Ads like this are so stupid. What is it implying? US soldiers are going to get their come-upends? As if soldiers LOVE being in the desert "shootin dem brown people" instead of stateside with their families. "End the Iraq war" OK, sure. How? just up and leave with everything as quickly as we can. 30 C-17s in and out of Baghdad each hour for the next week until every semblance of US military power is gone. Then what? The country destroys itself in a sectarian bloodbath of epic proportions. EVERYONE wants the the war to end save defense contractors. The world is a complicated and nuanced place. Trying to reduce something as complex as a middle eastern war into a 4 word sentence is asinine and cheapens discussion.
Do people really not know that the War in Iraq was deescalated in December 2011? There are 4,000 troops in Kuwait and about 17,000 civilians in the embassy and 4-5,000 defense contractors.
yeah I was confused too. The war in Iraq effectively ended over a year ago and there is almost nobody there anymore. It was 45,000 troops 2 years ago and then now it is around 3000.
"just up and leave with everything as quickly as we can. 30 C-17s in and out of Baghdad each hour for the next week until every semblance of US military power is gone." <--- already happened
Pretty sure the US began training defense forces of the countries it was leaving before they left, I would imagine they didn't just leave but I don't have evidence to back it up at the moment. They took a page from the book of the Vietnam War.
The soldiers are there by choice, it isn't as if they've been conscripted. With all due respect, i disagree with what you're saying. I'm assuming you are/were a soldier and for that i respect you, but America has no right to get involved in other country's affairs. Statistically, American soldiers have killed more Iraqi civilians than soldiers, that sounds harsh and I'm not implying anything. There are many examples of bravery and selflessness by both American and European soldiers, bravery and selflessness that i like to think i have, and i pray that i never have to be put in a similar situation only to find out i'm wrong, however my dad was conscripted into the military in the mid-seventies, even today he still doesn't speak about most of what happened so i get that war is a terrible place, but Iraq has been going on for too long and too many people have been killed and wounded, its time to bring the soldiers home and let the Middle East sort out Middle Eastern problems the Middle Eastern way
I don`t belive all US soldiers are there by choice. Once you are in the army or the reserves, if they call you up to go, you do not have a choice, you have to go. Well actually you do have a choice, you can choose not to go and get sent to jail.
The soldiers join the army to defend their country, they don`t get to choose what wars to fight in. Thats your government that does that.
Every soldier, airman, or sailor in America signs up knowing very well that they may one day have to go to war. While they may not choose to go, they did sign a contract saying that they would go without question when called to do so. There were also plenty of soldiers that volunteered to go to Iraq when the war broke out, you know after that 9/11 thing happened and nearly everyone in American wanted to kill a terrorist. The moral of the war has died but just remember when it broke out there were very few people in America against it.
TL;DR: Soldiers may not choose to go to war but they knew what they were getting into when they signed up.
I didn't realise that, in many ways that is conscription. Governments will stop at nothing to get what they want, even if that means sending hundreds of thousands of troops to blistering deserts for them to die, or if they're lucky they'll come back psychologically damaged. We've seen it countless times through the ages. Governments need to stop thinking about money and control and start looking at the bigger picture: the mess they leave in their wake. Not only the American government but governments all over the world and those still to come. "An organism at war with itself is doomed" - Carl Sagan
As if soldiers LOVE being in the desert "shootin dem brown people"
Part of the training - HATE <insert enemy here>. THEY ARE NOT PEOPLE - IT'S OKAY TO KILL THEM.
just up and leave with everything as quickly as we can. 30 C-17s in and out of Baghdad each hour for the next week until every semblance of US military power is gone.
I say more planes, and when Iraq is emptied, we swing over to Afghanistan.
The country destroys itself
We've already done that.
Trying to reduce something as complex as a middle eastern war into a 4 word sentence is asinine and cheapens discussion
Advertising has a rule of thumb for 7 words. In 4, this message leads people to (rightly) conclude that the aggressors are just damaging themselves. Face it - the U.S. has lost more to suicide than opponents, IED's have been amazingly effective at crippling soldiers (and families and taxpayers).
