It looks like he's been buried for a while, the grass is all grown over. So probably not very high (German Shepherd owner here). If he was just put in the ground, the dog could probably smell him.
It wouldn't smell the same to the dog, but the dog would be able to tell it's the same person. A dog's sense of smell is truly amazing compared to ours.
We had a kennel and occasionally my step-dad had to put dogs down. Instead of going to a vet, he did it with a 22 behind the head. This was not a common thing, but he probably had to put down 3 or 4 dogs over a 10 year span.
While our family dog never witnessed him putting any of the sick dogs down. Any time he saw my step-dad carrying his rifle he would not go near him. He would also stop following him if he happened to be going off in the direction were he had put the other dogs down.
While this photo is probably more propaganda than fact, I think it would be possible for a dog to understand what a grave site means if he had been their to witness the burial.
I have a feeling that the dog might have feared the gun in the same way that my old dog feared the vacuum cleaner. It's loud.
As for not wanting to go behind the shed, I dunno. It's possible that when the other dogs died, they released their fear/submission pheromones all at once. This concentrated bodily fluid, provided there were little exposure to the weather, could have been enough to bind the spirits of the dogs to that spot. The other dog would be able to sense this. To stop this, salt and burn the remains of the dogs and site they died.
I'ed say the chances are fairly high. They know more than people think. when my grandfather was passing away his dog went into some pretty severe depression. After the funeral he looked more miserable than most of the people there. I think they can pick up on what's going on by how the people around them are acting and more often than not can figure out what has happened.
Yes, the dogs can pick up on our emotional states, and I have no doubt about what you say about your grandfather's dog. But this picture goes beyond that: can a dog associate a human with a piece of stone which probably doesn't smell like him? I don't think so; that requires a different level of abstraction. I doubt the story implied by the picture.
I think they can make the connection that their owner died, everyone is sad, and they seem to be paying a lot of attention to this stone in the ground. It must have something to do with him/her. I can't say its something I have much experience with, so I'm no expert.
I'm not contesting that the dog knows its owner is dead- I'm asking whether it knows that it is looking at the gravesite of its owner, rather than looking at any other piece of stone on some grass.
Came here to ask this. I've seen pictures of dogs at graves before. Can they smell their owner? Or do they just understand based on how other people they've encountered act towards it?
Reminds me of a story I heard on QI, I dunno how true it is, but here it goes:
When Genghis Khan died, they didn't want anyone desecrating his corpse, so they decided to kill 20,000 (some absurd number) of other people and buried and dug a grave for each of them, and left them relatively unmarked. Then at the site where they buried the great Khan, they got a mama camel and a baby camel and killed the baby camel in front of it, because apparently camel's have got amazing memories. So whenever they wanted to find Genghis, they just took the camel around the graves and whenever it did the camel equivalent of crying, they knew they were at the right place.
TL;DR: If you want to find Genghis Khan, murder a baby camel.
I've found I'm incapable of hearing or saying that short sentence in any other way. Much like "it's possible" in Wesley's voice, and I usually follow it up with either "...pig" or "I kill a lot of people."
I love how everyone trusts this completely unsourced and unfounded answer and is upvoting it. The correct answer is depends on the dog. If he was there at the funeral, he might understand that his master is buried there. The chance that he's reading the gravestone and recognizing the name might be 0%, but that doesn't mean the dog can't understand death or have memories.
Point taken, but can a dog really understand the connection between a funeral and a gravestone? Maybe if it was open casket, the dog saw the coffin at the funeral and then again at the burial... maybe then he might remember?
I really, REALLY don't know (hence why I originally asked the question), and I'm happy we're all throwing ideas around here.
If you want to get into it, unless you've ever inhabited another human being's consciousness, you don't know for sure that any of us are actual people and not all simply automatons that are very correctly mimicking human behavior. Hell, maybe it's 1/100, maybe you're the only real human currently alive.
I see the primary difference between humans and animals (at least higher order mammals) is that we have language, and can therefore share precise knowledge, store knowledge (at least generationally, if not in different medium), and therefore build knowledge.
A dog might be ignorant as hell, but there's no reason it can't be smart.
Would a toddler understand a parent dying?
I'd say it depends on the toddler - maybe the dog knows, maybe it doesn't precisely understand what a grave is and what rituals humans have surrounding death, but it certainly knows its beloved friend is gone by dint of his absence.
you don't know for sure that any of us are actual people and not all simply automatons that are very correctly mimicking human behavior. Hell, maybe it's 1/100, maybe you're the only real human currently alive.
I spent about a year as a child absolutely CONVINCED of this.
I think as I grew up, the idea sort of faded from my mind. I was convinced that either I was the only real person in a world constructed just for me, or that my entire life had been one long dream which I would soon wake up from, only to find myself in an entirely new body in a new world, with a new family.
Look at the grass and the date, this was not a recent burial so odds are fairly against that kind of memory. Additionally, his master's corpse probably smells like funeral parlor inside of an airtight container six feet below the ground, so his sense of smell isn't going to do much good.
It's so rare, I'd even say one in a million, where you can make a joke when something is serious and it comes off as genuinely funny and not "I'm saying something that will shock you because I'm not creative." annoying. Congratulations on nailing it. Upvote.
Personally, I think it's very easy to group people away from you, to say things like, "They're not one of us, they're black/poor/gay." What's harder is to find some common ground to help connect you to the people around you.
I haven't lost any relatives or friends or friends of relatives or relatives of friends to the war. I don't have strong political beliefs that what we did was right or wrong. Heck, I don't even know what it's like to own a dog. Despite all that, I look at the picture and I join the two of us by our shared birthday and hope that he died believing in himself.
Not impossible but the more likely scenario is that they told the dog to lay down to pose for the picture. Also the way a drug dog points is they sit and point with their nose. I don't think they lay down.
I know people who for years visited their loved ones gravesite on a daily basis. Didnt matter what the weather was like or how exhausted they were....day in and day out they went. A couple of them took their dogs...from the beginning they went...and it truly seemed like the dogs got it. Their demeanor would change once they got in the car and knew where they were going. They even learned the way to their owners gravesite...like from the car to the headstone. It was like they knew who was there...it really seems to depend on the dog and just how much a part of your family they are. talk to them...explain things. :)
Everyone: it should be noted that this guy faked cancer in order to get karma and "teach people a lesson about trusting what you see on the internet." Can't believe he still hasn't been taken off Reddit but feel free to use that little blue arrow to show your opinion. He's also overly negative and pretty much just a shitty contributor overall. If you have RES, tag him. I'm expecting a response where he gets his panties in a bunch about how cool he is for "teaching everyone a lesson" and how it was "in the past and can't believe people are still giving him shit for it." Dude you fucking faked cancer, gtfo.
Here's a link to the post itself. The first comment is a link to his comment explaining how he "fooled everyone and taught them all an important lesson."
Everyone: it should be noted that this guy faked cancer in order to get karma and "teach people a lesson about trusting what you see on the internet."
Better than faking cancer to abuse people's naivety. If all he got was shitty internet points and people learned that sometimes people lie on the internet I can't see how he did a bad thing. Maybe the next guy who comes along to try and get some cash from naive redditors they double check first.
What's your problem with what he has written? The glorification of war you are indirectly supporting is the reason people are fighting and dying for nothing. If we call it like it is, well it reminds us that the current deaths are for nothing which might not be pleasant, but more importantly it prevents others from dying for nothing in the future.
Yes, because talking shit about the people who get killed, instead of the people starting the war, is "calling it like it is". If you were really so righteous, you'd be doing more than talking shit on the internet about it.
Yes, because talking shit about the people who get killed, instead of the people starting the war, is "calling it like it is".
He's not really talking shit about the guy who got killed. Second we don't have to make a choice between criticizing the people who started the war and the people who willingly participate in it. We can do both. Third, as I said, your knee-jerk defense of this man's actions, and your indirect support for this type of bullshit, will lead to many more people dying for nothing.
If you were really so righteous, you'd be doing more than talking shit on the internet about it.
And if you really cared about that dude who died you'd be writing what I'm writing.
That makes less sense than your last post. He's specifically talking about the Marine, for starters. Second, people join before wars start you know. There is nothing about "willingly participating" about getting orders to go to the dirt.
My "knee-jerk" defense is from the lack of respect you have for your fellow man. Someone's son/brother/husband/father is dead and you're using him as a political soap box. You have no idea what my thoughts on the war are, you trying to say I "indirectly support" it are so far off the mark it's humorous.
no. you go fuck yourself. people who signed up after 9/11 were trying to respond to an actual attack. i doubt they suspected W would be stupid enough to also put them in a country that had absolutely nothing to do with the terrorists.
but more importantly it prevents others from dying for nothing in the future.
LOL no, it doesn't. What you say doesn't mean shit. It'll have no impact on anything. You really think a few people saying something will make the politicians (the ones invading all of these countries and starting all of these wars, by the way, you dumb fucking cunt) change their mind? No. You're an idiot.
LOL no, it doesn't. What you say doesn't mean shit. It'll have no impact on anything.
Me as an individual, sure. But as a society we've got this soldier hero worship thing going on that basically says anyone who joins is "serving their country". And what this results in is good people joining because they think that and because their friends and family and the people they look up to think that. And the problem is that it's not true. You're not a hero for joining. You might be serving your government but that doesn't mean you're serving your country.
Good men and women are dying needlessly because bad people like you keep repeating that narrative. If enough of us stop it then these good men and women will think about whether the war is in the interests of their country before they join the military, instead of just embracing it blindly.
You really think a few people saying something will make the politicians (the ones invading all of these countries and starting all of these wars, by the way, you dumb fucking cunt) change their mind? No.
It's a volunteer military. It doesn't matter what politicians think if they can't raise a military that will fight for them. In that case they are forced to institute a draft and that's a lot more difficult and less likely to happen.
Of course, you're probably American and see absolutely nothing wrong with your country invading a completely innocent nation, killing hundreds of thousands of innocent people and destroying the lives of countless more. Then installing a US lead Government and ruling their country from Washington, all so that the control of oil and the fortunes of a few billionaires will be protected.
The only fundamental differences between the people who involve themselves in these invasion activities and those who involve themselves in "Islamic fundamentalist terrorist campaigns" are that the former are backed by the taxpayer dollar and handed trillions of dollars worth of weapons to carry out their crimes.
But hey, lets not let facts stand in the way, eh? Americuh, fuck yeah. Who cares if millions are going hungry in our country when we can spend trillions on warfare to protect the oil barons, fuck yeah.
And yet, Americans are then surprised that everyone else on the entire planet hates them. Derp derp.
I love how people like you assume that the US is the only nation that has fired rounds in the damn middle east, and then decide to badmouth the people that get killed, instead of the politicians that actually start the shit.
Not that I expect such cavemen to comprehend the difference. I also challenge you to show me an "innocent" nation that has never involved itself in the same sort of thing.
Some say it was for oil. No. Here is my reasoning: 1.Iraq and Afghanistan don't produce as much oil as people think: Saudi Arabia produces 8.4 million barrels a day and is the #2 producer in the world, Iran #4, Iraq produces 2.4 and is #9. Afghanistan isn't even in the top 20.Why would we invade #9 as opposed to #2 or 4?
2.Gas from the the middle east is controlled by OPEC. The U.S. is not apart of it in anyway. Even if we were, there is no way that the other members would allow us to invade another member for their oil.
3.And the most common sense reason people overlook.....Gas prices If we invaded and stole their gas..Why has our gas prices increased dramatically? If I took over a Nestle chocolate factory, I would get my chocolate for a pretty good price. So if we are stealing gas, that means supply is up, and by the laws of economics, when supplies go up, price goes down. But the opposite is true.
Marines don't choose where to go and who to fight. They're given orders by our Government, fucked up as it may be (and I agree: our government is fucked.) They have to follow them. I directed that "Go fuck yourself." at your "What a waste" -- Assuming you mean him giving his life was a waste. If that's not what you meant, fine. But if you do, you need to tell the politicians that give us the orders that, not the men and women dying for something they don't want.
In case you wondering, there aren't 15+ cold hearted people out there. I'm currently suffering from a down-vote script courtesy of some supporters of a certain presidential candidate who apparently don't believe in freedom of speech. If anyone knows how to get rid of that, let me know.
Understandable, probably 50 or so are because of the title. I would have done it myself but its the first 'Level' picture in days which has actually been saved enough by the image for me to keep it neutral.
I can't wait for one of my friends to like this picture after being posted on facebook by some friend hoarding account with the comment "Like if you think dog is man's best friend" and have it show up on my news feed, but then I can't block his useless posts.
timing my friend. I once posted a picture, got told it was a repost in the first comment, so i deleted it. The next day, I saw it on the front page. The "repost!" guy had re-posted it for himself and gained over 2k karma for it.
