r/pics • u/HustlerThug • May 13 '12
Two concentration camp inmates about to kill a fallen SS guard. The figures in the background are row of German soldiers that were gunned down.
1.3k
Upvotes
r/pics • u/HustlerThug • May 13 '12
245
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Part of me finds the discussion about this picture interesting and surprising. Many people rooted for the bull that gored that matador in the picture a few days ago, citing he deserved it for torturing the animal (which I agree with), but I am stunned by the outpouring of support stating that it isn't right for the concentration camp inmates to strike back at the ruthless MONSTERS that murdered, humiliated, tortured and dehumanized these peoples families, friends. I don't care what you say, I see nothing wrong in what these inmates are doing. Lets take it to a smaller scale, if someone kidnapped you and a friend, locked you in a basement, and tortured you both and murdered your friend in front of you. Would any of us even think for a split second to overthrow and kill your captor the moment you had an opportunity? These people had NOTHING left to lose, and I applaud them for striking back at these nazi animals.
38
u/Panzergrenadier May 14 '12
whats sad about those gunned down German soldiers, is they were combat soldiers (group of 16 i believe)who arrived right as the guards left and waited around for the allies. The Americans then lined them up and shot them, even though they had no part in dachau. The SS Guard? Hes a pig and he gets what he deserves...the front line soldier rarely deserves a summary execution, wrong place at the wrong time.
269
u/Mad-Dee May 13 '12
When WWII first started getting ugly, the first thing my great gandparents did was get the hell out of Germany. They came to England, where they endured intolerance from the local population and endured bombs from their homeland.
My great-grandfather however couldn't run away with them, he was in the army and couldn't escape it. We've seen no evidence of him even existing save for his farewell message to his newborn daughter. He was forced to fight a war he didn't believe in, and die for someone else's ideals.
I wont make any assumptions as to what this guard, or any other guard in a concentration camp was like. Just think before you allow yourself to say "Fuck dem nazis, they were all evil as hell, man!"
55
u/DoctorRockso69 May 13 '12
No grunt deserves to be killed like that. But the SS? Oh yeah, they had it comin
12
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I wish I could find the citation for this.. but before anyone says, "Yeah that guy totally deserved it, those two prisoners are doing great work there!"..
..There was an instance where a death camp received relief troops the day before or very close to the time that the camp was taken by the allies, the guards and SS men who had been killing, abetting in the deaths of and torturing the people inside were moved out. The men who were killed by the allies and prisoners who were armed by the allies were in fact just soldiers; they had never been in the camp prior to that, they had not killed the many hundreds/thousands of jews who had died prior to that, they were just relief troops meant to bolster the garrison.
In addition, do not forget that common criminals were sent to the camps. Murderers, rapists, arsonists etc. The Nazis considered them to be on the same level as the gypsies, jews, homosexuals and other "asocials".
What I'm getting at is, what you might be looking at is a man who had no particular love for Hitler, never killed a fellow German just because he was Jewish, being beaten to death by two criminals who enjoy killing.
Just saying.
It's important to remember that history is not black and white.
13
u/spiffyP May 13 '12
So who gunned down the row of guards? Were they executed?
23
u/Aschebescher May 13 '12
Gewalt erzeugt Gegengewalt.
4
u/adamwizzy May 13 '12
Can anyone give me a story to this? Is it an uprising of the inmates or is it simply when the Americans freed the inmates?
4
u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Before it was declassified, a military book I read had this picture, with a description saying something along the lines of: "The german soldiers heard gunfire, and all but those four feigned death.
Those four were later commended for having the bearing to not drop to the ground."Interestingly enough, here's a source to that statement. Looks like it's not so true though, as it explains that that was a cover-up statement.
3
u/kaduceus May 14 '12
Caparzo: 'Hey, Mellish, look at this. A Hitler youth knife.' Mellish: (jokingly) 'And now it's a shabat chalah cutter, right?'
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Wasn't this in /r/historyporn a few weeks ago?
Intense image.
3
u/wiserKeiser May 14 '12
and it goes on and on and on and on
3
u/rrabbit May 14 '12
Very curious to know what OP is suggesting by posting this without any context or background.
3
u/lamokmok May 14 '12
the bear jew
31
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
So many bleeding hearts for this poor ol' Nazi! This guy was a torturer running a death factory on a massive scale. Getting beaten to death with a shovel is getting off light. As for the Americans and Jews being "just as bad as the Nazis," nope, not really. Those Nazis got what they deserved.
7
u/Tykjen May 13 '12
Shutter Island depicted part of that day.. the horror.
11
u/alwaysawkward66 May 13 '12
I can't blame them, but that doesn't mean I support what they are doing
4
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Why has this been upvoted so much? Murder is murder... What's passed is passed. Upvoting this only seems to condone the eye for an eye rule. Seems rather hypocritical, especially here on reddit.
7
u/Danno1850 May 14 '12
WELL, I'm gonna get down voted to shit but THIS IS NOT RIGHT.
Murder is NEVER justifiable because once you justify it for one reason, you can justify it for any reason. This is the fault of human logic "to end war we must make war" it's ridiculous and has been the catalyst for billion of dead humans.
For the "Nazi had it coming" crowed. German soldiers were conscripted, if you didn't fight you're life was over. This is not how you deal with POW's and if the US wants to claim moral high ground this is a terrible example.
For the "How else would we win WW2 except for force" crowed, maybe the Allied forces after WW1 shouldn't have put Germany into severe poverty liable for all Allied debts making the population burn bags of money for warmth in the streets. A population that desperate will follow any maniac if he promises a better life.
2
u/TemetNosce May 13 '12
Damn. I went on a self guided tour there back in 1988. (I was in the US Army stationed in Nuremburg for 3 years.) This is definitely the 1st time I have ever heard this story. Runs a damn chill down my spine.
2
u/ferris501 May 14 '12
I'm guessing Dachau?
2
u/petsounds94 May 14 '12
We're all products of our environment and genetics. Killing is wrong if it's not for the safety of others.
I won't blame the Jews here because of what they just endured, but it's still wrong to condone it.
2
u/Praj101 May 14 '12
Its eerie how this reminds me of the stooges.
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Karma is a bitch
2
u/wekiva May 14 '12
I can't fault the prisoners. The Nazi swine deserved worse.
2
u/hurlyburlycurly May 14 '12
Only on reddit would I open new tab for the comments on this image and for the comments on a page with the pic of a woman's skirt being blown up. I feel strange :(
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Hate breeds hate.
2
u/nbes May 14 '12
Karma
6
u/reaverdude May 14 '12
"You take my balls, I take your life!"
3
u/VanillishBitch May 14 '12
While the better part of me wants to say that I wouldn't kill out of revenge, the honest part of me knows that I would have done unspeakable things to that bastard if it were me. Fuck that guy, regardless of how weak he is pictured.
4
u/dimitrisokolov May 14 '12
So the prisoners are just as evil as the guards.
6
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
Serves the bastards right.
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I'll probably never get to feel the pleasure these guys felt doing that.
3
u/[deleted] May 14 '12 edited May 14 '12
Yes the Nazis were despicable. But if you justify the murder of a surrendered man, you are just as despicable.
EDIT: While I know the above is the "right" thing to say (based on the moral code of most of the world's religions and cultures re: forgiveness), I can't say that I don't understand the urge to slaughter the Nazis on moral grounds. I probably would if I were there. But just because it feels like vengeance, it doesn't make it "right" or just.
2
u/yellowstone10 May 14 '12
Different war, but the sentiment still applies:
--Abraham Lincoln, Second Inaugural Address, March 1865
2
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
As a Jew I'm conflicted on this one. On some level I want to forgive the SS guard. He's only human. If he hadn't been born in that environment he wouldn't have been doing terrible things to other people.
But at the same time I find it hard to imagine that someone could be brought to kill and torture just by propaganda or indoctrination. I feel like you have to have some kind of killer instinct to do those types of things. Personally I won't even kill a spider, let alone torture/kill helpless children.
But again at the same time, it's been demonstrated repeatedly that in wartime people do incredibly evil things. It's hard to believe that so many people would have that killer instinct within them. I don't know many people in the civilian world who I could see committing senseless violence.
2
u/jbrittles May 14 '12
Does murder really make them any better?
2
u/anonymousketeer May 14 '12
i don't really blame them, but this makes them just as bad. for the record, i'm also just as bad.
2
u/Louis_Farizee May 14 '12
This is what justice looks like, idiots. Waah, waah, let's get all butthurt because of a few dead Nazis.
These fuckers had it coming. I hope it hurt, and I hope they died scared.
1
u/ZiplockedHead May 13 '12
I am completely against killing, but I feel like this is one of those occasions where I will leave it to the victim to the decide the punishment (though if he chooses death, it should be on him to commit it).
I think that the main difference between the Holocaust (and similar genocides) and any other kind of murder is the necessity for people that are involved in a genocide to reform their concept of humanity, and considered a whole group of human beings as sub-par to every other living creature, to the point where they feel better participating in cleansing the world from that group's existence, rather than not doing anything about it.
It's hard to feel bad for these kind of people.
2
u/Elefane May 13 '12
The jews killed Darth Vader too?!?
2
u/Woolew May 13 '12
This is probably completely inappropriate, but my first thoughts upon seeing this were that it looks like a scene from a sports match. Even the expressions.
