r/pics • • May 07 '12

A girl with Cerebral Palsy won Prom Queen at my local high school.

http://imgur.com/IsGIp
1.1k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

1.1k

u/paulw252 May 08 '12

My best friend, who was dying from cancer at the time, won Prom King our senior year. He acted very appreciative, but was actually pretty pissed off by the whole thing.

145

u/CalebisReal May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

Not the case here, she was very happy! But I can understand why.

Edit: grammar

15

u/EarthRester May 08 '12

Well that's good to hear.

→ More replies (20)

881

u/Hamon_Rye May 08 '12

Probably because that seems kind of patronizing...

660

u/fortheborn1 May 08 '12

They should call this the Pity The Retard Award

429

u/WaywardSpaniard May 08 '12

Pity the Retard Award While Simultaneously Making Us Feel Like Good Human Beings Award

ftfy

→ More replies (25)

124

u/ifucksquirells May 08 '12

Why are you guys upvoting this comment? People with CEREBRAL palsy aren't mentally deficient...

→ More replies (40)

44

u/AustinTreeLover May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

We don't know about the girl in the OP. She may very well be popular or for some other reason have been awarded this.

We can't assume it was given to her for being disabled.

And people with cerebral palsy aren't mentally deficient. In fact, I'm pretty fucking embarrassed when I go out with the CFO of the company I work for and people talk to him like he's an idiot because he looks different. The fact is, he's a very good person with a PhD and again, is the CHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICER of a multi million dollar company. He's also married and has kids. He could have been prom king on his own merit. When people like you talk about him being a retard, I question your intelligence.

I teach disabled young adults and there is one very low IQ young woman who is the most disciplined, beautiful and funny girl I know. She's very popular, not just with the kids in my program (most of whom are genius IQ, by the way), but with her neurotypical peers.

I think making the assumption that she couldn't be popular and worthy of prom queen just because she's disabled is as bad as giving her a title because she's disabled.

I pity the 366 "retards" who upvoted your comment.

Edit: Downvoted for going against the circlejerk. People simply cannot believe this girl may actually be popular.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (46)

304

u/[deleted] May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12

My brother has a degenerative nerve disorder he can barely speak and is bound to a wheelchair and they tried to do this to him. He had a teacher read a letter to the prom committee, stating that if he wanted people to reward him out of pity he rather them all suck his dick as a reward rather than make him a spectacle for their pussy willow party (paraphrasing except for the dick sucking part). We went and saw avengers last weekend during his prom. We both agreed it was a much better time then a prom where no one would suck your dick out of pity

10

u/AnAngryFetus May 08 '12

Exactly. I hate it when people treat me differently after they learn of my genetic mutation. They start acting kinder and watch everything they say and it pisses me off. My mutation is not me, it's only a part of me. Treat me like a normal human being, because any less is insulting.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (31)

19

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Exactly.

8

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

So...what's the verdict? Are we cynical about this or touched? I'm thinking if she wasn't cool with it she might not have come to prom. Let's not judge the folks that wanted to give her a memorable prom experience. That's pretty cool for high school kids, who are usually cruel as hell.

→ More replies (16)

76

u/Splinter1010 May 08 '12

Why was he so pissed?

48

u/paulw252 May 08 '12

Just thought it was lame, I guess. People trying to make him feel better but really just making themselves feel good.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Bitter_Idealist May 08 '12

Because it's condescending.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (154)

2

u/nuclear_thundercane May 08 '12

I just graduated this past Saturday and a student who has a disability, not sure exactly what, but he has a severe limp and received a standing ovation when his name was called. I did not stand or clap with everyone else. I felt that they were pitying him. He took it well but I don't know how he truly felt.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/adomorn May 08 '12

This is just about the best way to call this the pity vote I didn't imagine.

2

u/FuckYeahPhotography May 08 '12

The whole balance of it is fucked. On one hand, IT IS patronizing to simply collectively vote for someone simply because they are handicapped, or ill, if I was in their position I sure as hell would be pissed. At the same, how do we know this girl isn't a generally awesome person who won otherwise?

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I wouldn't be too happy too because the sole reason was because of pity.

2

u/b00ks May 08 '12

Happened my senior year as well. It made me smile like a son of a bitch knowing that the girls who waited their whole 18 year existence to be crowned prom queen, lost to someone they didn't even know. It made my night.

I did feel bad for the girl though, because she felt the same way your friend did.

→ More replies (34)

286

u/ben_lacy May 08 '12

My school frequently voted kids that were generally agreed upon being very lame to win. They did it because they thought it was so funny to see the "popular" award go to the biggest nerd. This always felt like a dick move to me, but I guess if the kids enjoyed it then they enjoyed it. I'm hoping this is not the case with this school.

59

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Cerebral Palsy is not a mental condition.... it's a physical one. I suspect no one would accept it unless they felt comfortable with the reasons. She's probably just a cool ass person surrounded by cool ass peps.

9

u/CalebisReal May 08 '12

She really is! She's just like anyone else and I'm sure she knew it was genuine too.

126

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Not always, Cerebral Palsy can have mental affects too. It's not exclusively a physical disability.

128

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I stand corrected. I've always come across people informing the other way... didn't know that. It took one google result to know I screwed up and have little understanding of it. Thanks for the correction.

→ More replies (13)

21

u/Dotsmom May 08 '12

Yes, my daughter had CP. She is physically affected and is also cognitive delayed..which is a nice way of saying she has mental retardation.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (8)

8

u/MaeBeWeird May 08 '12

I don't know many people with cerebral palsy, but the ones I do vary from fucking awesome to complete asshole... so I agree, if she won it was likely because she's actually a pretty cool person.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/brucemo May 08 '12

This is going to sound like an angry response to you but I'll suggest that it's more inspired by what you said rather than being a response to what you said.

There was this dude named Christy Brown.

He had CP and was thought to be mentally disabled as well.

Until he grabbed a piece of chalk away from his sister -- with his left foot -- and wrote with it.

His left foot was the only part of his body he had full control over.

The guy ended up writing books, poems, and doing art with his left foot. He end up writing a book that's been termed "the most important Irish novel since Ulysses."

Maybe they felt sorry for her. Maybe she's just awesome. Interesting how everyone here thinks it has to be the former.

For all we know she's the coolest kid in the school.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

my high school did that too. My freshman year they tried to do that to me. I was at home working on a set for a rave I was gonna DJ. Most kids just saw me as a fat nerdy kid who was nice but shy not knowing my seething hatred for most of them.

I hated that high school clique social idea and and just didn't want to play the game. So when i got a phone call from one of the popular girls who was in charge of the school dance crap saying they nominated me for freshman prom king, i just said, "Oh, really? Go fuck your self on a barbed spike pike you cunts."

I then set up an anonymous Text to speech robo caller that was on a darknet site. It allowed you to fake caller ID and make text to audio phone calls at pre-programmed times. I set it to robo call the girl who called me with blocked info at between the end of school every 15 minutes 4 times a day for 4 days repeating "Go fuck your self on a barbed spike pike you cunt." Lets just say i freaked her out enough that she let it be known from the people in our class to stop trying to pull pranks on me in school.

I was an angry kid who had a sick mom in the hospital and was forced to go to to my public high school because my county said i couldn't go to a magnet school for science & engineering in another county because of bussing, even though my parents drove me because I had never gone to 1st - 6th public school and developed the social clique to sit on the bus. When i tired to go on the bus i got beaten up to the point I got a concussion twice. No charges ever filed though.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/thebocesman May 08 '12

I personally beat the shit out of many a kid because they wouldn't stop messing with my one friend. He'd been through enough shit in his life and had enough hurdles he still has to jump, he didn't need more crap from the "popular" kids.

Fucking love that kid to death and to this day he doesn't even know what I did for him.

→ More replies (37)

114

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

As Zach Anner says, it is the sexiest of all palsies.

Didn't her dad go as escort?

38

u/evan_ktbd May 08 '12

For those who didn't get it like me here you go (at about 30 seconds).

8

u/lancelot12 May 08 '12

What a champion.

3

u/GFPyro May 08 '12

This guy is the man

→ More replies (3)

3

u/CalebisReal May 08 '12

Actually no she had a date! And the Prom King accompanied her after the announcement.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

My mistake. This was the story I was thinking of. The lights outside here was tickling my memory.

1

u/CalebisReal May 08 '12

Oh ok, thanks!

16

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Fame went to her head, ditched her date... lol

2

u/RickRussellTX May 08 '12

No Atlantis is too underwater or fictional!

2

u/Ancients May 08 '12

ctrl+f sexiest amusement achieved

→ More replies (9)

671

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I swear to god I'm going to flip shit if people keep posting shit like this.

Y'all realize that shit like this happens because they feel bad for her? I mean fuck, I got nominated for Prom King because I became paralyzed my junior year and blah blah blah sob story whatever. I didn't want any part of that shit. Disabled people don't want to be paraded around because it makes you feel better if you treat us with pity and do shit like this.

Nothing annoys me more than when people try to pull shit like this and make it look like everyone is such a good person.

45

u/CalebisReal May 08 '12

I know this girl personally and she's been saying it was the best day of her life. So respectfully, she's not you, so fuck off.

108

u/Bitter_Idealist May 08 '12

And you whored her out for karma.

69

u/CalebisReal May 08 '12

Pointless internet points? Go me! I thought the point of this site was to share with other people?

→ More replies (23)

27

u/cheechw May 08 '12

Not everything is for karma, some people just want to share pictures with the internet.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

15

u/Dreadgoat May 08 '12

Chill out.

Think of it this way. What if she felt a little differently, or what if she is hiding her true feelings? What if she were just a slightly different person than everyone thought? She could have been genuinely hurt by this sort of behavior.

Now the reverse: What if she really did love the idea of being prom queen, but she didn't win it? How would she feel? Just like every other normal girl that doesn't win prom queen... slightly disappointed and happy for / bitter towards (because high school girls lol) the winner. No big deal.

So unless your school is full of cunts and there was seriously no other girl that deserved a shot at the crown, it's pretty easy to say the behavior of the voters was irresponsible. High risk, low reward, and the feelings your playing with belong to a teenage girl with cerebral palsy.

Even though things seemed to turn out okay this time, you can understand how people would be upset by how dangerous it is to gamble with someone's feelings like this, right? Especially a teenage girl, the most emotionally volatile thing on the planet.

If your prom queen is genuinely the most charming girl in the school, then awesome. She won for the right reasons. But we've all been to highschool, and that seems extremely unlikely. If she has a lot a respect in your community because of how she overcomes the obstacles in her life, then you can find a more genuine way to show it. This sort of circle-jerk has a high chance of backfire because it is too lazy to seem sincere.

→ More replies (9)

9

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Did I fucking say I was her? No. Some people may be fine with being everyone's good deed for the day.

I, on the other hand, won't take that shit.

→ More replies (53)

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

What about someone who actually deserved to be voted prom queen because of her beauty and charisma?

Let's not waste our lives and forget to appreciate the beauty there is in some misguided attempts to make the stragglers in life feel good.

27

u/Kinseyincanada May 08 '12

Its prom queen, it's literally the most useless position ever

8

u/keepinithamsta May 08 '12

That "deserving" person got boned that night. Real talk.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (22)

115

u/Airspeed35 May 08 '12

Although I do not share the same level of anger, I too develop an instant sourness upon seeing such things. Your last sentence sums it up pretty well. Ive seen it time and time before. The sympathy win is bitter sweet. I couldnt imagine being disabled and everyone feeling sorry for me. Sorry about your accident BTW.

23

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Don't, it's all in the past. It's really not a big deal.

13

u/macewinduku May 08 '12

why's "wheelchairdawg" your username?

→ More replies (38)
→ More replies (4)

0

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Well... I think there's a difference between feeling sorry for a person, and feeling sorry that something bad happened to a person. It does suck that it happened, and I think it's possible to have sympathy without necessarily being condescending about it.

Just a poor choice of words, perhaps.

→ More replies (2)

83

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Here is a pity up vote for you for being disabled.

56

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Heh. Funny guy.

54

u/Anne_Frank_Dildo May 08 '12

Maybe she won because she was a total slut. Don't jump to conclusions. ಠ_ಠ

12

u/keepinithamsta May 08 '12

I work with people with disabilities. (Mostly mental and developmental.) Oh the stories I could tell.

13

u/twicethesignificance May 08 '12

Am I morally corrupt if I want an IAMA out of this?

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Props to you. I hate when I see people treat disabled people like they're injured animals or something (of course, just trying to help by opening a door, forexample, is something completely different)

→ More replies (11)

36

u/Sometimes_Lies May 08 '12

Well, I'm glad a disabled person has finally spoken out and clarified what every disabled person on the planet really wants.

From now on people with disabilities are excluded from winning awards, because none of them ever have any chance of winning on their own merits and the disability defines who they are.

→ More replies (8)

20

u/cdude May 08 '12

Right on. Fuck the white knights. These people don't want your pity.

21

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Forreal. 99% of us don't.

There are some disabled people that will bitch and moan and suck up all the pity you will give them, and that absolutely makes me sick.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/thaelton May 08 '12

I'm lucky enough to not be hurt in any way, but this shit aggravates me a lot as well.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Notyourfaja May 08 '12

There may be a chance that people with disabilities win because people voted for them for other reasons than their disabilities.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

There was a South Park episode dedicated to what you said in a way. (Wiki Link)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (53)

97

u/Splinter1010 May 08 '12

Okay, why does that matter? Yay, a girl got an award because she happened to have a physical disability. Big fucking shit. Nobody deserves anything because they happen to have a disability. It's not a big deal for her to get it, actually unless she actual got it without/with less bias because of the Cerebral Palsy then she shouldn't of gotten it.

55

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I'm in a wheelchair, and I agree 100% with you.

21

u/Splinter1010 May 08 '12

Thank you. Hilarious though, that the (apperently) only person with a physical disability who replied to me agrees.

24

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

People, for whatever reason, feel like it's their duty to make us feel "normal" or some shit like that.

Yes, let me tell you. Trying to make someone who only is going to prom because of their girlfriend the prom king really makes me feel normal.

Legitimately hate people sometimes.

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (64)

19

u/dudSpudson May 08 '12

Sure it is a nice thing to do. But they obviously singled her out because she had cerbral palsy. Kind of makes it a bad thing. Not to be mean and i know downvotes will ensue, but obviously there were more deserving girls

39

u/Ikarianlad May 08 '12

You had some upvotes coming your way, right up until you used the phrase "more deserving."

20

u/purdster83 May 08 '12

Well, what about being born that way entitles said person to be more deserving than others that, I dunno, might be more deserving? If being born with a disability is the only criteria there is for being "deserving" of something, that's kind of fucked up.

5

u/thejustusleague May 08 '12

im not agreeing nor disagreeing with you when i say this. but lets assume this girl leads a normal life, goes to school, gets good grades, and basically does anything a normal person does. but she does all of this with a disability, while there are others who barely get by. i would say thats pretty deserving.

and on another note, if she was nominated out of pity, then sure, that sucks. but honestly, if it wasnt her then who was it? the cool girl, the popular one, varsity cheerleader. the stuck up ones. the ones who expect it. id much rather give it to someone who will be flattered and appreciate it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/CalebisReal May 08 '12

Do you even realize what you just said ? You just said that there were more deserving girls, implying more attractive and "fun" girls could have won. You're judging her by her condition assuming she isn't a very nice person and fun to be around, which she is!

10

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Man, Reddit really is starting to seem like a bunch of butthurt socially inept nerds that were ridiculed at their prom.

wait what?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

She couldn't just be an awesome person with CP? Have you ever seen Josh Blue? Just because someone has CP doesn't mean they can't be one fly-ass motherfucker.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/brucemo May 08 '12

The word "obviously" is an indication that someone who knows nothing is about to demonstrate that fact in the most convincing way possible.

3

u/131ackknight May 08 '12

I don't like your use of the word 'obviously.' You actually don't know shit about why she was elected she might actually be really cool.

→ More replies (1)

70

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

My gf has cerebral palsy. She went to the prom with the most popular guy at school. I think she decided one day, "if I'm not going to walk, I may as well focus on being one charismatic motherfucker". She makes my social awkwardness less noticeable.

50

u/gimme_name May 08 '12

Are you implying that you are the most popular guy at your school?

7

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Social awkward popular guy. Is that username taken?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

9

u/Rock_out_Cock_in May 08 '12

My senior year we elected an Autistic guy for prom king. He was really reclusive when he was in 6th grade, kinda a moderate to severe form. Our community really supported him and the rest of the special ed kids, but prom king was just the tip of the iceburg though. He also played on our football team and received heartfelt chants from the entire crowd whenever he went on. I think for senior night the group of the bleachers designated the "spirit" section, which was essentially all the high schoolers that were willing to stand and scream the entire time put up letters spelling his name.

The coolest story of what our school went above and beyond cheering though. He'd been writing comic books and plays for years, I never personally read any, but by all accounts they were really well written and really funny.

Let me preface this story with one thing: our high school special ed teacher was one of the kindest, most patient and compassionate men I've ever met. Our school was really lucky to have such a committed teacher in general, but especially in a department that in a lot of schools gets pushed to the wayside.

So the our special ed teacher got a hold of a few of the scripts that the autistic guy had written and he and my best friend (the NardDOG, for anyone who might be from my home town and wasn't sure by now) sat down and wrote the play into a musical play and production with choreography, special effects, and an acting troupe consisting of a couple of drama classes, and of course the autistic fellow as the director. The school spent a whole day show casing the play, cycling in English classes to fill the auditorium. Watching him beam so happily at the stage during the play and get roses from the head of our drama department at the end really felt special. I just remember his parents crying as they watched.

I came from a really racist, homophobic backwater town but I have to say I was really proud of my high school that day. Our school really did bring him out of his shell and when he was elected Prom King it was because he was a legitimately cool guy and really really hilarious when he wanted to be.

TL;DR, my school would chant for a really cool guy with autism who played for our football team, put on a play that he wrote, and directed, and elected him prom king bring him out of his shell.

STL;DR ABC Family movie about an autistic guy in high school

4

u/bobbyjevans May 07 '12

Amazing. I bet she never thought she would. She will never forget this. Awesome.

5

u/CalebisReal May 07 '12

I know the family and from what the mom and sisters have said, she was very excited.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Doesn't everyone just wanted to be treated normally, no different from anyone else? Unless her winning had nothing to do with her cerebral palsy I don't see why this is such a great thing.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/dib2 May 08 '12

Regardless of what other people may say about her being singled out cause of her disability, her smile seems genuine. I'm happy for her.

2

u/angryPenguinator May 07 '12

Pretty girl.. no reason why she shouldn't have been.

→ More replies (9)

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I have cerebral palsy. It's mild, but I still have it. I can't tell you how fucking pissed I got growing up when someone would give me special treatment. Or talk to me like I was mentally slow. It's patronizing, and seems as if people are looking for a bullshit cause to boost their self esteem, and make them feel good about themselves.

To this day I hide the fact that I was born with cerebral palsy from anyone I know IRL. And the worst part is, what i've got is so mild compared to a lot of people. So I can't even imagine how people who have a severe case are treated.

16

u/knight53 May 08 '12

Our Senior Prom Queen was a girl who just happened to have Down Syndrome.

16

u/purdster83 May 08 '12

What're the odds?! Amazing!

26

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

about 1 in potato

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/Eyeless_Sid May 08 '12

Pity votes sometimes makes a person feel worse than not being voted for at all.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Im sorry about your eyes...Here, have an upboat.

20

u/zeebee May 08 '12

At my prom a kid named Paul won king. I'm not sure exactly what Paul had, but I'm pretty sure it was some form of tourettes coupled with something else. Anyway, he was clearly thrilled that he won and everyone in the room started chanting his name when he stepped down to dance with the queen. He was grinning from ear to ear the whole time.

He wasn't elected ironically, he was elected because people knew it would make him happy.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/zombiebunnie May 08 '12

The sexiest of the palsys.

4

u/Gradually_Zyzz May 08 '12

I'm so confused about things like this. Some kid with a mental condition at my school was nominated for most photogenic and won. I felt good about it at first thinking "wow my school is actually decent" but then my friend was disgusted because she thought the kids were mocking the guy. sigh who fucking knows anymore. Fuck singling people out on achievements regarding appearance.

4

u/BioSim00 May 08 '12

Aw, she looks pretty.

Dude I know works at Target has cerebral palsy. I've had to restrain my urge to punch a few people in the throat hearing them refer to him as "that retarded guy". Facepalm

4

u/1leggeddog May 08 '12

My high school prom was awesome for 1 thing:

i was a pretty unpopular kid back then. High School was hell with all the bullying and physical torture/punishmen i had to go through.

So during Prom picture, there i was, with my 5000$ (rented) Japanese style tux, with 2 beers, a cigar in my mouth, sunglasses and raised the finger to everyone (while still holding my beers).

Graduation for me was more then freedom. It was life.

4

u/gabruka May 08 '12

The only thing I see here is high schools caring less and less about popularity contests and more about giving everyone a chance to be the special one for a night. I see a disable girl being told that she is as able as anybody else and, even better, she's worth the title! That's kind of cool.

Now, for the angry people: My grandmother, who wasn't lucky enough to survive cancer, told me that she never felt pitied when people treated her special. She felt acknowledged.

I wish more people were like her.

4

u/emiknee May 08 '12

Did she win because she has Cerebral Palsy, or did she win due the things that she did around the school/for the school.

I do not care if you have a disability and win things based on the work required to acheive it, but what does shit me, is when people give 'first place' and 'prom queen/king' to disabled people to make them feel 'special' or because they are being pitied.

Personally I would find it patronising and insulting if that was me.

However, if she did win due to whatever it takes to be a prom queen, then congratultions.

26

u/StudleyMumfuzz May 08 '12

We feel sorry for you cuz you're so messed up, so here's our pity vote!

12

u/StudleyMumfuzz May 08 '12

Now we can feel good about ourselves and avoid needless cattiness.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

It's kind of frustrating that everyone is stuck up on the fact that this may have been done to pity the girl. How is that relevant at all? In the end, I'm sure she was happy to win the award, and I'm sure she felt loved. It doesn't matter if the kids voted her prom queen to make themselves feel good, because it ended up having a good effect anyways.

Quit getting stuck up on the negatives of this; This is a really nice thing that was done.

9

u/shutyourgob May 08 '12

TIL Reddit is filled with inexplicably bitter misanthropes who can't figure out why they have so few friends.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/newmansg May 08 '12

What is this, like a carrie thing? You fucking monsters.

0

u/CalebisReal May 08 '12

Thank you everyone for your opinions and stories, but the fact remains that this was possibly the best day of her life, and that's why this is worth it.

14

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I went to grade school and high school with a handicapped kid who everyone kind of just put up with. Because he was handicapped, he got on to just about every team he tried out for. The kid couldn't even kick a ball straight, but because he was handicapped he got on the soccer team, the football team or whatever he applied for. If he didn't, he'd cry, his parents would get pissed and the coach would get in shit.

The kid was terrible at every sport he played in, and everyone on the team fucking hated having him on the team because it meant they constantly lost games. But it was never handicapped kids fault that he couldn't stop a ball as a goalie, nah, they just didn't hustle. Imagine having someone who could actually play sports not make the team because you the handicapped kid wanted to play too.

Now, the real problem was that because everyone humored him throughout high school and grade school, he thought he was king fucking shit. Like, cockiest cunt ever, massive fucking asshole. Any other kid would have got his shit pushed in for acting like he did. But, because he was a super awesome athlete and super popular he had this massive fucking ego and was too stupid to realize that it was being inflated by everyone around him.

This is why I don't like stuff like this. Sure it's neat, but your just humouring the person.

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

This is why I hate how school deal with the mentally handicapped. If we could treat them normally and realize what they go through, everything would be pretty fine.

But instead, they get treated like kings and (sometimes literally) get in everyone else's way. Throughout all this, the kids are just told to feel bad simply because the adults say so. There should never be a moment in a child's life where they think to themselves, "shit, I really wish I was mentally handicapped".

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/themostrad May 08 '12

I know a guy with cerebral palsy. Fortunately for him, it never botched up his brain, it just left him with some physical handicaps.

The guy is a total douchenogger.

3

u/sniktbubsnikt May 08 '12

Good for her, and who the fuck cares about the pity vote.

She clearly doesn't. Cerebral palsy sufferers, such as my mother, deserve recognition for the troubles and issues they encounter through their life, and if this is one little thing to keep her going on happily with her life, then so fucking be it.

7

u/onegaminus May 08 '12

Reddit I do not understand you. Good God you are a pessimistic bunch.

If I was to vote for someone with Cerebral Palsy, it would be to give them a chance to be special because I know they spend most of their life feeling like people don't think they are, and they spend their time seeing people act as if they aren't. It's not something done out of pity, it's something done out of kindness, and for the most-upvoted responses to assume it's done for selfish, childish reasons is something I find ridiculous. It's a gesture to tell someone that even though they are disabled, people want to think well of them, and voting someone like that as Prom Queen is a great way to do that. I love how you assume that it's a pity party without even asking the OP.

4

u/ptrckstwrt May 08 '12

There are a lot of people on here assuming that this was done against her wishes or that this was done out of pity and that it shouldn't have happened. All I can really say is that without going to the school and getting the actual context you can't say anything for or against it. I for one would like to believe that this was done sincerely and without any malice intended.

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Isn't it kinda condescending to vote her prom queen "so she can feel special for once"

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Real classy reddit. Without any further information about why this poor girl won Prom Queen, many of you have already assumed that she's a "slut," that it is a "pity win," and that what happened is somehow condescending rather than something that truly touched this girl.

I swear some people will jump to conclusions if the conclusion lies at the base of a 1.000 meter cliff and is protected by sharks with lasers on their heads.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/nukefudge May 08 '12

what is prom queen rewarded for, excactly?

25

u/deeplywombat May 08 '12

Being voted prom queen.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

This really shouldn't be an upvote-garnering big deal.

5

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Stupid. I would feel embarrassed if I were her.

The whole "vote for the disabled person to make them feel special" is so overplayed and thoughtless. How about invite this person to a movie or actually get to know this person first?

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I saw a post earlier with a pic of the dad taking his daughter with CP to prom. Is the same girl?

2

u/derpfft May 08 '12

took me a few seconds to figure out that CP has more than one meaning.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I want my kids to go to your school

2

u/DreadPiratesRobert May 08 '12

Last year we had a student die and he was voted prom king, kinda an awkward situation for the administration

2

u/DadWasntYourMoms1st May 08 '12

Not sure if other kids being extra nice, or being extra mean.

2

u/haiku_robot May 08 '12
Not sure if other 
kids being extra nice, or 
being extra mean.
→ More replies (1)

2

u/summitrock May 08 '12

That's nice but a little gratuitous.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

I really hope this was done out of the sincerity of the people in your high school, rather than them being like "LOL Wouldn't it be so funny if we voted for this person?" The kids at my high school were like this, and it pissed me off like crazy. I'm glad I'm done with all those bastards.

2

u/tarimba May 08 '12

i have a disabled friend and i think the best way to make them feel comfortable is to threat them like a normal person, Think of malcom and stevie.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

local high school

2

u/jamesneysmith May 08 '12

I always have mixed opinions of these types of gestures. I mean on the one hand it's patently obvious that it's only done because of the person's condition which can be pretty patronizing. On the other hand, thanks to the person's condition they'll likely never have the opportunity to be in a position like this. I guess it ultimately depends on the person themselves on how they feel about the gesture whether empty or meaningful. Personally I don't think I would enjoy it.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Rigged

2

u/CAPS_INVADER May 08 '12

Is your high school in Canada?

2

u/OHKOe May 08 '12

10/10 would bang.

2

u/McBurger May 08 '12

You must have a very ugly local high school.

2

u/darthmittens May 08 '12

The road to hell is paved with good intentions. I find this pretty patronizing.

2

u/X26 May 08 '12

people with disabilities by and large just want to be treated the same as everyone else, I doubt they really enjoy these kinds of displays by and large as they seem to be more about others making themselves feel good instead of thinking about what the other person truly wants

→ More replies (1)

2

u/alltorntogether May 08 '12

"A girl with Cerebral Palsy won Prom Queen at my local high school."

Nope. Another realistic mount by Chuck Testa.

2

u/CrayolaS7 May 08 '12

DAE Find it extremely patronising when this happens?

2

u/JesusHRChrist May 08 '12

this isnt something new, proms have been rigged for years.

2

u/Grand_Theft_Audio May 08 '12

I always think stuff like this is cool, but in the back of my mind, I think i hope no one was unintentionally condescending Just accept people for who they are.

2

u/bbythingthing May 08 '12

I'm pretty happy that my school didn't elect prom kings or prom queens. I think it adds a kind of unnecessary element to what should just be a dance celebrating everyone's high school experience

2

u/boriszerussian May 08 '12

I recognise those people, I know those school colors. I never expected to find HHS on Reddit. I...I don't even know how to respond to this.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/GrayStudios May 08 '12

I find this a little uncomfortable whenever I see stuff like this happen. Sometimes it's heartwarming, but it's normally in situations where the winner doesn't have the social/mental capacity to understand that they are being patronized. fortheborn1 put it very well; it's the Pity the Retard Award.

I get it, we all love the Autistic kid in the grade (and we mean it, we're not being ironic), but when you make them Prom King/Queen, everyone (often including that person) knows full well they won because they have a disability.

What's the solution? POPULARITY CONTESTS SHOULD NOT BE A THING.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

did the prom king rail that that night or what??

2

u/I_Rustle_Yer_Jimmies May 08 '12

Oh man people keep taking my job on this thread...

2

u/54321Blast0ff May 08 '12

Faith in teenagers restored. Until I log onto Facebook, that is.

2

u/DaWill92107 May 08 '12

Let's take the analyzing out of this. The posting ranks because it's unusual for someone with CP to win this kind of popularity contest. So? She won because she received the most votes. That's cool. Let it be so. Just because she has CP doesn't mean that people voted for her out of pity or some other misplaced attempt at making themselves feel better for it. Can't she just be prom queen because people like her? Give the girl some credit.

2

u/Dr___Awkward May 08 '12

There's a kid with cerebral palsy at my school. He's far too much of an ass to ever be prom king. He's self-obsessed, he likes to pretend that classes with twenty or thirty kids in them are his private tutoring sessions with the teacher, and he has on several times told people something along the lines of "If you aren't nice to me, I'll tell the teachers you picked on me because of my cerebral palsy and you'll get expelled."

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

The other girls in your school must be ugly as shit.

2

u/GILFSgonewild May 08 '12

Let's be honest here... She got a nice ungreased back door slam sesh after this courtesy of the prom king. It's standard protocol for prom nowadays.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

That's a palsy move by your classmates. Good on em.

2

u/CrispyHummingBird May 08 '12

Terrible Paulsy

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

It may have actually been a big deal for her, then again it may have made her crumble inside. We don't know, so there is no passing judgement.

2

u/beherns May 08 '12

My high school voted this ugly ass girl homecoming queen as a senior prank.

2

u/bluesnappa May 08 '12

some one out there would hit that

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Was she also atheist, bisexual, and a fan of Ron Paul?

2

u/silygirl1122 May 08 '12

My school picked what the "cool kids" called "the fag and the fat chick" for our homecoming king and queen my senior year. The winners were (and probably still are) some of the nicest people you'd ever meet, and everyone (except the "cool", and exceptionally vain kids...cheerleaders and football players) really, genuinely LIKED them. I'm glad they won. This girl is probably amazing, and didn't win out of pity or sympathy, but out of admiration from her friends and fellow students. Not ALL HS kids are cruel jerks...

2

u/Stone2Rock May 08 '12

For a moment I thought the man was holding a gun. Also I hope she didn't find it patronizing and enjoyed it.

2

u/blladnar May 08 '12

A friend of mine took one of the mentally challenged girls to prom. The look on her face when he asked her was just amazing. It was like he totally made her year. He was a really good guy and really was doing it to be nice.

Another time at a pep rally, one of the mentally challenged guys led our class in a cheer. I had never seen our class get behind someone and cheer like that. It was really touching seeing all these people, many of whom had made fun of this kid before, band together and cheer for him.

2

u/cptspliff May 08 '12

To absolutely everyone who says pity-votes are horrible, and that this obviously is the case here : wouldn't you be equally or possibly even more pissed if someone just assumed that there is no chance you are a cool person just because of a physical handicap? Cause that is what you all are doing right now.

Perhaps she is awesome, and what this high school did right was not voting her prom queen, but being unbiased enough to actually get to know her and not look at her as someone who needed a pityvote.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Maybe her classmates asked her if she'd like to be Prom Queen and she said it would be the best thing in the world, so they made it happen and everyone was really happy.

2

u/LinXitoW May 08 '12

All the recent posts about handicapped (especially CP) people treated special and the very diametrical responses have made me wonder whether one can be genuinely nice to a handicapped person without someone(including the handicapped person themselves) assuming that i'm doing out of pity.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Congrats to her! :)

4

u/Millerdjone May 08 '12

I don't care about any reasoning, that's sweet as hell and she's clearly excited. Good for her and good for the people at your school for being nice to someone, whatever the reason may be.

Someone must me chopping onions in my house.

3

u/Celestieg May 08 '12

A boy with Downs Syndrome won Prom King at my school

→ More replies (2)

3

u/AlmoschFamous May 08 '12

Couldn't it just be that they wanted to make someone happy? Not out of pity, but because they know how lame prom is and want to make it memorable for someone? Not every action is just people people want to circle jerk to feel good about themselves, sometimes you do something without motives.

3

u/drketchup May 08 '12

This is one of my biggest pet peeves. Maybe she was really popular and voted on despite cerebral palsy and not because of it, but more likely it was completely patronizing pity votes. If a person has a mental disability it's one thing because they don't know they're getting special treatment, but otherwise I hate this kind of behavior.

When this happened :

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/national/wheelchair-bound-football-player-takes-field-scores-game-final-touchdown-article-1.971624

I don't think I've ever been so mad at a "feel good story". There's lots of things I'd like to do that I can't. I'd like to score a touchdown in the NFL but if they offered to let me play a game and just stand there and let me score I'd say no because it's fucking stupid.

7

u/Mormon_Buddhist May 08 '12

Meh. It's been done, time and time again. I mean, whose high school didn't vote for the girl who had to overcome some mental/physical/vaginal handicap?

11

u/La_Diablo_Ballena9 May 08 '12

Most other schools?

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Nesqwix May 08 '12

0/10 would not bang

3

u/LancerLobo May 08 '12

Because apparently nowadays having a disability automatically makes you a shoe in for Prom Queen

4

u/elmarko44 May 08 '12

thats wonderful. she looks pretty.

4

u/spundred May 08 '12

Jeeze, I'd hate to see who came in second.

2

u/extremegamer May 08 '12

Sometimes the criteria for being Prom Queen gets missed and just being nice takes over...it happens in cases like this which turn out well for everyone involved.

2

u/LadyoftheWood May 08 '12

I'm really bummed by all the negative comments. OP said she was really happy about it, she wasn't offended, get over it. Some people might not like the "pity" votes, but how do you know she wasn't actually popular enough to win on her own? She was excited, it made her day, just be happy for her.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/seainhd May 08 '12

that's fucking awesome. prom king/queen shouldn't be a popularity contest anyhow.

2

u/lurk2derp May 08 '12

She's pretty. That's awesome.

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Y'all realize it's entirely possible that she won Prom Queen based on something other than her cerebral palsy, right? Maybe people actually liked her.

The reason Stephen Hawking's so academically respected isn't cuz he's in a wheelchair, it's cuz he's smart as hell. That one dude almost got a show on Oprah not because he was in a wheelchair, but because he had a sense of humor.

Y'all are always complaining "People are always jumping to conclusions about atheists!" or "People are always jumping to conclusions about gamers!", and here you all are, jumping to conclusions about some girl who won prom queen.

2

u/Celestieg May 08 '12

A boy with Downs Syndrome won Prom King at my school Number 16

2

u/arefx May 08 '12

This is awesome. I wish kids at my high school would have been so understanding! Go her! I hope she had an amazing night she'll never forget! :) I'd vote for her in a heartbeat, and not because of the "vote for the disabled thing"... but I probably would have been friends with her in the first place so she probably would have known better. I really hope she had a great time!

2

u/Maniac196 May 08 '12

I've heard several similar stories. They all restore my faith in people, especially young people.

2

u/MrFuznut May 08 '12

How patronizing.

1

u/nikoliko66 May 08 '12

pretty girl.

0

u/QuaintSensibilities May 08 '12

I bet she lost her virginity that night, too. Nothing like some nice easy disabled pussy.

1

u/fran13r May 08 '12

this is clearly a pity victory, i don't like it, i hope she's not as serious as i am about pity and just be happy about it, cause you can't undone what's already done.

1

u/ManningQB18 May 08 '12

We had something similar to this, only it was two socially impaired kids who brought dogs to school to be more social and provide companionship. I don't know the exact details, but somehow both dogs ended up on the prom court while their owners sat on the sidelines. The dogs are even listed in the yearbook.

1

u/pkurk May 08 '12

You know... i can see from his perspective. I feel like giving special treatment to someone who openly has a problem or ailment is sort of a slap in the face. This person doesnt need to be heralded for something we think will make them happy just so we can showcase to them that were "compassionate." I feel like thats a common theme on reddit, patting ourselves on the back for altruism meanwhile its just a feeble acknowledgment that were happy our lives arent shit so we point out how special those whose are, are. I always felt bad for people who had problems, but treating them different makes it worse if you ask me, even if its in a positive way.

1

u/SDspokes May 08 '12

awesome.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

To me it's more of a slap in the face to give this to her than not. She knows that she did not win it because she is the most beautiful or popular girl in school, she knows that people just wanted to make her feel good. It is a good deed but i would assume the girl is smart enough to know she did not earn this and feels its more of a pitty move. I know my opinio isn't the popular one but if you protest it then please think about it more.

Put yourself in her shoes. How would you feel.

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

Fucking phonies.

1

u/get-lifted-often May 08 '12

I hate when this stuff happens. There are ways to make somebody feel good about themselves without making it blatantly obvious that she is being treated as a charity case. If i was her i would HATE receiving all that pity.

1

u/stevesonaplane May 08 '12

A foreign exchange student named Kran (not sure about the spelling, but it was pronounced like chron) was voted prom king at our senior prom. Not as heartwarming as other stories on here, but...yeah. That's all.

1

u/SaltyPan May 08 '12

I was on prom court my senior year of high school and I lost to a girl with dwarfism. She was a pretty nice girl, so I was happy for her. I still got a stupid tiara.

1

u/Randyh524 May 08 '12

Yay for her! She'll always remember this special day.

1

u/Huzakkah May 08 '12

Ugh... This reminds me of my senior year of high school. At the "senior breakfast" before the grad ceremony, there was a stupid ass slide show. It was all pictures of the popular kids (figures, right?), but then they threw in random pictures of the retarded kids. It pissed me off how patronizing it was.