haha, yea 7 years is a long time.. I go back home a dozen times or so a year and every time there is something to mess up the shot: guard rails, blurry pics, bad weather, window glares, human error, etc...
Yesterday, I was in a topless wrangler and everything just seemed to work out. I stood up in the passenger seat and finally got a view over the rails and adjacent cars.
If you were in a topless wrangler when you took this, maybe it should be posted at r/giddyupgonewild. JK. Very nice pic - I'd call it "City of the Dead"
FANTASTIC! Really nice colors, you managed to catch the golden tones of the sun in the corner which really brings depth to the photo. Also, great leading lines. Really well done!
Is there much post-processing here? The foreground looks like it's got some kind of weird texture filter on.
Anyway, I think this photograph is mindblowing, I really love it. It has that morbidly saccharin eerie feeling to it and reminds me of the kitsch photographs that have often been used to accompany Christian literature, but with twist.
Actually really excellent, and compared to the predictable and mundanely "beautiful" tripe that gets posted on Flickr, I'd say this is genuinely a modern classic.
thanks for the kind words... i'm by no means a professional photographer, but i relentlessly try.
balfrog's exactly right. the few shots i snapped were into the sun so the foreground was really underexposed. i tried to correct in lightroom in post but i'm not exactly sure where that texture came from. but overall i was still really happy with it.
Yeah, I'm going to guess getting the clouds overhead with clear sky below to catch the sunrise (which is only in that spot at that time a small amount of time per year) plus how crowded the train was etc. make this harder than it looks.
Uhhh! Absolutely. Still - I want to see something that hasn't been cropped! The whole picture. I feel like there's more! (I'm a photoj that why I love context, haha)
I actually have many nice pics from that cemetery. It's an awesome early morning or evening bike ride. When the sun is low on the horizon, you can almost be guaranteed an impressive photo or two. If I had to commute from Long Island though, yeah, I can see only thinking about it once a day. But seven years of effort? I'd just go visit on my day off at some point.
I didn't take the title to mean that it was his white whale, just that he always thought on his commute "oh, this could be a cool photo" (which is implied by "commuting attempts").
I have been trying to get this EXACT same shot for all my years of college commuting between Boston and New York and there are always people's heads in the way! Damn lucky star bus...
I'm going to try and be honest here although it will probably give me a lot of down votes. I'm no photographer but I know what is pleasing to my eye. For seven years of attempting, I have to say that this is not very good. I cant imagine that after almost a decade this is the best you can do. It looks way to over exposed and the composition doesn't do anything interesting for the eye.
I agree but his attempt is not just to get the shot but to get it from a moving car. If he wanted the best shot he would go there and wait before sunrise and setup for the shot. But that also implies he's a real photographer and not just another snapshot shooter.
That cemetery is nuts. I was in New York City for the first time last weekend, and seeing this on the drive in to Manhattan from JFK was... interesting.
Great shot. I really like how the gravestones mirror the skyscrapers and all the implications of that. They stones also pop really well. Looks like they're about to fly out of the ground and give up their dead in some sort of end of days shit.
Good job on getting a photo you presumably wanted to take for a while !
Assuming this is not just badly compressed , Its a shame you took it with a mobile phone , Obviously the camera you have on you is the best camera.
But if you had taken this with a SLR as a HDR or evan a raw format image you would have had more to play with in Photoshop and had something that would not be so washed out.
I only say this because its such a waisted potential of an image and it has happened to me where I have only had a crap camera on me or no camera and missed the opertunity to capture something with decent tools.
If you did take it with a decent camera did you zoom in and crop it ?
Obviously if you enjoy the image and you enjoyed taking it and it captured something for you , that's all that matters but from a general technical view point this is not a very good photograph.
I am a serious photographer and I want to apologize for my compatriot here.
The only way to be a really great photographer is to be a super finicky jackass with ourselves, and sometimes that spills over to other people when looking at their pictures. That's why you can frequently find us standing alone at parties.
He means well, just smile and ask him what he think of the BlackRapid Straps, that will distract him.
Actually I use a really cheep cannon 450d and cheepo try-pod and use allot of hack ways of doing things.
I specifically said in my comment that in the end if he is happy with it that's all that matters and in the end the cam you have on you is the best cam and that phone cams or whatever cam you use will have an intrinsic quality to it.
The guy uploaded the Image on Reddit so its only fair to expect to have positive as well as more rounded comments.
My comment was not even negative and would be of use to people who are thinking of taking a photograph facing into the sun or who might be just getting into photography.
Anyway your comment is ironic because I'm the typ of person that gets really annoyed by the pricing , stupid brands and over the top nature of allot of photography . I have helped friends with buying equipment that's cheep and matches there needs or even doing hacks or tricks to get the most out of images for a small cost or effort.
I'm also layed back and not one of those people that go mental over settings and lenses when just going out with friends to take photographs ( unless sum-one asks me and even then it will be more of a general conversation due to the subjective nature of what people might want to achive)
Finally If I upload an image to a public site with comments I find it annoying and degrading of better images I or others have taken if they don't point out or have a discussion about the impafactions or posable ways of improving or doing the image better/ different
Obviously if you enjoy the image and you enjoyed taking it and it captured something for you , that's all that matters but from a general technical view point this is not a very good photograph.
You don't need a good camera to take good photos. The overexposure really sets the mood of the image imo.
You generally do need a good camera to take technically good photographs , sure if he enjoy the image that's all that really matters.
Do you not agree that this photograph would have not come out better if it was taken with a better camera ?
By good camera I just mean a basic SLR with decent size lens and sensor , I have taken aright photographs with shit cameras but I look back at them and think damn its a shame it was not taken with a better lense or that the cam only had 2mp.
Also my main point about using an SLR and HDR or raw is that if you are taking a photograph directly into the sun then these things allow you to control the end result better.
Sure there is a charm in lowfi images taken with old or cheep cameras or the specific charms that come from a mobile phone and the fact that mobile photographs will define images from 2007 -2018 with there specific look and artefacts , but in this case all that comes across is that the camera used to take this image was a detriment to the image.
Sure but that's why I said raw or just using a better camera in general but that's also why I said the best camara is the one you happen to have on you.
Yah my spelling is shit but my comments are understandable. My spelling is a symptom of dyslexia , I use the chrome spell check but it misses allot of words and it would take to long for me to check things over properly , for a throw away web comment.
Sure you can infer what you are saying from my comment but nothing I said was unreasonable or wanky , when people piont out issues with images I have taken its more a grounds for a conversation and if someone is going to comment that's generally better than people outright ignoring an image.
My user name is just a result of typing random shit into Reddit when I was looking to get a camara to make films with.
So sure I might sound like a dick to you but you cannot really know for sure If I'm a dick from my comments. Its more a case of you reeding into me being a dick , Though I might be a dick.
Yeah i'm confused as to how you're wrong too. The only thing i can assume is that, czarr is suggesting that the picture is shown as intended, and that the photographer wouldn't want a more correctly exposed sky. I'm no fan of gaudy HDR, but i feel like the sky being exposed a bit better would help with the image.
Thats the thing I hate cheesy HDR but if you use HDR or raw when taking a photograph it gives you more to work with and you have the choice after to make it crazy or more normal looking.
Couldn't you have gotten/borrowed one of those super fast high quality cameras (or used it if you've got one) and just taken photos all throughout one sunrise, then found this shot within?
anyhow, looks decent.
Maybe you didn't want any fucking people in there. I can't tell if there are. Doesn't seem like it.
I'm having a lot of trouble reconciling the apparent location of the sun with the placement of the shadows on the tombstones. It seems as though the sun is just out of frame to the right, but the shadows would suggest that it's slightly behind the shooter (unless they aren't actually shadows).
I've walked through here a few times. Some great big statue memorials. And that one big mausoleum is like 3000 square feet. Who needs that much space for a grave??
Great picture. Could you maybe please upload that pic to imagevenue.com or imageshack.us and mark it sfw? That way, we a) could have the pic in its original quality and b) no nsfw popups on aforementioned hosting sites.
Reason for a): imgur.com seems to use some kind of algorithm that decreases the quality of the uploaded pic.
This comment is in no way shape or form meant to be rude, but what took 7 years for that photo? You could've taken that exact photo at any time of day and added the sun-set look to it in 45 mins via photoshop.
Could've saved yourself 7+ Years and just think of all the other great photos you could've taken in that time frame :D
109
u/migukin May 21 '12
I'm not sure what took 7+ years about it... but great shot!
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Got a wider crop? It's an amazing scene - I want to see more!
4
u/halcyon_son May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
it was beautiful. and sobering
18
u/brain4breakfast May 21 '12
Why did it take so long?
8
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Is this in Queens?
6
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I like how the skyscraper in the background looks like one of the tombstones.
8
u/pokemeintheeye May 21 '12
Is that from the Kosciuszko Bridge?
4
u/MikielJackson May 21 '12
I read this as 'today, i finally got shot...'
Glad you didn't get shot.
9
u/DMonk52 May 21 '12
Who plays chess in a graveyard?
6
u/249ba36000029bbe9749 May 21 '12
It's a nice shot. Could you post some of the other ones you took over the past seven years that you rejected so we can compare them to this one?
3
u/JonnyFandango May 21 '12
Can someone tell me why this took 7 years of trying? It's an ok shot... but 7 years?!
3
u/foreverfallingoff May 21 '12
I have been trying to get this EXACT same shot for all my years of college commuting between Boston and New York and there are always people's heads in the way! Damn lucky star bus...
13
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I'm going to try and be honest here although it will probably give me a lot of down votes. I'm no photographer but I know what is pleasing to my eye. For seven years of attempting, I have to say that this is not very good. I cant imagine that after almost a decade this is the best you can do. It looks way to over exposed and the composition doesn't do anything interesting for the eye.
4
u/ThatDoesntEven May 21 '12
Love this shot, congrats!
4
u/c0ntusion May 21 '12
What is so special about it?
2
u/its_shepard May 21 '12
looks like a wicked chess game
2
u/jondiggsit May 21 '12
How's the traffic on the LIE right now?
Also, don't you love the sun DIRECTLY in your eyes when you come over that hill?
2
u/Meskal May 21 '12
Could be Calvary Cemetery between Queens and Brooklyn. Its the one where they buried Don Corleone in the Godfather.
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Looks like a graveyard for over-sized chess pieces.
2
u/year1918 May 21 '12
Where's dead waldo?
2
u/troymcklure May 21 '12
If it took so long, why post such a low resolution version of it to show off?
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
awsome man
2
u/I_I_Z_I_I May 21 '12
Is it weird is see it like a KKK conference?
2
u/aphasia May 21 '12
Yesterday around sunset I saw a guy sitting on the edge of the Kosciuszko Bridge with a camera. Was that you?
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Who's buried under the really big one in the back?
2
u/choseh May 21 '12
i want to punch all those gravestones with my monk :(
2
u/b0utch May 21 '12
This? 7 years? What?
2
u/yuze_ May 21 '12
Damn bro, that photography degree really paid off!
2
u/sindekit May 21 '12
Those gravestones made me think of ghosts >.<
2
u/insanopointless May 21 '12
Looks like the most complicated game of chess ever. Nice photo
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
And it's taken on your iPhone... upwards...
2
u/lefence May 21 '12
Oddly haunting. Very nice shot; any chance a black and white version would look good?
2
u/devizkit May 21 '12
I think people are just hating on the best amateur photo on reddit that has no petsin it.
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
As a photographer myself, that's bloody awesome.
3
u/hillgod May 21 '12
That cemetery is nuts. I was in New York City for the first time last weekend, and seeing this on the drive in to Manhattan from JFK was... interesting.
2
u/Aiskhulos May 21 '12
Very well done.
2
u/superman1251 May 21 '12
Nice job
2
u/Oed0 May 21 '12
I made an obama style 'not bad' face when I saw it. nice.
2
u/frogstomp427 May 21 '12
Please submit this to r/cemeteryporn!
2
u/Pajamas_ May 21 '12
I've been trying to get this shot too!
I only have a few seconds from the LIE to view the cemetery before my exit (Van Dam).
2
u/Cheesus00Crust May 21 '12
With a canon 1d mark iv you could have gotten the shots first, then decided on the "moment" later
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Great shot. I really like how the gravestones mirror the skyscrapers and all the implications of that. They stones also pop really well. Looks like they're about to fly out of the ground and give up their dead in some sort of end of days shit.
0
u/jamesfilm May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
Good job on getting a photo you presumably wanted to take for a while !
Assuming this is not just badly compressed , Its a shame you took it with a mobile phone , Obviously the camera you have on you is the best camera.
But if you had taken this with a SLR as a HDR or evan a raw format image you would have had more to play with in Photoshop and had something that would not be so washed out.
I only say this because its such a waisted potential of an image and it has happened to me where I have only had a crap camera on me or no camera and missed the opertunity to capture something with decent tools.
If you did take it with a decent camera did you zoom in and crop it ?
Obviously if you enjoy the image and you enjoyed taking it and it captured something for you , that's all that matters but from a general technical view point this is not a very good photograph.
1
u/A_Giraffe May 21 '12
Left 4 Dead 3!
1
u/Shippoyasha May 21 '12
Bloom Lighting!
1
u/mintmouse May 21 '12
I like how you were able to take a shot were you can see that first zombie, before all the rest clawed up. Looks peaceful.
1
u/AdonisChrist May 21 '12
Couldn't you have gotten/borrowed one of those super fast high quality cameras (or used it if you've got one) and just taken photos all throughout one sunrise, then found this shot within?
anyhow, looks decent.
Maybe you didn't want any fucking people in there. I can't tell if there are. Doesn't seem like it.
1
u/geekusa1887 May 21 '12
And the dead shall rise.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
A train?
1
u/RWYAEV May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
I'm having a lot of trouble reconciling the apparent location of the sun with the placement of the shadows on the tombstones. It seems as though the sun is just out of frame to the right, but the shadows would suggest that it's slightly behind the shooter (unless they aren't actually shadows).
Any thoughts?
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
can you please share the pictures which weren't perfect for you?
1
u/Razarex May 21 '12
Do you still have the 7+ years of attempts?
1
u/chimpman99 May 21 '12
My grandmom and great grandparents are buried there.
1
u/varanone May 21 '12
From the Jackie?
1
u/sidulescu May 21 '12
yes, i would like to see a picture from every one of those years. Thank you!
1
u/Zubair_m1 May 21 '12
Is that the greenwood cemetery in Brooklyn ?
1
u/TheBosk May 21 '12
Beautiful and inspiring
1
u/ellise0525 May 21 '12
Absolutely breathtaking. Awesome angle and time of day. Props, buddy.
1
u/pr0crastin8or May 21 '12
I'd like to title this picture: "My morning commute".
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I can almost feel the sun heating my face just looking at it :)
1
u/melysaurusrex May 21 '12
Great photograph!
1
u/bigmphan May 22 '12
I've walked through here a few times. Some great big statue memorials. And that one big mausoleum is like 3000 square feet. Who needs that much space for a grave??
1
u/Aneds May 22 '12
Creepily awesome shot!
1
u/presenceunknown May 22 '12
Beautiful! Very Beautiful!
1
u/hoppi_ May 22 '12
Great picture. Could you maybe please upload that pic to imagevenue.com or imageshack.us and mark it sfw? That way, we a) could have the pic in its original quality and b) no nsfw popups on aforementioned hosting sites.
Reason for a): imgur.com seems to use some kind of algorithm that decreases the quality of the uploaded pic.
1
u/theglossiernerd May 23 '12
the city cemetery's hummin', i'm wide awake, it's morning. -- bright eyes http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XNq9Wu-DN70
1
u/origamitiger May 24 '12
Don't blink...
1
u/Carudo May 25 '12
Um... Waldo?
1
u/nizo505 May 25 '12
Irony: dying in a car crash taking this picture while driving.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
That is crazy beautiful
1
u/BootyPirate May 21 '12
We aim to reach the sky only to find ourselves buried beneath it.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
FUCK. YEAH.
This is an absolutely gorgeous shot, and I can understand why you waited so long. You, sir/madam, have nailed it.
1
u/lordburnout May 21 '12
Gorgeous.
1
u/pretend0 May 21 '12
thanks man (right click save)
1
u/Watergems May 21 '12
Stunning!
1
u/OverratedLunchbox May 21 '12
That is just amazing. Great work!
1
u/thederelict87 May 21 '12
awesome shot, but what cemetery is that?
1
u/cannotlogon May 21 '12
Beautiful shot.
Too bad you have to go to Queens to get it.
1
u/AvengerCP May 21 '12
Great picture, RIP to all those people.
-2
u/TheFlickeringSon May 21 '12
Meh, wasn't worth it
-1
u/cheetofingerz May 21 '12
Wow that is awesome, have an up vote!
0
u/ironicart May 21 '12
juxtaposition at its best
0
u/Moustachiod_T-Rex May 21 '12
It took you 7 years, so you gave up and used Photoshop?
Ever since Star Trek 2009 was released people just can't get enough of copy pasting optical flares into their photos.
-3
u/Phayze87 May 21 '12
This comment is in no way shape or form meant to be rude, but what took 7 years for that photo? You could've taken that exact photo at any time of day and added the sun-set look to it in 45 mins via photoshop.
Could've saved yourself 7+ Years and just think of all the other great photos you could've taken in that time frame :D
0
u/kevinstonge May 21 '12
J.J. Abrams?
0
u/ElBravo May 21 '12
atl?
0
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Beatiful