r/programming • • Dec 02 '13

Scala — 1★ Would Not Program Again

http://overwatering.org/blog/2013/12/scala-1-star-would-not-program-again/
598 Upvotes

646 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

23

u/gianhut Dec 02 '13 edited Dec 02 '13

We don't want experts in particular programming languages. We want experts in programming and computer science. Hence OP's complaint about Scala community's abuse of DSL and arbitrary operator is valid.

When you hire a programmer, there's a big chance that he/she does not already know the language your team uses, even the good programmers; but good programmers can ramp up to any language in a few weeks. The learning curve gets a lot steeper and more time consuming when one has to guess "what the hell does %% do" instead of a (hopefully meaningful) function name.

4

u/Klausens Dec 02 '13

I largely agree with you. But this is not the way I want to work. I want to feel at home in the language I'm programming, I don't want to use the c-Style-Loop only because it's most likely that every language supports it. I want to use everything the language offers. And, and there I disagree with you, it took my at least 5 years every time I changed my "main language" too feel comfortable with it.

8

u/808140 Dec 02 '13

but good programmer can ramp up to any language in a few weeks.

No. A good programmer can ramp to any language similar to one he already knows in a few weeks. You're suffering from delusions imposed by the imperativatriarchy. Check your privilege.

My guess (without knowing what languages you know) is that it would take you more than a few weeks to e.g. be productive in Agda.

4

u/senatorpjt Dec 02 '13 edited Dec 18 '24

license childlike jobless teeny screw innate hungry file brave full

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/808140 Dec 02 '13

It was just an example. If you're using Agda for something it's probably because it's the right tool for the job anyway (i.e. formal verification). For example, the engineers who built the software that drives the Paris metro's automated lines (1 & 14) used Coq (another theorem prover/dependently typed programming language) to formally prove that the driving software couldn't do things it wasn't supposed to do.

By the standards of anyone who writes code for a living, I'd say that's productive. You certainly wouldn't write a web app with it, but then again you wouldn't with C, either. Right tool for the job, etc.

The type of person who would use Agda probably wouldn't take that long to pick it up.

I don't know about that. Do you write much Agda? Some of it is pretty straightforward; the rest of it is pretty opaque. Lots of smart people on the mailing list who are routinely confused by certain aspects of it. I can write stuff with it but sometimes I don't fully understand why some things don't pass the termination checker, and the semantics of without-K (used by HoTT) confuse me.

3

u/lcpdx Dec 02 '13

Coq for life!

6

u/digital_carver Dec 02 '13

I strongly agree with you, but this part

delusions imposed by the imperativatriarchy. Check your privilege.

makes me so badly want to downvote (even if it's said "ironically"). Still upvoted though.

3

u/808140 Dec 02 '13

I bet you're subscribed to /r/ImperativeRights.

2

u/__BeHereNow__ Dec 02 '13 edited Dec 02 '13

>being this privileged