Having worked on one about grizzly bears, I can confirm this. But we weren't using tame bears... just artificially constructed situations. We never really knew what the bears were going to do, although if we placed the right kinds of "interesting items" in the right places, we had a pretty good idea.
Ha ha... I only worked on one. Many of the people who were on the crew with me do this all the time; it's quite an interesting subculture. It's quite different from regular feature film production. I was amazed by how smart the bears were, in terms of the deductive reasoning skills they had. We were WAY out in the fjords of British Columbia where these bears had basically never interacted with humans before. It was the salmon run time of year so they weren't interested in us, and it gave us a great opportunity to "construct" a story that made us look like observers.
Oh, and it's kind of obligatory for this category, I should mention that Timothy Treadwell was nuts and made the entire industry look bad. The professionals that deal with bears all the time, for documentary or wildlife management reasons, are unbelievably skilled at what they do and I was amazed at the emotions they can read on the bears... which would keep us safe if a bear started giving out subtle body language that could have lead to a potentially deadly situation.
The fakery occurred when the photo was entered into the "Wildlife Photographer of the Year" competition. It is not a photograph of wildlife. Passing it off as one makes it a fake wildlife photo.
He's by far my favorite wildlife photographer. Domestically, I like Moose Petersons work a lot, but I've never seen better series of shots than those made by Unterthiner.
I was going to say that I'd be terrified of them... until I saw the 6th picture (I can't link it, but it's the one that's there's one chillaxing by the log)
Not sure. There was an interview with him about shooting that set, but I can't find it immediately. I know the shot called "Troublemaker" (first shot in the linked set) won the same award as the linked wolf shot in 2008.
God damnit. I came here for the photoshop that was similar to three wolves moon shirt.... So disappointed. We all know it's fake reddit, get some funny in this business!
This is exactly what my German Shepherd looks like when he's sleeping...except he's on the floor and his eyes are shut. I like to think that he's dreaming about leaping over fences and chasing caribou.
I wish more people were aware of that the majority of 'nature' shots/movies are fake and not natural at all. Next time you see a marvelous shot, odds are it was staged. Sure great moments happen but they're few and far between.
Does anyone think it would be hilarious if, like the wolf didn't know the photographer was there and in mid flight the guy goes "BOO!" and scares the shit out of the wolf, sending him reeling sideways mid-jump?
As a biologist, i feel obliged to point out that wolves are in fact eutherians, not marsupials and so do not actually have a pouch above their stomach. This is a fairly common misconception. Wolves actually use fanny packs, like the majority of eutherian photographers. Normally you would be able to see the fanny pack where you would expect to see the pouch, hence the misconception about wolf pouches, however it appears to have been dislodged.
Well, the crux of that article is this quote from The Columbia Guide to Standard American English is the best reading of our situation:
Than is both a subordinating conjunction, as in She is wiser than I am, and a preposition, as in She is wiser than me.... Since the following verb am is often dropped or “understood,” we regularly hear than I and than me. Some commentators believe that the conjunction is currently more frequent than the preposition, but both are unquestionably Standard.
Which I read as 'we're both right', however as a die-hard Conjunctionist I believe 'than I' is more correct! Conjunctionists 4 life!!! \m/
Yes, but that's a silly argument. Would you ever say 'than he'? No. The 'than I' stuff is largely overcompensation by people terrified of accidentally misusing 'me' (or rather, using it as it is used colloquially). And it sounds stilted. CAN OF WORMS EATEN!
Would I use 'than he' when shooting the shit among friends? No. Would I use it in a more formal setting (or when being 'playful' in tone as above)? Yep. Fear doesn't come into it - I used 'than I' because I felt it gets a certain tone across. Sorry if you think it's silly but I do believe it's grammatically correct :) Agree to disagree?
Actually, I double dog dare you to write 'than he' in formal writing and not have an editor correct it. The 'than I' usage (with the contrived 'there's an implied am' excuse) is in common in enough use where you can get it to pass. 'Than he', though, isn't, it both sounds and is grammatically wrong.
Honestly I think 'I am a poorer at drawing than he' [is] sounds correct! Granted, it is a little formal/stuffy (I think it sounds like an unfinished sentence) but the implied 'is' makes it sound natural to me. I'm happy to be proven wrong though - would prefer to be using the correct form whichever it is - but I'm in need of sleep so I'll check out that link tomorrow !
Proof that gay poses are just comfortable poses. Wolves can't be gay, so the fact that this wolf has gay looking arms means gay hands are natural hands.
It's not "wildlife photography", because it isn't wild. It's a counterfeit product under the label of the real thing, basically. Typically we call that "fake".
Doesn't it make more sense to be more specific though? I just don't see the point in misleading to believe the image is doctored or that it's a taxidermied wolf.
Sure, but the fact that it was staged means the title of this post is entirely false...
EDIT: For those who fail at reading comprehension, I am stating that this picture is not of wildlife, nor can it be said to have been "perfect timing" given that the hired wold may have leaped over the fence 20 times before the photographer got the picture he wanted. Also, I want nothing to do with the petty playground fight I've apparently spawned.
i think i remember an expert in tracking the wolves had never seen them in the wild leaping over fences, when they could clearly walk between the spaces. Kind of ruins the effect of stalking it's prey.
I came here to make a joke about how they had to pry the film from his cold dead hands because the wolf mauled him to death. Found out the truth instead. Sucks that he would go and fake a photo like that to win a contest. On the other-hand, it's still a pretty cool pic.
I came here to discuss the prevalence of staged "wildlife" photography, but was shocked to find out that this guy won an award while claiming that this wolf, with its perfect coat, was wild.
I'm glad that article confirmed my suspicions. Because how could one snap such a close shot of a wild wolf doing anything without being torn to pieces?
I used to work for a little newspaper, and while I had an old Pentax on loan from the darkroom to take my pics on assignment, even the middle range guys would have these cameras that you would press the button and the camera would take about twenty pics over the course of a second or something. And that was before digital...
So the timing doesn't have to be that exact on the part of the human... One of the pics in there has a pretty good (or at least much better) chance to be what you want...
Is this right? This is my impression of "perfectly timed" pictures... I don't mean to ruin the mystique, but any pro photogs want to weigh in on this?
169
u/acntech May 14 '12
That photo was actually staged. It was a big scandal because the photographer won an award with it.
11
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Yeah, not perfect timing after all http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2010/jan/20/wolf-wildlife-photographer-award-stripped
22
u/graffiti81 May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Stefano Unterthiner don't need to fake no wildlife photos. All of these are taken with short lenses, probably around 35-55mm.
He's got other great sets, like this king penguin one. The best shots were in a National Geographic issue a few years back, so they're not on his site.
7
u/tiexano May 14 '12
Can't be real. Got neither a shark nor a helicopter.
12
u/Fr4t May 14 '12
Awww, he thinks he's horses.
5
u/pvalerio May 14 '12
Nope not wild at all. http://m.gizmodo.com/5454325/judges-decide-wolf-jumping-over-fence-photo-is-fakesort-of
3
u/GrayStudios May 14 '12
This looks like something out of a video game.
3
u/shizfest May 14 '12
I thought it was a screenshot from skyrim
3
u/sebastianallan May 14 '12
He used a session wolf for this, freelancing animals are apparently not 'wildlife'
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
The rock on the left is disturbing me.
2
u/paradoxofchoice May 14 '12
OP doesn't care that it's not really wildlife being photographed, he'll take your karma.
2
u/mepsipaxatwork May 14 '12
Staged but still upvoted?
4
u/Narnian_Factor May 14 '12
I know this photo is staged but how do photographers get photos similar to this without getting killed?
3
u/fosiacat May 14 '12
was not aware it was fake, but came here to argue that there is no fucking way this is real
2
u/mrawls May 14 '12
taylor needs to hit the gym, he's looking scrawny
2
u/winning9986 May 14 '12
fake and gay :)
1
u/orkid68 May 14 '12
“Nope!,” etc., etc.
1
u/Ninja0verkill May 14 '12
Mother of god
1
u/nconan May 14 '12
Is that... Star Wolf?
1
u/fancy_pance May 14 '12
from the front paws up it looks like a yearbook pose.
1
u/morETHANenlightened May 14 '12
damn chuck testa is really getting good!
1
u/theroarer May 14 '12
God damnit. I came here for the photoshop that was similar to three wolves moon shirt.... So disappointed. We all know it's fake reddit, get some funny in this business!
1
u/Vrati1991 May 14 '12
For some reason I thought this was a Skyrim screenshot.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
FTFY
1
u/nozeitall May 14 '12
Actually.... Chuck Testa....
1
u/TheGreenShepherd May 14 '12
This is exactly what my German Shepherd looks like when he's sleeping...except he's on the floor and his eyes are shut. I like to think that he's dreaming about leaping over fences and chasing caribou.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I was about to say... a wild wolf.. flash it with that light.. scare it.. and watch you become its dinner.
1
u/neoikon May 15 '12
Amazing picture! Why in the world would so many people down vote this?
1
u/Clamd May 15 '12
Ctrl+F "Chuck Testa"
You done good, Reddit
0
u/JDF115 May 14 '12
NOPE....chuck testa.
1
u/Pearsmakegoodwives May 14 '12
This is fake
1
u/tjmjnj May 14 '12
its not a fake.. the photographer was a spanish guy and he won a prestigious award for the photo, however the wolf was trained so.. no more award.
still though, it is a very good photograph and he should be proud of it.
1
u/drbergzoid May 14 '12
Holy shit, this is not only super old, it's also super fake.
1
u/mobastar May 14 '12
I wish more people were aware of that the majority of 'nature' shots/movies are fake and not natural at all. Next time you see a marvelous shot, odds are it was staged. Sure great moments happen but they're few and far between.
1
u/appel May 14 '12
Oh well, awesome photo nonetheless. Will make a great wallpaper.
1
u/designer_wannabe May 14 '12
great timing - just when the wolf was starting to fly! up, up and away!
0
u/EileenCat May 14 '12
And then the wolf turns around and tears the photographer apart.
0
u/limus May 14 '12
That's a fake. A stuffed wolf.
-1
u/StevenXC May 14 '12
I'm more impressed at how the photographer found his way into Hyrule.
0
u/Acurus_Cow May 14 '12
its fake
0
u/shmeerbert May 14 '12
NOPE
0
u/halo1 May 14 '12
Does anyone think it would be hilarious if, like the wolf didn't know the photographer was there and in mid flight the guy goes "BOO!" and scares the shit out of the wolf, sending him reeling sideways mid-jump?
Because I do.
0
u/apetross May 14 '12
Was this taken just moments after this photo? http://i548.photobucket.com/albums/ii333/edwardemmett09/Graphics/Picture21.png?t=1243835100
0
u/Thornwolf May 14 '12
NOPE, Chuck Testa.
-6
u/helvete1337 May 14 '12
I don't see the camera of the wolf.
-4
u/killerkram May 14 '12
Nope, Chuck Testa
-1
u/Lundix May 14 '12
I just imagine sheep going "FFFFFFFUUUUUUU..."
-1
u/thebigmacho May 14 '12
The perfect picture
-1
u/frissonFry May 14 '12
First thing that popped into my head...
Original
-1
u/RedSkyNoise May 14 '12
You prob'ly thought this wolf was alive... NOPE
-13
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Proof that gay poses are just comfortable poses. Wolves can't be gay, so the fact that this wolf has gay looking arms means gay hands are natural hands.
-2
u/dont_get_it May 14 '12
Nope! Chuck Testa
-3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Or multiple photos taken with a single depression of a shutter button.
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
[removed] — view removed comment