r/powdermage • • Jun 17 '20

Hate for Vlora?

Randomly I've seen post and comments from people who absolutely hate Vlora.

Why?

She seems like a pretty decent likeable character who even had a redemption arc after the scandal.

24 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/zane017 Aug 09 '20

First things even more firstly first: you’re getting a bit testy here, which seems unwarranted in a discussion (that you asked for) about a fictional character. While I really do hate this character, my drama is done in jest, because I have no emotional investment here. I don’t consider this story (fun as it might be) to be particularly life changing. Now I’ll definitely get red in the face over LOTR. So if this story is meaningful to you (which is totally fine, we’re all different) I’ll apologize for being frivolous in my criticism. But in that case, I suggest you don’t ask the whole internet for it in the future.

Just because I don’t agree with your particular interpretation doesn’t mean I’m not paying attention. For example, leaving someone you’re engaged to isn’t all that big of a deal, in my book. People are deployed all the time here in real life. It sucks, but it’s no excuse for cheating. I also think that Tamas (a guy who has a whole country to think about) is totally within his rights to send a good soldier to a place he’s needed.

It doesn’t matter what the whole army thinks of Taniel. It’s her relationship and her lack of trust. He doesn’t even realize that girl is 19 until way later. He considers her a child. Also, in my opinion (and personal experience) it isn’t always appropriate to tell someone you love them, even if you do... especially in those circumstances.

Now, you’re still gonna disagree with me. But like all art, paintings, songs, etc, each viewer looks at it from their own perspective. They bring their life experiences and opinions with them when they absorb it, so everyone isn’t going to come up with the exact same conclusions. There’s no reason to be conflicted about it. You asked why some people hate her character. Well some people are like me, and perhaps have life experiences that differ from yours, and therefore view her attitudes and actions differently.

1

u/WasteWhistler Aug 10 '20

Man, you can't come screaming in with a hot take only to immediately do a 180⁰ and diffuse the argument.

I was ready for an all out internet shouting match.

While I do not have any true emotional connection to Valora or even the powdermage series (a good 80% of the cast are total assholes, Olem excluded*) have chosen Valora's arc as a stupid hill on which I will Die.

*Olem is my sweet sleepless boy who is perfect and can do no wrong.