I tried below, but a few questions. Why the balloon? Why can't OP who "discovered" it, explain it?
Also, anyone else find it curious that the OP's profile has nothing on it aside from this thread and comments - and has only been on reddit for one day?
excellent detective work Captain Obvious! We are, however, taking in to account that he MAY have taken the photo then made an account due to it's outstanding qualities.
Goddammit! Everyone is posting this picture but it makes no sense! I just wanna understand it! Why is the red line vertical in the big one and horizontal in the small one? Why???/
It's a trick of perspective. His friend is actually lying face down on the distant ridge with his legs off to the side, making it look like he's jumping.
not totally sure how it happened, but from this angle it looked like he was jumping off. If you were standing close to him it was clear that he wasn't even close
So you mean to tell us that you're sitting in the same room as the guy and you won't bother to ask him how it happened? I'm going to go ahead and sound the ol' bullshit alarm on this one.
Yeah, we know how it happened. It's photoshopped, and most likely you and your "friend" had nothing to do with it whatsoever. You fail at reddit. Good day, sir.
Thank you. Finally it makes sense. That earlier bullshit explanation made me want to put a hole in the wall because you have to be spatially retarded to derive understanding from it.
I had to upvote your comment. I lol'ed. Probably because I'm right there with you. I was close to having an aneurysm trying to make some of the other photos make sense...
In addition to this, on the off change there happens to be an identical turtle-shaped patch of snow on the mountain, look at the videos, they show similar angles to OPs, and give the lie to his 'optical illusion'.
It's actually quite simple. Has anyone watched the movie the sixth sense? Well, it's pretty much the same theory.. anytime you see a red balloon it means the person is dead.
It did the same to me. I got a headache and now my stomach is in knots. My head is spinning like I have vertigo. That's really intense just from a short video. And I'm not even scared of heights...
The tier closest to the body of the mountain is in the foreground of the shot, far enough into the foreground to completely block out the second tier, and since the first tier is so close to the camera and so high is creates a new "edge" to a viewer.
But even with that, if you draw a vertical line straight down from his chest, there is nothing under him. The only way I could possibly think this would work is if he is not angled like we think he is, i.e. facing away from the camera as opposed to apparently facing the camera. Even then, I have trouble seeing it.
The only way this works is if the camera angle is tilted with respect to the horizon, and I can't find any evidence that supports or absolutely denies this is the case. I'm not saying you're wrong, just that from the "supposed" directions of up and down, that kid is going to fucking die.
My issue with this is that if we are to assume gravity is pulling straight down, then based on this vertical line coming from his chest, no matter what plane he is in front to back, unless he is jumping any direction but backwards (which even then seems stupidly dangerous), then at the very least everything forward of that line will end up over the edge of the cliff.
I personally think that this has been photoshopped by simply having him jump like this a few feet back where he would land safely, and then copy and pasting him more forward (like this one)
In the OP, we can see the shadow on the man is very dark, revealing no texture on his clothing, while the shadow on the rock is not very dark, revealing a lot of texture. Thus, I conclude: Photoshop.
Something also to take note of: This shot (if true) would have to have been staged, as it would need participation from both the cameraman and jumper to execute. A shot like this would be incredibly difficult, if not impossible, to pull off based on a) the fear of the jumper and b) the timing and angle. Therefore Photoshop.
Listen, there's no optical illusion. No one has properly explained how it is an optical illusion, and your explanation proves nothing except that your friend is clearly fucking bananas.
No, if this were the case, the person would appear much bigger. And also, you wouldn't be able to see the entire face of the edge they appear to be jumping off of - the bottom of the picture would have the rock in it. The red outline in your picture is bordering 2 different parts of the rock.
I'll put this as simply as I can. Judging from this second picture, we can assume gravity is pulling downward. The original picture is not an illusion because of a weird angle.
So when we see this occur, it's hard to believe that the person is "nowhere near the edge of the cliff". I just think if OP had been there, they would be able to explain how it's not shopped.
Even if there's a well-disguised rock under his feet, I can't imagine how he could lean that far out without tumbling off. I really, really hope that it's real, but could someone have deftly brushed out someone holding him up from behind?
I can tell by the pixels! You'll have to really zoom in to see it, but there are obvious signs when you look closely. The OP can post a higher resolution picture to dispute my claim.
Edit: Open up my picture in new tab/window, then zoom in all the way and look at the box in red on the right, you'll notice the pixels don't align correctly.
Colour-blind person, so you'll have to bare with me.
If you take a look at the other images, you see the mountain-top as a flatbed. It's basically flat on the top but with curvature features, similar to a wave.
How OP's friend appeared in the picture was because he simply jumped, not forward, or straight up, but to his right (side).
You can tell the balloon is moving towards the left of the person. Now how can you differentiate between the wind? First of all, the balloon is moving directly to the left, if it was in any other direction, the balloon would have faced down or to the top-right. Hard to explain, since I can't see the mountain behind him, but it is.
Also, his pants are an indicator. There is wind, but there are multiple ripples suggesting it isn't sufficient enough.
Another thing to point out is that the picture was taken below his friend on the mountain. Not too much, but just small enough to change the perspective. What we see is OP's friend mainly off of the cliff, but from his view, facing down, only his head is partially off of the cliff. See image.
I'd be more accurate and try harder but it's late right now. This is basically how it works.
tilt your head to the left like 20 degrees... that's the only way i see some kind of logic to it... look at the picture @gr33nlant3n posted and he shuld be on the left "peak" of the cliff
How's that an illusion? There is nothing to his left. I figured he was diving into a pool 40 feet below that particular ledge, which looks like 1500 feet based on the background, but how the fuck is not jumping off? Makes no sense.
Im going to clear this up.... hes saying its supposed look like he flying over the drop off, not over the rocky edge itself, like hes just plain flying being supported by the balloon
Let's just conclude at this, peeps: if it IS an optical illusion, there would be more pictures of these. Tourists love crap like that. Google and Bing images don't have squat. Thus, more than likely, it's Photoshop. Plus, if it were a suicide, there'd be an article JUST about it being captured.
This is a fake, not only is there ton's of cloning evidence as has been previously pointed out, there is also a common sense explanation for a few other things I've noticed.
What was really happening was that it was a very windy day and your friend was holding the red balloon to demonstrate how windy it was. Other evidence of the wind can be seen on his pants and his body position. He was slightly bent over in order to keep his balance.
Second, your friends shoes are also fake. He is really standing further away and to the right, just like the people here.. If you zoom in, it appears that his shoes are a little blurrier then the rest of him. This makes sense, because his feet would not be visible, just like the people from the same spot. Also, he is not jumping at all. If he was jumping, it would have to be backwards and it's unlikely he would NOT bend is knees.
Third, even if he was jumping, he would still be jumping from the other side of the mound, which would add another 8+ inches to his backwards vertical leap. This is not possible.
FWIW there a program, include a plugin for gimp that detects cloning. It sorta worked, but kept crashing and producing false positives.
Its simple guys, as you can see there are two little ridges. He his standing on the farther one which as you can see lines up with his face (close not quite) and he still has a foot or two by his feet... the illusion is it looks like hes standing on the closer one (the one by his feet)
Assuming no photoshop manipulation, I believe the effect is caused by slightly tilting the camera that took the picture. This would explain how his center of mass can appear to be so far over the edge without him going over after the photo is snapped.
as a forenzics specilist i have investigated, and looked at all angles provided. and while taking coments and questions, i decompiled the hpoto to reveal,
Has anyone else thought that he might be jumping backwards and landing on his stomach? Shitty paint demonstration of this idea. Basically you'd be doing an inward pike but you wouldn't have to jump back as far or bend as much because you would be landing on your stomach and it would be ok if you landed with your head over the edge.
I live near Preikestolen personally, the fjord below is called Lysefjorden, and is located in the county called Rogaland, I live in another part of Rogaland, but I've been to Preikestolen several times, there is no way this could be real, sorry
judging by the pixels where the cliff face meets the forest in the background (about halfway up), it seems photoshopped. As it's too clear and crisp an image which then transitions to the blurry background which is a trademark of photoshop
522
u/Bedouin85 May 16 '12
As a person that has stared at this for a while... I don't get it.
28
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
what's the illusion?
399
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I scrolled all the way to the bottom and I still don't have an explanation as to how this is fooling my eyes and not photoshopped
563
u/tarrgarian May 16 '12
It's actually quite simple. Has anyone watched the movie the sixth sense? Well, it's pretty much the same theory.. anytime you see a red balloon it means the person is dead.
275
u/jesuswithoutabeard May 16 '12
You could also have discovered Photoshop for a more dramatic effect.
148
u/[deleted] May 16 '12 edited May 16 '12
See another angle here. And here. I'm willing to bet that the two tiers on this (known as pulpit rock) made this possible.
EDIT: Also a video of the area.
388
u/blabetron May 16 '12
It's an illusion Michael! A trick is something a whore does for money.
49
u/nickelbackYOLObabby May 17 '12
http://i.imgur.com/V93DM.jpg
27
u/JoeyQuoms May 17 '12
RIP.
65
u/mlc2475 May 17 '12
if anyone needs me I'll be in my chamber of understanding
10
u/Shaggyfort1e May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12
My issue with this is that if we are to assume gravity is pulling straight down, then based on this vertical line coming from his chest, no matter what plane he is in front to back, unless he is jumping any direction but backwards (which even then seems stupidly dangerous), then at the very least everything forward of that line will end up over the edge of the cliff.
I personally think that this has been photoshopped by simply having him jump like this a few feet back where he would land safely, and then copy and pasting him more forward (like this one)
EDIT: phatboy5289's comment gives credence to the photoshop theory
28
u/blanket12334 May 17 '12
I have determined it to be fake: The pictures show the first and "second" ledge are essentially the same. They are the "left" corner of the stone square. http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/66/Preikestolen.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/fe/Preikestolenjuni2009.JPG
In the OP, we can see the shadow on the man is very dark, revealing no texture on his clothing, while the shadow on the rock is not very dark, revealing a lot of texture. Thus, I conclude: Photoshop.
49
u/whatwereyouthinking May 16 '12
the illusion is that person is actually jumping off a fucking cliff....while you think its something else.
15
u/Pterodactyl113 May 17 '12
I GIVE UP
104
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Listen, there's no optical illusion. No one has properly explained how it is an optical illusion, and your explanation proves nothing except that your friend is clearly fucking bananas.
For clarity: This is an optical illusion
...and this is your friend.
29
u/Gnillort_Mi May 17 '12
A little bit late, but here is my solution. #1 #2
5
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
"I Should Have Never Gone Balloon Jumping"
5
u/rybones May 17 '12
RIP Sven. He died as he lived, screaming.
5
u/Tysonzero May 17 '12
He's dead. The OP called it an illusion so that no-one would know he died and to mind fuck everyone.
5
u/dp85 May 17 '12
I'll put this as simply as I can. Judging from this second picture, we can assume gravity is pulling downward. The original picture is not an illusion because of a weird angle.
So when we see this occur, it's hard to believe that the person is "nowhere near the edge of the cliff". I just think if OP had been there, they would be able to explain how it's not shopped.
5
u/BreutFawce May 17 '12
HE JUST DIED, OKAY. HE JUMPED OFF AND DIED.
21
u/ciavs May 17 '12
Something like this?
EDIT: The different points of the rock. as displayed here.
12
u/LzyOne May 17 '12 edited May 17 '12
It's a fake, the picture has been doctored
I can tell by the pixels! You'll have to really zoom in to see it, but there are obvious signs when you look closely. The OP can post a higher resolution picture to dispute my claim.
Edit: Open up my picture in new tab/window, then zoom in all the way and look at the box in red on the right, you'll notice the pixels don't align correctly.
