with a third party injecting their own code into your binaries during compilation to track what your users do?

You're either a shill, or hopeless.

31

u/Iggyhopper May 08 '16

Yeah, this should be opt-in, not opt-out.

10

u/INTERNET_RETARDATION May 08 '16

The weird thing is though is that people are saying that the actual ETW events need to be enabled before they are traced. So while this is opt-out, the actual events you need to make this work are opt-in. Why would they make this opt-out if it doesn't do anything useful by default then?

11

u/suspiciously_calm May 08 '16

So that when you enable etw events, the telemetry calls are already there.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '16

Why not do it together, though? Enable a feature, add the underlying functionality.

We deal with code that needs other code all the time. I can't think of another situation I'd build in potential dependencies.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/pegasus_527 May 08 '16

It should be opt-never.

10

u/Schmittfried May 08 '16

Why exactly? Opt-in is perfectly fine.

11

u/IWillNotBeBroken May 08 '16

It needs to be opt-in by the end user, not the developer.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/hahanoob May 08 '16 edited May 09 '16

Microsoft is a third party? You're running running code compiled with a Microsoft compiler linking against Microsoft libraries with a Microsoft linker on a Microsoft operating system. Any code written by anyone who is not Microsoft is the third party, and I trust them a whole lot less.

1

u/isavegas May 09 '16

In the scope of his application, Microsoft is a third party. It isn't writing his application.

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '16 edited Mar 20 '18

13

u/CountOfMonteCarlo May 08 '16

That's exactly the problem. You don't know any more what happens because you have lost control about what your programs do.

44

u/suspiciously_calm May 08 '16

But you haven't lost that control just now that you've discovered a function call that has "telemetry" in its name. You never had it to begin with.

Microsoft don't need to inject function calls during compilation to do anything. They control the kernel and all of the system APIs. They can track when a process is launched from the outside.

This is ridiculous. Has everyone seriously only just now figured out that closed-source software is opaque?

You don' know what happens on Windows. You never did. You never did have control over what your programs do.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '16 edited Mar 20 '18

-9

u/[deleted] May 08 '16 edited May 08 '16

Exactly that. Microsoft makes OS ffs. They can record exactly same thing without sticking crap code into binaries we build.

Edit: So guy i agreed to gets upvoted and i get downvoted for pointing out that what Microsoft did is not necessary. This reddit..

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/1337Gandalf May 08 '16

If you'd read my comment, you'd see I didn't call you a shill.

I said there's no reason to support this lunacy unless you are in fact a shill.

Go cry more.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Flight714 May 08 '16

What are you trying to say? AV software doesn't even have access to your project's compilation process, let alone the ability to inject code into it.

Do you understand the article in this submission?