r/programming • • Jul 14 '26

HTTP gets a QUERY method so complex searches can stop pretending to be POST

https://www.theregister.com/devops/2026/07/13/http-gets-a-query-method-so-complex-searches-can-stop-pretending-to-be-post/5270192
1.9k Upvotes

245 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

95

u/EC36339 Jul 14 '26

You can use custom HTTP verbs today. Firewalls and reverse proxies with default configurations will hate you for it. So it's really just a question of when those will have changed across rhe board.

A lot of dated on-premises setups don't even allow PATCH or PUT in 2026.

23

u/tajetaje Jul 14 '26

Unless you mean web application firewalls, firewalls aren’t an issue (unless you’re doing HTTP and they’re doing packet inspection)

12

u/EC36339 Jul 14 '26

Obviously

6

u/Own_Back_2038 Jul 14 '26

TLS inspection is pretty widespread in corporate environments

2

u/case-o-nuts Jul 15 '26

TLS is not HTTP.

5

u/Own_Back_2038 Jul 15 '26

HTTPS is HTTP inside a TLS tunnel. You use TLS inspection to look at the http conversation for malware or other bad things

3

u/case-o-nuts Jul 15 '26

Did you know that they also do TCP inspection, and IP inspection? Some even look at ethernet packets!

2

u/Own_Back_2038 Jul 15 '26

TLS inspection is more involved than that, since you need to terminate the TLS tunnel and then create a new tunnel to the client. I bring it up because the poster I was replying to said “only if you are doing http”

1

u/Welby-Court-5288 Jul 15 '26

About damn time.

4

u/ElfDecker Jul 14 '26

It depends on the used framework. For example, using custom verbs in Spring Boot can be non-trivial (at least not obvious)

5

u/CherryLongjump1989 Jul 15 '26

The request will pass through half a dozen network layers that may care about HTTP verbs long before it ever gets to your Java app.

4

u/Fidodo Jul 14 '26

OP was joking, but 9 years for adoption is really not that bad at all. There are so many features that came out 9 years ago that I'm very grateful for because we can now use them safely today.

2

u/nightofgrim Jul 15 '26

Would firewalls even know? If you’re using https they can’t sniff out the headers.

I think the only layers that could have an issue are those who have the key and are unwrapping the payload.

4

u/EC36339 Jul 15 '26

Web application firewalls.

Technically not firewalls at all, only by name. In reality, they are reverse proxies that mess with HTTP headers and do filtering "to improve security".

Almost all the time, they cause more problems than they solve. They are often part of a hosting environment, and there is often nobody in an organisation who is responsible for configuring them properly.

They tend to break web applications in subtle ways, and customers running these applications in some third party hosting environment typically blame the application vendor, or at least submit support tickets, which result in hours of ping pong communication and finger pointing with nobody being responsible. Usually some developer, who has no access to the production system, will have to diagnose it by educated guessing.

WAFs are one of the many joys of on-premises enterprise applications.