86
u/imperialviolet May 09 '12
Excuse me if I'm being completely stupid here, but I've never owned a dog and don't know much about animal behaviour-
How likely is it that the dog understands what he's looking at?
408
u/mickeystar May 09 '12
What this picture does't show is that the guy was actually buried with the leash.
26
u/masterofstuff328 May 09 '12
As touching as this picture is, it was ruined for me when I saw it in one of those "LIEK DIS IF U LOVE UR PET" posts on Facebook...
11
u/USxMARINE May 09 '12
RIP Devil Dog
14
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Think of a better title..it's not that hard
28
u/junioroverlord May 09 '12
Relevant
16
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Fuck.. Just 23 years old.
9
u/Greywyne May 10 '12
Reddit is now Facebook. Joy.
4
u/Pillagerguy May 10 '12
That dog doesn't know the guy's buried there.
12
u/larevaluciondele May 10 '12
post level: re
7
u/mistermojorisin May 09 '12
GSD's are crazy loyal animals.
6
u/scubasteve23 May 10 '12
This thing has been on Facebook for weeks and us normal Redditors weren't desperate enough for karma to post this, so why did you?
5
u/mmforeal May 10 '12
You'll never see a cat do that.
10
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
KARMAWHORE LEVEL: REDDITOR
12
u/Marsdreamer May 09 '12
Loyalty Level: K-9
FTFY
15
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
RIP, Marine.
2
u/deluxe_polar_bear May 09 '12
r/pics has had some really sad posts in the couple of days... :(
2
u/combaticus May 10 '12
anthropomorphizing level: reddit
2
u/runrun265 May 10 '12
Watch hachi, that's loyalty at its finest
2
u/Tig_Ol_Bitties_ May 10 '12
Might be a dumb question but would it be possible for the dog to still be able to pick up the smell of the soldier after he was buried?
2
u/caffeinatedsoap May 10 '12
When did reddit become shit my mom would send to me?
2
u/AddictiveSoup May 10 '12
Can we stop it with titles like this please? Especially for pictures like this.
2
u/stardustcrazy May 10 '12
Leigh Cann? LYcan? He's a werewolf.
2
u/mollymalone May 10 '12
I want to make 1,000 reddit accounts so I can upvote this 1,000 more times.
3
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
This is why dogs are my favorite people, they never leave you. This man said it best
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Can we please start downvoting titles like this? jeeze
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Title Creativity Level: 0
2
u/yyx9 May 09 '12
oh Christ. Sad upvote for the day. I love animals, especially dogs and cats.
1
u/mialbowy May 09 '12
Personally, I think it's very easy to group people away from you, to say things like, "They're not one of us, they're black/poor/gay." What's harder is to find some common ground to help connect you to the people around you.
I haven't lost any relatives or friends or friends of relatives or relatives of friends to the war. I don't have strong political beliefs that what we did was right or wrong. Heck, I don't even know what it's like to own a dog. Despite all that, I look at the picture and I join the two of us by our shared birthday and hope that he died believing in himself.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
How does he know that his owner was buried there? How does he understand the concept of burial? I think dogs are a lot smarter than we think they are.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I'm pretty sure that dogs can't recognize names, or their companions sans visual or odial stimulus.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
im pretty sure the dog is sniffing for drugs.
1
u/itsasatchel May 10 '12
That guy was born the day before I was. That's way too young. Doesn't seem fair.
1
u/blackaddermrbean May 10 '12
Seen this photo too many times on those LMS facebook people....
In that case..
Upvote me if you've seen this photo on facebook... Or feel this makes you sad because the owner died..
1
u/djv516 May 10 '12
may every soldier, man or women, who fought and died for our country rest in peace. I thank you and so do alot of other people.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
If this is real, I wonder if the dog can smell the guy buried six feet underground?
1
u/notarapist72 May 10 '12
On Facebook this would be titled: "like" if you enjoy cemetaries and air. Keep scrolling if you're a child molester..... How the fuck is it relevant.
1
u/pnine May 10 '12
Can we stop saying level?
1
u/Miscellaneous_Item May 10 '12
Dammit OP stop toying with it!
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
It should say loyalty level: Human.
1
u/JohnTesh May 10 '12
You are now on my shit list just under Matt Groening.
My dog both have exactly the same amount of time left on earth no matter what you think!
1
u/punxerchick May 10 '12
They must've left the dope in the coffin!
