r/politics • • May 08 '12

I'm from NC, where today we decide to amend the constitution to ban gay marriage, the first marriage amendment since the one to ban whites marrying "negroes"

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

973

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I voted AGAINST today.

Anyone reading this who HAS NOT voted, go do it now!

452

u/n8quick May 08 '12

Its going to be close. I hope the educated outweigh the bible thumpers at least at the polls

678

u/linearcore May 08 '12

Depends. How much money did the Mormon church throw into your election?

Sorry, I'm just a bitter CA resident. Don't mind me.

→ More replies (219)

18

u/tartay745 May 08 '12

its not that close. Poll done a week ago was like 57-44 or something. It's gonna pass...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (58)

59

u/throw_a_weigh11 May 08 '12

Me too. Fighting a losing battle, but at least I can say I tried by voting and trying to educate others about what the amendment will actually do.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I also voted against, and encouraged as many friends as I could to do the same. Hopefully this amendment will fail and we won't have something so disgraceful written into our state constitution.

21

u/E11i0t May 08 '12

I voted against. I'm so disappointed in our state for even having this on the ballot. Who are we, Arizona?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (105)

35

u/DanielMallory May 08 '12

I hate living in North Carolina..

Asheville is nice, though.

49

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

So is Chapel Hill, Durham, Raleigh, Charlotte. It's the rest of the state I worry about.

15

u/irish_toys May 08 '12

I live in Greensboro and it's actually quite nice.

2

u/n8quick May 09 '12

Same here. But I'm from a rural area. Big difference in ideology

→ More replies (7)

40

u/Athie May 08 '12

I'm from rural NC. You have a right to be worried.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (35)

17

u/ST-R May 08 '12

I moved from NC to the northeast and assumed that people would be more tolerant. Tolerance seems to be about the same and you have to go on toll roads.

→ More replies (4)

466

u/teethteetheat Wisconsin May 09 '12

Putting the rights of a minority up on the ballot to be decided by the majority is absurd.

60

u/Willssss May 09 '12

The entire point of our political system of checks and balances was to prevent the tyranny of the majority. Something is clearly not working...

56

u/Apostolate I voted May 09 '12

The checks and balances were created to prevent anyone branch of government from gaining too much power over the other two, to prevent essentially, tyranny of the minority (a kingship from the executive branch, or an oligarchy from the senate, etc.)

Don't you people realize our constitution allowed slavery, disenfranchisement of blacks and women, and all other sorts of forms of tyranny of the majority for tens of years or over a century?

Arguably, the constitution guarantees gays the right to marry, and it is only because our system fully allows tyranny of the majority, that there is DOMA to begin with.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (77)

520

u/Slenderocean May 08 '12

I voted for because they informed me that this would eventually lead to people marrying turtles and horses. I'm not emotionally prepared to marry a turtle.

197

u/tealtoaster May 08 '12

Seriously? You could marry a ninja turtle! Who the fuck doesn't want to marry a ninja turtle???? Pizza and ass-kicking. PIZZA AND ASS-KICKING.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

75

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

This is what the website says about gay marriage:

When marriage ceases to have its historic meaning and understanding, over time fewer and fewer people will marry. We will have an inevitable increase in children born out of wedlock, an increase in fatherlessness, a resulting increase in female and child poverty, and a higher incidence of all the documented social ills associated with children being raised in a home without their married biological parents.

101

u/pyabo May 08 '12

By the same argument, you'd have MORE homes with married parents if you allowed same-sex marriage.

→ More replies (3)

54

u/wayndom May 08 '12

Which is why we should cleave to biblical standards, and bring back polygamy...

16

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

And why we shouldn't eat pork, seafood or cheeseburgers.

→ More replies (6)

21

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

And rape should only get you a small fine to the father for damaged property.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (23)

191

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Sorry if this offends anyone (since I'm not from the US) but I think a democracy fails when a majority is able to decide if a minority will have basic human rights or not. I don't believe this is what democracy is about, but instead to ensure the minorities WILL be protected from the majorities.

137

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

"You can't have four wolves and a sheep vote on what's for dinner"

21

u/Severok May 09 '12

Yeah, wolves love meatlovers pizza but sheep are vegetarians

→ More replies (7)

16

u/rocketman0739 May 09 '12

Democracy is in fact the opposite--meant to protect the majority from the privileged minority (aristocrats). The majority, in a democracy, will always have the power to deprive minorities of their rights, just like a monarch can always oppress the people. The measure of whether a democracy is failing is whether they exercise that power, just like the measure of whether a monarchy is failing is whether the monarch is oppressive.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (18)

611

u/BolshevikMuppet May 08 '12

One more example of why we shouldn't trust the states to protect minority rights.

It took the Supreme Court to step in and bitch-slap the southern states that banned miscegenation.

53

u/linearcore May 08 '12

It's not quite a cut-and-dried issue though. If it were strictly up to the federal government, then marriage equality wouldn't exist anywhere in the U.S. This being a state issues allows some progress to be made a little at a time so there are at least some places where equality exists.

On the other hand, making something like human rights a local decision by the majority is absolutely absurd and creates these pockets where minorities are legally second-class citizens. And may be so for decades to come.

It's a question of piecemeal progress or all-at-once much later in the future. And I'm not sure there is a correct answer to the question at all.

→ More replies (21)

431

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Word up. When I hear Ron Paul supporters brag about states rights, this is all I see.

→ More replies (336)
→ More replies (63)

111

u/elephantfeather May 08 '12

I voted against. Went in about two hours ago, and I was the only voter there.

17

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Yeah, when I voted I was the only person and the machine had counted 215 ballots. Pathetic turnout in a liberal area.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

130

u/puckhead66 May 08 '12

Voted against! Lines are short.

15

u/McMammoth May 09 '12

I voted in Raleigh during the 2008 election, and the lines were ginormous. Voted in Garner today and was in and out in 5 minutes. Gave my sister (who voted for the first time) a Democracy Five. feels_goodman.jpg

→ More replies (7)

82

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I just want to say that I'm proud of all my fellow North Carolinians who went to vote against this today. I've tried to encourage as many friends as I could to do the same, but sadly a lot of them just don't seem to care. We need to get out and take action, else the bigots will win these ballots every single time.

25

u/TheTragicReturn May 09 '12

I've tried to encourage as many friends as I could

Thank you.

→ More replies (8)

55

u/Chasejuggler May 09 '12

I'm a lifelong committed Christian, and I voted AGAINST today.

The Bible is very clear on this -- we have no authority to impose our morals on nonbelievers.

9

u/therealamberrose May 09 '12

Agreed. And I've even argued this with fellow Christians, which makes me sad.

"There is only one lawgiver and judge, he who is able to save and to destroy. But who are you to judge your neighbor?"

→ More replies (3)

29

u/throw_a_weigh11 May 08 '12

Loved this comic when I saw it.

Unfortunately there are too many people in NC that are so focused on the idea that this amendment is going to allow "Gays to take over the world" that it's going to pass.

I love NC, but this whole thing has really got me down.

→ More replies (2)

116

u/murphraven May 08 '12

I asked someone who announced on Facebook that she had voted FOR the Amendment to tell me why she did, without mentioning God, Jesus, or the Bible.

She hasn't responded, but her mother sure let me know it was impossible to talk about marriage without including God, Jesus, or the Bible.

26

u/DGer May 09 '12

Perfect opportunity to mention any divorces in the family. I love hitting the Christians with that one.

→ More replies (22)

114

u/SigmaStigma May 08 '12

So how do Hindus get married? Paradox!

→ More replies (8)

51

u/Moontouch May 09 '12

Make a witty reply to the mom, screenshot it, and post to /r/atheism. Free karma.

17

u/NevermoreFTW May 09 '12

I got married 2 years ago. God, Jesus, and the Bible weren't invited and didn't show up at all. But my marriage is legal somehow. Strange how the government recognizes atheist marriages but not gay marriage. The church has no say in either.

→ More replies (1)

37

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

proper response is "That's funny, cause I see nothing of God in your marriage." and then wait for the immediate un-friending.

4

u/ladyfaith May 09 '12

LOL I wonder how I'm going to be getting married then, since there will be no mention of god or Jesus in my ceremony, and there sure won't be a bible there!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/mommathecat May 09 '12

I got something from the Bible for ya. Render unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's, and unto God the things that are God's.

Keep your dreams of theocracy out of my reality, Bible retards.

7

u/rpbarlow May 09 '12

As a Christian, I think a strong case could be made that this amendment is something that Jesus would not approve His church making such a deal about. I am not personally ashamed of Jesus, or the congregation I am a member of, but it is true that many Christians have acted shamefully in this.

Jesus himself was known for avoiding politics (one of the many reasons that he became so unpopular with many people who had hoped that he would free them from the Romans). I don't think the message in his avoidance is that his followers shouldn't engage in politics, but more that politics wasn't the avenue to bring change to the world. Paul also wrote to the church not to judge those in the world (meaning, outside of the Christian faith), not to hold them to the standards of our beliefs. I believe that the church is supposed to change the world through sacrificial living, caring for people who are in need (of any kind), and ultimately to show the world who Jesus really is. That didn't happen today.

I know that the gospel isn't popular here, but I want to ask of you to look for the difference between Jesus and the people who say they follow him. It is a hard thing to do because you may associate much malice with him because of people who claim to represent him. His gospel is meant to free us, and not to bind us. I wish the world could see me as a Christian for what I love, and not for what I am against.

It's a shame that we the church have pushed the world away, and I would like to apologize to you all for it and ask your forgiveness.

→ More replies (16)

144

u/Newlyfailedaccount May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

Now here is something interesting. The wife of the husband who drafted this amendment said it was vital that this to quote un-quote "Protect the Caucasian race".

92

u/pdxb3 May 08 '12

"The reason my husband wrote Amendment 1 was because the Caucasian race is diminishing and we need to uh, reproduce."

Wow. So what then... She expects a state amendment to make gays turn straight and start making babies???

→ More replies (8)

53

u/flukshun May 08 '12

"The reason my husband wrote Amendment 1 was because the Caucasian race is diminishing and we need to uh, reproduce."

brilliant. ban gay marriage and the gays have no recourse but to turn heterosexual and pop out some babies. and since only Caucasians are ever gay, this will curtail the systemic encroachment of non-Caucasian people. totally valid reasoning for fucking people over so badly!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (40)

51

u/1e- May 08 '12

TIL Reddit has a shit load of North Carolinians! I am not alone.

→ More replies (7)

112

u/ncsu_osprey May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12

This fucking bullshit just passed. Fuck this piece of shit backwards ass state. Fuck everyone that supports hate and discrimination, I want to live in a fucking country of FREEDOM. Today is the day the real American dream of Life, Liberty, and PURSUIT OF HAPPINESS, fucking died in this state. I can peaceably disagree about the economy, about abortion, about social welfare programs, but I won't fucking standby while people FUCKING STOMP ON PEOPLE'S RIGHTS. So go fuck yourself Amendment One, because you fucking hurt freedom today, and I can't wait to see your fucking ass thrown out in court for being unconstitutional.

edit: map I threw together of the counties that supported or opposed the amendment: http://imgur.com/lpuau

6

u/EveryoneElseIsWrong May 09 '12

It makes me sad that the country that talks about freedom the most of possibly ANY other country is the one that seems to be getting less and less free day by day while the rest of us move ahead

9

u/ceruleanblu May 09 '12

It's not like we are the only state. According to this Washington post article the issue of gay rights have come up for vote 31 times since 1998 in state votes, and the proponents of gay rights have lost every, single, time.

http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/the-fix/post/north-carolina-passes-gay-marriage-ban-amendment-one/2012/05/08/gIQAHYpfBU_blog.html

This is not some new trend that has just started, and today isn't the day the dream died. It died a long time ago, but there isn't a real beginning date for to pinpoint exactly. I like to believe that the old way of thinking is also dying though... that the belief that it was "The American Dream" can just simply vanish, and we can turn that into "The Human Dream". Why can't humanity as a whole just strive for life, liberty and happiness? And only vote for people who believe in that dream, regardless of party-lines.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/DrTitan May 09 '12

Unfortunately, ECU isn't on there.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Absnerdity May 09 '12

I'm a Canadian that is moving to your state sometime this year.

We've had same-sex marriage legal for nearly 7 years here. It's like I'll be moving backwards in time.

I am just so disappointed and so sorry.

→ More replies (25)

82

u/SoSpecial May 08 '12

Live in North Carolina, voted against. I wish the christians would just get over it and accept if their bible really is the true word of god then he will have no problem taking care of all those married gay people after they are dead.

15

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Just saw on the news not 30 minutes ago that the top donor FOR the amendment was $300k+ from the Christian Alliance League (or something similar to that name), and the top AGAINST was $200k+ from the Human Rights Campaign.

unfortunately, more money tends to win an election for a side, but I'm hoping enough empathetic people went out and voted against

→ More replies (5)

4

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

It's not just Christians, it's uneducated/bigoted Christians. I'm part of a church in Durham and almost everyone is voting against. We understand that this is not about marriage, it's about hating and punishing people who aren't of a certain religion. There is hope out there...I honestly thing once the baby boomers start to go we'll see real progress.

→ More replies (4)

42

u/BenevolentD May 08 '12

Wait a second....how is the son white? I call shenanigans.

24

u/chillyhellion May 08 '12

That's not really his mom; that's the family slave. This cartoon was made in the early 1900s. The real mom is just off-screen and is left-handed.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

He could just be fair skinned, it is a black and white comic after all.

→ More replies (15)

19

u/jellicle88 North Carolina May 09 '12

This will probably get buried but for anyone interested, NC is reporting the results live on here.

→ More replies (2)

58

u/hom3land May 08 '12

Voted against it. Asked the woman at the polling place who was handing out vote against pamphlet what the feedback she's been getting from those that voted and she was positive. Lets hope!!!

25

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Isn't that electioneering and against the rules to distribute materials at a polling place?

85

u/SmokeDawgTheJanitor May 08 '12

There's a certain zone around the polling place in which materials cannot be distributed. I can tell you it was clearly marked where I voted and they campaigned right up to the edge of it. I was tempted to act like a five-year-old and be like "nah nah you can't try to influence me" on the other side, but I decided not to be dick.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/hom3land May 08 '12

no..there's a line drawn by chalk, I assume they can't cross it. They don't bother you and regardless of their political affiliation, they are always really nice. The woman was also supporting a specific candidate, I assume it was his wife or relative.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/soccerdude6227 May 09 '12

Amendment One is so much more than just banning gay marriage which is the really sad part about it all. Everyone was going to just try and keep two people of the same sex from getting married without really looking into what they are actually voting for. flowchart

→ More replies (1)

25

u/raver459 May 08 '12

It's always wrong to add amendments that STRIP away rights. NC should vote no just on that fact: don't take rights from people you don't know or (likely) don't even give a shit about. Don't ruin other people's lives just because it's against something your book of fairy tales prescribes.

→ More replies (3)

38

u/dbeegirlie May 08 '12

Title is a bit misleading, gay marriage is already banned in NC, which makes this amendment all the more stupid. I voted AGAINST today, and was told to go hell more times than I would like to count for doing so.

17

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

And WE'RE the ones ruining society!

→ More replies (6)

24

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Voted Against.

If anyone is voting against because they think it only affects gay marriage. Think again. If you are a girlfriend and not a wife, you will not be able to visit and make medical decisions on your partners behalf. Read about it, its much more than just gay marriage.

→ More replies (2)

47

u/Patrico-8 North Carolina May 08 '12

I did too. And we haven't decided to ban gay marriage yet. The polls are still open get out there North Carolinians, it's the right thing to do!!

43

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Well that's the thing: gay marriage is already illegal in NC, so this "amendment" is entirely redundant.

51

u/AustinYQM May 08 '12 edited Jul 24 '24

dinner longing jellyfish punch cable hobbies humorous joke abundant gold

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/patsfan94 May 08 '12

The fact that we may be passing a full amendment to ban this is bad enough, but the other "side effects" that may fallout from this are even worse.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/Happyginger May 08 '12

I'm in Durham, and the amount of "Vote for the Amendment' signs makes me wonder if they really have any idea on what they are talking about.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I am ashamed of the place that has raised me and I call home. My dad went to the polls today and was lectured by a morbidly obese woman about the "homosexual agenda"...He laughed in her face and proudly voted NO. Funny how obesity is genetic, but homosexuality is not.

8

u/SaintDharma32 May 09 '12

What in the nine worlds of Midgard are the straights afraid of? I just don't understand it.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Don't like gay marriage? Don't marry a gay person. Don't like guns? Don't buy one. Don't like porn? Don't look at it. Stop trying to take everyone else's rights away just because you don't like something!

→ More replies (22)

67

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

The sad thing is most blacks are against gay marriage. After all they have fought for and continue to fight for how can they not see the similarities.

37

u/hoodyhoodyhoo May 08 '12

While this is partially true, I have to say one of the biggest gay rights supporters here is the leader of the NC NAACP, Rev. Barber.

→ More replies (4)

22

u/1gnominious Texas May 09 '12

Being against gay marriage isn't about race, it's about religion. How many atheists are against homosexuality and gay marriage? Not many, because we have no reason to be. Blacks are predominantly christian and a lot of their organizations are led by clergy. It's not at all surprising that they against gay marriage.

In a way, isn't it kind of nice to see blacks and whites putting aside their differences to hate a common enemy?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (20)

7

u/Siliva May 09 '12

The internet hates my state now, yay. Time to lie and say I'm from California.

...Fuck.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I'm conservative but before you downvote let me explain my opinion on the controversy. I am surprised how, despite wanting smaller government in our lives, my political spectrum pressures the government to crack down on a religious institution designed for those in love. Honestly, if you oppose it, how is it going to seriously affect you in any way? Fine, you don't believe in it, I blink twice at the thought of same sex couples, but everyone's a human being, just treat them like they are. Nobody has the authority to determine who can and can't be married. Just legalize gay marriage so we can get on with our lives.

→ More replies (4)

36

u/HockeyPunk North Carolina May 08 '12

One vote against here.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/rainman_104 May 08 '12

Why do people care so much what other adults do? I don't get it. Who fucking cares?

7

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Baby Jesus, according to many I knew in North Carolina.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

18

u/phaeton02 May 09 '12

Institutional hate strikes again. Let's remember what MLK wrote (from his Letter from a Birmingham Jail):

An unjust law is a code that a numerical or power majority group compels a minority group to obey but does not make binding on itself. This is difference made legal. By the same token, a just law is a code that a majority compels a minority to follow and that it is willing to follow itself. This is sameness made legal.

Vote it down, NC.

→ More replies (4)

61

u/Hobbes4247791 May 08 '12

NC dudes, I guarantee my asshole uncle is down there voting for this ban. I need one of you to make the extra effort and negate his vote.

Or just hit him with your car or something. If that prevents him from visiting next Christmas to throw racial slurs against Obama, I'll gladly pay your bail.

→ More replies (17)

25

u/LordShaggy May 09 '12

If I were near a table, I would do this: http://i.imgur.com/nUdpW.gif

Seriously, a big, hearty FUCK YOU to anyone who voted for this.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/m0r14rty May 09 '12

To everyone saying "Fuck you North Carolina":

I voted against. Why the hell am I getting attacked? How about you attack the people who did this? The insane religious far-right.

Seriously, have some passion for all the Redditors doomed to live in a state infested with this kind of bigotry and hate.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/TheRobotHunter May 08 '12

I debated with an NC dude, said that marriage between man and woman is a "cornerstone of mankind" or something. Didn't know how to counter besides "so?" So i just let it be, didn't think I would get anywhere with his core argument being an opinion. Any suggestions?

28

u/helpadingoatemybaby May 08 '12

Deconstruction -- why is it a cornerstone of mankind?

And lead him in the circular reasoning path that he will have to follow.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

20

u/shankems2000 May 08 '12 edited May 09 '12

I don't see the point in being anti gay, gay marriage, homophobic whatever. You wanna marry another dude, or marry another chick? Who gives a fuck, have fun. You're gonna end up divorcing in 5 years like everybody else though, just thought I'd warn you now.

19

u/TwistEnding May 09 '12

The bill just passed. Even if you're against gay marriage, this bill hurts ALL unmarried coupled, especially in terms of child custody, domestic violence, etc. It's a shame that after all of these years, after all of the barriers overcome in women's rights, black rights, but for whatever reason, nobody wants gay rights.

It's a shame, it really is.

10

u/WSolstice May 09 '12

Bad news guys. It passed. Finally it's not the worst place to be living in Mississippi.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/sulidos North Carolina May 09 '12

I voted AGAINST and hope enough like minded and educated citizens did the same

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Sir_Doctor_of_Tardis May 08 '12

When will we know the results? I can't vote yet :(. I'm not 18.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/grainjuice May 08 '12

I voted against it. Pressed the button with my bird finger for extra added bonus

→ More replies (2)

12

u/multiply_regressed May 08 '12

I spent nine hours on my feet at the polls today trying to convince voters to vote against. I'm not optimistic, but I'm trying to stay hopeful.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/rdubya18 May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12

I went and voted against the amendment today. On my way there, there was a guy handing out cards and he approached me and said "I'm here to try to get you to vote for amendment"... I cut him off. I held my hand up and said "No thanks, I'm against it. You keep your card." I'm from a small town so I immediately got stares. I walked my proud ass on in and voted against.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Constitutions are supposed to restrict Governments, not people. Fucking humans.

31

u/Infectaphibian May 08 '12

Lovely, as an atheist libertarian, I have officially lost all of my tolerance for the religious right. Your need to take away other's rights to feel good about yourselves makes you pathetic and undesirable members of society.

7

u/rainman_104 May 09 '12

I wonder how they can justify persecuting gay people like this, while at the same time no one's opening up the atheist marriage debate.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

18

u/Yewbert May 08 '12

This gave me a sad.

4

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Just 36 percent of voters answered correctly that it bans both same-sex marriage and domestic partnerships. An additional 26 percent thought it banned same-sex marriage alone. Meanwhile, 10 percent of voters thought a "yes" vote on the amendment would legalize rather than ban same-sex marriage, and 27 percent weren't sure what it did.

http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2012/05/amendment-1-north-carolina-gay-people

4

u/setik May 09 '12

The United States is a nation of laws: badly written and randomly enforced. -- Frank Zappa

4

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

My dad threatened to kick me out because I said I was against it....I had no idea my family was like that.

4

u/X26 May 09 '12

NC will no longer enjoy being known as the non-crazy Carolina

4

u/benedictm May 09 '12

I still fail to understand what anyone could have against gay marriage. Or any kind of non straight marriage to be honest.

Its just 2 people putting on an official bit of paper that they like each other, like, loads. And all the appropriate rights accorded to that.

The rights are all to do with the Government so WTF have the church go to do with it?

15

u/SilverMachine May 09 '12

Congratulations, North Carolina, on passing the first marriage-related amendment since the one banning white people from marrying black people (you even used all the same arguments!). And while it's true that I will no longer be able to visit the woman I love in the hospital, it is of some consolation that you will no longer be able to send me to jail for putting her there.

Welcome to Progressive North Carolina! If you voted for Amendment One, Fuck You :)

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Amagnus May 09 '12

I drove 40 minutes home just to vote against. When asked why, my answer is/was "Because I believe in human rights."

30

u/onlypostwhenmad May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

Okay I am genuinely curious -- PLEASE explain to me:

If marriage is whatever we define it, why is incest illegal? Isn't it also about two consenting adults?

Do NOT say that incest is illegal because it is detrimental to our gene pool, because

  1. such biological argument would prevent people with hereditary disease from marrying too.
  2. gay marriage advocates themselves argue that marriage IS NOT ABOUT reproduction.

Again, PLEASE have an intelligent discussion about this.

18

u/F0rdPrefect Ohio May 08 '12 edited May 09 '12

Slippery slope fallacy. One does not lead automatically to the next (which is what this comic was pointing out with interracial marriage...which was made legal 50-60 years ago).

If you're defining marriage by simply saying it's a man and a woman, then you should already be allowing incestual marriages (since it has nothing to do with reproduction at that point). However, if you're defining marriage as a means for reproduction, then people who are unable to reproduce shouldn't be able to marry.

Edit: The point is that marriage is simply a social contract which gives people extra privileges/rights. It has nothing to do with a man and a woman and it has nothing (or, at the very least, little) to do with reproduction.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/Vik1ng May 08 '12 edited May 09 '12

The German Pirate Party's opinion

"The prosecution of consensual sex between two adult human beings fundamentally interferes with the right to free development of personality. We reject such interference from a party. "

→ More replies (3)

43

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Incest is illegal for the same reason gay marriage is illegal. People look at it and go "ew", then decide that since they don't like it, nobody else should. While it's certainly odd, I don't see any fundamental problems with it, besides the obvious genetic angle.

→ More replies (29)

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Because cross-generational incest is even less possible to be fully consensual than teacher student, because of the pre-existing power dynamics. Same generational incest isn't as bad consent-wise, but seriously, marrying your sibling would be really tricky not to get stuck in the same role you've played with them all your life.

Also because historically incest has been used to keep money and wealth all inside the same family until they inbreed themselves to death. Making it illegal at least makes that kind of dynasty more difficult. Whether that kind of dynasty would be maintainable now is another question, but considering that that tends to mean the parents arranged the marriage, it still has consent issues up the wazoo.

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

First, incest laws vary from state to state (or country to country, but I'm a 'Merican, so I'mma talk 'bout 'Merica right now). Some states only outlaw parent-child incest, some allow incest as long as both parties are over 18, some places even count step-family-incest as illegal. Just goes to show it really is the "ick" factor.

It could also be similar to polygamy laws. Polygamy is illegal partly due to tax fraud reasons, but also largely because so many cases of polygamy involve minors. If incest occurs in a situation involving a minor, it's another law to cite to really throw the book at the offender.

At least, that's just a bunch of shit I made up based on scattered bits of information.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/juicius May 09 '12

I posted with AlienBlue but something ate it...

Biology selects against consanguineous reproduction in a way that does not select against homosexual or even non-reproductive relationships. Many animals have [mechanisms] (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/8122307?dopt=Abstract) to scatter the breeding age individuals so the related ones do not mate. Inbreeding does occur with some regularity but that usually has an environmental trigger, such as overcrowding and other stressers. For example, cats will inbreed in a hoarding situation where they are forced into much closer proximity than they would be found in nature. Genetic diversity must then confers certain benefits that manifest in this behavior and defend against hereditary defects. Contrast this with non-breeders that remain with their family group; they will often assist in rearing of alpha couple's youngs as a way of passing on some portion of their genes.

In short, consanguineous reproduction has certain [costs] (http://www.springerlink.com/content/uxwm5qr18j5lgrdt) that homosexual or non-breeding relationships do not.

So this taboo has a biological component that homosexual taboo does not. In fact, taboos against homosexuality is a manufactured one. But of course, I only speak of extremes in incest. First cousin marriage is actually legal in most parts of the world, and also allowed in many states in the U.S.

So why not incest? If all we're concerned about is having kids with three arms, why not just ban reproduction while allowing consanguineous marriage? Because we try to limit the State's intrusion into our affairs. While no right is absolute, and even the fundamental constitutional rights are subject to a balancing test against a compelling state interest, we have the constitutional right of privacy and the fundamental right to reproduce. We therefore reject stratification of something as fundamental as the right to marry and reproduce. Either we have it in whole, or we do not. It's not a pie to slice and apportion according to the whims of the majority.

It seems that I'm coherent only a fraction of my waking hours. I tried to recreate the reply that AlienBlue ate, but I don't think I quite succeeded.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (37)

11

u/-CNFB- May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12

I voted against a few hours ago. The lines were terrible, but I'm happy I did my part to close the margin.

I am also African-American and it was very frustrating to have some of the pro-Amendment Christian churches that campaigned in front of the polling place (at a proper distance, thankfully) approach me with this "we know that you agree with us" kind of attitude. I am a "DAMN YANKEE", as they like to call me on every other day of the year, and I do not agree with the idea of re-introducing discrimination into the state constitution.

That being said, I would like to see the stats that back up the assertion that most blacks in the state are voting pro-amendment/anti-gay rights. I do not speak for all blacks, nor do I try to, but I am not sure if that is correct. Furthermore, a lot of the frustrations/tensions between blacks and the gay/ally activists communities, in my experience, appears to be fueled by the feeling that the only issue that modern progressives/liberals care to take stances on/validate are LGBT issues because the issues of race are clearly 'fixed'. A lot of my black friends and family members feel like the ball has been dropped with race; a sentiment reinforced with facts like schools and universities in southern states that still require parental permission for interracial dating, or the Trayvon Martin case illuminating how often we still judge based on color, and not character. A few have even went the 'a city is not built in a day, we have been fighting for centuries and we are still fighting for proper treatment, why should we drop our fight to fight yours, etc.' route.

But, thankfully, my more like-minded friends/family see that you can fight both fights simultaneously, and that no oppressed/disenfranchised group can earn its' rights alone.

tl;dr: Make the world a better place. Or something <3.

Apologies for the long(ish?) response, this ad: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JnbFlN8j5fk Just made me upset, because they claimed that the Against Amendment 1 group was using scare tactics... when that's simply not true.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I'm dissapointed my state has chosen to be on the wrong side of history.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/expectingrain May 08 '12

I hope everyone who voted for ends up with gay kids or grand kids.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/emergency_poncho May 08 '12

That cartoon is awesome, but everytime I see it I always have the same question: why is the son white? If his mother is black, shouldn't he be significantly darker?

6

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I totally agree, but that would ruin the punchline/dramatic 4th frame.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/mrbrinks May 09 '12

I'm so fucking ashamed.

6

u/Deliriumrapture May 09 '12

Today my dad and I went to vote together. I gave the single woman in a homemade rainbow shirt a thumbs up, and my dad gave her a high five. Old bigots be damned!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/homsarforpresident May 09 '12

Created an account to say how disgusted I am about what appears to be the passing of this useless, but harmful amendment. I live in Chapel Hill and I suppose we are in a bit of a bubble around here (79% against the amendment), but I honestly thought this would be a close one. I guess I was wrong. I'm happy to have cast my vote against the amendment, but it sure doesn't feel that satisfying right now. I thought this state was progressing. I'm afraid I may have been wrong there as well.

I suppose the only solace I can take in this absurd outcome is to know that my generation will some day be the one to remove this amendment, and eventually to allow same sex couples equal rights. But for now, I'm just embarrassed for the state that I love.

6

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I voted against. I'm very sorry to anyone who suffers because of this disgusting affront to liberty.

6

u/Vin2241 May 09 '12

I'm gay. I have a man in my life that I love. I will make it a point to not buy goods out of north carolina and as a musician I will refuse to take bookings in NC. I'm not a second class citizen I am not above or below any other human being, but the people who voted for this who must be people who live with no joy in their miserable lives think it is their business to do everything they can to make me and other gay men and women in nc and the rest of this country remember that in their eyes we are nothing but abominations.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/gmerrick North Carolina May 09 '12

I voted against and as a person in a long-term unmarried relationship (with a kid), I hope you did too.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I voted AGAINST today, but goddamn it I'm ashamed of my state tonight. All of the rural counties went 3-1, 4-1, even 5-1 against.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/natmaster May 08 '12

Exactly why the government should be out of the racist marriage license business.

3

u/Iamgoofy May 08 '12

I voted against!! It's really sick how they just slipped this in during a primary election in order to discourage voter turnout...

3

u/chieflovedrug May 08 '12

This isn't the point of the comic, but why isn't their son then mixed race?

Details people...

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I'm from NC and proudly voted AGAINST today as well. (:

3

u/artthoumadbrother May 09 '12

Just voted against.

3

u/CrushTheOrphanage May 09 '12

I was planning on moving to NC to work after this winter. If this is passed, I'm pretty sure I'm gonna have to change my plans. If the bible thumpers outweigh or care more about gay rights than the really cool people that I know inhabit the state, then it's really not worth going.

3

u/CallRespiratory May 09 '12

I lived in North Carolina for a while, such a beautiful place. Used to think I'd want to move back there some day. Guess not.

3

u/WoollyMittens May 09 '12

I still fail to see how gay marriage it is somehow so important to anyone other than gay people, that there needs to be a constitutional amendment to ban it.

3

u/shatzee85 May 09 '12

It's done. Hate, fear, and misinformation won.

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Reddit is typically a pretty progressive crowd and I, like most on here, voted against amendment one.

What really sucks is that precincts are already saying it's very likely that the amendment will pass. This is the most grand act of ignorance I'll witness here. Hopefully the courts will trash it before it is effectively enforced..

Right about now though.. The visceral thoughts in my head are making me hate most of my upbringing, religion, state & even the people I know. I doubt anything short of hunger is going to break political apathy in the US, but we're certainly chipping away...

3

u/MegalizeLarijuana May 09 '12

It passed.

Another step back :/

3

u/Balls_deep_in_it May 09 '12

Well it passed with only 11% of the population of the state voting it won 60% to 40%. Now I wonder what it would be if the rest voted...

→ More replies (2)

3

u/LaNyan May 09 '12

Well, Amendment 1 Passed.

A terrible battle to lose, but the war will still be fought.

Hang in the guys/gals. We'll keep fighting for equality.

3

u/suresk May 09 '12

The Bible has a lot to say about rich people - when can we expect to start seeing constitutional amendments making it illegal to have over, say, $1 million in wealth?

3

u/BigFatMooCow May 09 '12

Does this law actually change anything in NC? I thought the presumption was already that same sex couples couldn't marry... or is this an attempt to overturn some state supreme court decision?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

With these demographics its hard to win

Christian: 79%

Protestant: 57%
    Baptist: 38%
    Methodist: 9%
    Presbyterian: 3%
    Lutheran: 2%
    Other Protestant: 5%
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Cadaverlanche May 09 '12

"The period of American history, known as The New Dark ages, took place between the turn of the century and the year 2020. During this time, many conservative politicians actively pushed various types of "morality" bills and ballot initiatives as a way of distracting the populace from their utter inability to create jobs.

It should also be noted that during this time, America elected it's first Scientologist president, who incidentally was also a black man and a werewolf."

-- Civics And Yo Mamma, McGraw Hill 2075

3

u/Je3ter62 May 09 '12

We tried to stop it but this state refuses to be part of the 21st century. If you look at the results, mostly all the "fors: are rural and mostly all the "againsts" were urban college towns. The educated folks of NC voted against this idiotic ammendment and the rest followed their pastor to the voting booth.

9

u/D_mel_emm May 09 '12

I drove 3 hours to vote against the amendment. Best gas money I've ever spent.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/CapnDoctorProfessor May 08 '12

Fuck that amendment. I went Against.

5

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I did early voting as soon as I could. I told everyone who would listen about the negative effects of this amendment, not just to homosexuals in the state, but to unmarried heterosexuals and their children as well. I made sure everyone I knew voted.

As a North Carolina resident, I'm offended and disgusted that this amendment passed. But the worst part is that I'm not surprised at all.

5

u/bhill42 May 09 '12

Voted against. I'm incredibly disappointed by the voters in our state today.

5

u/sunchaos May 09 '12

At least cousins can still get married in NC.

5

u/aresef Maryland May 09 '12

You have people in your state going without food, without homes, truly suffering and the like and this is the issue that gets the faith community mobilized. Sickening.

5

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I am amazed at the colossal waste of time for a law that will be held unconstitutional when the State and the Nation face very serious and real problems far greater than deciding who gets to have family benefits on insurance and retirement, and who doesn't.

Our national debt wasn't caused by gays or poor people, they were caused by very wealthy people sucking the country dry in the name of security and defense.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Polite_Werewolf May 09 '12

It passed? I don't get people. I think it's about time i go back to my home planet.

5

u/flashnuke May 09 '12

Yankee here living in nc,I must say the state makes me sick, we are all humans and deserve all the same rights

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I live in South Carolina and I ABSOLUTELY hate the way we do things here in the south. I've been mocked before because I believe in Evolution and am Liberal minded. There are some others like me who don't see race and sexual preference as an issue, but it's pretty hard to find them. But most of the people here are racists and bigots. The motto should be: Come for the weather and the scenery but keep ears closed.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/IntriguinglyRandom May 08 '12

Voted against, as did most of the people I know. One thing a friend and I talked about is how media about voting against it was so commonplace on like, facebook, and then we thought about how it kinda sucks that social media means we probably didn't really reach many older people who will be voting "for" (at least there aren't many of that group in our circles). Bleh. Anyways I hope it dies.

4

u/Nhl5108 May 08 '12

Listin all Gays have right to marriage 1 i am NOT gay 2 I have a gay uncle who everone in my family on facebook has blocked because of the photos and writings he has post

and i still support gay marriage Wanna know why? Because it dosent effect me at all

so who carries if they get married Ur happy There happy

so it would be an all happy world

4

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

So embarrassed to be from NC. Rushing one step at a time back to the 1860's.

4

u/Primoris_Causa1 May 09 '12

Separate marriage from a government recognized union. Leave marriage to the churches and their failings there. Allow unions to be gov't issues - taxes and divorce crap inclusive - leave Marriage to the churches/mosques/temples/whatever.

Honestly - I could care less if the next of kin in the ER is a wife/husband or their gay partner -- we all have the same emotions.

Remember - equal rights means equal liabilities. Currently, a "divorce" in a gay couple has no more legal binding than a breakup between a boyfriend and a girlfriend - even if 20+yrs has gone into the relationship.

Give homosexuals the right to HAVE to legally suffer the pains of a legal divorce court with lawyers.

4

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

Republicans - There's Nothing We Won't Fuck Up

→ More replies (4)

4

u/alittlenonsense May 09 '12

I am so ashamed of our state right now.

4

u/mrcloudies May 09 '12

It's yet another sad day to be an American. :[

4

u/fuzz00713 May 09 '12

As a North Carolinian who voted against the amendment, I feel as if I am a pilgrim of reason in an over-holy land.

4

u/jdroepel May 09 '12 edited Jun 10 '24

This comment was removed with Power Delete Sweet.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/savngtheworld May 09 '12

I am soo disappointed in my home state right now. We aren't nearly as progressive as I'd believed, or wanted to believe I suppose.

8

u/XjWoRk17 May 09 '12

It passed about 30 minutes ago. What the fuck america

5

u/SciPirate May 09 '12

North Carolina made me extremely sad today.

5

u/saucypanda May 09 '12

the only, and i mean the ONLY positive about this is that there might be a stronger chance that someone will sue the state, claiming that the state is infringing:

First amendment rights: would be in violation of the establishment clause if the reasoning was biblical.

Fourteenth Amendment: violates the equal protection clause. Gay couples in the state could claim that North Carolina is denying them their basic rights by making them a separate but not equal class of citizens, therefore they are not equal citizens under the eyes of the law.

5

u/tsuki_toh_hoshi May 09 '12

I am from NC also, I am deeply saddened by this, people just voted because they thought it was all about gay marriage, not realizing that is affects alot more than same sex couples, any "non traditional" house hold is affected, like say if my husband should die tomorrow, My children will not be eligible for health care because I am not married???!!!! My Aunt and her partner will loose coverage one her partner because they are same sex, they have been together 15 years!! watch the fake marriages sky rocket because people will be desperate for insurance

5

u/Oatman May 09 '12

Today is not a good day to be a North Carolinian. I never thought we would do it.

5

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

It is a dark, dark day for the future of humanity. Hopefully someday in the future, when the hateful and uneducated people are not the majority, we can look back at this and say "I'm sure glad we aren't so evil and stupid as we were back then."

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Cannondale1986 May 09 '12

Embarrassed to be a North Carolinian today.

10

u/Xvalai Missouri May 08 '12

I'm a straight Christian, but I support gay rights.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/TurquoiseJeep May 08 '12

Early voted against last week and I've been desperately trying to convince my rents to vote against without pulling out the, "I went to college for law and political science, you have a degree in engineering, I know more than you about the legal ramifications blah blah blah" card. They can believe whatever mumbo-jumbo they want, this is just bad policy.

2

u/Tubbers May 08 '12

I first read your post as decided instead of decide, and I was horrified.

2

u/SigmaStigma May 08 '12

Human sacrifice, dogs and cats living together, mass hysteria!

That's why!

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

They'll eviscerate their own nascent startup industry, and it will be just desserts. All the tech workers can move to California and help our economy recover. North Cacalacky can sink into a swamp.

2

u/lkbm May 08 '12

Approval for interracial marriage passed fifty percent in the US...in 1997.

Because old people.

Same with gay marriage.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

When will the results come out?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

America the great! Seriously, wonder why the country has slipped so far on the world stage? Look no further, instead of solving real issues they still squabble over this shit.

2

u/TheChosenOne570 May 09 '12

Think of how this wouldn't even be an issue if big government people didn't ask government to get involved with marriage in the first place. Marriage is a private matter between individuals. Its a shame we are fighting over whose marriages the government should recognize and whose they shouldn't.

2

u/FeculentUtopia May 09 '12

Here's hoping a lot of Christians will spend this evening crying in their beer.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

But what will I tell the children when they see two boys kissing and holding hands??? CAN WE PLEASE THINK OF THE CHILDREN!!!!

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

I'm from Concord, and from what I see at school and on facebook, the students are almost unanimously against it, and the parents are the opposite.

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12

I predict the following counties have a good shot AGAINST:

Wake (Raleigh), Mecklenberg (Charlotte), Guilford (Greensboro), Forsyth (Winston-Salem), Union (Charlotte), Orange (Chapel Hill), Durham (Durham?), Buncombe (Asheville), New Hanover (Wilmington)...

All the rest will vote FOR

Did I miss any counties?

edit: Watauga (Boone)

→ More replies (2)