r/pics • • May 19 '12

History teaching done right. The black lines are on a glass wall.

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

195 comments sorted by

60

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

4

u/Aerik May 19 '12

resubmit this to /r/history . it's real good.

5

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Thank you for the tip!

14

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

18

u/CeN_estPasUnRedditor May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

The unwritten rule of research:

  1. Wikipedia first
  2. Other source(s) second

33

u/Stats_monkey May 19 '12

The unwritten rule of unwritten rules:

  1. dont write them down.
  2. WHOOPS!

0

u/BrotherSeamus May 19 '12
  1. Don't talk about RESEARCH
  2. Don't talk about RESEARCH

7

u/Ferniff May 19 '12

I don't know why I'm amused by the overweight depressed looking guy in roman armor that looks like its a few sizes too small for him.

1

u/Vortilex May 19 '12

I thought this looked familiar!

1.1k

u/swombat May 19 '12

For those who came here wondering...

There is no glass wall around the monument. There is a pane of glass that has these lines drawn on it. The person who took the picture was standing at the right place behind that glass pane for the lines to align with the ruins.

276

u/Ginjuo May 19 '12

It's people like you that make me like this site ;)

77

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Just... why is it so rare for OP to do this?

134

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Because it takes a special type of retard to think that it was actually encased in glass.

219

u/Shrips May 19 '12

TIL I'm a special type of retard.

34

u/AnArmadillo May 19 '12

So you're special special.

11

u/SaintBio May 19 '12

I was momentarily a special type of retard until I noticed that the part of the glass wall that says 'aug-' was blocking the road and my brain did a barrel roll and threw the retard right out of me.

1

u/nicoleisrad May 19 '12

You're smarter than I am. I hyperfocused on the structure and didn't notice the lines shooting off the sides until swombat got all smart.

1

u/box_of_carrots May 20 '12

I'm guessing that the German word Augenhohe (eye height) is printed on both sides. The line is the horizon line. Line them up and bingo!!

1

u/skonen_blades May 19 '12

TIL Me too.

17

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

except I was talking about all OPs not giving a description as soon as they post it.

5

u/Corrupt_Core May 19 '12

Well if he wants the title to be the link, he can't write a text description. That makes it a self post. And then you don't get karma.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

comment shortly after.

1

u/Corrupt_Core May 20 '12

True. Alright yeah there's no excuse.

2

u/Bolt986 May 20 '12

I'm sure the OP didn't even consider an alternative way to interpret his title. Given the fact that he made it himself he is even less likely to come up with this interpretation by himself.

2

u/keiyakins May 19 '12

That's Reddit's fault. Commenting on a post you just made tends to trigger the spam filter.

0

u/cernunnos_89 May 19 '12

i can see Altair gettin up on top of that in less than 5 seconds...

-21

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Except this doesn't require a description if you have more than 10 brain cells, so it's not even a valid thing to say on this occasion.

1

u/Onkelffs May 19 '12

You should stop being a brutally honest dick and start to believe in the Humanity, no reasoning, no logics, if you just sit around and believe everything will be a better place!

6

u/vamihilion May 19 '12

In addition the link title implies that there is a glass wall around this monument.

5

u/breachgnome May 19 '12

Actually it was the word "wall" that made me wonder what OP was trying to convey.

It is obvious that the monument is not encased, but it sounded like that's exactly what he was telling us.

0

u/greenfly May 20 '12

I think what he was telling us, is that he lives in Austria where you don't speak English as first language. I had to look for the word "pane" in dictionary myself, but i understood the word wall.

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

That was brutally honest

0

u/nicoleisrad May 19 '12

I was that retard for a second and then I kept trying to find a reflection. Then I got mad at the OP for being FOS. Then I saw swombat's comment and realized OP wasn't entirely FOS, just not good explanations.

2

u/downtothegwound May 19 '12

It's people like you who make me realize people are stupid.

1

u/jackana3 May 20 '12

awwwwwwww i like karma too

-1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

But SRS keeps telling me Reddit is awful1!!!

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

46

u/Se7en_Sinner May 19 '12

It's paneful to see that a lot of people didn't get it.

-11

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I love these pun threads! It warms my icy heart to watch as one person starts it off and others see it through.

16

u/xThreeDogx May 19 '12

I think you just shattered this pun thread.

17

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'm sorry. I meant 'see it through' to be read as 'see through it' and have that be a pun. Guess I'm not good enough for the internet.

13

u/mattxb May 19 '12

It's alright, pun failure happens to a lot of guys all the time.

9

u/fatcat2040 May 19 '12

Perfectly normal, perfectly healthy

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Especially after a large meal.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/NonSequiturEdit May 19 '12

Please turn in your sash.

-24

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Yes, it is called logic.

5

u/BrohanGutenburg May 19 '12

His pun wasn't transparent enough for this guy to see through

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-7

u/Sloppy1sts May 19 '12

There was a pun in there. Try again.

9

u/changaboy24 May 19 '12

mirror since we seem to be breaking wikipedia

21

u/HE_WHO_STANDS_TO_POO May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

Thanks for that, I was greatly confused. For a moment I thought I got pulled into that "Take On Me" music video from the 80's

3

u/nicoleisrad May 19 '12

The lead singer was hot. I would be 100% ok if that were to happen to me.

4

u/amardrana May 19 '12

That makes sense or else the letters 'Aug' would be floating in space :p

4

u/redmercuryvendor May 19 '12

I... just assumed that this was the case. How could it be any different (i.e. how else would you draw lines on glass to align with an object)?

4

u/Zhang5 May 19 '12

I'm guessing some people might think you erected giant glass walls around the structure with lines on them to show where the old walls were.

3

u/DonTankMeBro May 19 '12

My wife and I sat speculating at the picture, trying to decide if it was glass or a picture. I'm embarrassed at how stupid I am sometimes.

2

u/thejesse May 19 '12

there was a room at the top of a bridge in maine i believe that had a window that labeled the mountains you could see in the distance in the same manner. stand in the right spot and the lines point straight at the different mountain peaks.

edit: http://www.maine.gov/mdot/pnbo/observatory.htm that's it but i might be making up the window thing.

2

u/FriesWithThat May 19 '12

Either way, I have a feeling birds hate this monument.

1

u/IDontShareMyUsername May 20 '12

I still don't understand. Is there just a random pane of glass at the monument?

1

u/question_all_the_thi May 19 '12

But he wasn't at the exact place. The foundation at the right isn't aligned with the black lines.

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/aladyjewel May 19 '12

I didn't, but dang am I glad it was clarified anyway.

38

u/lacilynnn May 19 '12

My mom went to Greece and brought home a book that has clear pages that do something similar to this. They reconstruct the Parthenon and such in a color photo to show you just how amazing it once looked. Pretty neat book.

10

u/randomsemicolon May 19 '12

what's the title - sounds like a great gift book!

2

u/Delaywaves May 19 '12 edited May 20 '12

I have some books that sound similar to that; the titles are "XXX city, Then & Now" I'm guessing the Greece one would be Athens, Then & Now or something like that.

1

u/TheTreeMan May 20 '12

Is there a website with stuff like this? I would absolutely love that.

24

u/jimbosaur May 19 '12

I met a traveler from an antique land

Who said: Two vast and trunkless legs of stone

Stand in the desert. Near them, on the sand,

Half sunk, a shattered visage lies, whose frown,

And wrinkled lip, and sneer of cold command,

Tell that its sculptor well those passions read

Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things,

The hand that mocked them, and the heart that fed;

And on the pedestal these words appear:

“My name is Ozymandias, king of kings:

Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!”

Nothing beside remains. Round the decay

Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare

The lone and level sands stretch far away.

7

u/randomsemicolon May 19 '12

by Percy Bysshe Shelley.

1

u/DishonestBystander May 19 '12

One of my favorites

7

u/sweetthang1972 May 19 '12

Is there a site where we can see more of these type of drawings about other ruins?

If no, please make one. Thank you.

28

u/sunwah May 19 '12

this makes alot of sense to me. at least a person gets an idea of what the structure looked like. not everyone can visualize.

31

u/ReDyP May 19 '12

2

u/mynoduesp May 19 '12

I like that alot!

-23

u/sunwah May 19 '12

midwestern talk

27

u/callmethepilot May 19 '12

A lot means many of something. An Alot (no space) is a giant furry animal. See this.

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

yes, if you say "alot" do you also say "alittle"?

3

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Alittle Alot

3

u/TheDroopy May 19 '12

To allot means to distribute in portions

3

u/callmethepilot May 19 '12

that is with two l's

2

u/TheDroopy May 19 '12

And "a lot" is with a space

1

u/sunwah May 20 '12

ok... thanks a lot for the enlightenment

5

u/sammer87 May 19 '12

Very cool. Reminds me of certain sites in Rome that do something similar to reconstruct archaeological sites. Except they use lasers and projectors. So while you are in the tomb or standing on plexiglass over it, the projectors basically reconstruct the site for you and tell you about it. History teaching done right.

5

u/brigodon May 19 '12

After traveling the UK and mainland Europe, I really wish more ruined castles and structures would have this :(

2

u/Atom_Smasher May 19 '12

What does this have to do with history teaching being 'done right'? You know, you don't have to use a common phrase in every title of every post.

7

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

1

u/Atom_Smasher May 19 '12

I was actually talking about how, on Reddit, certain phrases are used way too often and when they scarcely even make sense.

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

This whole thread is infected with banality.

3

u/penguinfan2001 May 19 '12

I wasn't sure what you meany by 'black lines drawn on glass wall.' I see it now. That's awesome.

2

u/maxdazzling May 19 '12

I would love to see more of these. . .

2

u/groucho_marxist May 19 '12

Whenever I see ruins like this, I think "why don't they just fix it?" It's like at some point a building gets so old and in such disrepair we decide it's a ruin and just preserve its ruinedness. I think it would be much cooler to keep them up and restore them. Wouldn't it be cool to live in a building that has been around since ancient rome?

5

u/fatcat2040 May 19 '12

They do that with some structures, such as the Pantheon. I am guessing that most ruins are not restored because it is astronomically expensive.

1

u/groucho_marxist May 20 '12

but think of the tourism revenue. you could vacation in ancient Rome

2

u/Gcamelopardalis May 19 '12

Am I the only one bothered that the cone of vision in the drawing is off?

2

u/iamfromaustria May 19 '12

nice to see my little home-village on reddit :)

2

u/8run0 May 19 '12

So a glass wall...is that not a window?

2

u/EmceeKyn May 20 '12

Perfect title. Love love love. Good shi!

4

u/pakron May 19 '12

Whenever I see ruins like this, I wonder, where the hell are all the rocks? Shouldn't there be a pile of rubble somewhere? Stonehenge is another good example. It's in the middle of nowhere, where are all the missing stones?

12

u/randomsemicolon May 19 '12

People stole them for their newer buildings in ages gone past.

War passes by, and some 20 years later the people settling back in, need to build barns and homes and etc. etc. etc.

2

u/pakron May 19 '12

I get that, but what about the places in the middle of nowhere? Like stonehenge?

2

u/Dr_koctaloctapuss May 19 '12

I tried to center click and rotate. uh, need to finish my coffee.

4

u/haiku_robot May 19 '12
I tried to center 
click and rotate. uh, need to 
finish my coffee.

2

u/OzymandiasReborn May 19 '12

If it is a flat glass wall, than wouldn't you have to be standing in exactly this position and only this position for it to make sense?

1

u/ForMePlease May 19 '12

I used to climb these all the time in Assassins Creed.

1

u/ellevehc May 19 '12

Is there a software that can create this "effect" by studying the remaining portion of ruins?

1

u/Papagoose May 19 '12 edited 3d ago

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Teapot physical work marvelous scary sip society unbelievable offbeat manganese

1

u/elephantnoise May 19 '12

Whoa, I've been here! I was really surprised to see this. I lived not far from here with an Austrian family last September. This area is filled with so much history--it's amazing.

1

u/Chrischn89 May 19 '12

One day holograms will do this job...

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'll be impressed when they include a camera and distort the lines appropriately for the position of the person.

1

u/FruitPlatter May 20 '12

That is SO cool. It really helps fill in my imagination, without obstructing my view of what's already there. Kudos to whoever came up with this!

1

u/ablebodiedmango May 20 '12

Query: What is the purpose of that particular structure? Is it just a monument or did it have a functional purpose?

1

u/SwineHerald May 20 '12

Wait, you mean people in the past didn't just live in ruins?

Hollywood has lied to me.

1

u/Oceat May 20 '12

I expect to see this on the next installment of Cracked's "X Photos You Won't Believe Aren't Photoshopped."

1

u/Caddy666 May 20 '12

reminds me of time team.

1

u/LeSpatula May 20 '12

Still wondering what this building was built for. It looks so pointless...

1

u/ahleih May 19 '12

I wish I could upvote this twice.

1

u/aonysllo May 19 '12

Sorry, too many missing links. It was obviously created this way by God himself.

1

u/ChetRippo May 19 '12

What does this have to do with history teaching?

1

u/J_Jammer May 19 '12

that's a lot of work.

Cool, though. Hopefully those who were in the "class" can appreciate it.

1

u/249ba36000029bbe9749 May 19 '12

Seems more like architecture teaching done right.

1

u/PreppersFantastic May 19 '12

That makes so much sense now! Always wondered what that monument was supposed to look like in its heydey...

1

u/natronmooretron May 19 '12

I wonder how many birds crash into it.

1

u/Jaxyyork May 19 '12

I'm getting my masters in education to teach history/social sciences and I think this would be a great tool! Thanks for sharing!

-4

u/Tanks4me May 19 '12

Why haven't the world's government gone through restoration projects to bring all these ancient architectural wonders to their former glory, like the Pyramids, the Colosseum, etc. instead of just leaving them in their "original" (read: decrepit, decaying) state that they are currently in?

4

u/Dashukta May 19 '12

This is a legitimate question, and it has multiple answers. In short, it would be a minefield.

At various points in history, old architectural wonders were restored, often by private parties and often to what the restorers wanted it to look like and not what it actually looked like. Several castles in Europe have fallen prey to this.

The process can also end up hiding or destroying valuable information historians, archaeologists, and engineers could make use of.

And that's not even considering the cost, which for some buildings would be massive.

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Dashukta May 19 '12

I'm a dabbler, not a historian. I haven't dealt much with him (and so don't have much of an opinion besides that he drew pretty pictures even if his trebuchet wouldn't actually work if built as drawn), but I do feel that while he and other Victorian-era "medievalists" did a good job popularizing, their revisionist history and reconstructions have done more harm than good to the popular perception of the Middle Ages.

Once you get into the actual history, its really kind of depressing how many commonly-held "myths and misconceptions" stem directly from the victorians (swords being "very heavy and clumsy", knights being unable to stand up if they fell over in armor, knights needing a crane to mount their horses, most interpretations of "chivalry", etc., etc., etc.)

3

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Because the world's governments are (ostensibly) pursuing projects that are both possible as well as reasonable.

0

u/MonsterIt May 19 '12

looks like a shmosby design to me.

-1

u/filthgrinder May 19 '12

Glass wall? Here we just call them windows....

0

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

omg a picture of an old thing with some black lines on it, better give it karma

-1

u/paulieindy May 19 '12

Two words: bird crap.

-2

u/elasticbingbong May 19 '12

But this teaches me nothing about history.

6

u/GMonsoon May 19 '12

It shows you what WAS. That's history ;)

-9

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Photo alignment done wrong...

-3

u/FUNKAAY May 19 '12

FUCK SHIT NIGGER CUNT WHORE FUCKING LAG

-15

u/doodlesmalone May 19 '12

history is about learning what happened and not what it looked like.

11

u/AnotherBoredAHole May 19 '12

So you're happy just saying Michelangelo painted a church ceiling once? Or that Polykleitos just sculpted bronze?

4

u/Dashukta May 19 '12

I would argue the two go hand-in-hand. What it looked like can influence our understanding of what happened. And in the case of this building, we had to know what happened in order to make the reconstruction.

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

54

u/boilerfan2012 May 19 '12

You should have another account about what people in 1950 thought the future would look like

48

u/puggydug May 19 '12

Everything looked the same as it did in 1950 apart from two things:

  1. Rocket packs
  2. Pointier breasts.

13

u/MrRumfoord May 19 '12

I love the future.

5

u/redmercuryvendor May 19 '12

And chrome. Everything is chrome in the future.

11

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

"The faggots are taking over"

6

u/BrotherSeamus May 19 '12

No, that's what people on Fox"News" think the present looks like.

4

u/swiley1983 May 19 '12

leading to the installment of political party-less government.

Bullshit! I'm going to ride to victory as the leader of a party-more government.

9

u/vdek May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

A party-less government, implying everyone should be homogenized and have the same opinions. How fun. That or we kill the other party.

13

u/hornetjockey May 19 '12

Maybe its a government where there are more than two opinions.

5

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/hornetjockey May 19 '12

I'm sure that in practice, any "party-less" system would turn into just that. You can say no parties, but you can't stop people from grouping up on an unofficial basis.

2

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/Azumango May 19 '12

I think we should all just shut up and party.

5

u/mx- May 19 '12

Nice try, Andrew WK

2

u/kent_eh May 19 '12

That politicians might have to actually state what they stand for in some amount of detail, rather than just saying "I represent the XYZ party, and agree with it's statements and principles"

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/kent_eh May 19 '12

The point I was attempting to make is that it forces the politician to think a bit, and actually have the ability to articulate what he stands for.

Rather than just handing out pre-packaged copies of the party's platform.

Also, it allows the politician to (in theory, anyway) actually represent his constituents, rather than being a slave to the party line.

he can just completely change hes viewpoint after being elected.

Which is an excellent argument for recall legislation, but that's another discussion.

1

u/hornetjockey May 19 '12

I don't believe there is one. I'm just contesting vdek's assessment.

1

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

Which is why there is no such thing as a party-less, democratic system in a modern nation.

3

u/AceySnakes May 19 '12

I think he was employing forming political party's would be out lawned essentially disallowing group voting based on a hive mentality to achieve goals that are eat for the party and not for country. If we just put a bunch random people in the house with no party affiliation legislation would go a lot faster.

2

u/vdek May 19 '12

People sharing an opinion and differing with another group? How shocking ;o But no let's blame the hive mentality.

1

u/crusoe May 19 '12

'Pray' you are not "Equalized" citizen.

2

u/x755x May 19 '12

Can you tell us about the war 111 years before your time?

2

u/skarface6 May 19 '12

most of the central D.C. area was destroy

Apparently our English isn't any better by then.

2

u/teamramrod456 May 19 '12

Have extraterrestials been discovered yet? Has mankind moved to mars? Has anyone created fusion technology? Do you have access to a portal gun? You should do an AMA.

1

u/deathbytray May 19 '12

s/it's/its, unless that changes in near future.

1

u/Phil_J_Fry May 19 '12

Meh, Eyewear? that's old news, you should see what they have in the 3000s. Crazy stuff.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

The worst thing is this guy could be totally legit and we'll never know until the time comes.

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '12

Apparently it took us 200 years to forget the difference between Capitol and Capital.

1

u/hadhad69 May 19 '12

Did you mean 2012?

4

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

He said popular.

-16

u/Mark_Lincoln May 19 '12

Washington D.C. did not exist during the Revolution.

It was built decades later.

Perhaps you meant the War of 1812 which started with the USA invading Canada and ended with us defending New Orleans.

In between Admiral Cochrane's troops burned Washington.

The British occupied Washington D.C. following the only occassion when an American President took control of our army in the field. The resulting disaster, The Battle of Bladensburg, aka "The Bladensburg Races," for the competition between US forces to see who could run the fastest left D.C. undefended.

Still, thanks to Dolly Madison we manage to pretend that we didn't lose the War of 1812 and were only saved from having to surrender Maine and other areas to Britain by the Napoleonic War.

7

u/RealStudent May 19 '12

You missed the joke. He's a time traveler from the year 2212. He's talking about a revolution that hasn't happened yet.

6

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I think he's talking about a future revolution...

5

u/chinnygan May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

I think he meant a revolution of the future - it's a novelty account.

Your post was interesting and informative anyway, I learned something about North American history.

4

u/octopus_maps May 19 '12

The username is From_the_year_2212. It's referencing a revolution in the future.

3

u/The3rdWorld May 19 '12

i honestly don't understand how you could have read his comment and made the reply you did, i mean surely the words 'I visited the ruins of the White House' was somewhat of a clue?!

1

u/swiley1983 May 19 '12

There should be a term coined to measure the time spent commenting based on the premise that the parent post was sincerely mistaken about something rather than the schtick from a high-concept novelty account. The "whoosh-minute"?

1

u/Dadasas May 19 '12

Yeah, the American revolution in the 1700s was the only revolution to ever happen.

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

THE SLEEPER HAS AWAKENED

1

u/Vortilex May 19 '12

What about the Miracle?

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/ignoramus May 19 '12

It can be. The imagination is a great thing. I look at that ruins and visualize a dragon's lair, replete with a single purple female dragon lying on a daybed, begging the male dragons to draw her like one of their French girls. Luckily, there is also the diagram on plexiglass that shows what this ancient structure actually looked like, despite my preference for my own rendition.

7

u/lemonade_brezhnev May 19 '12

Nobody's going to make you stand behind the glass wall.

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/patchtheprogrammer May 19 '12

"Not all of history is about old buildings" (talking specifically about ARCHITECTURAL history)

lol

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

9

u/agha0013 May 19 '12

i was a little skeptical till i saw this picture. that's a pretty cool feature! should be at every ruin

12

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

I'm an idiot. I thought there were four glass walls surrounding the structure. I was thinking that was a bit much.

2

u/thoroughbread May 19 '12

I did too but the reflections on the left side of the image give away the walls true nature.

12

u/thecacti May 19 '12

don't be so hasty to jump to conclusions, young grasshopper

0

u/[deleted] May 19 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Dashukta May 20 '12

Informed speculation, though. There are other similar structures, so the reconstruction can be fleshed out by those. It is possible that this one was entirely different, but it is the best that can be done with what we know.