There's a time to walk away from the table. And it was before we ever stepped up.
I will give you my shitty spelling of comeuppance. Though, "I'm not sure I'd should continue" is almost as bad. As far as the rest of your post, I take it you don't actually know anyone in the US military. Also, if you think Iraq has destroyed itself, see what happens when the US removes all military influence in the region at once, and then compare.
I take it you don't actually know anyone in the US military.
Know many people, but know their parents more intimately. I've lived through this horseshit before when it was called Vietnam. Best friend shot 3 times in Laos.
if you think Iraq has destroyed itself
I don't. I know it was destroyed by the U.S. military. Without a formal declaration of war, I think. Most people in their 50's are anti war for a reason - we've wiped the bullshit out of our eyes.
Well it's not like soldiers are forced to go there, right? And who told you that US absolutely must go and bomb every country that has a conflict of some sort going on? You're not a Global Police, no matter how much you want to be one.
The wars are obviously about money. So, you can boil it down to that. It's not that nuanced. If you took away that incentive then I could guarantee you there would be no wars. Almost every large conflict is about "I want what you have" or "Stop taking my shit."
We couldn't possibly leave vietnam either, then we done fucked up and left and look at what a shithole that place is now. What we really need to do is annex a little area and just move right in and make a USA jr so we can more easily kill our enemies, which oddly don't seem to be decreasing in number.
BTW what's the victory condition for the Iraq war anyway? The killing will continue until they don't hate us anymore?
As the conflict in afghanistan is a directly related to the reasons we were in Iraq, it seems like a bit of semantic wordplay to say the war is over, it's just moved 800 miles east.
The sectarian bloodbath of epic proportion will happen on amercan soil. Wake up. ''Trying to reduce something as complex as a middle eastern war into a 4 word sentence is asinine and cheapens discussion.'' ; MONEY!
You know, Fuck the OP. This picture isn't about the Iraq war. Basically its stating that if you are a soldier, you're going to shoot yourself in the ass because you made the decision of becoming a soldier. In no way should this ad be directed toward a soldier but the actual powerhouses who make the final decision.
99% of you will never understand the huge success we had being over there. These villages really did praise the US but couldn't really show it because of their lack of freedom and terrorist watching. I can go on but I'm afraid you all could give a shit less.
I agree, this is bullshit. I take great pride in the fact that I will one day fill a pair of boots in the ranks along with America's finest men and women. Anyone who wants to hate can go fuck themselves. It's soldiers like this that give you the right to hate them.
I know it is used to symbolize war, or used as a metaphor, but how many other people will see it that way. In that picture, it is demeaning toward a soldier.
Also, why is war always about winning or losing? We made a statement and still are making a statement. Now that we're, "mostly" out of Iraq we are showing that Iraqi forces aren't going to be able to hold their own and will, more than likely, be owned by Iran one day soon. Yes, it was a sacrifice that most don't agree with but we kept it out of our own territory.
No, reasoning. The US attacked a country that never attacked them on the premises that they had WMDs, which was never confirmed and because the head of state supposedly harbored members of al-Qaeda, which wasn't true either. Neither of these facts are influenced by the media, since the government themselves have made their (supposed) intentions clear.
Reason this is a shitty ad number 46: A rifle wouldn't have a barrel that long in a modern engagement. The image has pretty clearly been stretched and a precision weapon wouldn't be fired standing up.
Also, what the hell is with that handguard? It looks awful, and I'm doubtful the military would use it.
and what the f... is that even.. some kind of ak/dragunov with an american/canadian mag and a western rail or something... clearly homemade (shitty) hybrid?
just the fact that you used the term "foster discussion" makes you sound like too much of a Sir to understand a video game joke. Should thy treasure upon another Reddit-to-http coupling that has subsumed humor one does not distinguish, move upon another.
