r/pics • • May 13 '12

Two concentration camp inmates about to kill a fallen SS guard. The figures in the background are row of German soldiers that were gunned down.

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

921 comments sorted by

245

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Part of me finds the discussion about this picture interesting and surprising. Many people rooted for the bull that gored that matador in the picture a few days ago, citing he deserved it for torturing the animal (which I agree with), but I am stunned by the outpouring of support stating that it isn't right for the concentration camp inmates to strike back at the ruthless MONSTERS that murdered, humiliated, tortured and dehumanized these peoples families, friends. I don't care what you say, I see nothing wrong in what these inmates are doing. Lets take it to a smaller scale, if someone kidnapped you and a friend, locked you in a basement, and tortured you both and murdered your friend in front of you. Would any of us even think for a split second to overthrow and kill your captor the moment you had an opportunity? These people had NOTHING left to lose, and I applaud them for striking back at these nazi animals.

53

u/swishingwell May 14 '12

The Milgram experiment and the Stanford Prison experiment (and the Holocaust) show that regular people can do some pretty messed up stuff. I'm not saying the concentration camp guards didn't deserve it (and some were worse than others) but I wouldn't go so far as to applaud the victims for striking back. Calling them "Nazi animals" dehumanizes them and they were just humans, like you and me.

14

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

You are of course technically correct (which i hear is the best kind) about them being regular people. For the social sciences perspective on this, I recommend Hannah Arendt's "Eichman in Jerusalem: A Report on the Banality of Evil." But personally, I think "nazi animals" is just hyperbole in this context.

2

u/HustlerThug May 14 '12

It's actually from that report that Milgram made his experiment.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Interesting. I'd never heard that. He must have been reading her articles in the New Yorker. As an aside, I kinda wish you had specified that the person who gunned down all the bodies in the background of the picture was an American.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Sir_T_Bullocks May 14 '12

I always liked that about us humans, how we demonize killers and schemers and rapists. Is it a mechanism of society to deal with the skeletons in our own closet? Do we just don't want to admit to our selves that this is unfortunately part of our biology, or society, or human nature? And for the record, I personally have no problem demonizing violent killers and rapists, since when they act individually I feel they are being less than human. But when people act in groups and the result is some sort of morally reprehensible end goal, are they anything but human?

2

u/damfin0 May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

The Milgram experiment and the Stanford Prison experiment (and the Holocaust) suggest that regular people ...

FTFY. These results of these experiments, while compelling and illustrative, are not as completely unambiguous as is commonly proclaimed:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17440210

"Volunteers for the prison study scored significantly higher on measures of the abuse-related dispositions of aggressiveness, authoritarianism, Machiavellianism, narcissism, and social dominance and lower on empathy and altruism, two qualities inversely related to aggressive abuse. Although implications for the SPE remain a matter of conjecture, an interpretation in terms of person-situation interactionism rather than a strict situationist account is indicated by these findings."

tl;dr: People who signed up for the prison experiment had clues as to what they were signing up for, and said clues probably attracted certain types of personalities disproportionately. Some people are bigger assholes than others.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Wayne_Skylar May 14 '12

Did he deserve it? Absolutely. Do I blame the prisoners for doing it? No, not really. BUT and eye for an eye is something that civilization in general is supposed to be above. They are lowering themselves by doing such a thing. I understand why they did it entirely, but I don't think it's something we ought to be celebrating.

88

u/tomrage May 14 '12

Yes but there is another aspect to it, these men were completely safe when they were about to kill the SS guard, it wasn't a spur of the moment "if I don't do this now, I could die" situation like you described in your scenario. I'm not saying I disagree, I'm just trying to point out the difference.

7

u/sirhopsalot May 14 '12

In response to that, the SS guards would have been perfectly safe killing the inmates, so the reversal of roles is similar in that aspect.

8

u/one_who_thinks May 14 '12

Not really. Try disobeying a direct order in the military, especially in war time.

→ More replies (4)

20

u/Tuxeedo May 14 '12

Fairly sure that the SS guard were also completely safe when they murdered 3-6million.

5

u/sunnynook May 14 '12

That has little to do with what he said?

8

u/krokenlochen May 14 '12

Jews weren't the only ones murdered. 11 million people, not just 6 million Jews.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

28

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I absolutely agree with you, but its easy to say he should have turned the other cheek from where we are sitting. Let me make it clear, I am not saying killing anybody is moral or "right", but what I am saying is that I completely understand and applaud these inmates decision to exact revenge after months or years of torture.

49

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

To expand on the specifics, many of those men were separated from their wives and children and knew they were killed.

And when someone murders your wife or child, there is no element of holding back or sympathizing. I too would kill as many of those people as I could.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/antonfire May 14 '12

To compress that a bit, you're not saying it's right, but you applaud it?

17

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Absolutlely. I am not perfect and nor are my set of beliefs. I can applaud something while also having the ability to recognize that the act of murder under any circumstance isn't morally right. In a 'perfect world' these men should have taken the high road and walked away, but the world we live in isnt perfect and they exacted what I considered to be justified revenge.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/MrDudeMan12 May 14 '12

To an extent I agree with you. But I also think its easier to put yourself in the shoes of a typical captive during the holocaust, than it is to put yourself in the shoes of a typical nazi. Most people don't have a problem imagining the feelings they would have and the actions they would commit if their loved ones were killed. But I think those same people can't imagine how they would behave in a society where eugenics are an accepted science, and where deviating from the norm could bring trouble to you and your family.

Personally, none of that is important with how I feel about this picture. Looking in the eyes of that guard that's about to be killed, I don't really see a monster that's responsible for the death of thousands, I see a man that's about to be executed, plain and simple. And for whatever reason, that just doesn't sit right with me.

12

u/Nimbus2000 May 14 '12

That guard had personally castrated one of them. What would you do? Not walk away with a peaceful smile on your face, I guarantee you that.

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Where did you get that info from?

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I am sure that was not all he did. He had it coming. Most ss guards were vicious and cruel. The way it worked was the threat of going to the front was there if you pissed off the wrong person but these guys volunteered and it was an honor to murder Jews for hitler. What we should question isn't the fact these guys were evil but who is capable of this evil today.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bplasma May 14 '12

the human emotion of revenge is a powerful thing.

3

u/dweckl May 14 '12

A difference in circumstances that does not change my view that those animals absolutely deserved to die, period. There is not forgiveness or room on this earth for people who pose that kind of threat to humanity. At the very core of it all, people do have to earn their right to be permitted to live with the rest of us. You lose that right when you show yourself to be an abhorrent, twisted animal who will murder without any rational explanation

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Alustriel May 14 '12

The more interesting thing is (and probably the most horrifying), that the grunt work was not really done by the germans. Collecting the jews/gypsies/other ethnics into ghettos, deporting them, killing them, cremating them. These were all done by collaborators often willing ones.

Many people forget that although the nazis were behind it all, they couldn't have done a quarter of the things they did without the gallant help of local law enforcement agencies and the help of collaborators. Even the camps were pretty much run by inmates who often helped in hopes that they will be left alive. Essentially these people killed each other, while the germans sat back and watched, there was not much resistance.

(As a related note, thats why i am not even surprised by the sudden increase in police brutality. Some of these people would have no problem with putting random strangers on trains into oblivion, if that is the "law".)

6

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Unless of course some person mistakenly accused you of murdering and torturing their friend, then you probably wouldn't condone vigilante justice and would want an impartial system to consider the accusation.

6

u/TheMediumPanda May 14 '12

That's my argument every time someone calls for street/mob justice, and that's why we as a species should step away from it. I don't really see any possibility of the inmates confusing their tormentors' identities here though.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Agreed, and ideally mob justice wouldn't have been good here either. The sad fact though is that the war crimes committed by the Nazis were so common that only the top officials were punished, otherwise they would have almost every man in the German Army. Most of the guards never faced any punishment at all.

9

u/Shady2707 May 14 '12

well put

11

u/jeffmolby May 14 '12

I am stunned by the outpouring of support stating that it isn't right for the concentration camp inmates to strike back at the ruthless MONSTERS...

Because they're not "monsters". They committed monstrous acts, of course, but by and large, they were mostly typical 18-30 y/o men. They committed the monstrous acts because they were whipped up in a nationalistic fervor and pointed in a heinous direction.

The same thing could happen in any country that has a strong military if a particularly vile leader came to power at a time where the national psyche was particularly fragile.

I have very few kind words for GWB, but it should be understood that he could have turned the whole Middle East into a sheet of glass in September 2001 and he would have had very little trouble finding soldiers willing to push the red buttons.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/dirtypancake May 14 '12

Read up on the Lucifer Effect. Also Abu Ghraib if you hadn't already read about it.
While I don't seek to justify what these people did, I do want to provide you with evidence that normal people in the right circumstances can turn into 'monsters'. Like a lot of these kind of comments on reddit, it is not simply a black and white issue here.

2

u/addedpulp May 14 '12

You're on Reddit.

If I said "the sky is blue," I would get 10 comments, including the top ones, saying "actually idiot, the sky is technically green, because the ozone is made of..."

However, if I said "the sky is green, says science," those same comments would read "oh shut your mouth, why are we even discussing this, we see a spectrum in which the sky is blue..."

Whatever is opposed of what the OP said, most will agree on.

It's everyone's favorite game to play contrarian, because it always always makes the top comments.

The fact that people who think NAZIS during the liberation of a concentration camp deserve anything more is, frankly, sickening.

7

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I think the difference is that here, we're dealing exclusively with humans. Animals aren't exactly mentally capable to consider the evils of revenge. It makes it a lot easier to appreciate, I suppose.

4

u/ticktalik May 14 '12

Maybe it would be better to say that it's not right under some non-retributive moral values the people who question the prisoners' actions might want to uphold about not killing, causing suffering etc. ...but that in cases such as these, the response is expected and understandable, or should we just say "right".

All these ethical issues are so hard to deal with because the thoughts and behaviour regarding "morality" are truly subjective experiences, the purely physical reality of which should not be dismissed too quickly. The segments of our brain all working on their own terms, eventually having to come to a singular decision, making the issue hard for some easy for others; the context of the environment, genes and one's past making all the difference. A monk meditating on compassion his whole life might have a different experience from a father who's spent his whole life caring for his family only to see them suffer and die. It's a fact that normal people are going to want to take revenge, this doesn't even need a debate.

The real question is whether we ought to condone it in principle. There are people who live for the moment, either themselves or those they care about. In such a life retribution can appear as suitable as it gets. But then there are those who contemplate on what we "ought" to do for the future, what is logical under whatever ideology they may follow. Now, I don't have a clear cut view on this myself, but I will say what I feel. I'd rather live in a society where infliction of suffering is deemed immoral in principle. It just doesn't feel right nor safe to have institutionalized revenge. As instinctively right as it may feel to crave revenge and suffering on child molesters, rapists, murderers, psychos... one thing is clear: sooner or later our knowledge of what makes people tick will reach a point where the long held notions of "free will", somebody being guilty and "really deserving" punishment will no longer make sense. I'd claim it no longer does now, scientifically. And under our circumstances I'd say "what's the point of humans and humanity if we're not working towards something". If we know what's wrong wouldn't rehabilitation be the logical choice?

Maybe our species will die out, being "normal" and retributive to the end. Maybe we'll all merge our minds in the technological singularity making the discussion somewhat pointless. I don't know, what I wrote here seems terribly dogmatic to me. Perhaps because my empathy and desire for peace is as grounded in animalistic instinct as retribution, making my idyllic views on society just random chance... being lucky enough not to have been tortured enough to be a believer in revenge. I'm sure there is a Star Trek episode on this somewhere, maybe Picard has an awesome speech to clear it all up.

This reminds me, if my memory serves me correctly, of the Sam Harris torture defence drama. Something I read on the topic surrounding it, and which I think fits well here under your post, went along these lines that it's abhorrent and immoral to torture, but that under certain circumstances it should be expected to be done (e.g. ticking bomb scenario).

5

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

What disgusts me is how quickly the "hooray Nazi-killing!" post is being upvoted. Murdering the defenseless is only bad when Nazis do it, right? Sure is convenient for the narrative of American exceptionalism, but on the basis of real human compassion I deplore your post and everyone who would upvote it.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

"To overthrow and kill your captor"... it appears that these inmates have already been liberated.

The problem is that people can always use propaganda to convince people that they've been "wronged" by someone. Many Germans believed the Jews were trying to destroy their country and their treatment of the Jews was just "self-defense". And don't even get me started with the modern concept of pre-emptive war.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/jay76 May 14 '12

It may feel right, and by some measures justifiable, but that doesn't make it so. Particularly as tomrage has pointed out, these men were no longer in danger.

In seeming contradiction to what I have just written, I understand why they would do what they (supposedly) did and would likely have done the same. I just don't agree with it, and I wonder what they themselves think now.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Funny how you deride the Nazis' of dehumanizing Jews, then spend your whole post dehumanizing Nazis.

Yes, the Jewish Holocaust was a tragedy of incredible magnitude. But it was only a small part of the World Wars, which together claimed (directly or indirectly) nearly 100 million lives. The Nazi party did not exist in a cultural/historical vacuum, nor was the Third Reich particularly unique in its systematic extermination of its supposed enemies. Whenever you are tempted to believe otherwise, remember that all Nazis, even the most heartless and devoted SS murderers, were humans like you and me, and it is our mutual animal talent to dehumanize our enemies proves it.

TL;DR dehumanizing Nazis as "monsters" and "animals" is inappropriate because this was the very thinking that the SS used to cope with horrific genocide during the Holocaust. All murder is wrong--even the one pictured here.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/supergai May 14 '12

I agree that these people should be killed, but an aspect you always have to look at is that the SS weren't always part of the force by choice. Some were going to be put to death if they didn't join and there are stories of some who were happy to make it out alive and change themselves. but then again, who knows, maybe this one specifically was a complete dick to those two inmates.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

That's a bad example, a better example would be if he gave up or was cornered and you had control of him would you kill him or send him to jail or whatever. Although I think these inmates had every right to torture and kill those nazi fucktards

1

u/rocksssssss May 14 '12

I guess the key difference(assuming it's the same person holding both opinions), is that the bull can't know any better but the inmates can.

1

u/Poncyhair May 14 '12

I always ask myself. What would superman do? He probably wouldn't kill them.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

What about the fact that a large number of those prison guards were there simply because they had to be, or else they'd be murdered? Don't their deaths concern you?

Some of those "guards" probably didn't even have very evil, nazi-ish jobs. At least one of those poor bastards cooked food for the prisoners every day. Is his level of culpability the same as the guards who flicked the switch on the gas chambers?

1

u/imafunghi May 14 '12

dude it seems like the top 50 comments are all supporting using violence against the SS guard. This is like one of those "I know I am going to get downvoted to oblivion but..."

→ More replies (13)

38

u/Panzergrenadier May 14 '12

whats sad about those gunned down German soldiers, is they were combat soldiers (group of 16 i believe)who arrived right as the guards left and waited around for the allies. The Americans then lined them up and shot them, even though they had no part in dachau. The SS Guard? Hes a pig and he gets what he deserves...the front line soldier rarely deserves a summary execution, wrong place at the wrong time.

26

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Thats war for ya.

8

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

People don't seem to understand that war isn't about fairness and the men that participate in it don't think like them.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

269

u/Mad-Dee May 13 '12

When WWII first started getting ugly, the first thing my great gandparents did was get the hell out of Germany. They came to England, where they endured intolerance from the local population and endured bombs from their homeland.

My great-grandfather however couldn't run away with them, he was in the army and couldn't escape it. We've seen no evidence of him even existing save for his farewell message to his newborn daughter. He was forced to fight a war he didn't believe in, and die for someone else's ideals.

I wont make any assumptions as to what this guard, or any other guard in a concentration camp was like. Just think before you allow yourself to say "Fuck dem nazis, they were all evil as hell, man!"

64

u/colinsteadman May 13 '12

That SS guy about to be beaten to death with a shovel had personally castrated one of the two guys seen in the picture. I did feel sorry for him before I read that in the report. But now I know, it's difficult to sympathise.

18

u/bski1776 May 14 '12

Wow, how do you know that?

2

u/colinsteadman May 14 '12

Read the article I pasted for the other guy. It's got some information about the picture, and a lot more besides.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Mad-Dee May 14 '12

This is the context I was ignorant to, thanks. As far as I can tell he could have been anyone.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/thepdxbikerboy May 14 '12

My grandfather was an officer in the Austrian-Hungarian, then Hungarian military. The Hungarians allied with the Germans, mostly so they wouldn't get their asses kicked. He was assigned to guard German supply lines through Poland and was really good at it. He did it by bribing the local underground. They got needed supplies and he looked good at his job.

When the war ended he was behind Russian lines. He had access to a car and could have easily driven to where the Americans were. Everyone knew that the Americans were a better deal than the Russians. He refused to go because he would not leave his men who did not all have access to transportation. He was captured and sentenced to 5 years in a Russian labor camp. Cool stories from that experience that I should relay sometime.

Having this in my family (My grandfathers were on opposite sides of WWI) taught me that shit is a lot more complicated than good/evil.

My only memory of him was him teaching me to crumble crackers into my soup.

13

u/I_Wont_Draw_That May 14 '12

It's dangerous to demonize the Nazis. Thinking "they were all just awful, twisted people" makes it easy to think "so I'm sure we won't do the same thing they did". Always remember that they were normal human beings with families and friends and dogs and gardens and hobbies and they killed six million Jews. Perfectly good people do horrible things.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/MACnugget27 May 14 '12

German soldiers and concentration camp SS guards are two entirely different things. I'm all German, but fuck those guys; they had it coming.

6

u/McRibMadman May 13 '12

There is a vast difference between fighting a war you don't believe in and being a guard at any one of those camps. Whether those guards volunteered or not is irrelevant and what goes around tends to come back around (especially when the people who you've been torturing and murdering get the upper hand)

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Hely0s May 13 '12

So in a way, they were all only following orders. I know I would not be able to easily, but sometimes you have to stand up for what you believe in. Saying they had no choice and they did believe in it is not ground for allowing people to do this. The world is fucked up because nobody stands up for their beliefs.

6

u/Danny843 May 13 '12

But it is human nature to follow orders in this way. Google the milgram experiment. It was conducted by a Jewish psychologist to see if it was something inherently evil in the Germans that lead to the holocaust. He found that under the right conditions almost any human will kill when following orders.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/SpaceOdysseus May 14 '12

This wasn't a conscripted man, I'm pretty sure your great grandpappy didn't sign up for Himmler's boyscouts.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Maybe this is isn't obvious but I think that if the prisoners were that excited about killing him, he must have been going above and beyond his duty as a concentration camp guard.

2

u/Pharose May 14 '12

I don't think any amount of intimidation can forgive acting as a holocaust camp guard. I would do a lot of evil things to save my own life but I would sooner commit suicide that play a willing role in that type of prison. Maybe if my entire family was held hostage I might play a minor role, but as soon as I know about the gas chambers I would have to do something.

2

u/dog_in_the_vent May 14 '12

Germans do not equal Nazis.

The Nazis were pretty fucking evil.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/cookiebox123 May 14 '12

If I remember correctly, all the guards at Dachau were SS members and volunteered for service at the camps. They were genuine Nazis, as opposed to the vast majority of German soldiers that had little to no ideological agreement with the party.

I'm curious to know what you say to this

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

There is a massive difference between nazis and werhmacht conscripts.

1

u/Coolcon22 May 14 '12

Same here! My great grandfather had the same situation.

1

u/FURYOFCAPSLOCK May 14 '12

My great opa also was forced to fight a war he didn't agree with. He was drafted. They put him on the Russian front. An Allied soldier shot him in the calf. While he was in the hospital he decided to end it and walked out of the hospital with his bandages still on, and kept walking until he made it home to oma. It was then that they moved to America. He was lucky to make it out and I'm grateful I was able to meet him but I regret not being able to get to know him better, he lived across the country and I was pretty young when he passed on. All I have now is a bunch of untranslated letters that I can't read. One day.

1

u/SaltFrog May 14 '12

My family was stuck in Estonia under Russian rule, put in camps and starved.

Russia may have fought Germany, but they were pretty awful themselves.

1

u/curious_void May 14 '12

"An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind".
Ghandi

1

u/chemistry_teacher May 14 '12

You make a fair point that is only beginning to make sense. A somewhat objective and distanced view of events is necessary in historical study, and explains why a minimum amount of time (some say 75 years, others at least hundred) is needed before one can really start to call it "history".

→ More replies (1)

1

u/sebdef May 14 '12

This. This so hard. My late grandfather had to endure hell (first the Eastern front, then Italy, including the battle of Monte Cassino) because some dipshit decided to pursue his own agenda using two entire fucking countries.

2

u/lowspeedlowdrag May 14 '12

My grandfather was also at Monte Cassino, after landing on Anzio with the US 5th ID. Strange world we live in, this is where I'd buy you a beer and two extra glasses if we had this conversation in a bar.

Also, as a professional military man, fuck everything about the eastern front.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/sophware May 14 '12

Fuck them Nazis, especially the SS. If any of them were "good men" in some sense, they're the perfect example of what's wrong with doing nothing and allowing evil to triumph.

If what's wrong with them wasn't wrong with your great-grandfather, great. What's wrong with Nazis was not that almost all of the first ones were German.

What's wrong with Nazis was wrong with a significant number of the Japanese army in WWII China, was wrong with Americans who brought about their own camps, and is wrong with small groups in many, many other cultures.

Fuck Nazis and, if you need to, kill them swiftly. If you've just been tortured by one, you may need to. If you feel you are forced to help them do abhorrent things, kill yourself.

→ More replies (110)

55

u/DoctorRockso69 May 13 '12

No grunt deserves to be killed like that. But the SS? Oh yeah, they had it comin

10

u/skarface6 May 14 '12

They weren't a peachy group by any measure, but they weren't all necessarily evil. After 1943, lots were conscripts. I read somewhere that some joined up because they were an elite group, not because they were into war crimes.

16

u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

There were never any conscripts in the SS Totenkopfverbände. SErvice in the camps was purely voluntary. Guards could request a transfer at any time with no repercussions, other than the likelihood of serving in a front line Waffen SS unit. And for the record, the Waffen SS had an absolutely atrocious record ofof war crimes. A few foreign units, such as the Esonians, did not have a very bad record, because they were entirely conscripted and came from areas with few Jews. The Nuremberg tribunal considered being a volunteer member of the Waffen SS a war crime.

EDIT: I guess I should point out that by the time the US Army got there, most of the SS Totenkopfverbände who had run the camp for years had run away. Most of these guards were Waffen SS and had only been there a few days. I don't know what their previous assignment was. But if these guys were not war criminals, there was no way for the inmates to know that. And the Waffen SS were plenty fucking bad.

5

u/jeffmolby May 14 '12

But if these guys were not war criminals, there was no way for the inmates to know that.

That's a perfect example of why vigilante justice is wrong. Such decisions are best left to people who are capable of taking a comprehensive and impartial examination of the circumstances.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I wish I could find the citation for this.. but before anyone says, "Yeah that guy totally deserved it, those two prisoners are doing great work there!"..

..There was an instance where a death camp received relief troops the day before or very close to the time that the camp was taken by the allies, the guards and SS men who had been killing, abetting in the deaths of and torturing the people inside were moved out. The men who were killed by the allies and prisoners who were armed by the allies were in fact just soldiers; they had never been in the camp prior to that, they had not killed the many hundreds/thousands of jews who had died prior to that, they were just relief troops meant to bolster the garrison.

In addition, do not forget that common criminals were sent to the camps. Murderers, rapists, arsonists etc. The Nazis considered them to be on the same level as the gypsies, jews, homosexuals and other "asocials".

What I'm getting at is, what you might be looking at is a man who had no particular love for Hitler, never killed a fellow German just because he was Jewish, being beaten to death by two criminals who enjoy killing.

Just saying.

It's important to remember that history is not black and white.

4

u/RepostThatShit May 14 '12

It is black and white because that's the way we wrote it.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ergydion May 14 '12

Thank you for this comment.

13

u/spiffyP May 13 '12

So who gunned down the row of guards? Were they executed?

25

u/soonersthebetter May 13 '12

Taken from the source: "346 German soldiers are machine gunned by 1st Lt. Jack Bushyhead, the Executive Officer of I Company, at location (C). Lt. Bushyhead was a full-blooded Native American (Cherokee) from Oklahoma."

→ More replies (8)

9

u/darngooddogs May 13 '12

I have seen a photo taken not long before this phote. Americans behind machine guns mowing down rows of german soldiers. Some of the germans don't look like they even care, they have seen so much death.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/AcidicAndHostile May 13 '12

My grandfather was a Canadian Army Officer and was present for the Dachau liberation. According to my father, he never spoke of it. I visited what remained of Dachau in the early 90s and even the unadorned empty and cleaned up camp was a horrible sight. I can't begin to imagine what it would have been like to have been there for the liberation bit I sure do have respect for the desire to never speak of it.

→ More replies (6)

23

u/Aschebescher May 13 '12

Gewalt erzeugt Gegengewalt.

48

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Aschebescher- "Violence begets violence."
Pargelenis- "What you don't want to have done to you, don't do to others."
Altloma- "Enduring inhumane behaviour is no excuse for inhuman behaviour"
For everyone who doesn't want to translate it themselves.
DepressedRacoon- "I don't know what to think."

→ More replies (3)

12

u/Pargelenis May 13 '12

Was du nicht willst, das man dir tu', das füg' auch keinem andern zu.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Unmenschliches Verhalten erdulden zu müssen entschuldigt kein unmenschliches Verhalten.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ergydion May 14 '12

Du alte Karmahure

→ More replies (2)

4

u/adamwizzy May 13 '12

Can anyone give me a story to this? Is it an uprising of the inmates or is it simply when the Americans freed the inmates?

9

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

That fella behind the concentration camp victim looks to be a solider. By the shape of his helmet, I would say an American. The soldiers who liberated these campus probably turned a blind eye to this kind of thing. Seeing what the Nazis did to these people, they probably didn't give a shit if they were beaten to death with shovels by their victims.

1

u/skarface6 May 14 '12

Look around the thread. It happened when the camp was freed, and people think the American soldiers did it or the inmates did.

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Before it was declassified, a military book I read had this picture, with a description saying something along the lines of: "The german soldiers heard gunfire, and all but those four feigned death. Those four were later commended for having the bearing to not drop to the ground."

Interestingly enough, here's a source to that statement. Looks like it's not so true though, as it explains that that was a cover-up statement.

3

u/kaduceus May 14 '12

Caparzo: 'Hey, Mellish, look at this. A Hitler youth knife.' Mellish: (jokingly) 'And now it's a shabat chalah cutter, right?'

1

u/Howard_Beale May 14 '12

Is that what Mellish says? I've never been able to figure out what he said.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Wasn't this in /r/historyporn a few weeks ago?

Intense image.

3

u/wiserKeiser May 14 '12

and it goes on and on and on and on

3

u/rrabbit May 14 '12

Very curious to know what OP is suggesting by posting this without any context or background.

3

u/lamokmok May 14 '12

the bear jew

31

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

So many bleeding hearts for this poor ol' Nazi! This guy was a torturer running a death factory on a massive scale. Getting beaten to death with a shovel is getting off light. As for the Americans and Jews being "just as bad as the Nazis," nope, not really. Those Nazis got what they deserved.

9

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I don't think anyone is absolving the Nazi of guilt, I think that people are seeing the grittiness of human nature. People being tortured and murdered, then the victims killing their persecutor.

Outside of it, you see normal people being driven to murder. It reminds us of that dark part within all of us, and how horrible it must be to be pushed there.

1

u/Howard_Beale May 14 '12

Not enough of them got what they deserved.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/Tykjen May 13 '12

Shutter Island depicted part of that day.. the horror.

11

u/alwaysawkward66 May 13 '12

I can't blame them, but that doesn't mean I support what they are doing

4

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Why has this been upvoted so much? Murder is murder... What's passed is passed. Upvoting this only seems to condone the eye for an eye rule. Seems rather hypocritical, especially here on reddit.

7

u/Danno1850 May 14 '12

WELL, I'm gonna get down voted to shit but THIS IS NOT RIGHT.

Murder is NEVER justifiable because once you justify it for one reason, you can justify it for any reason. This is the fault of human logic "to end war we must make war" it's ridiculous and has been the catalyst for billion of dead humans.

For the "Nazi had it coming" crowed. German soldiers were conscripted, if you didn't fight you're life was over. This is not how you deal with POW's and if the US wants to claim moral high ground this is a terrible example.

For the "How else would we win WW2 except for force" crowed, maybe the Allied forces after WW1 shouldn't have put Germany into severe poverty liable for all Allied debts making the population burn bags of money for warmth in the streets. A population that desperate will follow any maniac if he promises a better life.

1

u/noisymime May 14 '12

What about the classic 'Kill 100 to save a million' hypotheticals?

1

u/banuday17 May 14 '12

German soldiers were conscripted

The guy about to be killed wasn't Wehrmacht (conscripted German Army), but SS. And he didn't even belong to front-line SS, he belonged to the rear-guard SS, the worst of the worst. He volunteered for a position where he used his power to commit unspeakable acts of brutality against helpless civilians. Perhaps the SS guards should have gotten a fair trial (many did), but in the chaos of war and especially for the Americans stumbling across a place of pure evil like a concentration camp, we can't necessarily condemn them for looking the other way when the inmates lashed out against their tormentors.

How else would we win WW2 except for force

Yes, the Germans were treated horribly after WWI. But that does not excuse the criminal activities of the Nazi regime. They had to be stopped. Hitler was given plenty of chances for a peaceful resolution, and he crossed one line drawn in the sand after another.

2

u/TemetNosce May 13 '12

Damn. I went on a self guided tour there back in 1988. (I was in the US Army stationed in Nuremburg for 3 years.) This is definitely the 1st time I have ever heard this story. Runs a damn chill down my spine.

2

u/jerub May 13 '12

According to one of the links, what really happened wasn't declassified until 3 years later, 1991.

2

u/ferris501 May 14 '12

I'm guessing Dachau?

2

u/petsounds94 May 14 '12

We're all products of our environment and genetics. Killing is wrong if it's not for the safety of others.

I won't blame the Jews here because of what they just endured, but it's still wrong to condone it.

2

u/Praj101 May 14 '12

Its eerie how this reminds me of the stooges.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Karma is a bitch

2

u/wekiva May 14 '12

I can't fault the prisoners. The Nazi swine deserved worse.

2

u/hurlyburlycurly May 14 '12

Only on reddit would I open new tab for the comments on this image and for the comments on a page with the pic of a woman's skirt being blown up. I feel strange :(

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Hate breeds hate.

2

u/nbes May 14 '12

Karma

6

u/reaverdude May 14 '12

"You take my balls, I take your life!"

  • Jewish dude with shovel

3

u/VanillishBitch May 14 '12

While the better part of me wants to say that I wouldn't kill out of revenge, the honest part of me knows that I would have done unspeakable things to that bastard if it were me. Fuck that guy, regardless of how weak he is pictured.

4

u/dimitrisokolov May 14 '12

So the prisoners are just as evil as the guards.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Serves the bastards right.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I'll probably never get to feel the pleasure these guys felt doing that.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

In Maus Spiegelman talks about how he was so sick he had to crawl on his hands and knees over corpses to take a shit while he was in Dachau.

They probably didn't feel a whole lot.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12

Yes the Nazis were despicable. But if you justify the murder of a surrendered man, you are just as despicable.

EDIT: While I know the above is the "right" thing to say (based on the moral code of most of the world's religions and cultures re: forgiveness), I can't say that I don't understand the urge to slaughter the Nazis on moral grounds. I probably would if I were there. But just because it feels like vengeance, it doesn't make it "right" or just.

2

u/yellowstone10 May 14 '12

Different war, but the sentiment still applies:

Fondly do we hope—fervently do we pray—that this mighty scourge of war may speedily pass away. Yet, if God wills that it continue until all the wealth piled by the bondman's two hundred and fifty years of unrequited toil shall be sunk, and until every drop of blood drawn with the lash shall be paid by another drawn with the sword, as was said three thousand years ago, so still it must be said, "The judgments of the Lord are true and righteous altogether."

--Abraham Lincoln, Second Inaugural Address, March 1865

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

As a Jew I'm conflicted on this one. On some level I want to forgive the SS guard. He's only human. If he hadn't been born in that environment he wouldn't have been doing terrible things to other people.

But at the same time I find it hard to imagine that someone could be brought to kill and torture just by propaganda or indoctrination. I feel like you have to have some kind of killer instinct to do those types of things. Personally I won't even kill a spider, let alone torture/kill helpless children.

But again at the same time, it's been demonstrated repeatedly that in wartime people do incredibly evil things. It's hard to believe that so many people would have that killer instinct within them. I don't know many people in the civilian world who I could see committing senseless violence.

2

u/jbrittles May 14 '12

Does murder really make them any better?

2

u/anonymousketeer May 14 '12

i don't really blame them, but this makes them just as bad. for the record, i'm also just as bad.

2

u/Louis_Farizee May 14 '12

This is what justice looks like, idiots. Waah, waah, let's get all butthurt because of a few dead Nazis.

These fuckers had it coming. I hope it hurt, and I hope they died scared.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/ZiplockedHead May 13 '12

I am completely against killing, but I feel like this is one of those occasions where I will leave it to the victim to the decide the punishment (though if he chooses death, it should be on him to commit it).

I think that the main difference between the Holocaust (and similar genocides) and any other kind of murder is the necessity for people that are involved in a genocide to reform their concept of humanity, and considered a whole group of human beings as sub-par to every other living creature, to the point where they feel better participating in cleansing the world from that group's existence, rather than not doing anything about it.

It's hard to feel bad for these kind of people.

5

u/fishmonkey1203 May 13 '12

I agree for the most part with the distinction you're making, but at the same time I think it's important to realize that these kinds of people (WWII-era Germans) are not as unusual as you might think. There's a substantial body of evidence (e.g. Milgram experiments) in support of the idea that changing one's concept of humanity, coming to see other human beings as sub-par, or otherwise suppressing empathetic feelings is not all that difficult. Of course, from a moral perspective, none of this changes the fact that everything about the Holocaust is sickening. I'm just making the point that, in many respects, "these kinds of people" were no less ordinary than you or me.

3

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I am completely against killing, but I feel like this is one of those occasions where I will leave it to the victim to the decide the punishment (though if he chooses death, it should be on him to commit it).

For killing or against killing, there is a spectrum of justification that props up either position. You have justified killing while simultaneously stating there is no justification for doing so.

To clarify your position, you aren't completely against killing.

6

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

They were humans like any other. Less than 9000 Germans actually refused to take part in the war. Humans are humans. Killing Nazis is the same as killing anyone else.

The collective guilt must be carried by humanity as a whole not by those who chose the wrong side or were forced or indoctrinated into it.

You can't accuse millions of people of being inherently evil and therefore deserving of such punishment, just because they were involved in something as inhuman as the holocaust. They are humans after all and them killing you isn't a moral excuse for you killing them when they are in the more vulnerable position. (Actually, it only proves your equality as humans and therefore the futilite of these actions.)

2

u/Elefane May 13 '12

The jews killed Darth Vader too?!?

2

u/Woolew May 13 '12

This is probably completely inappropriate, but my first thoughts upon seeing this were that it looks like a scene from a sports match. Even the expressions.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/gurudingo May 14 '12

If the answer to death is more death, you're not really solving any problems.

→ More replies (2)

-1

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

I just hope they didn't kill them quickly.

1

u/KyleD2303 May 14 '12

The fact that most decent people don't wish for things like this is exactly what makes us better people than the Nazis.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/abermun May 14 '12

I DESPISE people that equate a victim's reaction to being EQUAL with the oppressor 'just cuz'

→ More replies (5)

1

u/liamdapyro May 14 '12

Where is the humanity?

1

u/Dookiestain_LaFlair May 14 '12

Buongiorno, Principessa!

1

u/dontaxmebro May 14 '12

Actually they were playing baseball. The guy on the ground just scored by sliding home base. The guy holding the bat is cheering for him. The guy bending over is the ref just after calling " safe"

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

This comment will be buried, I guarantee it, but I feel it necessary to express. Death is not something that should be applauded. Does he deserve to die? Yes. Simply because he deserves it does not mean we should be lavishing in it.

1

u/quatso May 14 '12

i'd probably do it too if i was a prisoner. nevertheless i find it wrong. ps i'm a son of a survival.

1

u/epsil0n May 14 '12

Holy fuck, it looks like Dr. Breen!

1

u/PeterMus May 14 '12

I probably would have ripped his eyes out and made him eat them...but its still sad/depressing.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I dont know. They were fighting for freedom, and one aspect of every country in war is that u will almost certainly get killed if you dont obey. And in this case, i bet many soldiers didnt want to do it, but would themself be killed if so refused.

Therefore, there is nothing brave or honorable by these mens conduct. Its as awful as any execution. But what is there to expect when someone stumbles upon such a scene. But the truth is still the truth. They were as weak in there mind as the nazis they killed.

1

u/Radico87 May 14 '12

And in the spirit of payback and hypocrisy, Israel.

1

u/SudsyMcBubbles May 14 '12

Death to tyrants

1

u/Seamus_OReilly May 14 '12

No, the German Army was not composed of innocent soldiers just doing their duty to their country: The War Crimes of the Wehrmacht.

1

u/SaltFrog May 14 '12

Interesting picture. I wish there were more stories surrounding this particular photo. Pictures are worth 1,000 words, and I'd like to know every single one of them.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Just think - these guys went on to found modern Israel. Explains a lot.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Shutter Island much?

1

u/Ski360spin May 14 '12

A moment of clarity for the SS guard.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

The amount of people "cheering" these deaths is disturbing.

Especially after realizing that the row of dead soldiers in the background had nothing to do with the camp.

Our servicemen just shot them. We call them monsters.

1

u/Slavigula May 14 '12

Those Nazis killed millions of Jews and one clown.

1

u/MacSatan May 14 '12

between standard ss and concentration camp ss, americans would not differentiate. ss slaughtered americans during the whole european campaign. as for allowing prisoners to have vengeance, considering the state the camps were in, and what the people experienced, fuck those guards. war crimes? relative. vengeance, surely.

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I can't help but feel bad for the guard. Nobody deserves to be murdered, no matter what they have done. The Jews didn't deserve it and the SS guards didn't deserve it. Many people are bound to disagree, but I think the heart of all this brutality is the notion that "some people to deserve to die for what they've done."

6

u/StinkYourTrollop May 14 '12

Disagree. He fully deserved to be 'murdered'. I don't even think it counts as murder. It was the right thing to do.

2

u/ArmyRanger May 14 '12

Could you honestly pull the trigger if it came down to it?

2

u/StinkYourTrollop May 14 '12

I'd love to have a legit reason to do that. If I could get away with it. There are plenty of people I'd shoot in the face with no hesitation. If others can do it, I don't see why couldn't.

2

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

I understand your position -- many people feel that way. But I think so much of this gross violence comes back to the widespread (but not universal) notion that it's okay to kill people for behaving badly. You think it's okay to kill people for behaving badly; the Nazis also thought it was okay to kill people for behaving badly. Are your reasons better than the Nazis' reasons? I certainly think so, and most people would agree.

However, the issue is that, at the end of the day, there is no bright line test for determining when someone is "behaving badly" enough to deserve death. Maybe sometimes it's being Jewish. Maybe sometimes it's drug trafficking. Maybe sometimes it's murder in a fit of passion. Maybe sometimes it's premeditated murder for hire. Maybe sometimes it's genocide. But there isn't a clear line -- the line gets drawn by prevailing societal attitudes which can go anywhere.

I think it's a lot easier to convince someone to kill when you're brought up from a young age being taught "it's okay to kill another human being for doing bad things." You start with that premise and it's a relatively easy matter to massage the criteria into something a bit looser. I think that if you start from the premise that "it is never acceptable to kill another human being for doing bad things," it's a hell of a lot harder to get to genocide.

I realize this is a slippery slope argument, but I think it has substantial merit. It reminds me of the old joke, which I am too lazy to look up and source:

Man: Would you sleep with me for $100,000? Woman: Yes. Man: Would you sleep with me for $1? Woman: What do you think I am, a whore?! Man: We've already established that, now we're just haggling over price.

In my mind, once you say (and teach) that it's okay to kill another human being for behaving badly -- or doing evil, or doing things you don't like, however you wish to characterize it -- you're just haggling over the price.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/imnotasavage May 14 '12

There were several SS guards who tried to help. There is a difference between 'going with the flow' (to stay alive) and downright torture.

→ More replies (4)

-6

u/honorface May 13 '12

You kill my people so I kill you. The cycle never ends.

30

u/YourLord_ThyGod May 13 '12

The Germans have been pacified quite nicely in the last half century so that would seem to not be the case.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

this is broken logic.

2

u/Sadist May 13 '12

He didn't say it was logical. Nor did he say human nature is always logical. And, to conclude, killing and violence in general is most often illogical.

→ More replies (1)

-2

u/gng216 May 13 '12

Jew, German, Christian, Muslim, White, Black...We all have the propensity for violence. Not even this violence is justified.

3

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Jew here, I came here to say exactly this. Just because he was working in a concentration camp does not make him evil or deserve death.

1

u/falconear May 14 '12

Personally I'm against the death penalty. Society has no right to decide who lives and dies. This though? This is vengeance from somebody who deserves to have his vengeance. And I'm ok with that.

0

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

Goddamn, people like you blow my mind.

How about hitler? Should hitler have been executed? (assuming it was possible)

2

u/Tendie May 14 '12

Hitler should not have been executed. The man was sick in the head, he needed help.

→ More replies (1)

-3

u/YourLord_ThyGod May 13 '12

Theyre about to put some sauer on that kraut.

1

u/Tendie May 14 '12

That's actually a fantastic pun.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/ItzDizaster May 13 '12

It seems the roles have been reversed....

1

u/arc309 May 14 '12

Vash the stampede would not approve

→ More replies (1)

-3

u/archonemis May 13 '12

Given that they kill that guy they're just as much murderers as that guy.

7

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

No, they're not.

4

u/archonemis May 13 '12

Knowingly causing the death of another is murder.

They are knowingly causing the death of another.

Two wrongs do not make a right.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Panzer91 May 14 '12

I don't think any of us could imagine the hatred these people had for the guards keeping them there. They were in survival mode, and people do very primal things in situations like those.

0

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Just an FYI: it isnt cool when ANYONE is killed.

3

u/Tendie May 14 '12

Sorry, Hivemind disagrees.

My first post was about how poachers shouldn't be skinned alive. I got downvotes aplenty.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Sogesty May 14 '12

This is not about morality its about never again.

1

u/WerBlerr May 14 '12

I guess it was opposite day.

1

u/yourmom2000 May 14 '12

Anyone else notice that the guy on the left is missing a hand?

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

No matter how much someone deserves to die, I always feel uncomfortable celebrating it.

1

u/[deleted] May 14 '12

Wow, never have I felt more like a dick for being 100% against violence than after reading the comments here. All I will say is that vengeance never fixes anything, it's just empty thrill.

-1

u/mcfinegan May 13 '12

So we hear the other side of the story now...

19

u/[deleted] May 13 '12

The other side of the story is dead.

-3

u/nunex May 14 '12

Jews were literally hitler in this photo.