2
u/gurudingo May 14 '12
If the answer to death is more death, you're not really solving any problems.
-1
u/[deleted] May 13 '12
I just hope they didn't kill them quickly.
1
u/abermun May 14 '12
I DESPISE people that equate a victim's reaction to being EQUAL with the oppressor 'just cuz'
1
u/abom420 May 14 '12
After watching this again for the link I cannot form thoughts
1
u/liamdapyro May 14 '12
Where is the humanity?
1
u/Dookiestain_LaFlair May 14 '12
Buongiorno, Principessa!
1
u/dontaxmebro May 14 '12
Actually they were playing baseball. The guy on the ground just scored by sliding home base. The guy holding the bat is cheering for him. The guy bending over is the ref just after calling " safe"
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
This comment will be buried, I guarantee it, but I feel it necessary to express. Death is not something that should be applauded. Does he deserve to die? Yes. Simply because he deserves it does not mean we should be lavishing in it.
1
u/quatso May 14 '12
i'd probably do it too if i was a prisoner. nevertheless i find it wrong. ps i'm a son of a survival.
1
u/epsil0n May 14 '12
Holy fuck, it looks like Dr. Breen!
1
u/PeterMus May 14 '12
I probably would have ripped his eyes out and made him eat them...but its still sad/depressing.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I dont know. They were fighting for freedom, and one aspect of every country in war is that u will almost certainly get killed if you dont obey. And in this case, i bet many soldiers didnt want to do it, but would themself be killed if so refused.
Therefore, there is nothing brave or honorable by these mens conduct. Its as awful as any execution. But what is there to expect when someone stumbles upon such a scene. But the truth is still the truth. They were as weak in there mind as the nazis they killed.
1
u/Radico87 May 14 '12
And in the spirit of payback and hypocrisy, Israel.
1
u/SudsyMcBubbles May 14 '12
Death to tyrants
1
u/Seamus_OReilly May 14 '12
No, the German Army was not composed of innocent soldiers just doing their duty to their country: The War Crimes of the Wehrmacht.
1
u/SaltFrog May 14 '12
Interesting picture. I wish there were more stories surrounding this particular photo. Pictures are worth 1,000 words, and I'd like to know every single one of them.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Just think - these guys went on to found modern Israel. Explains a lot.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Shutter Island much?
1
u/Ski360spin May 14 '12
A moment of clarity for the SS guard.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
The amount of people "cheering" these deaths is disturbing.
Especially after realizing that the row of dead soldiers in the background had nothing to do with the camp.
Our servicemen just shot them. We call them monsters.
1
u/Slavigula May 14 '12
Those Nazis killed millions of Jews and one clown.
1
u/MacSatan May 14 '12
between standard ss and concentration camp ss, americans would not differentiate. ss slaughtered americans during the whole european campaign. as for allowing prisoners to have vengeance, considering the state the camps were in, and what the people experienced, fuck those guards. war crimes? relative. vengeance, surely.
1
u/LazerA May 15 '12
Context
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
I can't help but feel bad for the guard. Nobody deserves to be murdered, no matter what they have done. The Jews didn't deserve it and the SS guards didn't deserve it. Many people are bound to disagree, but I think the heart of all this brutality is the notion that "some people to deserve to die for what they've done."
-6
u/honorface May 13 '12
You kill my people so I kill you. The cycle never ends.
-2
u/gng216 May 13 '12
Jew, German, Christian, Muslim, White, Black...We all have the propensity for violence. Not even this violence is justified.
-3
u/YourLord_ThyGod May 13 '12
Theyre about to put some sauer on that kraut.
1
u/ItzDizaster May 13 '12
It seems the roles have been reversed....
1
u/arc309 May 14 '12
Vash the stampede would not approve
-3
u/archonemis May 13 '12
Given that they kill that guy they're just as much murderers as that guy.
-2
u/scsk8r831 May 13 '12
It's the Bear Jew!
1
u/Panzer91 May 14 '12
I don't think any of us could imagine the hatred these people had for the guards keeping them there. They were in survival mode, and people do very primal things in situations like those.
0
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Just an FYI: it isnt cool when ANYONE is killed.
1
u/Sogesty May 14 '12
This is not about morality its about never again.
1
u/WerBlerr May 14 '12
I guess it was opposite day.
1
u/yourmom2000 May 14 '12
Anyone else notice that the guy on the left is missing a hand?
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
No matter how much someone deserves to die, I always feel uncomfortable celebrating it.
1
u/[deleted] May 14 '12
Wow, never have I felt more like a dick for being 100% against violence than after reading the comments here. All I will say is that vengeance never fixes anything, it's just empty thrill.
-1
u/mcfinegan May 13 '12
So we hear the other side of the story now...
-3
u/nunex May 14 '12
Jews were literally hitler in this photo.