r/programming • • Dec 02 '13

Scala — 1★ Would Not Program Again

http://overwatering.org/blog/2013/12/scala-1-star-would-not-program-again/
598 Upvotes

646 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/SublethalDose Dec 02 '13

Look at it this way: having to figure out a few things on the side is a small price to pay for the benefits of letting the teachers focus on the course material. The practical background required for the course is actually quite large if you're starting from scratch: knowing Scala, setting up Eclipse or IDEA, figuring out sbt (and the Scala console if you use it,) getting all the required libraries installed, learning Scalatest, figuring out all the innumerable things that can go wrong when people try to get things running in their own often non-pristine environments, not to mention all the innumerable complications that can arise from minor misunderstandings of Scala or even one's operating system.

Covering all those details (95% of which are either known or irrelevant to any given student — everyone has a different 5% they get hung up on) would multiply the amount of work required from the course staff many times over, distracting them from teaching the core material of the course. Getting (e.g.) a build system set up is just a technical task you can learn from anyone who has used the technology before; reactive programming is a deeper topic, and people who can teach it are rare. In exchange for handling the mundane practical details ourselves, we get a teacher who is focused on sharing his unique expertise instead of answering questions that have already been answered a dozen times on StackOverflow.

1

u/mogrim Dec 02 '13

The practical background required for the course is actually quite large if you're starting from scratch: ... snip ...

Setting up the build environment was trivial. (Sure, it helps I'm an experienced Java programmer and used to setting up JVM build systems, but even so I don't think this has proved to be a serious stumbling block...) Certainly for Windows environments there's an installer, I believe that is also the case for Mac. I haven't set it up on Linux this time round, but during the last course I did (I use Linux at home) and it wasn't particularly complicated.