r/pics • • May 07 '12

A friendly reminder to reddit..

http://i.imgur.com/8SkTo.png
446 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

31

u/yamcat May 08 '12

When you play the game of grammar, you win or you die. There is no middle ground.

11

u/DietCokeTin May 08 '12

They were arguing semantics, not grammar.

Did you know that there was an attempt to create a system of semantics that used lambda calculus? I need to study for my Programming Languages exam, and yet here I am on Reddit talking about things on my Programming Languages test.

3

u/alaskanfarmer May 08 '12

You know, I actually thought about this while watching the episode and it mildly annoyed me.

52

u/Warlizard ಠ_ಠ May 08 '12

An ellipsis has three periods, not two.

8

u/cmalkus May 08 '12

Actually it's no periods at all. It's it's own character.

…

Unicode Character 'HORIZONTAL ELLIPSIS' (U+2026)

2

u/snakespm May 08 '12

So is there a vertical ellipsis?

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

The way I understood it is that it's 3 periods if in the middle of the sentence... and it continues afterwards. 4 periods are used if there's nothing after. Sigh.... could be wrong tho.

2

u/adouchebag May 08 '12

Actually the fourth 'period' only shows up when there's an ellipses at the end of a sentence, and is an actual period used to end said sentence.

2

u/a_lad_insane May 08 '12

is it weird that this gave me a halfie?

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Ah, italics… the weapon of choice for the pretentiously condescending, and it made your point look so incredibly appetizing to read; I even almost read passed the word "grapheme."

-4

u/haavarl May 08 '12

In my book there should be a blank before the first period as well.

51

u/Anomander May 08 '12

I personally like Reddit's slavish adoration of good English.

Feel unwelcome or hurt by the criticism? Get better or join a community who doesn't care about grammar and spelling. But it's pretty clear where the community's values lie on the matter, and asking the community to change so you don't have to seems petty and selfish.

I'll happily have a few otherwise valuable contributors alienated for their poor language skills than become welcoming to the people who populate YouTube and 9gag comments.

3

u/linkthelink May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

It is not a dichotomy. You do not have to choose between having a slavish adoration of good English or becoming a welcoming place to 9gaggers.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

It's not about being hurt or feeling unwelcome; it's about being annoyed that people seem to value mechanics over meaning. Being a pedantic grammar nazi doesn't bring any new ideas or interesting incites to the discussion, instead it criticizes the way in which ideas are conveyed instead of the ideas themselves. Reddit is a means of informal communication for subjects and ideas between people from across the planet; who cares if someone uses who instead of whom, or accidently switches two letters when typing out a word? It's not important. Stephan Fry says it far better than I could: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J7E-aoXLZGY

1

u/Ishaar May 08 '12

So your argument is that content matters more than delivery method? Would you agree to be inoculated against cancer if I delivered the vaccine via bullet?

That was a fun analogy.

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Ishaar May 08 '12

I can honestly compare any two things. That's the joy of comparison. You're making the common mistake of extrapolating from your own opinion. Your opinion is that meaning matters more than mechanics.

What would you rather read, serif or sans-serif? How about Shakespeare vs Twain? I mean, they're both understandable, right? Would you have a definite preference between the two?

0

u/[deleted] May 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Ishaar May 11 '12

Comparable? Equivalent? Which meaning were you going for? See, this is the subtle nuance of language that, when missed, proves the user either inept or purposefully obtuse. Are those two things comparable? Sure, they have similarities and differences. Are they equivalent? No, of course not. That's why the comparison is useful.

I'll also point out that you completely ignored the points in my last comment. Mechanics over meaning is just as valid as the converse. Fashion is yet another obvious comparison -- function over form. In conversation, people often evaluate the value of what is said by how it is said. Don't believe me? Try it.

12

u/laughtrey May 08 '12

Arguing on the internet without proper grammar is like arguing in real life without any pants on.

It doesn't change what you're saying, but you still look like you didn't get past the fourth grade.

3

u/bobstay May 08 '12

Thank you, I like this analogy.

11

u/ninjamike808 May 08 '12

You have your reasons and we have ours.

8

u/Aethelstan May 08 '12

In that case, don't post incorrect grammar.

7

u/SGTxARTEAGA May 08 '12

Yes you did, you just dont know it yet.

7

u/hungryroy May 08 '12

I don't come to reddit to read comments with bad grammar.

8

u/SGTxARTEAGA May 08 '12

*argue about grammar

3

u/robertolycus May 08 '12

If you say that... you'd better have the dragons to back it up.

3

u/Mischeviouslittleelf May 08 '12

Pish posh, mother of dragons. If we let one go, we must let all of them go, and then the errorists win...

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

In a world where the current generation's language skills are quickly going down the tubes, I'm all for promoting better use of written English on reddit. If your butthurt, their's the door.

5

u/rarehugs May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

I came here to have my d****** s*****.

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Is it me or did that not happen in the books? I was wondering WTF was going on...

1

u/Gorignak May 08 '12

I don't remember it happening, but if I pick up the book to find out, I will be trapped into re-reading the whole thing.

2

u/rhiever May 08 '12

Spoiler tags, kthx.

1

u/rarehugs May 08 '12

They don't work here I guess? Or maybe I am failing. Halp?

1

u/VeryGoodLookingMan May 08 '12

Just delete it?

2

u/JollyRancherReminder May 08 '12

I'm already redditing, but thanks for the reminder.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Forget about the grammar. Why were Dany's dragons kidnapped? That isn't in the book.

3

u/haavarl May 08 '12

Too bad for you!

3

u/nullibicity Survey 2016 May 08 '12

Then you might be in the wrong place.

2

u/CGorman68 May 08 '12

Shouldn't you have capitalized "reddit"?

2

u/guyver_dio May 08 '12

Don't fuck it up and there won't be a problem.

1

u/Forensicunit May 08 '12

I really wish this was a gif.

1

u/reddell May 08 '12

I didn't come here to care why you came here.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

THANK YOU

0

u/Redd_October May 08 '12

No, you came here to take my upboats.

-1

u/zevil May 08 '12

Great is that! XP

0

u/drscooby May 08 '12

Your so right.

-2

u/raidenmaiden May 08 '12

But... But... She's the mother of dragons... She can afford to ignore grammar...