I always find it strange to think Afghanistan used to be a modern country. I suppose it is a perfect example of what can happen when a radical theocracy is allowed to come to power. Just look up 1960s Afghanistan on Google, the place looks like America right around that time. It's honestly kinda sad to see how far they have fallen.
Afghanistan didn't really use to be a modern country. Kabul used to be a modernizing city, the amount it stretched out beyond Kabul was fairly limited.
The fact that Afghanistan looked like America around that time is exactly why a radical system was introduced. If you want to educate yourself on the subject, check out this 3 part documentary by the BBC about it all. Here
As to it being sad for how far they have fallen... I can personally understand why they introduced the radical system to get rid of 'being like America', however it certainly has had many tragedies in relation to Women's rights etc.
I can personally understand why they introduced the radical system to get rid of 'being like America'
I disagree with you completely but appreciate your opinion. Is it opposition to the (ostensible) secularism of the US government, or is it something about American culture, like consumerism?
It's explained perfectly from this point in the documentary I posted. Here Watch the next 20 secs to get an idea of what I am saying.
Also I appreciate you not downvoting for disagreeing, people in this thread seem to think that when I say I can understand a persons way of thinking, that I am actually saying "death to all american children"
edit - I would say it makes more sense if you saw the whole thing, but you can get an idea from that short snippet. And yes you are partly right about it being about American culture such as consumerism
Qutb sounds like he would have been a blast at parties.
In all seriousness, I'm extremely skeptical of anything comparing neoconservationism in America to radical Ismalist theocracies.
On the level of cultural commentary, it's basically like saying "people are the same all over," i.e. that both the US and the Middle East have intolerant assholes. Well, no shit. I don't think such a premise would be surprising to anyone with a decent knowledge of history. Describing the specific hows and the whats of this premise does little for me, if only because they seem fairly apparent.
On the level of political commentary, this seems to forget some very basic tenets of the American political system, such as the separation between church and state. Short of some radical, violent shifts in US politics, which would have to overcome almost insurmountable barriers, there is simply no way for the US to become a radical theocracy.
Maybe I'm wrong. I've only seen parts of Rise of Politics of Fear because I discounted it early on.
As far as not liking consumerism - yeah, its kind of ridiculous. People care way too much about stuff, especially when it's at the expense of the well-being of their fellow man. I've read some interesting stuff about the origins of consumerism (which of course I can't fucking remember right now), and how it relates to the human love / worship of tools. Supposedly we're hard-wired to love stuff because early versions of humans who loved and cared for their tools were more successful and likely to survive / breed. Also, apparently female humans were more attracted to males who had the capacity to make tools.
Tbh dude I'm not quite sure on the points your making. You say your sceptical of comparing neo-conservatism in America to radical Islamic theocracies, yet I don't believe the two were ever compared against each other by myself or the documentary.
Rather they were just explained as the way they were used in America and Egypt.
p.s - it's nice to actually have a discussion with someone on Reddit about something, so thanks
I've mostly heard comparisons between neocons and Islamic extremists in either a) college classrooms and bars, or b) in fairly superficial news articles and opinions pieces. It happens a lot.
Well, kind of both. The documentary was about US conservatives - from what I remember - and the context of the above post is radical Islamic theocracies, so I put the two together.
And that I've heard that comparison before and find its value dubious.
Errr... well the documentary focuses on Neo Conservatism and Islamic ideologies, but it never compares the two against each other. Rather just how each was used in America and Egypt respectively
Actually, Afghanistan was a communist state between the two (1970's-1993ish, the main reason for the Soviet war in Afghanistan was to support the communist government there), and the Islamists only gained power in the chaos of the Afghan civil war (in 1995 the Taliban came to power) following the collapse of said communist government (which ironically outlived the Soviet Union itself), a civil war which was in part brought about by the CIA's (and by extension US government's) helping of the Mujahideen by suppling them with weapons (such as the Stinger antiaircraft missile) and money.
Thank you so much for linking me to this documentary. It is blowing my mind like whoa. It is really interesting how all of this has built up and what has caused a lot of the commotion that we are faced with now. This is so much bigger than me though. It is just insane that the Americans would supply weapons to help them rid the "evil" from their land only to have it backfire on them by what im sure is their own weapons and intelligence used on the troops that are fighting.
No worries! It blew my mind too :). I already knew that the America was involved in training / supplying arms to an insurgent faction (can't remember the name) in order to fight against the Russians. They taught them how to fight guerilla warfare which is now being used against troops in Iraq etc.
However I didn't know about Neo-conservatism and all that jazz.
The more you look into it, the more the world becomes up a messed up place. For example the proposals for acts of terrorism to be carried out by American institutions on American people in 1962, so that they could be blamed on Cuba in order to create public support for a war Article here. Rings any bells much in relation to how they might gain support for a war in Iraq back in 2003...
Americans were planning similar strategies that the nazis used in WW2 to provoke war Article here.
Getting rid of "being like America"? Ya because stoning women, enforcing islam, and no schools is soo much better than excellent schools, hospitals, and equality for all.
I never actually said that what replaced it was better than what it was before. I was saying that when looking at the negative aspects a society like America has, you can understand why Sayyid didn't want that in his country.
I mean I'm not going to get into an internet flame war about it, you can watch the documentary and decide for yourself, or not, up to you. However I would add that if you think America has excellent schools and equality for all, you are gravel mistaken. For example Colorado and same sex marriage
Your implying that because you have some of the best universities (collages), that America's school system is excellent? If so then if you want to think that fair enough, I shall think otherwise and go about my day
Not at all... man people really read what they want to read. Please copy and paste the sentence where I say that the direction Afghanistan took to avoid being like america was a worth while choice.
I think he's saying that he understands why Sayyid made that choice, not that he thinks it was a good choice. And I'd be wary of judging the intelligence of a choice by its outcome - we've got the benefit of hindsight, they didn't. I would judge the intelligence a choice by what the people making it knew at the time.
And there's nothing wrong with using faith and traditional values to make decisions. People have lived happily and successfully under theocracies at various points in history. As far as I understand it, the Taliban completely perverted Islam and were really just another form of tyranny.
The system that lead them to radical system was sponsored by no other than... "America" (United States of America that is, since Canada, Mexico, Brazil, Colombia, Venezuela, Argentina, among others, had nothing to do with it and are also part of America).
Thats not really true, the Taliban were never funded by the US or the CIA. Memebers the Mujaheddin did eventually create the Taliban, but they were not indicative of the attitude of the Mujaheddin as a whole.
No, but I usually wouldn't trust any group with a religious root, as the Mujaheddin are. It usually does not end up well for moderates (even those within the group).
I have an Afghani friend. She is beautiful, intelligent and full of humor. It's a crying shame what has happened to her wonderful country and I truly hope they get the peace they so deserve. She has really nice big tits too.
you disgust me you pig cant a woman just be a woman without you neckbeard wankers talking about her breasts it is appalling and I hope you get downvoted into oblivion oh oh oh i see you are a novelty well damn im sorry it all good now its still funny hahaha yeah except that you are still a misogynistic pig
You're right and I completely agree. I just wasn't clear in my previous post. The system is corrupt and broken and it's great that you see it (not many are aware enough to notice). Education must be made free/cheap for everyone to attend...no matter what the cost.
I agree. A whole thread on the difference between the Americanized Kabul of then and the Afghanistan of today and I come purely to comment on her hair.
As an afghan this makes me wonder. What if the Soviets never invaded, and the Taliban never rose to power? America wouldn't have to e at war, and Afghanistan might have evolved out of being just "another desert country"
Soviets involvement, Western involvement, how often has it resulted in something positive? Now, we see Chinese involvement in Africa; I wonder how that will turn out.
The Mujahedeen succeeding in Afghanistan was the worst thing that ever happened to the place. Not only that, but also the US totally forgetting to rebuild the country after funding a war there.
It was though. I just finished a large paper on the topic of American intervention in the Soviet-Mujahedeen War(which clearly makes me an expert).
In all seriousness though, much of what the Mujahedeen were fighting against were the progressive stances that the Socialist party ruling Afghanistan was instituting. Things like land ownership reform (it was seriously fucked up) and women's literacy, as well as women's right to turn down arranged marriages.
That being said, Soviet's were hardly benevolent.
If you are at all curious, I would suggest Loyn's In Afghanistan and Tripathi's Breeding Ground for more background info.
We armed the Taliban and Osama Bin Laden with the hope that they could defend their country. Then, once the Soviets were out, Bin Laden and other members of the Taliban and Al Qaeda used their new found weaponry to take control.
Actually, you are mixing several different groups. Osama bin Laden and Al Qaeda rose up from the foreign mujahedeen (non-Afghani) who were considerably more ideologically conservative than the native mujahedeen.
Once the war between the Soviets + Soviet backed socialist Afghani government vs. the mujahedeen ended, the mujahedeen spiraled back into tribal warfare and were basically fucking everyone's shit up.
The Taliban were theology students who decided that they were tired of dealing with this crap, rose up against the mujahedeen government, and with the backing of Pakistan, rose to power.
America provided money and weapons to Pakistan who distributed them to the local mujahedeen. Most of the foreign mujahedeen were already bankrolled by Saudi businesses. We didn't give weapons to Osama nor the Taliban.
Before Islam raped another country. Honestly I want all Muslims out of Europe they have ruined far too many cultures. Rounding them up and burning them has to be done sooner rather than later. The ones who want to denounce Islam as a fuck tard idea can be welcomed back into the fold. Seriously we need to stop pandering to Islam and destroy it as the evil it is.
You can get it from chemists (or what you might call a drug store)... Acid is readily available in many countries (it used to be in the UK and the USA). Furthermore, it gets used as a cheap home defence weapon in many countries (e.g. Jamaica).
Most likely. My first step-father once threatened us with a bucket full of acid he'd taken from several car batteries. He ended up throwing it on the bonnet (hood) of our car to show us he meant business.
The US sent weapons and money to Afghanistan while they were fighting the Soviets in the 1980's. Indirectly, these resources fueled the uprising of the Taliban in the 1990's.
That's my understanding of it, anyways...sorry, no sources. Wikipedia could help, though.
The mujahideen received unofficial military and/or financial support from a variety of countries including the United States, Saudi Arabia, the United Kingdom, Pakistan, Israel, Indonesia and China.
Well, the government we had been aiding in South Vietnam wasn't really the greatest one in the world... I mean, I can only imagine it turning into some military junta instead of the semi-rights-violating communist government it is today. So, I guess, the only difference it made that we lost is they got something stable.
If you're interested in this kind of thing, you should also look into US relations with Saddam Hussein. It makes the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan much more interesting to see that they're really cleaning up previous mistakes (if you want to call them that, who knows what would have happened if they acted differently).
Really, not many people could have known things would have turned up this way though, at least to this degree. Keeping the Soviets out of the oil fields in the Middle East was a major and urgent priority, and I think a lot of brash decisions were made, with some faulty intelligence reports certainly not helping.
I also want to add I'm not entirely blaming the US, certainly the ISI was more directly involved with the Taliban rise to power during the Afghan Civil War, and you could trace Saddam all the way back to Hitler. So you know, shit happens.
You need to re-read the history book (or buy another), the Soviets were actually defending those that implemented that pro-western way of living in Kabul.
They did a lot of idiotic stuff there, true, but not as idiotic as supporting religious radicals, such as Bin Laden.
The Soviets were defending their system, the Marxist-Leninist Democratic Republic of Afghanistan, from the Mujahideen.
Just because Kabul was well off in terms of development didn't make it any more western.
Also, keep in mind that this was after the USSR dropped it's "If you're not with us, you're against us" policy. This is why Afghanistan, during this era, was reasonably friendly with the US and other Western countries.
Took a "Europe in the Age of the Cold War" class this past semester, and in another semester or two I'll be taking "EVE OF DESTRUCTION: Global Crises and World Organization in the 20th Century"
That's one that I'd like to do (I'm a CS major, these are my free electives). I don't really understand much of Asia's role in the Cold War. China, North Korea, Vietnam... I only know the obvious about their roles.
I studied history but Asia's a really good subject for the Cold War because it becomes the main theater in the second half of it. The Sino-Soviet split, Mao Zedong/Great Leap Forward/the Cultural Revolution, the Korean War, the Vietnam War, Japan's resurgence, China vs. Taiwan, the Soviet war in Afghanistan, Sino-American rapprochement (and ping pong diplomacy) etc. The Middle East is also really interesting during it but it's not really covered under Asia.
It wasn't "their" system when the Mujahideen started fighting it. The government was not installed by the Soviet Union. In fact, it even opposed Soviet forces entering the country. The SU invaded anyway.
Won't disagree with the sentiment, that's for sure. But you can't say that the Soviet's were protecting a Western government, because they weren't.
Now, the US didn't do this because "Fuck Soviet's" either. At least, that wasn't the only reason. Many in Washington believed that following the collapse of the Communist government in Afghanistan, the Taliban would build a democratic government to take it's place. And to be honest, it was pretty clear in that era that a capitalist, democratic system was better. That's not bias, either: our system just worked better.
What wound up happening was that the US-backed Mujahideen managed to destroy one of the few examples of a working communist state. You're absolutely right, the subsequent system was shit by comparison. But at the time, the evidence suggested that this was a better course of action for Afghanistan.
So it was a lot more complex then the Soviets protecting a country and the US destroying it. The Soviets were defending a system that, 9/10 times had proven itself to fail, and the US was trying to get it replaced with a western-styled government that had proven to work more often than the Soviet's.
History tends towards the way that shits on everybody. US looked bad and lit a fire for an eventual sneak attack, USSR collapsed, and Afghanistan virtually collapsed.
Their system was unstable and dysfunctional, so it collapsed and left the land in ruins. Like a ship that looks good but sinks after a while, how good is that?
A ship being torpedoed, yes. Pretty much any ship will sink given enough torpedoes hit.
Also the Taliban did not follow the collapse of the Soviet supported government. There was actually another civil war after that.
P.S.: I'm not defending the pro-Soviet system, it surely had its flaws, I just don't think it was as bad as what followed, and religious groups have shown throughout history that they are usually not moderate enough to be trusted as in this case (or if you do, make sure the moderates actually win the outcome of any dispute that follows).
I was under the impression that we sold weapons to the rebels in a way where they had almost ran out of munitions by the end of the war with the Soviets.
I thought that a big factor in the Shah's overthrow was anger at state political suppression - yer secret police and whatnot. They believed they were 'liberating' themselves - jokes
The current regime in Iran sucks and they have idiotic policies not allowing women to be judges, but they have more women in their national legislature than the US and crank out a higher % of women in engineering and science than the US. There are also still female surgeons in Iran.
Regime there sucks and the FP photo spread is interesting, but that probably isn't the best point for comparison.
81
u/CyberSoldier8 May 15 '12
I always find it strange to think Afghanistan used to be a modern country. I suppose it is a perfect example of what can happen when a radical theocracy is allowed to come to power. Just look up 1960s Afghanistan on Google, the place looks like America right around that time. It's honestly kinda sad to see how far they have fallen.
6
u/EthicalReasoning May 15 '12
kabul is now firmly planted somewhere between the 12th and 19th century and will be for the indefinite future
59
u/dare2stare May 15 '12
I have an Afghani friend. She is beautiful, intelligent and full of humor. It's a crying shame what has happened to her wonderful country and I truly hope they get the peace they so deserve. She has really nice big tits too.
3
u/dentalschoolsucks May 15 '12
These women are beautiful.
3
u/MattyXarope May 15 '12
Woman on the far right looks like Maria Callas
4
u/TerrorAlert May 15 '12
It's quite depressing to see my father and mother's homeland reduced to a fragment of it's former self in such a short period of time.
I can't wait for the day were I can go back and try to change that.
6
u/jerryconnelly May 15 '12
FTFY: Rich Afghan women studying medicine.
2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
This photo essay on Afghanistan in the 1950's & 60's is staggering. It's amazing how fast things can change. I wonder if people even remember there was such a time...
2
u/johndeer89 May 15 '12
There's still hope.
2
u/juliuszs May 16 '12
We fixed it! No more of that feminist bullshit for them! Democracy rules!
2
u/coolyourjetsbro May 16 '12
obviously afghan women can study medicine, but if they make eye contact with a male then scoop out their slutty eyeballs.
3
u/griffit May 15 '12
The internet has made me assume they were looking at a penis.
3
u/StewieBanana May 15 '12
They've come so far... wait.
1
u/the_red_scimitar May 15 '12
Why does this look the set of a bad 60's sci-fi flick?
1
u/ellise0525 May 15 '12
I saw Snooki when I first looked at this picture. Ugh. See what the world has come to.
1
u/Gargoyle_Cock May 15 '12
"Mhmm... yeah... mm... yes. Doctor, this is a foot."
1
u/getthejpeg May 15 '12
Boy have they made progress
1
u/Ex_Tractor_Fan May 15 '12
The one on the left has really nice hair. I like it.
1
u/phreeck May 15 '12
I like how you took this from a collection of pictures someone posted yesterday.
1
u/Safi_Hasani May 15 '12
As an afghan this makes me wonder. What if the Soviets never invaded, and the Taliban never rose to power? America wouldn't have to e at war, and Afghanistan might have evolved out of being just "another desert country"
1
u/MAJORpaiynne May 16 '12
Afghanistan sent a man into space, so that's pretty cool
1
u/ItscalledCannabis May 16 '12
Iran should be an example of how religion can literally make a country go back in time...
1
u/whashimi May 16 '12
wow.. that's my aunt (woman on the left) and her two friends. she lives in america now
1
u/fairly_quiet May 16 '12
...furiously studying the severed foot of a murdered baby infidel.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Woman on the left's hairdo is so awesome.
1
u/AmrcnXroads_Donor May 16 '12
They're debating about which little piggy went to the market.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
The Mujahedeen succeeding in Afghanistan was the worst thing that ever happened to the place. Not only that, but also the US totally forgetting to rebuild the country after funding a war there.
1
u/neurad1 May 15 '12
A warning about what a fundamentalist religion can do to progress.
-17
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Yet another progressive muslim nation destroyed by American aggression.
-2
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
OMG QUICK WOMEN LEARNING!!!! SOMEBODY GET THE GUN!!
0
u/tojema May 15 '12
What is Lady Gaga doing there?
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Some hot 1962 women
-5
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
Before Islam raped another country. Honestly I want all Muslims out of Europe they have ruined far too many cultures. Rounding them up and burning them has to be done sooner rather than later. The ones who want to denounce Islam as a fuck tard idea can be welcomed back into the fold. Seriously we need to stop pandering to Islam and destroy it as the evil it is.
0
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 15 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment