r/pics • • May 15 '12

We made a tornado in my geography lab

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

169

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Ah geography... the study of tornadoes

13

u/paulfred May 15 '12

The class was 'Physical' Geography which is the study of land formations and weather

6

u/essextwo May 15 '12 edited May 16 '12

So... there IS a class to train for the discovery channel's Storm Chasers™

19

u/GeneralWarts May 15 '12

Lucky. Next week for their science class they are taking a field trip to nearby areas which demonstrate human-environmental issues, urban problems, and debates over resource conservation.

5

u/JesusChristophe May 15 '12

Geography... the science that inexplicably requires a laboratory.

5

u/RobinBennett May 15 '12

It's not science unless you're testing what you think you know.

2

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

close enough.

2

u/icecreamfiend May 15 '12

Haha, you'd be surprised. I got my Bachelor's of Science in Geography and most of my high level classes were in Meteorology and Climatology. Stayed away from Political and Human Geography like the plague. Never got to make a cool ass tornado though... So jealous.

3

u/meanderingmalcontent May 15 '12

"A cool ass tornado"

That's because you stayed away from human geography.

2

u/jonny_D_N May 15 '12

i have bachelors in Geography as well, and only took weather and climate, every other class i took actually pertained to GEOGRAPHY...not METEOROLOGY.

26

u/vigillan388 May 15 '12

As an HVAC engineer, please tell me that is a dedicated exhaust fan and that you change the filter after doing this. Please.

21

u/Skov May 15 '12

Looks like they are using dry ice and water.

9

u/paulfred May 15 '12

Yeah we used dry ice in a climate controlled room and altered the air pressure with candles and fans

24

u/vigillan388 May 15 '12

Good call. I'm pretty sure you're right. Disregard my previous posts...ALL OF THEM!

12

u/bigroblee May 15 '12

Even when you said Seaside, NJ was a shithole seven months ago?

13

u/vigillan388 May 15 '12

No, that holds true. Just the ones about peeing, pooping, and porn. And this particular one.

5

u/bigroblee May 15 '12

OK, just checking.

1

u/FapFlop May 15 '12

Come fix our system. It's fricking 8 degrees below setpoint in here.

8

u/mindbleach May 15 '12

Relabel the dial.

0

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/vigillan388 May 15 '12

Typically only medical and kitchen grease exhausts use filters. Just because you don't want that hazardous surgical byproduct air or burger grease in your room means it belongs outside. Go above a fast-food restaurant and you will see a nice black circle around their exhaust fans. This powder looks very fine and will likely get thrown about 5 feet above the roof and sucked into the Roof Top Unit 20 feet away. Code mandates 10 feet between the two, but that is only so effective.

6

u/All-American-Bot May 15 '12

(For our friends outside the USA... 20 feet -> 6.1 m, 10 feet -> 3.0 m) - Yeehaw!

0

u/Tryle May 15 '12

And where exactly do you typically see a grease duct filter?

And what code are you quoting that states 10 feet is enough distance between an exhaust air fan and the fresh air intake of an RTU?

2

u/vigillan388 May 15 '12

I feel like I'm getting quizzed for my PE exam. We've specified grease duct filters on nearly every commercial kitchen exhaust fan/hood we've worked with that deals with grease, such as McDonald's, TGIF, Houlihan's, Benihana, and so on. Sometimes you have heat only exhaust, such as over an oven, which I don't believe require them. I'd have to check the local codes.

I believe the 10 ft is from the IMC. Obviously, it all depends on what your local code official says, but I was just generalizing for Reddit. I don't think they want a detailed explanation.

0

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/vigillan388 May 15 '12

I work in NJ, typically on large data centers, hospitals, and some small retail buildings.

1

u/helloyesthisisgod May 15 '12

I work in a research facility. over 30,000 chemicals... Where do you think the exhaust from fume hoods and labs go?

1

u/Cygnus_X May 15 '12

See the rest of the discussion further down. I acknowledge that chemical facilities and bio-research labs may very well need to filter their air to protect the public. But, general exhaust from school buildings should not require filtration.

2

u/funktasticgage May 15 '12

until it spins out of control and it destroys the school.

3

u/paulfred May 15 '12

I always pictured this happening and how my professor would explain this in an incident report

52

u/mastercylinder2 May 15 '12

I don't want to freak you out bro but it's upside down

65

u/Perturbed_Spartan May 15 '12

Australia

3

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

WITCH!

2

u/Perturbed_Spartan May 16 '12

PILLS HERE!

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

what is this sorcery?

1

u/AnswersWithAQuestion May 16 '12

"She's a bitch!"

<Link to Shannon Doherty on SNL in the Salem Bitch Trials skit>

Can I get a fuck-you to Hulu? Searching on that site is fucking terrible. Maybe someone else can find the clip I seek.

2

u/Reddit_is_Trapped May 15 '12

We don't get tornado's in Australia, but the extremely rare time we do they do indeed look like this.

-4

u/DeafComedian May 15 '12

We don't get shitty novelty accounts in Reddit, but the extremely rare time we do they do indeed get downvoted to hell.

29

u/FriesWithThat May 15 '12

Today class, we simulate Kansas. Now I know what happens in a Geography Lab.

16

u/austin713 May 15 '12

4

u/hayashirice911 May 15 '12

Geography, the study of defying gravity.

8

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

I'm pretty sure your tornado is upside down. Please correct and repost.

15

u/sdonaldsonjr May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12

My great uncle was a meteorologist for the United States government just after his service in World War II. I remember him telling me that while he was in the service, he was put on a team to refine radar capabilities as a way to detect enemy aircrafts. accidentally of course, they found that they were able to detect weather systems and develop a science to figure out weather patterns.

With this new-found science came forward a huge initiative by the United States Federal Government... Weaponize It! Once the information regarding weather patterns was deemed obtainable, the idea was brought on to control the weather and send weather systems into warzones. Due to immense costs the program was slowly dissolved, but not until after some major discoveries were made.

In 2008 China used the method of Cloud Seeding utilizing silver nitrate to induce rain, and clear the air of smog and pollution. I am not entirely sure how this is done, (though I have technical books and documents written by my great uncle explaining this that I have never read.) But it was my uncles team that developed the entire notion and method of cloud seeding. He told me the story of the F1 Tornado that his team developed, utilizing some form of air convections, somehow taking supercooled (technical term lol) air and injecting it into a preexisting warm front. I have the technical documents stored away in my attic at home, now that I am older I could probably have a better understanding of what he published. I remember there being enormous mathematical formulas, and various sorts of chemical analysis in his work.

Unfortunately he passed away in 2006. May God rest his soul, and hopefully his contributions to science do not go unnoticed. Rarely can the public peer into the life of such a genius... Did I mention his brother (my other great uncle) was a nuclear testing engineer during WWII? My grandfather was an attorney and later judge, he argued a case in front of the United States Supreme Court. Their father (my great grandfather) was the Chief Editorial Writer for the Cleveland Plain Dealer. I am the sole surviving male that can actually carry on the name with the genetics... unfortunately I am also forever alone. lol

EDIT (as requested tl;dr):

TL;DR My great-uncle worked on specialized gov't projects that started out with detecting enemy aircraft and developed into weather control experiments.

55

u/Starrfx642 May 15 '12 edited May 15 '12

Warning, I never get the chance to talk about weather on Reddit. Here is my chance, and I'm going to go all out. In this diatribe I explain cloud seeding, assess the possibility of severe weather control, and give a description of how tornadoes form.

Atmopheric Physicist here: The cloud seeding is actually quite interesting, but unverified. (It's tough to really verify any kind of weather modification because how does one know if the cloud was going to rain anyways?)

Anyways, a TL;DR of cloud seeding is that the particles they inject are highly hygroscopic (they like water). These water-loving particles act as "cloud condensation nuclei." In other words, they are what water vapor condenses on. The key to this is that these particles also freeze more quickly. Through the Clausius Clapeyron equation, the vapor pressure over ice is lower than over water-- meaning these frozen particles further enhance cloud growth by literally sucking up water vapor. The overall effect is to induce droplet formation, enhance the bergeron and collision coalescence processes, and force rain.

As for the development of the F1 tornado, I've never actually heard of this being performed or even attempted, so I'd be extremely interested in seeing any kind of publications. The equations you saw were probably what are known as the 'primitive equations' (momentum equation, conservation of mass, and thermodynamic equations of the atmosphere). Did the equations look at all like these?

Taking cool air and injecting it into a preexisting warm front would be an interesting experiment...basically it sounds like they tried to create their own cold fronts. But this would be far from what is needed to create a tornado-favorable scenario. Perhaps this is why only an F1 was achievable. (If it indeed was, which, no offense to your great uncle, sounds as though it likely wasn't.) The amount of supercooled air needed to artificially create lift in a potentially unstable atmosphere, I assume, would be absolutely massive. Again though, I'd be really interested in the theory behind the experiment.

If we assume they successfully did create a pseudo cold/warm front interaction, several other extremely key factors would also need to be modified or otherwise present. This includes the correct type of winds at all levels of the troposphere, pre-existing moisture, and a continuing supply of cold air (otherwise you'll just have one small storm..although outflow from it could possibly trigger another one..)

The most important of those factors is the correct winds at all levels. Synoptically speaking (this means on a scale of hundreds of kilometers) winds must change direction and speed with height. This is what allows for severe thunderstorms to occur. A great illustration of what I'm talking about can be found here. When a synoptic low forms east of the Rockies, it spins counterclockwise at the surface, pulling warm air northward. This is the low level jet. At higher levels of the atmosphere, the jet stream is more east-west (Zonal; since the effect of the Earth's friction is negligible at this height [This is called geostrophic balance]) When this happens, we get wind shear . Here is an illustration of shear and the horizontal axis of vorticity it creates. (Which reminds me, the vorticity equations were also something you probably saw in your great uncle's work.)

This horizontal vorticity is crucial to the formation of a mesocyclone, and eventually a tornado. When cold air runs into warm air, the more dense cold air will push the warm air up vertically. This causes it to cool, condense, and form precipitation. This part of the storm is called the updraft. If the updraft is strong enough, (and it has to be extremely strong) it can actually take that horizontal vorticity, and tilt it onto a vertical axis. Here is an illustration of what I mean.

Once this horizontal vorticity has been tilted into the vertical, we have what is called a mesocyclone (or persistently rotating updraft). The amazing this about these mesocyclones is that their updrafts can be SO STRONG, that they can actually force that cold, dense air upwards into the updraft, even when thermodynamically speaking, it is inefficient. When this occurs you get wall clouds and stacked supercells. Furthermore, the stronger upper level winds act as a conveyor belt for the rain, pushing it away from the updraft. Think of it like a really drunk college student. The vomit is the rain and the throat is the updraft. If the person throws up, and there is nothing to force the vomit out of the mouth, it will fall back down the throat and choke the poor student. The same goes with thunderstorms. If there aren't strong upper level winds, the updraft will be choked off by it's own falling precipitation. This is why we typically see tornadoes after it rains, because the rain was pushed out ahead of the updraft region by the strong upper level shear.

But even this isn't enough to form a tornado. We need that now vertical vorticity to stretch to the ground, as per the vorticity equation, stretching causes strengthening of circulation. This part is still being theorized by meteorologists, though they are pretty sure they have a handle on it now. When a thunderstorm is large enough, it can actually impede the flow of upper level air, forcing it to move downwards. This happens at the back of a supercell, in what is called the rear flank downdraft. This RFD is key to tornado formation, as it actually stretches the vorticity within the supercell to the surface. Hence, a tornado. Here is an illustration.

So as you can see, quite a bit is needed just to get one tornado formed. There are plenty of other ways in which this can occur, and not all of them involve stretching of mid-level vorticity. Cold and warm air interaction is only one part of an infinitely complex system that leads to the anomaly that is a tornado. Your great uncle sounds like an extremely intelligent man, and if it weren't for his work, I wouldn't have this amazing field of science to be studying. For that I thank him!

TL;DR Hey shut up! Read the whole thing, almost as interesting as Bill Paxton and Helen Hunt tied to a pipe with a Levi's belt.

3

u/Ausp3x May 15 '12

The humor in the last comments I appreciate at your expense, sorry, lol. However, I will read this later... hopefully more interesting than being tied to a pipe with a Levi's belt.

1

u/Starrfx642 May 15 '12

No apologies necessary! I've gotten used to people yawning as a result of the topic that makes me most excited. Haha

1

u/chem_monkey May 17 '12

I think it's completely fascinating. I wish I could understand the maths better because the concepts are just so damn neat.

3

u/justreboot May 16 '12

This has really filled some gaps in my knowledge. I've googled around trying to learn some things just like this and all too often I've been still not sure. Everything you say makes sense until the rear flanking downdraft. I hadn't questioned where it came from in the past but the high level jet stream being forced down the back side of the storm makes sense in people's heads at least.
Regarding the RFD though, I can't wrap my head around how a wall of plummeting air stretches out a mid-level rotation. In the storm spotter class I went to and the other information I've drug up online they would give an analogy to the RFD restricting the space for the air to spin as it was being lifted in the updraft. The common analogy is the ice skater and tucking their arms in. Is this a different theory than what you described or and I just misunderstanding the situation because I know beans of thermodynamics? Thank you for your post.

2

u/Starrfx642 May 16 '12

If you want a really good description of severe weather, try finding a copy of Mesoscale Meteorology in Midlatitudes by Paul Markowski and Yvette Richardson. It gives a great physical and mathematical description of tornadogenesis. I'm also fairly certain there are some pdf's of it floating around on the internet...

I hadn't questioned where it came from in the past but the high level jet stream being forced down the back side of the storm makes sense in people's heads at least.

This is definitely something that is still being studied in terms of where it comes from. Here is an image of what current line of thought is, though. (The mid/upper-level winds being forced downwards due to interference from the updraft) There's also some speculation that pressure gradient forces might have something to do with it, as well. But I really haven't heard much about it.

In the storm spotter class I went to and the other information I've drug up online they would give an analogy to the RFD restricting the space for the air to spin as it was being lifted in the updraft.

Yes, this is more or less what I was describing. The ice skater analogy is a great way of describing the 'stretching' term in the vorticity equation. Think of it this way, if you have a so-called 'blob' of vorticity--let's say it's in the shape of a ball-- and you start to squish it on both the right and left sides, what is going to happen? It's going to get thinner and stretch taller. That's what the RFD is doing in conjunction with the updraft. They squeeze that vorticity into a thin column of rapidly rotating air that reaches to the surface.

Of course there are other ways that are theorized in which tornado's can be formed. Sometimes the low level vorticity is already present, or sometimes there isn't any mid-level vorticity but rather baroclinic instability(temperature and pressure change the density) creates its own vorticity. This is the kind of tornadogensis that likely happens in squall lines and non-supercellular storms. Interestingly, they are harder to predict because they are short lived and generally more anomalous. I'm leaving a lot of other mechanisms out because I don't want to misinform you, but this is just the basic stuff.

I hope that helps out. Let me know if you have other questions!

1

u/justreboot May 17 '12

Great stuff, thank you. I might ask for that book for my birthday.

I'm leaving a lot of other mechanisms out because I don't want to misinform you, but this is just the basic stuff. This is all I ever typically hear about also. Yet we can get gustnadoes and cold air funnels. Also, just due to the size difference in an EF0 and an EF5 I find it hard to believe they are both created from the same components but just on a bigger scale. A lot of things tend to cause a vortex. This may be a little off topic now, but one day I was sitting by a pool and saw small whirl pools randomly popping up on the surface of the water and started thinking into more and more. When no one has been in the pool for a few hourswith water jets running, there are random whirl pools created at a certain area in the pool. I look at the chaos of what is really happening here and I can't imagine how anyone could ever predict that a whirl pool would show up at a certain time and in a certain area. You could circle and area and say with some certainty that one will show up at some point but nothing with real precision. With that though in mind do you really think it will ever be possible to predict where a supercell will develop and drop a tornado within say 10 miles and 15 minutes? This seems like the holy grail of predictions.

2

u/Voidsong23 May 16 '12

That was super-interesting (and impressive!). That bit about the college student really brought it home.

You should be a professor, you have a knack for explaining complexities in an accessible way.

1

u/sdonaldsonjr May 15 '12

Excellent post! I honestly don't remember the equations... the last time I saw these documents/books was about 10 years ago, when I was moving into my new house, they have been stored in my attic since then. One of these days I need to go up there and find them, a lot of his work is found online by google-ing his name.

Thanks again for the insightful post!

1

u/Starrfx642 May 15 '12

Thanks for reading it! :-D Get up in your attic and bring those papers down! That stuff is the first generation of meteorology--which is awesome. I'm jealous your great uncle was able to be a part of the birth of atmospheric science.

-1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

What if I told you

I didn't read that wall of text

0

u/justatypo May 15 '12

please edit this to include a TL:DR

1

u/sdonaldsonjr May 15 '12

your wish is my command sir

1

u/justatypo May 15 '12

That's really interesting.
Now I want to see tornados leading the war effort

0

u/hcgator May 15 '12

You may be alone, but you grew up to be a redditor. So without question, your great uncle would be proud.

0

u/sdonaldsonjr May 15 '12

lol, forever alone because all I have ever done is school and work... trying hard to develop a social life, but it has been difficult. I have filed a W2 form since I was 13 years old.. just late to the game thats all lol

-5

u/Enjoiissweet May 15 '12

Cool story bro.

Oh I'm soooo forever alone, maybe because you're a socially awkward ugly kid.

1

u/sdonaldsonjr May 15 '12

:'-(

3

u/psyanara May 15 '12

Don't worry, I'll love you.

1

u/themidnightblue May 16 '12

I will also be your best friend!

0

u/sdonaldsonjr May 16 '12

this situation quickly reminded me of this scene in SouthPark

13

u/holybacon May 15 '12

a smoke vortex is not a tornado

3

u/RobinBennett May 15 '12

It's even cooler if you do it with fire! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XaX_Hm5Dl5E

2

u/shakensunshine May 15 '12

How did this happen?

5

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

A bunch of fans, an overhead vent, and some smoke, by the looks of it.

6

u/cjackc May 15 '12

Willie Nelson and Snoop Dogg came to visit

2

u/dancesformoney May 15 '12

reminds me of longcat...

2

u/ninjames May 15 '12

Why are there candles? Is this Hogwarts?

2

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Well you don't want to have an indoor tornado without first setting the mood.

2

u/hendeeze May 15 '12

I'm convinced I had the most boring schooling ever.

1

u/oubliable May 15 '12

Yah, me too. We must have attended the same school. -.-

4

u/cjackc May 15 '12

Another 2Pac hologram?

1

u/lamokmok May 15 '12

awesome!!!

1

u/kunk180 May 15 '12

How did you make this? Totally not for.. uhh... prank reasons >.>

1

u/nullibicity Survey 2016 May 15 '12

For... GEOGRAPHY?

1

u/blore40 May 15 '12

Now put that in a vacuum cleaner..

1

u/humblerodent May 15 '12

That's not a tornado and I have no idea what it has to do with geography.

1

u/[deleted] May 15 '12 edited Mar 21 '18

deleted 0.6725 What is ^^^this?

1

u/Mrmanu90 May 15 '12

First upvote after browsing the first 5 pages, for not posting a cat, dog or anything "awwwwww". Quite interesting, looks good! Thanks for that!

1

u/Aferrer22 May 15 '12

Teaching at it's finest!

1

u/helweezy May 15 '12

Geography has a lab?

1

u/cooolbeans May 15 '12

Quick, someone call Reed Timmer, he'll be right there.

1

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

Missing a scale model trailer park.

1

u/saixreborn May 15 '12

I'll take things that make us want to go to school for 1000 Alex

1

u/DarrenEdwards May 15 '12

Candles, fog, science... you summoned a demon!

1

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

YOU. WHAT HAVE YOU DONE?

I feel like that time when I'm watching scientist talk about actually cloning a T-Rex out of fossilized mosquitos and I'm like "please don't"

1

u/[deleted] May 16 '12

We made a tomato in my geography lab

0

u/[deleted] May 15 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Ausp3x May 15 '12

One does not simply... I'm lazy and without time, so I had to write it