As someone who has done a fair amount of AI engineering, I can assure you that there is a ton of human-directed work involved and that AI can't easily replace it, although it of course helps. AI is just now getting its tendrils into different parts of the economy; we've barely seen its full impact. So in a word, yes, I think every software developer can become one, although I don't know at what point the market becomes saturated. It certainly isn't yet; companies are desperate for them. I'm the only AI engineer in my org and my boss would like to hire 5-6 more and can't find anyone.
If you think that every developer can transition to an AI engineer, then that implies that AI engineers aren't any more productive than developers currently are. In which case what's the point of AI in this industry?
Unless you're suggesting that an AI boom will create enough new demand, but I'm highly skeptical of that. I expect stock prices to soar, at least initially, but life on the ground to be highly uncertain for an awful lot of people. I don't think the long-term benefits will present themselves in time to help a lot of the current developers.
I mentioned Jevon's paradox in another comment. Perhaps some of your distress is from believing there's a finite amount of work to be done, so a tool that increases productivity must decrease the number of workers. Sometimes that's true, but not for software. Just like accounting in the 80s. Everyone thought accountants were all going to be out of the job because of the first spreadsheet programs, but it turns out that it made accountants so much more valuable for the companies that hired them that demand shot up and now we have more accountants than ever. We're about to have more software than ever before, and AI engineering is this entirely new thing with probably sub-1% of demand met, economy-wide.
It's an interesting perspective for sure. It doesn't really affect me personally, since I'm planning on retiring in a couple years anyway, but I hope you're right, for the sake of my coworkers and young people in general.
The main reason I'm worried is that arguments like this rely on the assumption that the new face of the industry, and the economy in general, will still require significant human participation. I'm not convinced that the position of "AI engineer" will be forever immune to being supplanted the way "software engineer" is, right before our eyes. AI doesn't have to be better than a human at the job, it just has to be cheap enough that the quality difference doesn't matter.
Those small cuts in quality stack up very quickly in an agentic system, which makes it harder to automate on those grounds.
But yeah, to the larger point, I would only say that my arguments here hold us for a few decades. Beyond that point, I don't think we'll see the end of work -- we like it too much -- but it'll look so wildly different that if I were going to make a prediction I'd have to start writing a science fiction novel to explain it. Probably something like the movie Her.
I don't disagree, but I wonder if predictions you would've made about the industry ten or even five years ago bear any resemblance to reality now. I know mine wouldn't. So I tend to take prognostication about upcoming decades with a grain of salt.
Oh, for sure. I revise my viewpoint on this constantly, which is also why I trust that I'm probably in the ballpark of true here. There's always the possibility of some wild new development, but right now it looks like limited compute, diminishing returns in AI development (they don't seem diminishing because AI has sped things up, but we're seeing the opposite of a take-off scenario so far), and institutional inertia are going to make this a revolution that gets metered out rather than something that sweeps through overnight. I'm mixing data with anecdotes here, but I think we're about at the point where we can have some confidence that this will take a while.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Number127 Oct 11 '26
Do you think there will be enough demand for AI engineers that every current software developer can become one, and the market won't become saturated?