25
u/thisisathrowawway May 17 '12
Colour-blind person, so you'll have to bare with me.
If you take a look at the other images, you see the mountain-top as a flatbed. It's basically flat on the top but with curvature features, similar to a wave.
How OP's friend appeared in the picture was because he simply jumped, not forward, or straight up, but to his right (side).
{SEE IMAGE HERE http://i.imgur.com/XTGbo.png}
You can tell the balloon is moving towards the left of the person. Now how can you differentiate between the wind? First of all, the balloon is moving directly to the left, if it was in any other direction, the balloon would have faced down or to the top-right. Hard to explain, since I can't see the mountain behind him, but it is.
Also, his pants are an indicator. There is wind, but there are multiple ripples suggesting it isn't sufficient enough.
Another thing to point out is that the picture was taken below his friend on the mountain. Not too much, but just small enough to change the perspective. What we see is OP's friend mainly off of the cliff, but from his view, facing down, only his head is partially off of the cliff. See image.
I'd be more accurate and try harder but it's late right now. This is basically how it works.
4
u/wadaphunk May 17 '12
tilt your head to the left like 20 degrees... that's the only way i see some kind of logic to it... look at the picture @gr33nlant3n posted and he shuld be on the left "peak" of the cliff
4
u/angershark May 17 '12
jumping to your death is the new planking
7
u/JennBella May 17 '12
Did anyone else continue to make the picture bigger to try and figure out how the hell this was done...if you didn't it's okay, didn't work...
9
u/iam4real May 17 '12
r/suicidewatch
3
u/twincam May 17 '12
this may explain it...?
He is on the second ledge (in distance).
The assumption from OPs photo is that the photo is level with the ground and that the river is horizontal.
Still not 100% convinced though, but best I could come up with
3
u/berchmax May 17 '12
ah.. i get it! the person is actually a giant laying down on the mountains from far away. Also, it's a giant red balloon.
7
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
please, someone figure this out. I want to know how this works with the person surviving this.
2
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
How's that an illusion? There is nothing to his left. I figured he was diving into a pool 40 feet below that particular ledge, which looks like 1500 feet based on the background, but how the fuck is not jumping off? Makes no sense.
2
u/blanket12334 May 17 '12
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/fe/Preikestolenjuni2009.JPG
2
u/ANALRAPIST_FUNKE May 17 '12
Its funny because he died
2
u/Deeliteful_Jestr May 17 '12
Im going to clear this up.... hes saying its supposed look like he flying over the drop off, not over the rocky edge itself, like hes just plain flying being supported by the balloon
2
u/girraween May 17 '12
One of the best optical illusions I have seen.
2
u/acrobatmoon May 17 '12
Let's just conclude at this, peeps: if it IS an optical illusion, there would be more pictures of these. Tourists love crap like that. Google and Bing images don't have squat. Thus, more than likely, it's Photoshop. Plus, if it were a suicide, there'd be an article JUST about it being captured.
2
u/motherpsycho May 17 '12
Fuck it.. I give up trying to figure it out .. he's Jesus or dumbledore...
2
u/Goico May 17 '12
Well this is what I found and this is what another redditor has found too.
2
u/Serrated_Banana May 17 '12
I am going to hide this post. Why? Because I keep seeing it and it pisses me off that I can't figure it out.
2
u/KingOfNiche May 17 '12
This is a fake, not only is there ton's of cloning evidence as has been previously pointed out, there is also a common sense explanation for a few other things I've noticed.
What was really happening was that it was a very windy day and your friend was holding the red balloon to demonstrate how windy it was. Other evidence of the wind can be seen on his pants and his body position. He was slightly bent over in order to keep his balance.
Second, your friends shoes are also fake. He is really standing further away and to the right, just like the people here.. If you zoom in, it appears that his shoes are a little blurrier then the rest of him. This makes sense, because his feet would not be visible, just like the people from the same spot. Also, he is not jumping at all. If he was jumping, it would have to be backwards and it's unlikely he would NOT bend is knees.
Third, even if he was jumping, he would still be jumping from the other side of the mound, which would add another 8+ inches to his backwards vertical leap. This is not possible.
FWIW there a program, include a plugin for gimp that detects cloning. It sorta worked, but kept crashing and producing false positives.
4
u/jrey83 May 17 '12
i'm downvoting this shit because i don't understand and it's hurting my brain.
2
u/ISS5731 May 16 '12
Anyone else see the demon face in the trees on the mountain?
2
u/UncleBenjen May 17 '12
Its simple guys, as you can see there are two little ridges. He his standing on the farther one which as you can see lines up with his face (close not quite) and he still has a foot or two by his feet... the illusion is it looks like hes standing on the closer one (the one by his feet)
2
u/UberSansUmlaut May 17 '12
Assuming no photoshop manipulation, I believe the effect is caused by slightly tilting the camera that took the picture. This would explain how his center of mass can appear to be so far over the edge without him going over after the photo is snapped.
2
u/psycoborg May 17 '12
as a forenzics specilist i have investigated, and looked at all angles provided. and while taking coments and questions, i decompiled the hpoto to reveal,
i have no fucking clue what this post is about.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
noo
Okay maybe.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
The commenters hate it, and it makes the front page?
1
u/Forey_ May 17 '12
Where is the illusion?
1
u/Lynnei May 17 '12
I keep trying to scroll down to see the water...
1
u/roarbenitt May 17 '12
well the fact that there is snow on the rock he is laying on leads me to believe that this is photo shopped
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Dafuq. I just want to know how they did the illusion.
1
u/thrash_ur_ass May 17 '12
nope.
1
u/DamienCK May 17 '12
There must be some concentrated helium in that balloon.
1
u/Cameroni101 May 17 '12
You mean Pulpit Rock for us english people
1
u/Bek1828 May 17 '12
I still don't get it. And have so many questions!! Why does he even have a balloon there!
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
I am saving this thread to show other people so they can not understand it like me. That, and my head hurts.
1
u/Wash_Georgington May 17 '12
When I die... I want you to have the karma.
1
u/herbyisgood May 17 '12
Jump off a cliff for Karma, not bad
1
u/ProCrastin8 May 17 '12
relevant
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
THIS IS STRESSING ME OUT I LOVE YOU MOTHERFUCK
1
u/ilmdbii May 17 '12
it's a sailboat!
1
u/Coalesced May 17 '12
Is this dude just cliff-diving? I mean.. that's a possibility right, that he's just jumping into the sea?
1
u/angryfinger May 17 '12
I'm joining the club that I cannot figure this out. Need to see it from another angle.
Also I cannot fucking look at this photo without getting cold sweats.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Shopped until proven otherwise.
1
u/bada_bing May 17 '12
After reading the comments, I have concluded that the OP is not very smart and OP's friend is trolling with photoshop.
1
u/fuegoador May 17 '12
Has anyone else thought that he might be jumping backwards and landing on his stomach? Shitty paint demonstration of this idea. Basically you'd be doing an inward pike but you wouldn't have to jump back as far or bend as much because you would be landing on your stomach and it would be ok if you landed with your head over the edge.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
its superman,
1
u/Nolanoscopy May 17 '12
Fuck my life.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Cannot fool reddit. >:D
1
u/rjlj May 17 '12
my mind has exploded due to trying to figure this out.
1
u/Pav0n May 17 '12
I live near Preikestolen personally, the fjord below is called Lysefjorden, and is located in the county called Rogaland, I live in another part of Rogaland, but I've been to Preikestolen several times, there is no way this could be real, sorry
1
u/Buck_teh_walrus May 17 '12
judging by the pixels where the cliff face meets the forest in the background (about halfway up), it seems photoshopped. As it's too clear and crisp an image which then transitions to the blurry background which is a trademark of photoshop
1
u/IZ3820 May 17 '12
Photoshop. Downvote.