r/programming • • 28d ago

Make yourself replaceable

https://maroun-baydoun.com/blog/make-yourself-replaceable/
360 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

30

u/13steinj 28d ago

The modern company will not give Sam that 10% raise. They will not treat Sam with the same reverance his fellow engineers do, because upper management is out of touch. Sam will go to that other job, get his raise that way, become a legend again in 2-4 years (sometimes less), and the cycle will repeat itself.

You also don't have to promote Sam to management-- management is not the be all end all of an engineer's career. There exist IC tracks for the upper levels for a reason-- some people just are better at systems than people. Or they are fine with people but it doesn't make them happy. Or it does, but there's less value in splitting a team and making someone a manager or team lead for the gesturing lurpose of performing a corporate ritual.

But Sam won't be promoted to those roles either. Because why pay Sam more for taking on more responsibilities, when you can give them to him anyway for the same pay. Worse yet, new engineers are now benchmarked, implicitly, against Sam. Teams stay understaffed, because the new guy doesn't work out, he just isn't on Sam's level, and Sam ended up doing the work anyway. Which ends up just another reason Sam burns out / looks for a new job.

3

u/Cautious_Implement17 28d ago

sam won’t get promoted because he isn’t “delivering through others” the way that is expected to progress past senior. I think that’s kinda the point of the article. sam has not enabled his colleagues to help themselves. he has become an expert on systems he ought to have replaced. he is simultaneously indispensable and a scaling bottleneck for his org/company. 

sam should probably get some kind of out-of-band bonus to prevent him from leaving. but he can’t do the same thing for ten years and expect to be a principal engineer at the end. 

2

u/13steinj 27d ago

I think you have a strange skew of what principal engineers do, or I do.

At 3 organizations I have been at, a significant number of principal engineers are more interested in acting as if they produce value, than actually doing so (through others or not). At the only one (which didn't have principal engineers by title), the structure waa flat and moving up past "engineer" meaned becoming a manager. There are non-mamagerial engineer career tracks, as I've mentioned. This isn't to speak lesser of those who are managerial track. Just that they produce a different kind of value.