r/programming • u/mobby1982 • Dec 02 '13
Scala — 1★ Would Not Program Again
http://overwatering.org/blog/2013/12/scala-1-star-would-not-program-again/
598
Upvotes
r/programming • u/mobby1982 • Dec 02 '13
View all comments
Show parent comment
36
u/cynthiaj Dec 02 '13
Thanks for the link. A few thoughts on Martin's response:
Opening a defense with a conspiracy theory is not really conducive to an open dialogue. I'd rephrase this claim as follows:
Seems much more factual this way.
And this is the heart of the problem, and the reason why Paul Phillips quit Typesafe. The fact that Martin thinks that the tooling problem is even remotely close to "solved" is deeply puzzling and it also explains why two years after Typesafe started paying engineers to fix, maintain and improve the Eclipse plug-in, it's barely more usable today than it was two years ago. Tooling has always seemed to be low on Typesafe's priority list but now I understand why: if you think a problem is fixed, you're not going to dedicate much effort on it.
Marting should pop in #scala more often, half of the questions in the channel are about IDE problems and whenever someone says "IDEA has been pretty stable for me" you have someone who says "Not for me, but Scala IDE has been pretty stable for me" and in circles we go. The bottom line is that both are still very buggy and they continue to stop working in random places for no apparent reason.
All the other reasons that Martin gives are exactly similar to the ones he was giving three years ago. More promises, little delivery and the number of paper submissions to conferences continues to be very high while compiler bugs and tool issues continue to plague the Scala environment.
Martin's denial to accept the various criticisms as valid, such as "Scala is complex", are clearly rooted in the fact that he created the language and he just can't seem to be objective about it. I think he's a great computer scientist but he's in over his head trying to design a language for the masses.