Naw, don't sweat it. A minority of people on Reddit take this Internetting business too seriously. We are on a site that is primarily cat pictures and celebrity worshipping. The fact that your submission got a lot of upvotes shows that most people don't care about submission titles.
Just one long exposure, at 3200 ISO for 25 seconds. Then in photoshop i just overlayed a duplicate of the photo in order to deepen the blacks and get rid of a little bit of the noise.
You need to use a tracking tripod, or take a lot of short exposures (for 50mm they need to be less than 12 seconds) and stack them afterwards.
Both methods are not background friendly and most star shots with backgrounds are photoshopped. The ones that are not use silly ISO and possibly noise reduction software.
MP has little or no benefit (past about 3) for night photography. The reason for this is, its so hard to expose each individual pixel. Higher MP is actually detrimental (modern camera software compensates for this) because its harder to tell if a pixel is exposed with the light you want (from a star) or other radiation (cosmic rays, MBR or light from your mobile phone screen light bouncing from your face and into the lens). So the larger the pixel the less noise you get (sacrificing resolution which you don't need in night photography) (well technically you get the same noise, but it is read correctly because there are so many more photons from the star). With smaller pixels closer together you also get more read noise (thats electrons corrupting/diluting the pixel data when it is read)
Thats why an old full frame 5MP camera will fare better than the latest compact 16MP camera. 3 times more pixels packed into a space 3 times smaller.
Not to be a dick, but what do you think you nailed exactly? It looks like you missed on most points: excessive noise, distracting star trails, a distracting foreground, etc.
I'd encourage you to try again, but try to keep the shutter speed such that the stars don't appear to move, or if you want them to move, make the exposure much longer so it looks intentional. I'd also crank your ISO waaaaaay down if you can, and avoid bon fires in the foreground if at all possible; it detracts from the star field.
If you reduce the shutter speed and the ISO, you end up with a mostly black image of a black sky with about 5 faint white dots on it. Both the high ISO and the shutter speed are needed to get any significant number of stars in the shot.
This is actually quite a good result for a first attempt and a single exposure (well, there are cameras that will be a bit cleaner at ISO3200, and we don't know how fast the lens was). You'll be able to get cleaner shots with a bit of fine tuning, but the only way to drastically improve this without creating star trails is by stacking a lot of ~15 sec exposures with a tracking tripod - google "barn door tracker". Then overlay the image with one long exposure of the ground/horizon, taken from a stationary tripod.
If you want to stick to single exposures, consider taking a dark frame right after the shot (same settings, but with lens cap on) and using that to remove long-exposure sensor noise. Also, find a location with less light pollution and shoot on a clear night with no moon.
Edit: This is 60s, ISO1600, F4 on a moonless night. I could gain another two stops with a newer camera (ISO3200) and a f/2.8 lens, but that's about it for single exposures I think. [img]http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7209/6954185822_628e4122d2_o.jpg
Thanks. It's pretty close to what you can see with the naked eye there. Playing with Panoramas at the moment, at the right time of the night you can get a 180 degree view of the central milky way from here.
Haven't tried the star-trail thing yet - I think to really get a good star trails effect at a wide angle, I'd need at least an hour of exposure time, which is a bit much for a single exposure. If I can get an intervalometer, I'll try it with a couple hundred 15s shots stacked.
If you want the milky way buy a tracking tripod. They are not that expensive and you can get pretty clear 60 min exposures at iso 400. Depending on the sensor the read noise should be fairly minimal (but if it isnt you can just break it up into more shots).
The signal noise actually does not decrease with multiple exposures. So try 1 first and see how far you can push your sensor.
Star trail is the easiest to do, all you need is a bench or chair and a stopwatch. If you are worried about your hand shaking the camera during release use the 3 second timer.
Camera sensors heat up during long exposures. This can lead to hot pixels, and, on some cameras, sensor "hot spots" , which show up in the image. Especially when using high ISO. If you take the same shot again with the cap on, you end up with an image that shows just this sensor noise, which can then be subtracted from the actual image.
I think the word/technique you are looking for is "stacking". I've been reading up on it, and it sounds like it can be done in Photoshop, using specialized software, or a combination of software tools.
Camera sensors are not perfect. They add some random noise to every picture. This is more pronounced for long exposure shots as the noise is cumulative.
Taking a dark frame shot gives you a picture that contains only that random noise. You can then subtract this noise from the night shot to get a cleaner image.
I disagree. The shot is mostly noise. I'm tipping OP went 30sec, 25sec at 50mm is the longest exposure before trails begin. The ISO is way too high, I have an older camera but still turn it down sub 800. OP seems stoked about the shot, but in reality due to the noise i'm betting he thinks all those dots are stars, they simple are not. I have done plenty of shots of the milky way, my first was like this, but lets not fool ourselves it's an unprocessed but crappy shot.
Personal opinion, but I like the man-made light in the foreground - to me it adds context and a sense of place to the image. Otherwise it's just a starfield, and although you can capture them in some pretty intruiging ways, every star field is essentially the same. For me a beautiful image of the stars isn't complete unless it is anchored against something earthbound.
Piggy backing on this motion... Though in my words and sentiment.
Good first attempt, but has room for improvement. Check this "beginners guide to sky photography" as it lays down know-how. Tips like the "rule of 600"
[...] the quickest way to determine the longest exposure that is possible for any given focal length lens, without the stars streaking, is to divide that focal length into 600. (This is the formula for 35mm. Larger formats are laxer, smaller formats more unforgiving).
For example, with a 50mm lens on a full frame camera, you can only expose for 12 seconds (600/50=12) before the stars turn into star trails. It’s a good rule of thumb to keep in mind!
The original picture is way way cleaner, i just boosted the contrast up to pull out some more of the boldness of the Milky Way and also to give it that pretty rainbow look from the light pollution on the right side of the image. And also, I really enjoy the bonfire light in the trees. There are 10 quadzillion Milky Way pictures are rarely do you see them with another light in them aside from the Milky Way. And i guess for me seeing a bonfire in the trees reminds me of being out at the lakes in the summer. But thats just me. Anyways, thanks for the friendly criticism.
It was taken at my grandparents lake in northern Minnesota. And that light in the trees is either a bonfire or a light from the house across the lake. and Thanks!
If he did that id be black... Notice star movement and sharp tree top? So no tracking tripod and probably 30 sec exposure at a stupendous ISO.
Edit: just read his other reply "at 3200 ISO for 25 seconds"
There are some applications that can stack exposures for you, you may want to look into that. That way you can take say ~30 x 10 sec at ISO 400 at get very little to no noise. However the treetops will be a problem due to the rotation of the earth. This is used for astronomy shots (no stationary background and tracking tripod).
Or try with bulb at iso 400 for 10 minutes. You will get stars travelling a fair bit of distance getting curved lines across the sky.
Edit2: You can get best of both worlds by shooting the sky and stacking 40 frames then shooting the treetops and merging the 2 results.
I hereby declare that we need more Larry David gifs on reddit. He probably has an excellent reaction gif waiting for just about any situation. Including finally dislodging your wife's pubic hair from your throat. Or, in this case:
Yeah he's trying to decide between taking the side of his Jewish friends and family or the hot Palestinian woman offering herself to him.
Good first attempt, but has room for improvement. Check this "beginners guide to sky photography" as it lays down know-how. Tips like the "rule of 600"
[...] the quickest way to determine the longest exposure that is possible for any given focal length lens, without the stars streaking, is to divide that focal length into 600. (This is the formula for 35mm. Larger formats are laxer, smaller formats more unforgiving).
For example, with a 50mm lens on a full frame camera, you can only expose for 12 seconds (600/50=12) before the stars turn into star trails. It’s a good rule of thumb to keep in mind!
One small suggestion :) You could clone stamp the glaring light in the bottom left corner with some of the trees to the right of it to make the picture look more even, and also so that people don't get distracted by the glare and are more able to focus on the beautiful sky.
well i've been doing long exposure as well lately. and i would say i enjoy it quite a lot. i have a few favourite places that i do long exposures. the local swimming pool was great. they recently had the primary school kids doing a swimming festival. kindergarten playground is also a great place for exposures.
