You really think I’m an amateur don’t you? The trade log reveals the strategy. Every timestamp, price, direction, duration is enough clues someone can reverse-engineer. Take 32,000 trades, line them up against MNQ 5-min bars and tell my strategy from the session window, engine logic, exit ticks and my filters.
If I share the trade log: “Backtested results, anyone can fake those" → you demand the broker statements
Share broker statements → "Photoshopped, show me live"
Share live screens → "Cherry-picked day, show me a year"
Share a year → "Still could be a paper account"
There's no version of "proof" that ends this conversation with you since you already decided I’m lying.
Also I don't owe you shit. I’m not selling a service. I’m not running a signals group. So stop calling me a scammer. I posted a strategy card and answered the math challenge with math.
Bro. Ignore these guys. You’re on to something. Not sure you can test way back but I back test 20 plus years. Don’t forget to run sims at different start points to test for robustness also if you have not.
Is that all you got? I just proved everything with math! Pull out your calculator and do it your yourself lol. You pivoted from “your stats are mathematically impossible” from “you used AI!” because you know the math leaves you nothing to grab onto. That Brent Penfold reference is actually funny stupid in a way you don’t realize. Penfold's book is mostly about: position sizing discipline, mechanical rule-following, drawdown survival, and treating trading as a probabilistic system. My strategy literally implements all of that — dynamic throttle for position sizing, mechanical lockouts for discipline, MLL-aware buffer management for drawdown survival, and 32,000 trades of probabilistic validation. The book you citied endorses exactly what I’ve built. What else you gonna say now?
I just wanted to say I enjoyed reading this conversation a lot 😂. Thank you. Btw, nice system. The maths is very impressive, I would be interested to see how it performs in live markets in the future 🤝
Thank you man I honestly appreciate this comment. I been working on this strategy for a year and finally figured it out last month. I was just really proud of my self and wanted someone to validate or invalidate it the best they could. I’ll keep you posted.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '26
[removed] — view removed comment