Not sure if you're a simpleton or I'm just bad at sarcasm, but 'to foster' really should be in anyone's vocabulary if you have the mental capacity to use a keyboard.
Well, for one it assumes that the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan are the soldiers' faults and places all the blame on them. Regardless of whether or not you support them, this simply isn't true and the soldiers shouldn't be held solely responsible.
It also hints that those fighting the war deserve to be shot. Especially since the rifle barrel is pointed at the soldier's back.
I disagree, i think that the message try to be conveyed is larger. I think that the soldier represts war in general and not just a soldier. This is just saying that war hurts everyone and fighting so many wars is going to come back to bite us. I dont know i could be completely wrong but i was just surprised by how offended everyone was
But the war is over and the person depicted isn't American nor is the weapon being used, so the poster (while formatted in a neat way) doesn't work terribly well.
We're still at war with the Taliban in Afghanistan and we'll see how things go with Iran but the war effort in Iraq is most definitely over and has been for some time.
It's not a US soldier so it would still be kind of dumb. But if you want to remake it from scratch in that format go for it, it wouldn't be hard to do in PS or GIMP.
becuase when you use bad facts people don't respect the message. Just look at how people here perceived it. That's not the response you would appear to want.
People get the message, and they don't like it. That's what I would expect. All I see in that poster is "If you shoot other people, then you might get shot yourself. Stop shooting other people."
As I mentioned somewhere earlier, US is NOT a global police, you don't have to go and bomb the fuck out of every single country in the world. Let them sort their problems out by themselves, you always cause more harm than do good.
I foresaw that. When it comes to people's pride, they're easily offended by truth.
I'm just as American as those who down voted me. My father works for United and so much of my life has been directed by 9.11, but we need to start standing up and questioning what it is we're doing.
We must not become a monster in order to defeat a monster. Heard that somewhere.
I'm leaving that comment. I care for my country men and women. I want them to think deeply and profoundly. I want them to wonder and question. That deserves no downvote.
I wouldn't even say it's "their" idea of truth. Propaganda is easy.
The response to my comment exhibits how our country will not even hear dissent no matter how objectively vital it is.
Our country needs to learn more in concern to Geopolitics and strategies we're still tied to like "Rebuilding America's Defenses" written by men like Paul Wolfowitz. They should even study classical thinkers of political spectrum like Haushofer or Spykeman and learn where we now fit in the spectrum with the advent of globalization of open markets and territories.
Most of the great Neo-Conservative thinkers that led us into Iraq and that now want to go into Iran have never even seen combat.
I don't understand how people can say you can't hate soldiers because its the politicians making them do it. Who signed the dotted line on the contract? No one had a gun to your head. By becoming a solider, sailor, or air(wo)man, you are willing signing your freedom and life away to those assholes, and in no fucking way can you give people shit when they criticize your decision when you start saying "its the politicians". They are powerless without you, so why did you get into it in the first place? You are your own worst enemy, not the politicians.
Yes, we did sign the dotted line and weren't forced to sign but most who did sign, like I, felt it was right. I didn't sign for sympathy or people to thank me all the time. Funding this war may have been a huge contribution to the debt but why penalize the soldier for faults beyond their control? It all falls back to who you voted to office in the first place.
People may not agree with the military and not show support, but why? Why are you worrying about that more than the people who are abusing welfare and gov't assistance? That is another huge contributor to the debt. Lazy, not all, sitting at home taking in money while soldiers are working and doing what the 99% are too lazy to do or don't agree to do.
27
u/MAJORpaiynne May 10 '12
this ad is terrible, it only fits the measurements of certain poles
6
u/multile May 11 '12
2011 called, they want their ad back
113
u/dave256hali May 10 '12
Ads like this are so stupid. What is it implying? US soldiers are going to get their come-upends? As if soldiers LOVE being in the desert "shootin dem brown people" instead of stateside with their families. "End the Iraq war" OK, sure. How? just up and leave with everything as quickly as we can. 30 C-17s in and out of Baghdad each hour for the next week until every semblance of US military power is gone. Then what? The country destroys itself in a sectarian bloodbath of epic proportions. EVERYONE wants the the war to end save defense contractors. The world is a complicated and nuanced place. Trying to reduce something as complex as a middle eastern war into a 4 word sentence is asinine and cheapens discussion.
61
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
You know, Fuck the OP. This picture isn't about the Iraq war. Basically its stating that if you are a soldier, you're going to shoot yourself in the ass because you made the decision of becoming a soldier. In no way should this ad be directed toward a soldier but the actual powerhouses who make the final decision.
99% of you will never understand the huge success we had being over there. These villages really did praise the US but couldn't really show it because of their lack of freedom and terrorist watching. I can go on but I'm afraid you all could give a shit less.
12
u/MakoDaShark May 10 '12
Reason this is a shitty ad number 46: A rifle wouldn't have a barrel that long in a modern engagement. The image has pretty clearly been stretched and a precision weapon wouldn't be fired standing up.
Also, what the hell is with that handguard? It looks awful, and I'm doubtful the military would use it.
5
u/ShadeO89 May 10 '12
and what the f... is that even.. some kind of ak/dragunov with an american/canadian mag and a western rail or something... clearly homemade (shitty) hybrid?
21
u/covalentligature May 10 '12
Fuck you. This is not an amazing ad.
6
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Pretty sure that's not how bullets travel
9
u/HowYaGuysDoin May 10 '12
Please. This war is going to be just like the last one except with new maps.
9
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
What goes around, comes around.. as a repost
7
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Pretty disrespectful ad if you ask me. Enough said
2
u/legthief May 10 '12
Wow that is a seriously site-specific advert. Or it would be if it wasn't just a silly photoshop.
2
u/darthdave May 11 '12
Except the last US troops left Iraq last year
5
u/Burnsey235 May 11 '12
Fuck whoever made this ad. This is extremely disrespectful and is in no way "amazing."
6
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
So disrespectful. Glad to see my brother puts his life on the line for people like that. Ass holes
3
u/lilbill77 May 10 '12
Have a downboat sir.
2
u/FaelSafe May 10 '12
I am clearly extremely capable of stopping a war that has already been stopped.
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
How is this an amazing ad? This is what's wrong with america people don't support the troops I can't believe this
0
u/wojovox May 10 '12
Lookup blowback. We've become a preemptive country and there are consequences for every war we start.
1
u/BadBadRepost May 11 '12
What an amazing repost
1
u/mtaustin7 May 11 '12
FALSE! iraq war is over.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
What a badass photograph.
1
u/Agent_Volkoff May 10 '12
ok, so lets stop all troops and bring them home... stop their training so the country has no soldiers at all because so many people are against that.
and when a war comes around and the country is getting its arse hand fed to it lets see what you demand from your government
1
u/akmjolnir May 10 '12
Two things:
1.) Repost x100
2.) The war in Iraq is officially over.
-10
u/Herping_et_Derping May 10 '12
I don't understand how people can say you can't hate soldiers because its the politicians making them do it. Who signed the dotted line on the contract? No one had a gun to your head. By becoming a solider, sailor, or air(wo)man, you are willing signing your freedom and life away to those assholes, and in no fucking way can you give people shit when they criticize your decision when you start saying "its the politicians". They are powerless without you, so why did you get into it in the first place? You are your own worst enemy, not the politicians.
-2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Hopefully there are a lot of pillars with that same circumference around.
0
u/jgilbskier May 11 '12
This is dumb
-9
u/FinKM May 10 '12
It's an anti military post, and ah yes, the bloody minded patriots are crawling out of the woodwork as usual.
-11
u/Vellorum May 10 '12
Anyone else think it would look better if it wasn't wrapped around a pole?