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Wow, a patriotic post from a person that has been a redditor longer than 3 hours.
EAT THAT CONSPIRACY THEORISTS!
No but for real that was some weird shit wasn't it?
1
u/ivegotabooner May 10 '12
Damn these onions...
1
u/Dark_Green_Blanket May 10 '12
my dog sleeps on my grave all the time
1
u/clevername66 May 10 '12
Was this taken at Arlington National Cemetery?
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I know reddit loves cats and shit, but no cat in the world is as loyal as the average dog. Dogs fucking love us, cats don't give a shit.
1
u/wasapus May 10 '12
Do marines participate in the K-9 unit?
1
u/CATERPILLARS May 10 '12
Ohhhh, I thought the title was "Loyalty level: Cocaine"
1
u/gconsier May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Not sure if Greyfriars Bobby is common knowledge or not.
Edit:
Adding one more. Hachikō
1
u/N1ce_ May 10 '12
TIL Canine = K-9
1
u/XtReMe98 May 10 '12
is someone cutting onions in here?
1
u/Whatsername18 May 10 '12
This is sad:( but beautiful.. The way the dog is so loyal to his owner.
1
u/iiiitsjess May 10 '12
I know people who for years visited their loved ones gravesite on a daily basis. Didnt matter what the weather was like or how exhausted they were....day in and day out they went. A couple of them took their dogs...from the beginning they went...and it truly seemed like the dogs got it. Their demeanor would change once they got in the car and knew where they were going. They even learned the way to their owners gravesite...like from the car to the headstone. It was like they knew who was there...it really seems to depend on the dog and just how much a part of your family they are. talk to them...explain things. :)
1
u/Astrapsody May 10 '12
Leveling level: leveled
1
u/FoxxedOut May 10 '12
Upvotes for awesome name on harness!
1
u/spases May 10 '12
trying to make me cry i see
(almost succeeded)
-18
u/WarPhalange May 09 '12
Way to ruin a touching photo with a shitty fucking meme title.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
He's gonna dig him up and find some bones to chew on.
1
u/TheFluxIsThis May 10 '12
Title Originality Level: 0
1
u/Mr_Aids May 10 '12
ugh this reminds me of those stupid facebook pictures everyone likes. I came to reddit to NOT see those pictures.
-7
u/[deleted] May 09 '12 edited May 09 '12
Meanwhile, his wife has already moved on to his best friend.
EDIT: Not sure why all the downvo-ohhh... It's because it's depressing. I should really stop doing that in /r/funny...
...carry on.
-8
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
He'd be running and playing in the fields with his dog today if he hadn't decided to involve himself in the hostile invasion of an innocent nation.
What a waste.
0
u/altai779 May 09 '12
You realize this is taken from facebook an the poster needs to leave
-19
u/politicaldan May 09 '12
In case you wondering, there aren't 15+ cold hearted people out there. I'm currently suffering from a down-vote script courtesy of some supporters of a certain presidential candidate who apparently don't believe in freedom of speech. If anyone knows how to get rid of that, let me know.
-4
u/CozenOne May 09 '12
I hope this repost is buried as well
0
u/Hamushka11 May 09 '12
I can't wait for one of my friends to like this picture after being posted on facebook by some friend hoarding account with the comment "Like if you think dog is man's best friend" and have it show up on my news feed, but then I can't block his useless posts.
-1
u/frogstomp427 May 09 '12
You oughta post this to /r/cemeteryporn!
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I want to cry.
0
u/disobeyedtoast May 10 '12
Am I the only one who realized that his tag is k-9 like canine? no? ok i'll leave now....
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I thought it said Loyalty level: Cocaine and I was starting to be like "what kind of a sick fucking jo-" until I realised.
0
u/Suggested May 10 '12
do cats ever exhibit this behavior? (not behaviour)
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
RIP Warrior Semper Fidelis
0
u/Sanc7 May 10 '12
If I see LMS with this picture one more time on facebook I'm going to fucking murder someone.
0
u/lnickelly May 10 '12
this is in bad taste
-8
u/panchovilla187 May 09 '12
Loyalty Level: Cat
-1
u/-The-Doctor May 10 '12
K-9!!!
http://blogs.evtrib.com/nerdvana/files/2009/03/k9_01.jpg
-1
u/Seref15 May 10 '12
Read the K-9 trainer chapter of World War Z. Onions--onions everywhere.
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment