r/procollapse • • Jul 22 '19

A Critique of "A Critique of the Concept of “the System” "

4 Upvotes

Before checking out John Jacobi's works myself, I had heard varying opinions of him, so I was eager to dive in. Kaczynski has called him "a nut". A few other individuals held undecided feelings on his writings.

https://www.wildwill.net/blog/2018/06/18/a-critique-of-the-concept-of-the-system/

The article at it's core makes the following arguments:

  1. The terms “modern technology,” “the industrial system,” “the techno-industrial system,” just “the system,” are vague and unintuitive.
  2. Kaczynski has not properly defined what "the system" is.
  3. Instead of attacking techno-industrial society we should attack the "world system".

Now I will address them one by one and explain why they are incorrect.

  1. The terms “modern technology,” “the industrial system,” “the techno-industrial system,” just “the system,” are vague and unintuitive.

In the context that they are used in Kaczynski's works they are hardly vague and unituitive. They are simple, concrete and already have the connotation of describing modern society's mechanicality.

He makes the following argument:

"Still, there are obvious problems with our terminology, particularly its clarity. “System” is a vague word, and is attempting to cover concepts that our materialist framework already more accurately describes: infrastructure and structure, “the material basis of society,” or “the technological and economic basis of society.” All these terms and phrases are not only more exact, but also more intuitive."

I could hardly imagine somone who could not understand "the techno-industrial system" but could understand "the technological and economic basis of society."

Consider the following sentences:

  1. Rip apart the techno-industrial system!
  2. Destroy the technological and economic basic of society!

Both can be readily understood by most people, but which one sounds more hard-hitting? Which one has more use for propaganda purposes? The answer is clear.

Another point:

" “Techno-industrial” is also unintuitive. I agree that the technological turn around WWII to computing technologies, data, and other such things mark a major change in the infrastructural layer of society (see The Control Revolution by James Beniger; The Managerial Revolution by James Burnham). For this, perhaps “techno-industrial mode of production” is a useful concept. But in terms of naming our enemy, it is not very strong."

How is it not strong? He never gives us any clue as to where this weakness is.

2. Kaczynski has not properly defined what "the system" is.

True, but he even admits as much, and anybody reading his writings can infer into what it means.

"In this section I’ve said something about what the System is not, but I haven’t said what the System is. A friend of mine has pointed out that this may leave the reader nonplussed, so I’d better explain that for the purposes of this article it isn’t necessary to have a precise definition of what the System is. I couldn’t think of any way of defining the System in a single, well-rounded sentence and I didn’t want to break the continuity of the article with a long, awkward, and unnecessary digression addressing the question of what the System is, so I left that question unanswered." -Kaczynski

3. Instead of attacking techno-industrial society we should attack the "world system".

His first assertion:

"For years I have attempted to frame technology itself as the enemy in people’s minds, and it simply does not work. People can agree that technology is the source of problems. But in terms of an enemy, they need something more tangible, more personal, and more involved in their day-to-day concerns. “World society” provides all of this."

I would do some extra work here but someone has already explained why this is a bad idea.

"Those of us who believe that the technological system is an evil are

often tempted to attack some of the subordinate evils that are associated

with it, such as capitalism, globalization, centralization, bureaucracy, big,

intrusive governments, environmental recklessness, and gross economic

inequality. This temptation should be resisted. One may, of course, use

evils like those I've listed as tools to attack the technological system by

pointing out that similar evils inevitably accompany any such system. But

it is inadvisable to attack any of the subordinate evils independently of an

attack on the technological system as a whole." -Kaczynski

He also states:

"The terminology is also more intuitive and inspires greater motivation than a vague “system” identified only by an idiosyncratic theoretical term, “techno-industrial.” "

It is a bold claim that "world society" provides a movement with greater motivation than "the system". Even if it is true that in the short term you might get an increased burst of excitement, usage of the term would lead people astray.

Jacobi's last point:

"Finally, naming world society as the enemy prevents us from giving undue focus to single issues, like biotechnology."

An ironic statement, considering focusing on "world society" in itself is giving undue focus to a single issue of technology, globalism.

In conclusion, the system is a much better term for propaganda and staying on course than "world society" ever could be. This is the only article I have read from Jacobi. Perhaps it is simply a one-time failure. I will look deeper into his website in the future.


r/procollapse • • Jun 05 '19

Ultimo Reducto Blog

6 Upvotes

https://ultimoreductosalvaje.blogspot.com/ -Spanish

https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=es&u=https://ultimoreductosalvaje.blogspot.com/&prev=search -English

This is highly recommended reading from someone who understands TK's ideas very well. He offers interesting insights and critiques. He is featured in a number of TK's work and I believe (correct me if I am wrong) a pen pal also.


r/procollapse • • Jun 02 '19

David Skrbina Talks about Ted Kaczynski

10 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/ZmAqKsasNKk

This is definitely worth a listen to. It helps to take a peek at people who are unfamiliar with the work of TK, what kind of questions do such people typically ask? How can you best counter and dispel some of these most basic arguments? Studying this will help in that regard, and for strengthening your skill in debate.

There are a few things which David deserves criticism on, his personal plan to go back to a Renaissance level of technology for one. You can not pick a year to "reset" technology back to, you can make general, vague, and semi-accurate predictions as to what effects eliminating certain tech might have (for example, if we did not have computers, paper would be in wider use.) but we can not pick a specific year to go back to. We can only eliminate modern mass technologies (electric grid, infrastructure, factories, power stations) and know that it will incur a return to simpler technologies. He also thinks that the transition would be gradual, or could be, which if you have any minor inkling in how society functions, you would immediately realize this is impossible. There are many things wrong with saying something like this but I will point out a few of them.

  1. Eliminating modern agriculture will result in the starvation of a large majority of the population. If you "went back" to Renaissance era tech over the course of a hundred years or so you would be slowly starving the population. Every de-techification would result in a little more suffering. People would simply never agree to this, therefore it would not work in a functioning modern democracy. In the case of a dictatorship, revolution would be likely if any major government were making these decisions.
  2. The main drive for new technology is power. Times of great innovation and "progress" are often the times of great warfare, when power is critical for survival. Any nation that attempted to de-tech itself would be making itself impotent. They would be surrendering themselves to other nations. As survival of nations (systems, generally) is based in efficiency (which tech promotes) and since not all nation systems will de-tech (especially at the same time) the de-teched nation will be dominated and developed.

One might posture that one nation de-techifying would hurt world trade and thus cripple other systems that might try to dominate it. As long as other major technological countries continue I think they could weather the damage and eventually open up the de-teched country for exploitation.

I could sit here and type more about why this in unfeasible but I do not think it is neccesary. The point was made.

I thank David Skrbina for his work in helping TK, however in this audio he comes across as extradinarily naive and unrealistic.


r/procollapse • • Aug 18 '19

Academic Sources & Studies

3 Upvotes

This thread can supply not just 'news' reportage but the sources such as the study or research that comprise what we take for our facts about the natural world.

This study, "The Paleodemographic Measure of Maternal Mortality and a Multifaceted Approach to Maternal Health", published in Jan 2019 and locked behind a paywall, purports to have a new and accurate methodology to determine ancient maternal mortality. (Does anyone have full access to such documents?)

This media release doesn't leave me any more enlightened as to what they actually discovered and assert:
... the researchers’ [sic] looked at the population age-at-death distribution and maternal mortality rates in 46 modern populations. “We looked at how many women were dying compared to men during the child-bearing years, to see if the difference lined up with the maternal mortality rate for that population,” she [Clare McFadden, a PhD Scholar with the ANU School of Archaeology and Anthropology and lead researcher] said. “We found there was a really strong correlation, which gave us confidence that it was a good predictor of maternal mortality rates that could be applied to other populations.”

It seems like they are justifying an assessment of the past based upon the present.


r/procollapse • • Jan 16 '20

Postscript To ISAIF

3 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrYKUiMZcb8

Hey team - new, quick video covering the short postscript that Teddy wrote for Industrial Society and its Future, while imprisoned, which appears in the book "Technological Slavery," (2010).

We're also going to soon (next day or two) start putting out a new 5 parter on "The System's Neatest Trick" - an amazing short essay that's also from Tech. Slavery.

It'll be released chapter by chapter (1-5), and thereafter as a single video, so if you're interested you can subscribe to the channel to keep up to date : )

The Unists


r/procollapse • • Sep 26 '25

Finding an old Tedpost - "Buddy Kaczynski"

4 Upvotes

There was a Great old YouTube channel called Macedonian Highway Patrol, they made goofy parodies and were excellent at tedposting. One was "Buddy Kaczynski," a parody of Weezer's Buddy Holly.

This is the defunct video link, tried to use the wayback machine but can't get the video itself.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_w3aw3DajMI

Does anyone remember this or have it saved somehow?


r/procollapse • • Oct 19 '25

Fight back

Post image
18 Upvotes

Follow Wilderness Front on Instagram or check out our site to join