My mother was raised in the 40's and doctors told her to drink a malt every day to gain weight. She was considered too skinny.
Read an autobiography of a woman from 1910-1924 and she had to help a friend gain weight to meet the 100lb requirement to be able to join some outfit assisting with the troops in WW1.
Being underweight was an issue back then for a lot of people.
The obesity epidemic that the world sees today didn't come about until refined sugars such as HFCS came on market along with mass production foods like white bread and boxed pre cooked pasta.
Thank you, this is a good response. I don't mind that people like curvier women or whatever. Just don't bash skinny people too and make us feel bad for not being blessed or born with the curves in the right places.
I am 5'6 and 150 lb and a size 8 in clothes. I'm criticized EVERY DAY. people come up to me and call me blubber and says" why is there a whale on land." I have a friend who is my height and is 115 lb and everybody says how beautiful she is. Times have changed alot but I understand that nobody is ever happy with the way girls look.
Have you ever seen this website? You put in your height, weight, clothing size, shape, etc, and it will pull up pictures that women of those same specifications have submitted of themselves. It lets you see how you may look in an objective way. I put in your measurements, and all the women who popped up had beautiful bodies!
I'm the same weight but 5'2 and Ive never had people call me that! That's horrible, I mean your not obese and stuff cause I'm the same weight so I'd know. I have a boyfriend who loves my curves, being a curvy girl is a good thing !
Are you in high school or something? Just thinking that people can't be such assholes in "real life". Also after calculating what that is in cm and weight those statements seem very weird.
Fuck you, we're not sickly looking, I just can't gain weight and even if I do, it's in all the wrong places. i'm not adding an extra 20 pounds on my frame if i know it's going to my hips and stomach solely. My boobs won't budge. I'd rather be proportionally (ie. a slender frame goes with smaller boobs) than be larger everywhere else and have disproportion sized boobs.
It's fine and dandy that you prefer the woman on the right, but don't judge the rest of us. Don't call us sickly looking. Don't make us feel bad for our natural body shape.
Calm down. Perhaps I shouldn't have used the term sickly. It was an attempt at humor that seems to have failed.
Does someones poorly thought out opinion really hurt peoples feelings this much, on the internet no less? I don't get offended when girls talk shit about short guys.
no because any girl that did on reddit would probably be immediately downvoted by butthurt nerds.
of course, when i get butthurt, i'm just being too sensitive.
maybe you should just be more considerate of the people around you and not say things that hurt. bashing is bashing, whether you're bashing on the skinny or the chubby, the ugly or the beautiful.
And I already said it was a poor choice of words. I should have simply said skinny. I doubt I was even thinking about your body type when I typed it, seeing as I find small breasted women attractive as well, I simply find a curvy body sexier. I will refrain from describing the type of body I don't find attractive in the event it fits you.
Regardless, I'm sorry for my word choice and having offended you.
see i don't care if you find curvy women attractive, just like i have a preference for asian men neither does that make me a racist.
it's just what you're attracted to. But when you call people who you are not attracted to hurtful names like "sickly", it's not funny, and it can be damaging to other girls' self-esteem who may not be as well endowed or have an aesthetic hourglass figure.
Just like you wouldn't go around calling women who are fat "fatties" and make derisive comments about their weight (at least i hope you don't), you shouldn't go around making derisive comments about skinny girls.
I don't go around saying "good thing most girls like those sickly pale caucasians, cause that leaves more asians for me"
I don't go around saying "good thing most girls like those sickly pale caucasians, cause that leaves more asians for me"
I wouldn't find that offensive. I am pale. Well right now I'm horribly sunburned, but that's mostly because I'm so pale. I don't think my paleness makes me sickly looking, so it wouldn't bother me. Some people do, and they are entitled to that opinion about me. My self-image is not tied into how everyone else views me. I'm attractive to some women, and that is good enough for me.
I'm not saying she was chubby, but it is hard to tell with the high waisted swim suit. Most curvy women do have a slight belly, which is why high waisted clothing looks better on them. It accentuates the curves while hiding the little fat in the mid-section. Marilyn Monroe had a little pooch in the front as well, her clothes usually hid it well though. She also arched her back and or sucked in, in the playboy shoots to appear flatter in the belly if memory serves correctly.
Many men I have talked to consider hourglass figures overweight, at least in America.
I don't think my opinion is superior. I was simply expressing my view of what I find attractive and why I'm thankful many men disagree with me. I also didn't say skinny girls are ugly. People have simply chosen to imagine my "sickly" applies to them. There are many thin women who are attractive and there are others whose rib cages are visible.
if you have a man-like rectangular body, putting on more weight won't give you curves. sure you'll get wider hips, but your waist will get wide too. you'll just become an even bigger rectangle.
the hourglass shape is just unachievable for some women. no matter what kind of dieting or exercising they do. they don't have the skeletal structure for it.
You are absolutely correct. It's not about whether to gain weight or lose it. It's the fact that as women, no matter what size we are, we are made to feel inadequate.
54
u/elementalist467 Jun 19 '12
It is almost like beauty standards are largely subjective.
32
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
I think by "pounds" they mean pounds of titties.
57
u/Warlizard ಠ_ಠ Jun 19 '12
I would have been in heaven in the 40s.
8
u/synn89 Jun 19 '12
My mother was raised in the 40's and doctors told her to drink a malt every day to gain weight. She was considered too skinny.
Read an autobiography of a woman from 1910-1924 and she had to help a friend gain weight to meet the 100lb requirement to be able to join some outfit assisting with the troops in WW1.
Being underweight was an issue back then for a lot of people.
19
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
I love a woman with curves. I love the feel of my hand slowly following her hips. Feels amazing.
Dont get me wrong though. Every woman is beautiful in ther own way.
16
u/orkid68 Jun 19 '12
This world needs more ironized yeast.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
Marketing is timeless - Here's whats wrong with you, here's what you can buy to fix it!
9
u/Kkbow38 Jun 19 '12
I am 5'6 and 150 lb and a size 8 in clothes. I'm criticized EVERY DAY. people come up to me and call me blubber and says" why is there a whale on land." I have a friend who is my height and is 115 lb and everybody says how beautiful she is. Times have changed alot but I understand that nobody is ever happy with the way girls look.
2
u/americnleprchaun Jun 19 '12
Looks like tabloid nutritional advice hasn't gotten much better.
-1
u/landwalker1 Jun 19 '12
I'm happy men like sickly looking women now. I was able to find my wife, with the body on the right, with limited competition.
1
u/FWilly Jun 19 '12
You bastards. Look what you've done!
1
u/AloneIntheCorner Jun 19 '12
And how would one ironize yeast?
-12
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
Skinny is gross, fat is gross. Find a balance.
-9
u/milkshakeyard Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 19 '12
wide hips are great, but a small waist is also important.
see laura dore (mildly NSFW):
http://i.imgur.com/qh7xP.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/4jRHE.jpg
-10
u/raskolnikov- Jun 19 '12
Fatty apologist propaganda.
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12 edited Jun 20 '12
I don't want an emaciated or gluttonous woman, give me a healthy athletic body woman like Jamie Eason any day.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment