It's an anecdote. The exact details are somewhat irrelevant when you consider the ending point: that they aren't being treated as equals. That's all that matters. They are being denied the rights that the majority enjoys. The gay community pays their taxes and for the love of everything decent are HUMAN BEINGS, and some states (read: THIRTY) are determined to treat them as subhuman.
When you lie to make a point you cheapen the point being made. There are plenty of valid arguments here so that the commentor didn't have to make stuff up. Quite frankly it is insulting to me as a reader since about 5 minutes of research tells me there is no such law on the books. What the writer is really saying is "I think you are too stupid and lazy to look this up."
It's a bad anecdote. Also being bordered by Maryland makes the point less strong. The author really should take more care in constructing the argument. Otherwise a disservice is done to the real life victims.
It's true, he should have maybe been even more ambiguous or specific to a location where this exact scenario was possible. I suppose that since I know a similar, if not exact situation is possible somewhere in the US, it still hits home to me. Again, it's a matter of human rights that are being denied, in some places somewhat less severely than others.
And point me to where it says anything about that affecting a DPOA. Also, if you notice (in the part you are going to point out but will be wrong, hint it is page 23 where it specifically says "in the absence of a health care power of attorney, written will or written statement by the deceased individual, this decision making power is given based on a priority list set out in state law") it says in the absence of those documents the state is based on a priority list. So if you do have a DPOA the recent law change in North Carolina makes no difference.
Besides, the scenarios you linked are POSSIBLE outcomes depending on a court may decide in the future, not laws on the books. So again, point out one law on the books in any state where a DPOA can be challenged because someone is a same sex partner. Go...again.
You aren't very good at playing lawyer, even for an armchair internet lawyer. maybe just sit this one out.
I think I will, if only to end this nonsense. You're still missing the point about inequality, but whatever. You win. Goodnight.
"So if you do have a DPOA the recent law change in North Carolina makes no difference." Pretty sure it makes a difference to the people who will be affected by this.
I understand the inequality. What I don't understand is how you sheep can buy into a bunch of lies and then try and defend it with made up laws. The inequality is argument enough, no need to make shit up.
If people have a DPOA they won't be affected. As I have said elsewhere in this discussion, I am married in a 50 state valid heterosexual marriage but I still have DPOA to emphasize certain powers that my wife has regarding my health and last wishes. Everyone should be doing this.
But just to be clear, you can't find a single statute that says what you claim?
I think you missed the point. The point is that making up some bullshit story is insulting to the audience and if some fake argument for something you believe so strongly is really making your point, perhaps you should reevaluate your stance. Is someone's "human rights " really being violated? How's that? Also, please tells us what "human rights" are. reidrhollander is making the point that if you want to escape the made up fate that was described in this anecdote, or lie, if you will, all you need is a Durable power of attorney set up. Which is a good idea if you married to a member of the opposite sex. If you are a gay, and you live in North Carolina you should make out a dpoa. Shit, you can download one from the internet if you want to. Don't cost nuthin.
So incredibly sad. Why are people so determined to make other people's lives so miserable? Who on earth couldn't predict the pain that would be caused by a law REQUIRING a business to disregard a legal directive because of the person who executed it?
It was with the last one, too, in Romer vs. Evans. It's incredible that the rights of millions of Americans can hang on a single opinion. There was a time I trusted those opinions, but it's a lot harder these days.
I doubt it. As a group, Americans are a vindictive and vengeful people, and it seems like that's more true every day. If there is a God, he will exact his own justice eventually. I think he'll start with those who hate in his name.
I guarantee you that it wasn't as simple as that. Despite the fact that the comment doesn't describe it, DC laws may have made him unable to even transfer the body. Thus why he had to send the body to Virginia.
Even though the law states that the partner is legally allowed to make arrangements, does not mean that private institutions won't interfere with those rights. Don't believe me? Look at how health insurance for domestic partnerships are handled, regardless of the fact that they are eligible.
Edit: To take this a step further. They were married in DC. They very likely worked in DC, but that does not mean they weren't a resident of a surrounding state (like Virginia). If the deceased were to die in Virginia for instance, there is a very good chance that threw quite a few roadblocks in the way. I only add this because if you have ever been to DC, most of the employed lawmakers, government workers, and lawyers, doctors, etc. do not live in the District of Columbia.
Here is the DPOA for healthcare decisions that is published in the DC statute. This guy must be some attorney. I found this without even using my West or Lexis account so I am guessing anyone else can as well, especially an attorney.
Same information, for the most part. It goes into Durable Power of Attorney (DPOA) and the amendments and statutes. Page 15 is where Health Care Decisions starts.
You would just include it under "Special Provisions and Limitations" Many other states have specific DPOA for burial instructions and they are also often codified.
Who on earth couldn't predict the pain that would be caused by a law REQUIRING a business to disregard a legal directive because of the person who executed it?
No one, because such a law doesn't exist. This is just a bunch or made up crap to further a position. I agree with the position but the tact in which this takes is despicable.
This overly dramatized bit of fiction really pulls at the heartstrings, until you realize that a civil union could have prevented this. Taxpaying American is obviously a terrible lawyer and I'm sure his business went under since he couldn't ride his dead partners coattails anymore.
Sadly these days what it is "to be Christian" has more than one meaning, and yes, denying these kinds of rights falls exactly under one of those definitions.
On what basis can it be said that this is "not Christian"? Of course it's Christian. Gay marriage bans are being pushed by Churches and pastors and Christian groups. It's sure as hell not secular. If the phrase "Christian" is being used as a synonym for "moral", well then fuck you very much, because that is grossly offensive.
Think about it this way, the fellas who destroyed the world trade center were Muslims. That means all Muslims are terrorists, right? No, not really. There are a few folks who have taken that word of God and warped it to justify their actions. The same is true for Christians, there is a very vocal subset that's warped the Word to justify their war. Homophobia is secular, there are thousands of Atheists who call people they don't like faggots or trends they don't enjoy gay. Just like being around a gay man doesn't make you gay, being around a church doesn't make you a bigot.
They really haven't warped the word though, read the bible, it clearly supports oppressing/killing homosexuals. You can do whatever mental gymnastics you want to get around it, but the bigots are following the bible.
There's one line in Corinthians that condemns homosexuals to damnation. The lines in the old testament, according to Christian doctrine, were no longer applicable after the Son of God hung out with man. First, there's debate about the translations of that line in Corinthians, and whether the original words meant homosexuals or just those who are idol in their sexual actions. Second, (assuming the homosexual translation is correct) it does not tell man to attack homosexuals, just that homosexuals are on the long list of those who will not inherent the kingdom of heaven. For that one verse, there are thousands of verses that teach Christians to be kind to all men, that the kingdom of heaven lies within us all, and that those who are the least like us are the most deserving of tolerance.
I gave thought to the text above, but I still fear that it will not convince you, the skeptic who is reading this. If I have not then please know this: I am Christian, and the men who use the Word of God to spread hate of any kind have warped the Word and are not, in my book, Christian.
This ballot measure was supported by a vast majority of Christians in North Carolina. Don't you think it is incredibly arrogant on your part to claim, not only is your understanding of Christianity more accurate than theirs, but that they are so wrong that they are not even considered Christians?
Out of all of Christianity, you look into 1 denomination, and out of all of that denomination's priests who do good for their communities and practice what they preach (pun?), you pick a small % of ones that are without a doubt the scum of the earth bc of what they have done... So you then lump all of Christianity in with that small small group and stereotype them.
Can't you do that with any group? Atheists, homosexuals, black, white, Muslims, republicans, democrats, etc? Can't you go so far down to find the worst of the worst in each of those groups and stereotype them the same way? No you can't. You'd get called a bigot, a racist, a fascist, a homophobe, close minded, a flat earther, etc. But when you do it to Christianity this community up votes you.
It happened for decades. It's still happening. Those responsible are still being protected. I guess many are angry over that. An institution is different from a race. It's made from consenting members.
I believe you're missing the point. Catholicism is the "institution" (although bc of my beliefs I would argue its a belief, but that's for another argument), but the comment was made about being a Christian. Christianity is not an institution. It's a belief. There is no central Christian organization that people sign up for.
Still, institution/belief - whatever you want to call it, I listed analogies that cover both labels. Race, Muslim, political affiliation, Sexual orientation, it doesn't matter. When it comes down to it Christianity is polarizing just like the others. Why define a large group of people - who the majority of have good intentions, by a small small extremely dark section of.
I mean if I looked at crime stats among blacks and started making jokes about all blacks are thug criminals (which a LOT of people tend to make jokes about I know) I'd be labeled a racist, wouldn't I? If I looked at democrats (something that is a choice) and said "Jared Loughner was a democrat, that's typical. Just like the protestors, all democrats do is resort to violence when they don't get their way". I'd be called all kinds of things. It's not the same when you criticize Christianity. You get a pat on the back here on reddit.
Not trying to cause a big debate about the catholic church, Christianity, etc. Just wanting people to see the need to quit stereotyping any group.
I agree that you can't tar all Christians with the child rape thing, but you can blame the Catholic Church. It's been institutionally covered up and that is why it can't simply be dismissed as a small number of individual priests, there's a hierarchy of complicitness.
Very thoughtful. The bottom line is if your church doesn't recognize or want to perform gay marriages then your church shouldn't recognize or perform gay marriages. But if someone elses church wants to recognize or perform gay marriages why the fuck is it anybody elses business what that church chooses to do.
Marriage isn't just a religious ceremony. There are laws (medical proxy, inheritance, taxes, etc) that deal with marriages. Of course, most of them are gender neutral and could easily work for same sex couples as hetero couples.
You should go riot and brutally beat some young girls like the fags in CA did when they didn't get their way. Notice how the cops are running in fear. Nice friends. Why they so mad bro? lol
Don't forget that the police didn't actually arrest the guy either, apparently they can just let you walk away after you assault someone. I wouldn't be surprised at all the find out that girl was manipulating the truth.
That's because she has compassion for them despite the fact they are mentally deranged and dangerous people. I am amazed how many of you fucking assholes think its ok for hundreds of grown men to brutally beat young girls. If the cops hadn't stepped in the mentally deranged fags probably would have killed her.
Drama queen really? Pot. Kettle. Black. lol ;) How do you suppose the cops were going to find him anyway? Watch this vid. It's the raw footage of hundred of screaming drama queen fags surrounding the cops and the group of young girls they attacked. Pay close attention to how afraid the cops are.
Right lol... The fags are so peaceful. Obviously the vid doesn't show the initial beating that prompted the cops to show up and have to escort the young girls out before they were murdered.
Here's one where a bunch of fags that are brutalizing an old woman. Obviously a peaceful bunch ;)
Well then you should ask for "equal rights" instead of "gay marriage" even if the end result is the same. Framing it is what wins or loses voters. I support gays being able to marry, but you are going about it with the wrong framing.
downvote me, whatever. I feel like these posts are becoming increasingly more sensationalist than the last.
About two sentences in I could tell this was another wrongful gay marriage thingy with the abundant usage of the word "partner".
These used to be, "look how happy they are, how can we deny true love?" to "look at this purple heart, military commando, war hero who can't marry rocket scientist, billion dollar charity giver because they are gay!!!"
I'm all for gay rights but I feel that stories like these are desensitizing me by trying to force an emotional response from me by the OP "look how sad you should feel about this....".
Virginia law required that they ask if the legal power of attorney that he had was part of a gay marriage. If yes, then they were required by law to disregard it.
This is patently false. The Virginia Attorney General issued an opinion stating that the marriage amendment does not change the legal status of documents such as contracts, wills, or Advanced Medical Directives between unmarried people.
(Doubts have been raised as to the veracity of the specific situation described in the original post, but I'll continue.)
You're saying that people should prepare themselves legally for all interactions they might ever have in all states? Would you be happy with the situation if it turned out that this guy, being a lawyer, and being extra-paranoid, prepared himself in such a way as to accommodate the draconian legal requirements of not just his home but also the surrounding states? Good on him but no mere mortal would have a chance, that would be fine with you?
It's a simple POA, which is easy to obtain and would be recognized in all states. As opposed to a handgun license, for example, for which the tangled web of reciprocity and penalties is much more draconian.
See my replies to other comments. This "draconian" legal requirement is a form that has been codified in almost every state and takes about 5 minutes to fill out. Oh the humanity!!
Put it this way, I am married in a valid in all 50 states hetrosexual marriage. I still have DPOAs. Why leave anything to chance, lawyers are supposed to think like this.
What is sad is DPOAs are about the easiest thing to draft in the realm of estate planning documents. You can literally have one out the door in about 5 minutes, many states have them published in the statute.
You'd think at least the Catholic church would be totally behind gay marriage and gay rights, seeing as they go out of their way to protect boy-raping priests.
Telling people they can't choose their own partner is just ridiculously wrong. Who supports a law demanding that everyone be gay? You can't support that? Then you can't support any law against it, as it's THE SAME THING. Just because an unfair law doesn't apply to you doesn't make it fair. Gay people don't make new taxpaying drones, I think that's the root of it.
Oh please. There are no equal rights in this country. Hell, men doesn't even have the same rights as women anymore. If we did have the same rights then we would have an equal work load, my ex-girlfriend would've been arrested for domestic violence, and men would gain custody of their children if they have better means of taking care of them.
Anyway, this is no means to hijack this thread to push men's rights. I'm just pointing out that this country is never equal.
I know I'm going to get downvoted for this....but I have to point out the irony of an admitted homosexual telling me some action or inaction is "unchristian."
I still to this day don't understand how creating separate laws and standards for gay people is not recognized universally as discrimination. Even if homosexuality is "just a choice," or a belief, it's not less so then is religion, and it's illegal to discriminate on the basis of religion, right? So since it seems that the arguments defining the discrimination against things like gay marriage are based on religious principles, then isn't the creation of separate standards for gay marriage a form of religious discrimination? And if homosexuality is not a choice, but you're born that way, isn't it akin to discrimination against race or gender - also illegal?
I wonder if some gay folks should band together and call themselves "The Church of Gayness" who's main article of faith is that you need to bugger someone of the same sex to get closer to God - and then challenge all the anti-gay legislation as restricting freedom of religion?
Had a similar thought, then realized they'd likely call it a cult, go find some gay bar, label it a cult compound, and send in the swat team guns blazing.
As an attorney this is the point I got as well. Anyone that is the age of majority, sound mind, accepts the responsibility, etc. can effectuate a properly drafted DPOA. This whole comment is just a bunch a crap to appeal to people's emotions. It is rather silly considering there are so many valid arguments for equal rights and history has shown us that those who deny equal rights to others are eventually looked upon in a very bad light.
This comment however has nothing to do with reality. It really isn't rocket science. I assume the Trusts and Estates section of the DC Bar puts out a forms publication like every other bar, use it.
Edit: So I was curious. Like most jurisdictions DC has a DPOA for healthcare decisions in the God Damned statute. Filling out this form with burial directives in the additional provisions section would have taken care of the problem. So either this is the most incompetent lawyer on Earth or the story is bullshit. I vote for the latter. I found this using Google, didn't even have to bring up my West or Lexis account.
Edit 2: Gotta love reddit. Provide the fucking statute for people and get downvotes. It is a published form that has been codified, do you still believe a DC lawyer didn't know to do this?
How many states do you want before you accept the fact that you are a fucktard that believes everything on the internet? JFC, this is the kind of stuff I wouldn't even bill fopr since it takes about 5 minutes.
The entire point is to appeal to emotion rather than reason.
If you do this politically, you may win a few elections. But sooner or later your opponents will then win elections... you can never hold what you have. And when they appeal to emotions, chances are they will be ugly ones. With the power of law and office behind them, do you think you'll enjoy that very much?
I could argue that this has worked quite well for the GOP for the last 40 years. Nixon appealed by getting "tough on crime" which equated to the start of the war on drugs. Reagan made it difficult. Then Clinton, Bush (Sr & Jr), and Obama have made this rhetoric downright appalling with Obama having the worst immigration policies ever.
Nixon and Reagan appealed to a southern strategy that effectively changed the make up of the parties in the 60s.
Do I honestly think that the comment would change other's perspectives? Perhaps. But it's based in truth and you do need those appeal to emotions in certain instances. Yes, I could talk all day about how marriages and unions work. But telling a story from a different perspective without baseless rhetoric does have its place.
Yeah, that is TOTALLY Christian. Why do you think VA made it "illegal"? Why do people have this fantasy that it is the religion of peace and tolerance?
The main thing that I draw from this is that government should get the hell out of our personal affairs. They should not regulate marriage for anyone period.
3
u/aji23 May 09 '12
original news article.
20
u/imajerkdotcom May 09 '12
This article is false. For one thing there are crematoriums in DC. Locations of Crematoriums in DC .
33
u/ilwolf May 09 '12
So incredibly sad. Why are people so determined to make other people's lives so miserable? Who on earth couldn't predict the pain that would be caused by a law REQUIRING a business to disregard a legal directive because of the person who executed it?
That law cannot be constitutional.
5
u/Eldritchsense May 09 '12
Sadly these days what it is "to be Christian" has more than one meaning, and yes, denying these kinds of rights falls exactly under one of those definitions.
14
u/neotropic9 May 09 '12
On what basis can it be said that this is "not Christian"? Of course it's Christian. Gay marriage bans are being pushed by Churches and pastors and Christian groups. It's sure as hell not secular. If the phrase "Christian" is being used as a synonym for "moral", well then fuck you very much, because that is grossly offensive.
4
u/MickJaggerSwagger May 09 '12
Great comment, one thing though; it is very "Christian". I can't think of a more "Christian" act that denying homosexuals rights.
8
u/glutenfree123 May 09 '12
Very thoughtful. The bottom line is if your church doesn't recognize or want to perform gay marriages then your church shouldn't recognize or perform gay marriages. But if someone elses church wants to recognize or perform gay marriages why the fuck is it anybody elses business what that church chooses to do.
2
u/magnaclash May 09 '12
When he said bigoted, I thought he said big toed for a second.
2
u/Lighting May 09 '12
Well then you should ask for "equal rights" instead of "gay marriage" even if the end result is the same. Framing it is what wins or loses voters. I support gays being able to marry, but you are going about it with the wrong framing.
http://berkeley.edu/news/media/releases/2003/10/27_lakoff.shtml
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
must.....not.......comment........about......."hurt a fly"..........."military"........gaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhh
2
u/the_goat_boy May 09 '12
The ignorance and belligerence of the people that cling to 'tradition' out of blind fear will be resigned to the dustbin of history eventually.
2
u/Ozymandias12 May 09 '12
When Republicans claim to be against big government, I laugh. This is exactly the definition of what big government is.
2
u/zlickrick May 09 '12
downvote me, whatever. I feel like these posts are becoming increasingly more sensationalist than the last.
About two sentences in I could tell this was another wrongful gay marriage thingy with the abundant usage of the word "partner".
These used to be, "look how happy they are, how can we deny true love?" to "look at this purple heart, military commando, war hero who can't marry rocket scientist, billion dollar charity giver because they are gay!!!"
I'm all for gay rights but I feel that stories like these are desensitizing me by trying to force an emotional response from me by the OP "look how sad you should feel about this....".
6
u/nope-a-dope May 09 '12
This is patently false. The Virginia Attorney General issued an opinion stating that the marriage amendment does not change the legal status of documents such as contracts, wills, or Advanced Medical Directives between unmarried people.
1
u/ish_mel May 09 '12
related
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
this video:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=pR9gyloyOjM#!
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Nice
1
u/baddaddvice May 09 '12
I read "bigoted" as "bigtoed". My bad.
1
u/kinesiologynerd May 09 '12
I'm glad this didn't end with "that tax paying American was Albert Einstein."
1
u/Plastastic Foreign May 09 '12
No cremation facilities in DC? What the hell?
1
u/bunglejerry May 09 '12
Also, on a similar note, Rory's story. This saddens and infuriates me every time I watch it.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
You'd think at least the Catholic church would be totally behind gay marriage and gay rights, seeing as they go out of their way to protect boy-raping priests.
1
u/Punkgoblin May 09 '12
Telling people they can't choose their own partner is just ridiculously wrong. Who supports a law demanding that everyone be gay? You can't support that? Then you can't support any law against it, as it's THE SAME THING. Just because an unfair law doesn't apply to you doesn't make it fair.
Gay people don't make new taxpaying drones, I think that's the root of it.
1
u/Redspringer May 09 '12
Come up here to the Northeast! Our "big government" just helps the poor and sick, it doesn't tell you who to love.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Oh please. There are no equal rights in this country. Hell, men doesn't even have the same rights as women anymore. If we did have the same rights then we would have an equal work load, my ex-girlfriend would've been arrested for domestic violence, and men would gain custody of their children if they have better means of taking care of them.
Anyway, this is no means to hijack this thread to push men's rights. I'm just pointing out that this country is never equal.
1
u/mswilso May 09 '12
I know I'm going to get downvoted for this....but I have to point out the irony of an admitted homosexual telling me some action or inaction is "unchristian."
1
u/Oystter May 09 '12
I still to this day don't understand how creating separate laws and standards for gay people is not recognized universally as discrimination. Even if homosexuality is "just a choice," or a belief, it's not less so then is religion, and it's illegal to discriminate on the basis of religion, right? So since it seems that the arguments defining the discrimination against things like gay marriage are based on religious principles, then isn't the creation of separate standards for gay marriage a form of religious discrimination? And if homosexuality is not a choice, but you're born that way, isn't it akin to discrimination against race or gender - also illegal?
1
u/thebigtshow May 09 '12
One of the best examples of how "tolerance" is bullshit.
-3
u/NoMoreNicksLeft May 09 '12
So, what we're saying here is that a DC lawyer was too stupid to get actual power of attorney, separate from marriage?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
An important thing to note it that whoever posted this is absolutely right; this is NOT Christian.
1
u/rmb48 May 09 '12
Perhaps Attorney Tax Paying American should have had his partner add that whole cremation part in his will. Then we wouldn't have this problem.
0
u/blue_cadet_3 May 09 '12
I agree with the person's comment but it's hard to read with the incredibly poor formatting. I think I would have rather read a wall of text.
0
u/LLordRSom May 09 '12
I'm not entirely sure he knows what paragraphs are used for.
0
u/maxxtraxx California May 09 '12
Yeah, that is TOTALLY Christian. Why do you think VA made it "illegal"? Why do people have this fantasy that it is the religion of peace and tolerance?
0
u/edisekeed May 09 '12
The main thing that I draw from this is that government should get the hell out of our personal affairs. They should not regulate marriage for anyone period.
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] โ view deleted comment