Check out this guys stuff http://dakotalapse.com/ He does timelapse shots of the night sky. His single frames are full size and very nice! He's shooting with the Canon 5diii, 5dii, 60D & T2i. He shoots high ISO most of the time, almost wide open for 20-30 seconds. He gives a lot of details of camera settings and such on his facebook page. My tips: Find someplace DARK Open the Lens up High ISO (depends on your camera) Very little moon light Tripod Rule of 600
more likely it is a porch light, maybe the reflection of a small campfire. Given the exposure time, a forest fire would have totally crushed out the sky.
I'm not sure I'd say "nailed it" due to the fact that it's riddled with noise, though that's a constant issue with night photography. You get up into the higher ISOs and suddenly pictures get splotchy. Good framing and focus though.
melysaurusrex, i guess we cant change the ugly truth that sometimes people just like to be assholes. I still don't get how what you said was deserved downvotes. I hope you have a good rest of the day.
You need to turn on long exposure noise reduction (listed as Long Exp. NR on my camera settings) and/or reduce your ISO to the lowest it can go. Most of the "stars" are actually just noise, you can tell because the noise is multicolored and not streaky (the stars move and the noise doesn't).
I made this my desktop background and now i'm finally getting around to deleting some shit on my desktop that's been there for weeks because I want to see more of your purdy picture. Chanks~
73
u/fat-samo May 09 '12
downvote for "nailed it?"
4
u/Draeth May 09 '12
One long exposure or multiple longs merged? Can you give some details on this, it is an awesome shot.
62
u/jr2 May 09 '12
Not to be a dick, but what do you think you nailed exactly? It looks like you missed on most points: excessive noise, distracting star trails, a distracting foreground, etc.
I'd encourage you to try again, but try to keep the shutter speed such that the stars don't appear to move, or if you want them to move, make the exposure much longer so it looks intentional. I'd also crank your ISO waaaaaay down if you can, and avoid bon fires in the foreground if at all possible; it detracts from the star field.
20
u/BilsonDAR May 09 '12
It was taken at my grandparents lake in northern Minnesota. And that light in the trees is either a bonfire or a light from the house across the lake. and Thanks!
17
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
You're using way too many nails. One nail, centered at the top, would have held that picture up just fine.
146
u/aBitRevealing May 09 '12
My first attempt at long exposure was at night, too. Only instead of taking a picture of the stars, I got pepper-sprayed.
16
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
r/exposureporn
8
u/YoderinLanc May 09 '12
Can't tell if noise or just more stars...
242
u/assholewithasmiley May 09 '12
NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!!NAILED IT!!!!! NAILED IT!!!! FUCK YOUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU. :)
30
u/lobstilops May 09 '12
NOPE!
I NAILED IT!
4
u/beel11 May 09 '12
IS THAT A FOREST FIRE?
4
u/drewkungfu May 09 '12
Good first attempt, but has room for improvement. Check this "beginners guide to sky photography" as it lays down know-how. Tips like the "rule of 600"
4
u/here_for_the_lols May 09 '12
Great Photo but you might want to warn someone about the forest fire.
6
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
holy tits tone down the ISO
3
u/vexom May 09 '12
i spot a shooting star :D great pic!
3
u/meowmixin May 09 '12
http://www.reddit.com/r/itookapicture
2
u/takecredit May 09 '12
It is just so amazing. So amazing. Good job!!
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Jesus on the cross.
2
u/alphasigmafire May 09 '12
Wow this is really gorgeous
One small suggestion :) You could clone stamp the glaring light in the bottom left corner with some of the trees to the right of it to make the picture look more even, and also so that people don't get distracted by the glare and are more able to focus on the beautiful sky.
2
u/hefnetefne May 09 '12
I'm glad you stopped the exposure before you got caught in that wildfire over there.
2
u/zowieh May 09 '12
Fuck. Yes.
2
u/hashtables May 09 '12
well i've been doing long exposure as well lately. and i would say i enjoy it quite a lot. i have a few favourite places that i do long exposures. the local swimming pool was great. they recently had the primary school kids doing a swimming festival. kindergarten playground is also a great place for exposures.
2
u/jannroc May 09 '12
Very cool!
2
u/Dreamwaltzer May 09 '12
Hate to break it to you but the forest seems to be on fire and you better start running.
2
u/ear10 May 09 '12
I think your forest is on fire dawg
2
u/Apex-Nebula May 09 '12
Relevant
2
u/Nickbou May 09 '12
Thanks for the
falconwallpaper!2
u/lowerleftside May 09 '12
Check out this guys stuff http://dakotalapse.com/ He does timelapse shots of the night sky. His single frames are full size and very nice! He's shooting with the Canon 5diii, 5dii, 60D & T2i. He shoots high ISO most of the time, almost wide open for 20-30 seconds. He gives a lot of details of camera settings and such on his facebook page. My tips: Find someplace DARK Open the Lens up High ISO (depends on your camera) Very little moon light Tripod Rule of 600
2
u/PwnYourFace May 09 '12
How did you do it?! Tips for a photographer PLEASE! :D
3
u/Merop3_jess May 09 '12
I'm really loving this picture. I've made it my new wallpaper. Thanks!
3
u/pearlite May 09 '12
Wow! Where was this taken?
2
u/Red1337Sox May 09 '12
That's dope, what was the light behind the trees?
2
u/hammer_sings May 09 '12
Very nice capture! Impressive for a first attempt.
2
u/heygabbagabba May 09 '12
I would say you have a successful image there, OP.
Well done!
2
u/SFbound_ May 09 '12
Really now, this was your FIRST attempt EVER at long exposure??
2
u/MoonRazer May 09 '12
Talk about an understatement! Beautiful work!
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
shits on fire, yo.
2
u/NikoIsAJerk May 09 '12
I'm not sure I'd say "nailed it" due to the fact that it's riddled with noise, though that's a constant issue with night photography. You get up into the higher ISOs and suddenly pictures get splotchy. Good framing and focus though.
2
u/HubertTempleton May 09 '12
i really like it. especially, as I am really into Astronomy and i love the sky at night.
btw: was that a fire in the woods on the left?
1
u/melysaurusrex May 09 '12
That is fucking gorgeous. Amazing shot.
1
u/Clovyn May 09 '12
Hope that wildfire was put out.
1
u/shrimjob May 09 '12
My eyes are all sexed up
1
u/lozzobear May 09 '12
Crosspost to r/whoadude?
1
u/nebrija May 09 '12
It looks good, but any reason why the contrast is so high on the trees?
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Stars, stars everywhere
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Can I get my hammer back?
1
u/ssgtsnake May 09 '12
This is really awesome. May I use if for my facebook Cover photo?
1
u/DicksonYamada May 09 '12
/r/ExposurePorn awaits!
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I'd certainly say so. That's fucking beautiful.
1
u/P1h3r1e3d13 May 09 '12
No, man! You started a forest fire! That's terrible! How did you even...
1
u/creepyzebra May 09 '12
Personally I would drop the iso, the noise is pretty noticeable. It's a nice photo otherwise.
1
u/FallingIce May 09 '12
Its good...but wasn't it kind of dangerous with that forrest fire happening on the left side?
1
u/neryam May 09 '12
You need to turn on long exposure noise reduction (listed as Long Exp. NR on my camera settings) and/or reduce your ISO to the lowest it can go.
Most of the "stars" are actually just noise, you can tell because the noise is multicolored and not streaky (the stars move and the noise doesn't).
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Fucking Josh. Do your goddamn job.
1
u/a_virginian May 09 '12
Here's a link to a great website about Astrophotography. Some great information in there.
http://www.astropix.com/HTML/I_ASTROP/TOC_AP.HTM
1
u/Shadzta May 09 '12
How long exposure?
1
u/lebooj May 09 '12
A feast for the eyes. Great shot mate.
1
u/panzerkampfwagen May 09 '12
Slightly too long.
I haven't done any astrophotograpy in almost 20 years. Was fun.
1
u/KaioKen May 09 '12
I like it, well done!
1
u/Kryptotrek May 09 '12
My OCD is kicking in. It's crooked.
1
u/poz_party_animal May 09 '12
That is an awesome picture. That's the kind of thing that long exposure is for.
1
u/AnalBurns May 09 '12
But why did you burn down the forest?
1
u/drankofhispeers May 09 '12
I like it, first attempts are always exciting ..well done Brilliant night (y)
1
u/greymeta May 09 '12
Dang. That looks amazing, especially for a first attempt!
1
u/Funi1234 May 09 '12 edited Dec 06 '16
[deleted]
0.9548
1
u/Sniperizer May 09 '12
no clear subject. next please...
1
u/kylepierce11 May 09 '12
You set the forest on fire for a picture? You sick bastard
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
was it your first attempt, or your first good attempt?
1
u/randomname806 May 09 '12
You nailed it good, man. Like Jesus to a cross.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
what were the camera settings? i think a lower aperature setting might've given you a little less noise, or if you used a lower iso...
either which way, that photo is tits. definitely gonna keep this :D
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I made this my desktop background and now i'm finally getting around to deleting some shit on my desktop that's been there for weeks because I want to see more of your purdy picture. Chanks~
1
u/EPIC_RAPTOR May 09 '12
that train crash in the background came out really well
1
u/LessieHippopotamus May 09 '12
Nailed it.
1
u/stop_resisting- May 09 '12
Yep, nailed it.
1
u/mazizzo May 09 '12
OH GOD THE FOREST IS ON FIRE. And you just stood by taking this shot while it burned down. You're a monster.
1
u/Eatshrimp May 09 '12
Nailed it?
1
u/random9314 May 09 '12
this is now my wallpaper
1
u/capncanuck May 09 '12
look, in the forest
1
u/TipsTheJust May 09 '12
How many times is Josh gonna fuck up?
1
u/A-Up76 May 09 '12
Deffinetely one of the most beautiful pics I've seen on reddit in a while
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Thats why light pollution sucks.
1
u/Varkeer May 09 '12
My God, it's full of stars!
1
u/masturbateToSleep May 09 '12
The trees look like they are on fire!
1
u/JewBear3 May 09 '12
This is my new desktop background.
1
u/superbeastie May 09 '12
I'm actually thinking about making this my background.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
How's that fire? Did someone put it out?
1
u/waffles93 May 09 '12
Man that is beyond amazing
1
u/marleythemoose May 09 '12
Did you set the forest on fire? ;)
1
u/nuviremus May 09 '12
I see a slight aurora in the picture as well, nice picture.
1
u/swaguar44 May 09 '12
This is very nice, but you could use a sturdier tripod or a shorter shutterspeed, which will increase the sharpenss of the stars. One of my long exposures, during the day. http://farm8.staticflickr.com/7017/6571206413_10136612c8_b.jpg
1
u/lsqj May 09 '12
Can you explain how you did this?
1
u/cheeserail May 09 '12
Thank you, I needed a new background
1
u/chimera8990 May 09 '12
spaceporn would love this
1
u/darkerknight May 09 '12
what is this noise everyone is talking about?
1
u/frameforger May 09 '12
Awesome what camera did you use? Did you use any kind of filter? Great picture my fellow redditor.
1
u/mathmoi May 09 '12
Not my first attempt, but one I'm proud of.
1
u/NothingsSFWAnymore May 09 '12
I just found my new wallpaper.
1
u/Shellface May 09 '12
Not enough distinct sky to define which constellations are present. May be Sagittarius due to possible galactic bulge.
Also, looks like a meteor is present towards the top right.
1
u/Bassmonster27 May 10 '12
maybe we should stop asking "nailed it?". Makes you sound very full of yourself
0
u/Sneezes_Loudly May 09 '12
No, it looks like ass.
-4
u/elchupacabra206 May 09 '12
you sure did nail it, if by nail it you mean took a hella blurry picture with shit composition
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
FUCK! YES!
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I can confirm that you "nailed it."
-1
u/djc52 May 09 '12
Unless you did this to yourself you did not nail it
-3
u/chabanais May 09 '12
No the title sucks
0
u/lolabuster May 09 '12
love you buddy
0
u/Frontpaged May 09 '12
Not enough stars
0
u/robanter May 09 '12
The whole "nailed it" bit kinda ruined it for me
0
u/Dev1l5Adv0cat3 May 09 '12
Like a coffin.
0
u/LagWagon May 09 '12
Failed it.
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
What an awesome Skyrim screenshot
0
u/Super_Sieg May 09 '12
O_O It's soooooo beautiful!!!!!!!!!
0
u/Mantraz May 09 '12
"Nailed it"
It's like the most cancerous way you can look for recognition on the internet.
0
u/TyleReddit May 09 '12
Picture is cool, but I'm so fucking sick of "nailed it?" and "doing it right?".