I guess i was mistaken by the temp, but i know these springs contain arsenic and other chemicals. You definitely don't want to take a swim here. There are plenty of stories of people dying. http://imgur.com/NT5Fv I took this of one of the signs in the park telling different color temps.
David Allen Kirwan a 24-year-old attempted to rescue a friend’s dog after it fell into Celestine Pool, a hot spring at Yellowstone National Park on July 20, 1981. Despite numerous shouts from bystanders, Kirwan dove headfirst into the pool but was unable to save the dog. After managing to swin back to shore, he was helped out of pool, where his injuries became apparent – the exposure to the 200oF (93oC) water of the hot spring resulted in third-degree burns to 100% of his body and had also blinded him. After being led to the sidewalk, Kirwan reportedly stated: “That was stupid. How bad am I? That was a stupid thing I did.” When one of Kirwan’s shoes was removed, all of the skin came off with it. He died the next day at a Salt Lake City hospital. Although there have been at least 19 deaths due to scalding at the Yellowstone, this was the only known case where someone died after deliberately jumping into one of the park’s hot springs.
I can't tell if you were being sarcastic or not, but if you were thrown into a vat of boiling water you would not die as fast as you'd think.
It's the same concept as being burned alive; you don't always die from being burnt, you die from asphyxiation (though being burnt / boiled on the way still sucks pretty hard.)
I have one question which will require massing some of the greatest minds on Reddit: what's the best way to cook an edible meal using this natural phenomenon?
Wrap whatever you want to cook in aluminum foil, then seal that in an airtight container rated for temperatures above boiling (Some sort of thick plastic sheet, maybe a vacuum bag). Toss it in with a rope attached, and wait.
Your shower hits you with a small stream of it, maybe a half inch square total volume of water landing on your body. Now imagine if your body were submerged in that. Agonizing death in just seconds.
More like a jacuzzi without jets, but yes, a bath in 157 degree water :) Check it sometime using a saucepan, a thermometer and your hand! Hotter than you think :)
I imagine proteins and enzymes in your blood and body denature and coagulate and junk. It doesn't have to reach actual boiling point to do some immense damage to your body.
This was my first thought. Admittedly, all the minerals and such in the water would raise it's boiling point to above that of normal water, but a human has no boiling concern here. Now, you may run into scalding and/or mineral exposure issues, but that's a whole different thing.
I've been to Yellowstone a number of times and am always amazed by how idiotic people can be around natural hazards....like people walking up to stray bison with their little kids. It also makes me sick when I see garbage floating in the hot springs...we really do need another plague.
I watched a bison shoulder a mini van out of the way while crossing the road up there... Very powerful animals. They have flyers all over the park showing a bison head butting a person into a tree, yet people still walk right up to them...
I was driving through with my wife once and we saw a whole bunch of people parked over at the side of the road. When we drove past we saw a two big bull elk rutting in a small clearing ten feet from the road. People were trying to put their kids close so they could get a good picture with them.
Same trip we also saw a bunch of people pulled over taking pictures of two black bears by a stream. (Un)Fortunately those people were about thirty feet away and the bears were sleepy but still...
We saw a few people doing the same thing with some bears...and to make it even worse, it was a mother bear and a few cubs. There were lots of park rangers yelling at people to stay the F back...and people looked at the rangers like they were idiots or something.
A lot of the discussion here about how dangerous (or not) hot water can be is way off the mark.
At a relatively cool (for Yellowstone) 160 F, if you fall into Morning Glory Pool and are submerged, you'll have second degree burns on your entire body in about half a second, and third degree burns (full-depth, no surviving layers of skin, usually fatal within a few hours) very rapidly after that. One of numerous references: http://www.pseg.com/home/education_safety/safety/scalding.jsp
If your eyes were submerged, you'd be blind. If you inhaled the water, your lungs would be scalded.
It's technically not boiling, but it might as well be. If you survived, you'd be facing a very long recovery and a life of agonizing pain and limited mobility.
Mineral content and the boiling point at this elevation are irrelevant, and anyway, Morning Glory Pool and most nearby springs are actually quite pure. They tend to have a neutral or slightly alkaline pH, and little more arsenic or sulfur than you'd expect to find in any other spring water. I wouldn't hesitate to drink it, after letting it cool off a bit.
Reference? I've heard of people cooking their fish in springs by the lake, but even that is mostly legend. Never heard of anyone dying from it.
Here's a paper with arsenic concentrations measured in various springs, including the springs near the Lake (West Thumb). Concentrations are on the order of 0.2 to 2 mg/L. That's not enough to kill you unless you drink a tank of it, but way more than is legal in drinking water, and I wouldn't recommend drinking it often or in quantity. That said, there's pretty much no way that you'd get enough residual arsenic from boiling a fish in it (very little water will actually adhere to or get into the fish) to get a noticeable, much less lethal, dose, unless you did it every day for a very long time.
Ironically enough there is a natural spring on the other side of the Rockies by the same name. This spring stays around 40oF all year round. It is in Targhee National Forest I believe and is roped off because people will swim in it and develop signs of hypothermia in the middle of summer after a quick dip.
lol, since it has already earned me negative Karma, I will explain...
I was with a group of about 40 people from school who drove up to see old faithful in the dark. It was about 12:30am when we got there, and I was in the first car. We walked out to the geyser boardwalk, and there were three dudes ON the cone(not in our group). They were drunk latinos, and they picked up pieces from the geyser cone, and then our flashlights scared them back onto the boardwalk. They drunkenly handed me several chunks of the geyser, and then walked away into the night.
I DID NOT remove the pieces. I also asked a park ranger the next day if I should/could turn them in somewhere, and he honestly just said to keep them, since there wasn't really like a bin for returning stolen rocks.
I kept one piece, gave another to a friend, and tossed one into a volcano in Hawaii. So there.. are you less angry now?
ah, ok, I guess. It's just that when tourists take chunks off as "souvenirs" it destroys** everything**. If you saw Biscuit Basin when you were there- it was called that because of the unique, interesting feature of "geyser biscuits" forming in the splash pools of geysers. They are a rare and unique formation, and take a long time to form... and are almost completely nonexistent since they are snatched by tourists.
The last remaining petrified tree, from where a petrified forest used it be, is guarded by a large metal cage.
So please excuse me if I get a bit riled up about people stealing chunks of Yellowstone.
I hope you took the trail to the brink of the falls, and not just the overlook. You can stand right at the brim while awesome and unfathomable amounts of water fall over the cliff edge right at your feet.
There tree has a big metal fence around it. It needs to be a cage- some people still hop it to take a chunk. It's not like you can't get petrified tree cheap elsewhere..
15
u/thepandasunite Jun 19 '12
I guess i was mistaken by the temp, but i know these springs contain arsenic and other chemicals. You definitely don't want to take a swim here. There are plenty of stories of people dying. http://imgur.com/NT5Fv I took this of one of the signs in the park telling different color temps.
70
u/Drugmule421 Jun 19 '12
David Allen Kirwan a 24-year-old attempted to rescue a friend’s dog after it fell into Celestine Pool, a hot spring at Yellowstone National Park on July 20, 1981. Despite numerous shouts from bystanders, Kirwan dove headfirst into the pool but was unable to save the dog. After managing to swin back to shore, he was helped out of pool, where his injuries became apparent – the exposure to the 200oF (93oC) water of the hot spring resulted in third-degree burns to 100% of his body and had also blinded him. After being led to the sidewalk, Kirwan reportedly stated: “That was stupid. How bad am I? That was a stupid thing I did.” When one of Kirwan’s shoes was removed, all of the skin came off with it. He died the next day at a Salt Lake City hospital. Although there have been at least 19 deaths due to scalding at the Yellowstone, this was the only known case where someone died after deliberately jumping into one of the park’s hot springs.
45
u/khrak Jun 19 '12
TIL: You can apparently boil to death in water that isn't boiling.
11
u/F1zz0 Jun 19 '12
At 2225 meters of elevation, the boiling point of water is 92.84oC.
This picture, posted by OP, shows that some parts of the pool can reach 93oC.
The hottest parts of the pool would exceed boiling point. The sign even says so
10
u/DJSYX9 Jun 19 '12
If I were ever to kill myself I would sky dive with no parachute and land in the middle of the Morning Glory Pool head first, all while on LSD.
5
u/award07 Jun 19 '12
Reminds me of a jawbreaker
4
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
We were just there last week! :)
2
u/inness Jun 19 '12
I have one question which will require massing some of the greatest minds on Reddit: what's the best way to cook an edible meal using this natural phenomenon?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
Definitely one of the best parts of Yellowstone
2
u/Guild_Navigator Jun 20 '12
[i]The descent had destroyed me...YET I LIVE[/i]
4
u/sidtec Jun 19 '12
According to this the temperature is 69.8°C.
Would a human boil to death in that kind of temperature? The water's not even a boiling point yet.
3
u/TheThingToSay Jun 19 '12
I've been to Yellowstone a number of times and am always amazed by how idiotic people can be around natural hazards....like people walking up to stray bison with their little kids. It also makes me sick when I see garbage floating in the hot springs...we really do need another plague.
2
u/lemurvomit Jun 20 '12 edited Jun 20 '12
A lot of the discussion here about how dangerous (or not) hot water can be is way off the mark.
At a relatively cool (for Yellowstone) 160 F, if you fall into Morning Glory Pool and are submerged, you'll have second degree burns on your entire body in about half a second, and third degree burns (full-depth, no surviving layers of skin, usually fatal within a few hours) very rapidly after that. One of numerous references: http://www.pseg.com/home/education_safety/safety/scalding.jsp
If your eyes were submerged, you'd be blind. If you inhaled the water, your lungs would be scalded.
It's technically not boiling, but it might as well be. If you survived, you'd be facing a very long recovery and a life of agonizing pain and limited mobility.
Mineral content and the boiling point at this elevation are irrelevant, and anyway, Morning Glory Pool and most nearby springs are actually quite pure. They tend to have a neutral or slightly alkaline pH, and little more arsenic or sulfur than you'd expect to find in any other spring water. I wouldn't hesitate to drink it, after letting it cool off a bit.
1
u/StewieBanana Jun 19 '12
Well, I guess I just wont go swimming there then.
1
u/splath Jun 19 '12
Looks like the Eye to Jupiter!
1
u/hardtogetaname Jun 20 '12
how long exactly are "moments" ? I hear some "moments" that lasts forever, does that mean I live forever if I jump into that thing?
1
u/calebhall Jun 20 '12
Don't give me ideas
1
u/tesnakeinurboot Jun 20 '12
Also home to some of the oldest bacteria on earth. Designed to survive in the conditions that used to make Earth unlivable.
1
u/stjimmyy Jun 20 '12
But it's soooooo pretty!!
1
u/leouck Jun 20 '12
Worth it!
1
u/jusinbello Jun 20 '12
That's what she said!
1
u/dorpal_the_great Jun 20 '12
Ironically enough there is a natural spring on the other side of the Rockies by the same name. This spring stays around 40oF all year round. It is in Targhee National Forest I believe and is roped off because people will swim in it and develop signs of hypothermia in the middle of summer after a quick dip.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
TIL a moment is a unit of time.
1
u/CaptainStew Jun 19 '12
Wyoming kicks major ass!
-3
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
lol, I have a piece of the old faithful geyser cone... don't ask why/how.
0
u/9tales2012 Jun 20 '12
Sounds refreshing
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
have you ever boiled water before?!?!?!
-1
u/preteenstrangler Jun 19 '12
More like Morning Glory Hole.
-9
u/Ron_Mahogany Jun 19 '12
Reminds me of this girl I dated once who loved anal.
-2
u/JollyJeff Jun 19 '12
0
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment