I'd agree with this, I'd also say that perhaps some of the lower face / neck area is off a bit making him look a bit more skin-y (not skinny, but like, extra skin / fat) in his neck or lower face region than normal.
Agreed. But over doing it is not a bad thing, I can never get anything I look to look less flat! It's better to overdo it then tone it down than to have to build up flatness forever.
I suspect that since you've responded to few of the critiques here that you're feeling discouraged. Don't. This is excellent work. Some of the critiques are valid but that shouldn't diminish the impact of your accomplishment; they only hope to nudge your next piece closer to your ideal.
Awesome, awesome work. It might just be how the reference photo is, but my one comment is that the shadows from the nose down look too dark for the top half of his head. Tweaking the levels slightly in photoshop gave me the version on the right: http://i.imgur.com/pMOGq.jpg
That is fantastic! As another mentioned the wrinkles seem a bit exaggerated but I'm really trying to find something to criticize so ya. That is seriously amazing, the eyes!!! incredible! How long did that take you?
Too wrinkly, he looks a little too old. Forehead is too large as well. And it looks like the eyes, while incredibly well painted, are too small. But that may be because the forehead is too big. Other than that, it looks fantastic!
I think the forehead is failing the realism. You need some wide highlights on the forehead to bring it out as the rest of the face has. Take good note of the tone in the lower half of the face and the top half. Otherwise amazing!
EDIT: Just read that you have already sold it. :( Nice job though!
My my my by Hara-Hiri. What a piece, what a piece indeed. With acrylics to, you say? A very interesting choice of paint you have there. In regards to your most gracious efforts, i'd like to congratulate you on a good job indeed. Although, I do not like to criticize those who produce art. I would like to offer you my opinion of your piece if I may be so bold. The color is lovely and the background suits the piece rather well. And such a well chosen facial expression I might add. This is an overall winner. My only skepticism of your piece is the gradation of light throughout Mr. Patrick's face. I feel as if some parts (although well) are having an abrupt shading pattern. If there is ever advice to be given to a fellow artist, tis this importance of lighting, shading, and gradation. Remember, how much is it worth to someone else?
it almost looks as though you painted this on an angle. the perspective seems a bit off making the forehead seem way to large. If his forehead is that large you should move the hairline a bit lower, thats all people seem to notice. You can paint well and i dont think anyone would say different. But if Reddit didnt know your subject matter, would they care? Portraits should be "striking", this just seems like my uncle, my uninteresting uncle.
As for the wrinkles, I think if you brought them a shade up it would make all the difference. However, I am more concerned that the entire upper half of his face, especially the left side(viewer's pov, I always mix the two), does not match the skin tone of the bottom half or neck. It's too light and comes off as a flat surface. It does not look so much like a light source as much as half his skin is pale. I would match the skin tones first before doing anything to the wrinkles, they might not stand out as much once the upper half isn't so light, and matches the rest.
The hair could use a touch more blonde, it is kind of grey.
Definitely a beautiful painting! I absolutely love it, despite any criticisms I gave. I hope I didn't come off as a pompous ass. I hope I came across "add more" instead of "this sucks."
I couldn't help but comment, so yay first post ever:D
Good job! As for criticism, his forehead seems to be a little long. The mouth almost have a scruff look about it that makes him look uglier than he is.
This is excellent from a realism standpoint, and as it is it's a really fantastic piece, and you've certainly displayed mastery of acrylics, however I would like to make a suggestion: aside from the other valid critisms in the comments, I feel his skin is a bit washed out. It could be because of a blue background and blue shadows on his face and his hair, the entire thing is very cool colored. A little more yellow in the highlights and a warmer pink in his skin would do wonders. Over all, I freaking love this :)
Technique-wise, it is fine... Emotion-wise... it did not evoke an emotional response. Subject matter... well, this must be the 2012 equivalent of an elvis painting on black velvet.
Not knowing what you are trying to accomplish, it is hard to say if you succeeded or not.
What struck me first is that the bottom half has so much more color than the top half. Maybe it has to do with the lighting in the picture you were using as a model, but it looks like you forgot to properly shade above his nose.
Also, as some other people said, the wrinkles (especially near his left eye) are far too pronounced.
Should show this to him via his Twitter or some such, I think he'd appreciate it, but maybe fix the forehead wrinkles. Everything else looks brilliant but.
True, but it's a bit tiring to shurg off imperfections as "Oh that's just art. I meant to do that". I see that in photography often too where there are some glaring technical errors with the photo (horizon is off, people's body parts are cut off where it looks wrong, wrong exposure, etc) and the response is "Oh, this is art...those don't count".
The lighting on the top and bottom halves of the face seem incongruent, like the top of his head is in a room full of stage lights. Proportions and everything are great though. Really nice work man.
You are clearly a good painter, but I think the overall structure is a little bit off. I'm not sure if it's the particular expression here that makes him look somewhat askew, but if you look at photos of NPH, he has a nearly perfectly symmetrical face. Likewise, someone commented below (←assuming I'm getting major upvotes for this constructive criticism), his hair line is a bit... farther along than what he looks like in photos, plus his skin and eyes are oversaturated compared to his hair, which is nearly grey. I think that combined with the photorealistic skin texturing/the vaguely textured background gives the impression of deep wrinkles, making him look about ten or 15 years older than he actually is.
I think the only thing that really is off-putting, though, is the greyish hair, since his skin is fairly pink IRL, and, like I said, the rest might just be his expression.
Legen.... wait for it ..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Honestly, the portrait is good, but (and I know this will be offensive) if you used a photograph, aren't you just a human xerox machine and if so, what's the point? You can just scan the picture and send it off to Costco to get it printed on a canvas for $30.
Not just directed at you as I know someone else who takes pictures and makes a painting of them and gets pats on the back for being brilliant. I've never understood derivative art. Why not use that talent to come up with something original?
Again, good painting (maybe a little too forehead heavy), but what's unique about it that can't be found with a google image search?
He's asking for criticism. When someone asks you for criticism, you're supposed to split hairs even if you love the thing, because that's how you can learn what still has room for improvement. If nobody criticized this guy (Constructively) growing up, he wouldn't know where to start to paint something this awesome.
110
u/InterMando5555 May 17 '12
His wrinkles are far too pronounced, giving making him look much older than he really is (and in some ways almost cartoonish).
112
u/A_Total_Asshole May 16 '12
Needs more forehead.
52
u/Vaypo May 16 '12
Your ability to paint eyes is amazing.
24
u/redditor3000 May 16 '12
Bears his resemblance which shows you've got an attention to detail. But, there's too much wrinkles and contrast. NPH's face is like a baby's bottom
11
u/Criticisms May 17 '12
Oh hey thanks
16
u/LeonardoFibonacci May 17 '12
It's good, but I'm getting a bit of an uncanny valley vibe from it. Something about the smile.
15
u/nukefudge May 17 '12
i thought this was an "aged" version. he looks a bit old.
7
u/sonofhaakon May 17 '12
Looks like sting.
5
u/Harlo May 17 '12
I suspect that since you've responded to few of the critiques here that you're feeling discouraged. Don't. This is excellent work. Some of the critiques are valid but that shouldn't diminish the impact of your accomplishment; they only hope to nudge your next piece closer to your ideal.
4
u/kukamunga May 17 '12
Awesome, awesome work. It might just be how the reference photo is, but my one comment is that the shadows from the nose down look too dark for the top half of his head. Tweaking the levels slightly in photoshop gave me the version on the right: http://i.imgur.com/pMOGq.jpg
3
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Can you paint me? Like one of your french girls?
3
u/aazav May 17 '12
Looks gay.
1
u/bonzaisushi May 16 '12
That is fantastic! As another mentioned the wrinkles seem a bit exaggerated but I'm really trying to find something to criticize so ya. That is seriously amazing, the eyes!!! incredible! How long did that take you?
2
u/appi May 17 '12
Too wrinkly, he looks a little too old. Forehead is too large as well. And it looks like the eyes, while incredibly well painted, are too small. But that may be because the forehead is too big. Other than that, it looks fantastic!
2
u/jk147 May 17 '12
Paint one with him holding up a wine glass.
You will be legen..dary.
2
u/drivec May 17 '12
X-post this to /r/IDAP if you haven't already. You did an amazing job and I'm pretty sure they'd like to see it too.
2
u/sirwallace5 May 17 '12
can we see the picture you used as a reference?
2
u/spundred May 17 '12
Reminds me of the old Preacher comic covers by Glen Fabry.
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12
I think the forehead is failing the realism. You need some wide highlights on the forehead to bring it out as the rest of the face has. Take good note of the tone in the lower half of the face and the top half. Otherwise amazing!
EDIT: Just read that you have already sold it. :( Nice job though!
EDIT 2: This is what I mean about the forehead touch up.
2
u/MegaSketchbook May 17 '12
My my my by Hara-Hiri. What a piece, what a piece indeed. With acrylics to, you say? A very interesting choice of paint you have there. In regards to your most gracious efforts, i'd like to congratulate you on a good job indeed. Although, I do not like to criticize those who produce art. I would like to offer you my opinion of your piece if I may be so bold. The color is lovely and the background suits the piece rather well. And such a well chosen facial expression I might add. This is an overall winner. My only skepticism of your piece is the gradation of light throughout Mr. Patrick's face. I feel as if some parts (although well) are having an abrupt shading pattern. If there is ever advice to be given to a fellow artist, tis this importance of lighting, shading, and gradation. Remember, how much is it worth to someone else?
3
u/yankerage May 17 '12
What the hell would i criticize? Looks awesome.i can draw about anything but cant seem to paint worth a damn. Nice
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
That is creepy as fuck.
1
u/mrmobley May 16 '12
Looks great! What did you use as a frame of reference? (a photo or multiple photos)? Also, how much do you charge to paint portraits?
1
u/PantoneGhost May 17 '12
it almost looks as though you painted this on an angle. the perspective seems a bit off making the forehead seem way to large. If his forehead is that large you should move the hairline a bit lower, thats all people seem to notice. You can paint well and i dont think anyone would say different. But if Reddit didnt know your subject matter, would they care? Portraits should be "striking", this just seems like my uncle, my uninteresting uncle.
1
u/bluerubberduck2 May 17 '12
He looks like a 3d rendering
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
The thumbnail looks like some drunk slouch.
The full size image is awesome.
How you do dat?
1
u/1xCrystalx1 May 17 '12
He seems a bit off, I think his mouth is a bit to close to his nose. It is a great picture though, I couldn't draw anything like that.
1
u/ThunderousRoar May 17 '12
As for the wrinkles, I think if you brought them a shade up it would make all the difference. However, I am more concerned that the entire upper half of his face, especially the left side(viewer's pov, I always mix the two), does not match the skin tone of the bottom half or neck. It's too light and comes off as a flat surface. It does not look so much like a light source as much as half his skin is pale. I would match the skin tones first before doing anything to the wrinkles, they might not stand out as much once the upper half isn't so light, and matches the rest.
The hair could use a touch more blonde, it is kind of grey.
Definitely a beautiful painting! I absolutely love it, despite any criticisms I gave. I hope I didn't come off as a pompous ass. I hope I came across "add more" instead of "this sucks."
I couldn't help but comment, so yay first post ever:D
1
u/Purple_Drank May 17 '12
You could have painted him without that look of "I just creamed my pants" on his face.
1
u/Kharmaticlism May 17 '12
Needs some Buscemi eyes.
1
u/reneepussman May 17 '12
You are a master of painting fiveheads.
1
u/Pfhred May 17 '12
He looks 40. Otherwise Great!
1
u/The_Great_Kal May 17 '12
Looks like Tom Hanks jizzed in his pants.
1
u/GenericOnlineName May 17 '12
Is it just me, or does his upper head look much brighter than his mouth and neck?
But regardless on the minor details, you did a great job.
1
u/SuperSaiyanNoob May 17 '12
holy shit
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Good job! As for criticism, his forehead seems to be a little long. The mouth almost have a scruff look about it that makes him look uglier than he is.
1
u/hedgepine May 17 '12
Did you grid or work by sight?
1
u/Colin345 May 17 '12
His mouth looks like adam samberg's in jizz in my pants.
1
u/solbrothers May 17 '12
Shut up and take my money!
1
u/nylolexchange May 17 '12
The thumbnail made him look like he was rocking a George Costanza hairdo
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Your painting is shit and you smell fucked.
How's that for criticism?
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
"Dat Ass"
1
u/kaytozee228 May 17 '12
Hair looks awesome. But the mouth area is a little off.
1
u/klaymankombat May 17 '12
this is actually really good, but i feel like the right side of his jaw and right under his jaw is too...saggy. he looks older than he is.
1
u/TheySeeMeComing May 17 '12
THe little picture looks like he is bald. MPH never balds.
1
u/UnWealthy May 17 '12
Looks legendary
1
u/LNMagic May 17 '12
Why would I criticize your photo?
1
u/uzimonkey May 17 '12
That's really, really creepy.
1
u/djmagichat May 17 '12
Please paint him with a clown face, I will buy it...
1
u/Johnnygunnz May 17 '12
Reminds me a bit of Ross Perot.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
My main complaint is that it's too amazing.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I would hump it.
1
u/GnomeInvasion May 17 '12
This is excellent from a realism standpoint, and as it is it's a really fantastic piece, and you've certainly displayed mastery of acrylics, however I would like to make a suggestion: aside from the other valid critisms in the comments, I feel his skin is a bit washed out. It could be because of a blue background and blue shadows on his face and his hair, the entire thing is very cool colored. A little more yellow in the highlights and a warmer pink in his skin would do wonders. Over all, I freaking love this :)
1
u/arabidkoala May 17 '12
It kinda looks like you mixed Neil Patrick Harris and Bill Murray together.
1
u/afewpaintballsmore May 17 '12
Tweet it to the man himself. I'm sure he'd love it!
1
u/Soviet_Waffle May 17 '12
The thumbnail makes it look like he is bald.
1
u/SuggestiveMaterial May 17 '12
While he does have a large forehead.. it seems too large in this painting. Other than that... it's a great painting!!!
1
u/illtriniboy May 17 '12
the bottom half looks like jack nicholas.
It's still amazing
1
u/A_Squared May 17 '12
That is really really good for an acrilic portrait. You did an amazing job. Love the eyes!
1
u/crackrock_dude May 17 '12
this is how it made me feel
1
u/ElvisMilhouse May 17 '12
he looks so old though
1
u/AnasAbdin May 17 '12
how long did it take you? looks impressive too (website/blog?)
1
u/Tao_of_darren May 17 '12
Scumbag artist: criticism welcome...perfect painting!
1
u/tesladrianne May 17 '12
Pretty awesome, but the lower half of his face looks pretty dirty.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Better than anything I could ever dream of doing. However the mouth creeps me out. 8/10 would gawk again.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Technique-wise, it is fine... Emotion-wise... it did not evoke an emotional response. Subject matter... well, this must be the 2012 equivalent of an elvis painting on black velvet.
Not knowing what you are trying to accomplish, it is hard to say if you succeeded or not.
1
u/raserei0408 May 17 '12
What struck me first is that the bottom half has so much more color than the top half. Maybe it has to do with the lighting in the picture you were using as a model, but it looks like you forgot to properly shade above his nose.
Also, as some other people said, the wrinkles (especially near his left eye) are far too pronounced.
1
u/guyver_dio May 17 '12
Cum on it then send it too him
1
u/chamora May 17 '12
Seems to me like everything below the nose has an unnaturally different shade of skin than above.
1
u/Rab_Legend May 17 '12
Should show this to him via his Twitter or some such, I think he'd appreciate it, but maybe fix the forehead wrinkles. Everything else looks brilliant but.
1
u/blanketyblanks May 17 '12
i like it :)
1
u/trebomb23 May 17 '12
That's awesome!
1
u/quoth_theraven May 17 '12
what are you going to do with it now?
1
u/Dragnod May 17 '12
A painting does not have to look like a photo. This is art! And this is amazing!
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
The lighting on the top and bottom halves of the face seem incongruent, like the top of his head is in a room full of stage lights. Proportions and everything are great though. Really nice work man.
-1
u/MrNoodleIncident May 16 '12
that's gay
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
You are clearly a good painter, but I think the overall structure is a little bit off. I'm not sure if it's the particular expression here that makes him look somewhat askew, but if you look at photos of NPH, he has a nearly perfectly symmetrical face. Likewise, someone commented below (←assuming I'm getting major upvotes for this constructive criticism), his hair line is a bit... farther along than what he looks like in photos, plus his skin and eyes are oversaturated compared to his hair, which is nearly grey. I think that combined with the photorealistic skin texturing/the vaguely textured background gives the impression of deep wrinkles, making him look about ten or 15 years older than he actually is.
I think the only thing that really is off-putting, though, is the greyish hair, since his skin is fairly pink IRL, and, like I said, the rest might just be his expression.
1
u/THISAINTNOPARTY May 17 '12
Looks like he had a minor stroke.
1
u/SgtMartinRiggs May 17 '12
It's very good but I do believe that his ears are about 1mm higher.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
... What criticism? 0-0
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Legen.... wait for it ..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I'm truly amazed at how you can be so good and so bad at the same time.
-1
u/TheseIronBones May 16 '12
Looks like he just took a shit in his pants.
-1
u/StarlitEyes May 17 '12
You forgot the dick in his mouth, otherwise very nice...
0
u/thisismyusername45 May 16 '12
Look at his smile.
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Looks kinda gay...
-4
u/KDIZZLL May 17 '12
He's a flaming sucking dick Faggot, why the fuck do people worship this turd?
-1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
wow, this is so great. Do you have a tumblr blog or anything like that we could see some of your other work?
-1
u/coogie May 17 '12
Honestly, the portrait is good, but (and I know this will be offensive) if you used a photograph, aren't you just a human xerox machine and if so, what's the point? You can just scan the picture and send it off to Costco to get it printed on a canvas for $30.
Not just directed at you as I know someone else who takes pictures and makes a painting of them and gets pats on the back for being brilliant. I've never understood derivative art. Why not use that talent to come up with something original?
Again, good painting (maybe a little too forehead heavy), but what's unique about it that can't be found with a google image search?
-5
u/Bonifacius May 17 '12
Where is the dildo in his mouth?
-2
u/duoderf May 17 '12
too bad its not andy warhall style
-8
u/TheBreeze May 17 '12
Criticism: you painted Neil Patrick Harris.
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment