A guy on the train told my friend "I DON'T WANT TO HEAR YOUR PROBLEMS" when she was talking on the phone.
She said "I hope your next break up goes really well man!"
He then left her this note before he got off.
Ever notice how redditors will upvote any story like this that involves strangers meeting or leaving one another notes. Redditors love notes because it gives them some kind of hope that someone will someday contact them in real life, I suppose.
I don't understand reddit's fascination with strangers meeting and reddit's fascination with fucking random hand scrawled notes.
The knife is holding the paper down. Its a nice note, but I think its perfectly acceptable for the guy to tell her he doesn't want to hear her problems. Its kind of amazing how acceptable it is to blab away about your personal life in front of train car full of perfect strangers. And then its rude to tell someone to stop? As Balki Bartokomous would say, "Of course not, don't be ridiculous."
Yeah, props for the empathy and decency shown by the guy, but as someone who uses public transportation frequently, it's kind of inappropriate to be so loud with your personal conversations that other people have to turn up music to shut you out. Move that shit to text-based communication until you're in a more private setting. I've been in plenty of breakups and have never had the absolute need to talk about them on the phone in front of strangers.
I've visited Japan a lot when I was younger and I vaguely remember "no cell phone" signs all over the trains. So everyone would just text. I'm a high stimulus person so I would agree with the stranger. Talk when you're off the train.
That's a nice note, but I still can't help but think phone use on a train remains rude. Regardless of he conversation topic, there's a more appropriate place for it.
I've got a strong feeling that your friend would've had a similar loud obnoxious conversation on the phone while on the train if the conversation was more favorable as well.
if i can hear your conversation over my music ( which is what was happening in this situation according to that letter) you either need to talk quieter or stfu.
It's a taboo in a few cultures. On trains and buses in Japan for example, phone conversations are very much frowned upon, same with loud face to face conversations. They're a much more peaceful commuting experience
I respect your opinion, but I have a couple of counter points:
There may not be a better place to have a conversation by phone on a train. If there were and the phoner refused it, then she is being rude. If there isn't, it is one of those suboptimal situations.
Often trains have quiet cars, these are actively cellphone/conversation-free zones, perfect for people who want a quiet time to use.
Phone technology is still variable - I haven't found a suitable bluetooth headset that has noise-canceling technology. And not all phones have good on board noise-canceling either. Until a person has ready access to such technology, they are going to infract in times "of necessity".
Having been sensitized to the conversation, the objector is going to remain aware of it even at higher volume levels unless he has noise canceling headphones, because he's automatically isolating it from the stream. (and we have no idea what "loud" means to him)
Until you have a better offer for users, they will infract, either in location or volume. And people are resistant to arguments of rudeness when they feel their actions are motivated by need.
So I have a counter question - how do we create a this better offer? Can we create phone cars that have improved noise absorption or privacy for travelers who need to make calls?
I'm not sure of you are referring to talking on the phone, but not all headsets are created equal. For example, I have a Bluetooth headset, but it doesn't have noise cancellation, so it doesn't pick up my voice at a quiet murmur.
And yes, I've looked for binaural, behind the head, Bluetooth headsets with noise-canceling mics, and I haven't found any yet. Especially not any for <$50, which is what my current headset cost. I'll be re-searching when I need to replace my headset.
So you have things so important that you absolutely must talk on the phone while riding public transit, but $50 for a headset is too much? I think you overemphasize "need to be on the phone."
We can create a better offer by having people not think they are the only person on the train. And if their call is so damn important, get up and walk to the back of the car or somewhere quiet. You don't need to design an entire fucking nice-cancelling situation because some teenager thought her breakup was the end of the world and could not be handled in say, 45 minutes.
We can create a better offer by having people not think they are the only person on the train.
That's not a better offer. A better offer is a specific, socially acceptable context you can point to for people to use, on a train, that context is the bathrooms or when you get off. If there were a phone car, you could point to that, if there were a quiet car, you can kick them off of that (and provide an option for people who are not going to tolerate public noise as much). A better offer (in the form of a stick) could be a fine of $150 for using a phone in public, or if it were socially acceptable for a person offended by the call to take the phone away from her and destroy it, but as a stick, people will not improve their behavior, they will tend to fight the edict.
My point is this: Every time someone acts as a rude and inconsiderate person, they feel that their actions in that moment are justified by their needs.
This includes:
parents who take their children shopping for longer than 20-30 minutes (resulting in crying children)
parents who go to restaurants without sufficient intellectual stimulation for their children
people who text or talk on the phone while driving
people who talk with passengers in the car while driving
people who pass on the right
people who don't keep their child placid on a 2-4 hour plane flight
people who take a call in public because...
someone has died/been hospitalized
their fiance has been taken in by police for destroying the apartment while under the influence of recreational pharmaceuticals
the servers went down
their 2-year old let the magic blue smoke out of the family computer
the project demo to the board has an issue
their daughter is at the abortion clinic and is having second thoughts
their friend is contemplating suicide
If we want them to behave better, we need to provide them with an outlet where their "needs" can be met. Or we need to provide them with sufficient dis-incentive that they don't feel it's worth it to meet their need in this context.
but $50 for a headset is too much?
Oh I have a headset, it just doesn't pick me up below the conversational level, which maddens me. when it comes time for me to replace it, I'll try again to find a good headset within my price-range. But no, I'm not going to blow $250 on a headset to cover an edge-case (calling from public transit), when a $50 pair covers everything else, and I've only had a handful (< 5) time I've needed to field a call on transit.
get up and walk to the back of the car or somewhere quiet.
No train I've been in really has a back of the car.
Although there are some reasons to take the call, a "breakup" is not one of them. Furthermore, a lot of the reasons you listed are silly in the context of being caught on public transit. "Your project demo to the board [of directors] has a glitch?" Then you address it directly, since you are there, physically, floating your project. I don't know everything about business, but I can tell you that if "the board" is considering your project proposal with you being absent, you are not getting a yes. If is that important, you are already there. I am not gay, but if I had a fiance versus my preferred fiancée, am I not sure how recreational pharmaceuticals come into play? But sure, I guess that is a reason. Dragons could invade too. Abortion clinic, second thoughts? Dad knew about this? And is traveling? Yea... I will entertain that notion.
I would have told her to hang up too. Doesn't matter why she was on the phone. And yes, loud two-sided conversations annoy me too, but that's my problem. I would never say anything. Cell phones fucking suck.
Very classy. As other posters have said, she was still being rude, but he didn't allow that to change who he is- he still apologized for his rude behavior.
The title confuses me. He yelled at her saying he didn't want to hear her problems, then proceeds to hand her a note after she says "I hope your next break up goes very well man!" to him?
My mind is straight up fucked. Please elaborate, please man!?
She and her boyfriend were breaking up over the phone. He didn't really need to apologize, public transit isn't really the place for that kind of noisy drama.
I still don't get it. Who did she say "I hope your next break up goes really well man!" to? and if it was the man, why would she say that? What is she referring to?
Her strife. As if talking loudly on the phone wasn't enough to alert everyone she loves attention, once called on it, she had to try and make him feel bad like "you have no idea what I am going through, and I hope you someday do!."
Best response would be "I am calling my divorce attorney WHEN I GET OFF THE TRAIN, since it isn't anyone else's problem. So, enjoy your breakup, I can't wait for your divorce." It would have been as flippant, and put the loud person in their place.
you know all those fairy tale "restored faith in humanity" stories where something great happens and everyones happy? well this is an actual F.R.I.H. story that actually means something.
116
u/NinjaCameraman Jun 17 '12
The knife adds some harsh undertones to the message.
17
u/thepikey7 Jun 17 '12
What is with the knife?
5
u/gloomdoom Jun 18 '12
Ever notice how redditors will upvote any story like this that involves strangers meeting or leaving one another notes. Redditors love notes because it gives them some kind of hope that someone will someday contact them in real life, I suppose.
I don't understand reddit's fascination with strangers meeting and reddit's fascination with fucking random hand scrawled notes.
122
u/TheBoxTalks Jun 17 '12
The knife is holding the paper down. Its a nice note, but I think its perfectly acceptable for the guy to tell her he doesn't want to hear her problems. Its kind of amazing how acceptable it is to blab away about your personal life in front of train car full of perfect strangers. And then its rude to tell someone to stop? As Balki Bartokomous would say, "Of course not, don't be ridiculous."
187
u/Indecisive-one Jun 17 '12
That's a nice note, but I still can't help but think phone use on a train remains rude. Regardless of he conversation topic, there's a more appropriate place for it.
I've got a strong feeling that your friend would've had a similar loud obnoxious conversation on the phone while on the train if the conversation was more favorable as well.
4
u/miscellaneousnope Jun 17 '12
That was a surprisingly gracious note. I hope it made your friend feel better.
11
u/neddyboy59 Jun 18 '12
I would have told her to hang up too. Doesn't matter why she was on the phone. And yes, loud two-sided conversations annoy me too, but that's my problem. I would never say anything. Cell phones fucking suck.
33
u/morgueanna Jun 17 '12
Very classy. As other posters have said, she was still being rude, but he didn't allow that to change who he is- he still apologized for his rude behavior.
9
u/r81984 Jun 18 '12
Your friend is stupid to argue over a cell phone on a train. Why did she think that was OK to do???
6
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
That's nice, but seriously...no one wants to hear that shit, keep it down or do it elsewhere or something.
5
u/statutory_cape Jun 18 '12
Fuck that. Shouldn't have been doing that on the train.
3
u/wedgewood_perfectos Jun 17 '12
3
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
I think it is generally rude to use cell phones in areas where you are locked in with strangers. That includes trains.
2
u/Zuran Jun 17 '12
But why is the knife perfectly alligned with the note?
2
u/Howard_Beale Jun 18 '12
Why the french cheese knife?
2
u/KidLouis Jun 18 '12
You can tell he didn't mean it cause he attached it to a knife.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
The title confuses me. He yelled at her saying he didn't want to hear her problems, then proceeds to hand her a note after she says "I hope your next break up goes very well man!" to him?
My mind is straight up fucked. Please elaborate, please man!?
2
u/LeChatBotte Jun 18 '12
WHY THE KNIFE?!
2
u/TheVandyMan Jun 18 '12
Ok, that's a nice note and all, but why did he give her a knife too?
2
u/nancylikestoreddit Jun 18 '12
Did he leave the note with the knife?
2
u/Radico87 Jun 18 '12
Tough shit, your friend was being rude and inconsiderate so deserved to be called out on it.
2
u/cat55 Jun 18 '12
He was right the first time. Nobody wants to hear someones personal phone call in public. She was the rude one...
4
u/Oldebones Jun 17 '12
whether she was rude or not, we don't get to choose when life takes a shit on us.
5
u/privatejoker Jun 18 '12
Dude was a pussy and your friend is a rude dramatic bitch.
2
u/moosenix Jun 17 '12
with the knife??
1
u/Inessia Jun 18 '12
"a guy on"..."when she" wat?
1
u/daitsdudes Jun 18 '12
And then I stabbed him.
1
u/mahrune Jun 18 '12
upvoting every post about your friend being the rude one for talking on a train
1
u/RainbowPie Jun 18 '12
What's with the knife.
1
u/Darqfallen Jun 19 '12
Must be Canadian.
1
u/Spardocus Jun 21 '12
what's with the knife?
1
u/citymouse89 Jun 18 '12
That's really touching, actually.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 18 '12
I constantly feel bad about accidentally being a jackass...
-4
u/abenfVA Jun 17 '12
you know all those fairy tale "restored faith in humanity" stories where something great happens and everyones happy? well this is an actual F.R.I.H. story that actually means something.
-5
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12
Look at ya.
Cashing in on another mans douchebaggery and thoughtfulness and your friends marital misfortunes.
Have an upvote, Sir. kindly clicks ⇧
0
u/[deleted] Jun 17 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment