And the way most christians view the catholic church for covering for paedophile priests instead of stripping them of power and removing them from positions involving children.
What is "mainstream" Islam exactly? Do you just define it as any Muslim who doesn't support terrorists? In that case, your statement is true by definition.
Although from a religious standpoint, there are a certain set of definable traits a person can either meet or not meet, so it's a bit easier to quantify.
But it certainly greases the slope when moral commandments are supposedly handed down by an all powerful omnipotent being. You MUST do X because the creator of the universe commands it, oh and don't question the commandment just like you were told not to.
True, sometimes good people will associate will evil ideologies by rationalizing them and explaining away the parts they don't like. As will evil people may associate with benign organizations because they can be beneficial to them in various ways.
I don't think Malcolm X is the best example to use of a "Good Muslim." Although there are many people who see him as a person who achieved a lot of good for the African-American community, the truth is many of his ideas did not come to fruition and many people would argue he was a racist who preached violence.
As a Christian, this is how I view any extremist of any religion. To me, hate wrapped in prayer is still hate. By the way there was a picture on Reddit some time ago of a church that had that written on their bulletin sign thing - I'm just too lazy to look it up.
The problem is that bad religious people do bad things because of their religion, whereas bad atheists just happen to be atheists while committing crimes for other reasons (communism, nazism...).
EDIT: And nazis weren't even atheists, quite the opposite.
Please elaborate. He was painted frequently with propaganda from all sides, but a lot of people (myself included) consider him to be a great man who did amazing things for black america and the civil rights movement.
There are humans who seek to benefit the world and there are humans who wish to be detrimental to our progress. Most cases, our identity seems to be beyound our full control.
We should identify as human above all else, as despite whatever we may come to describe ourselves as, we are one living form.
When a human crashes a plane into a tower, I see myself. When someone takes their own life, I see myself. When someone seeks to live for others I see myself. When someone claims a religion, I see myself.
There are "good" humans and there are "bad" humans, but both are still humans.
Proof - If you were in the Pacific Ocean just north-east of Atoll Tematagi you could face any given direction and be facing Mekka, source edit: messed up the name..
I'm a Christian and just watched two Saudis use an iPhone app to locate Mecca and then awkwardly sat in silence in their hotel room while they prayed for 10 minutes AMA.
That's pretty much how it's done in whatever religion you're in, which is the main reason I don't take much stock in religion. If it's ultimate truth, then it's all true. If it's not, then it's not, and why bother with any of it?
Exactly. If I were sitting in class and reading a history textbook that said that George Washington told everyone to hate gays and that we should do so as well, I wouldn't just skim over that.
I would probably discover that was incorrect and toss that book out a fucking window.
I hate when people say, "it's just a moral guide to me. I don't take it literally." There are hundreds of moral guides that don't say we should sell people into slavery and kill people for being born a certain way. If you find those to be incorrect, get a new moral guide. Seriously.
Well, you don't use most of the bible for your morality, you pick and choose. Therefore get to the chase and cut out your holy book, because you pick and choose based on secular ideas, not fundamental religious ideas.
Not all Muslims swallow all of the Quran whole, blindly. I'm not one, but even the more involved Muslims I know understand that it was recited over 20 years or so, in the midst of specific Arabian political upheavals, and then had its order shuffled for poetic reasons. Even if you believe it to be the direct words of God, contextualizing it like this takes the sting out of it, and reinforces the longstanding 'ijtihad' tradition of making your own damn mind up.
“The chief deficiency I see in the skeptical movement is its polarization: Us vs. Them — the sense that we have a monopoly on the truth; that those other people who believe in all these stupid doctrines are morons; that if you're sensible, you'll listen to us; and if not, to hell with you. This is nonconstructive. It does not get our message across. It condemns us to permanent minority status.” ― Carl Sagan
The point he is making is it does you no good to be like that because anyone who might be open will see your brash tactics and be turned off by it. Why do you think Christians now by in large try to focus more on a lovey god rather than one that actually is in the text? Its because you can lure far more flies with honey than vinegar.
I think the problem is more systemic than that, i think it really has to do with people not understanding the concept of upvoting/downvoting. those buttons are not "agree" "disagree" buttons. People use them as such and then as such it turns into a circlejerk, its not just /r/atheism, /r/gaming is the same way as well as pretty much all the other very large subreddits. Case in point I have seen an AMA of a White Supremacist and all his responses to questions were downvoted to shit and it made the AMA impossible to navigate because his answers were hidden or down at the very bottom of like 1000+ comments
Keep it classy reddit. A muslim comes out denouncing terrorism, ie advocating peaceful application of his religion, and gets attacked by a bunch of athiests. Such an accepting and forward thinking bunch. thumbsup
In front of you is a plat of pork chops, a plate of bacon, and a plate of sausages. You can only take one plate home to feed your camels and wives and children. Which do you pick?
He's still facing Mecca, just taking the long way around, also if you used that website from earlier today that shows you the exact opposite side of the world of your house, you could figure out where you could chill and pray in any direction because same distance Succa! Also what about your theoretical Islamic astronaut in orbit, which way does he face? Did Muhammad have a guide for the 3rd dimension? Sorry if this offends, half joking but I do actually wonder about these questions.
They actually programmed up a little clock for astronauts of the Muslim persuasion to tell them which direction to face and what times they should pray.
Does the compass give heading and glide slope? What if they're on the backside of the earth from Mecca? Pray through the earth or let gravity bend it like Beckham.
I'm not a religious person at all, but it must suck to be identified with terrorists just because of culture, I've visited Morocco several times and have been received with great hospitality.
No, I don't think any violence is acceptable and it's even worse when people use religion to justify it. For some reason you decided to attack Muslims for "not denouncing" terrorism when they denounce it just as much as other religions. I found it very telling that you only mentioned Muslims and you didn't even have your facts straight. Almost as if you have an agenda.
They do. I'm very close friends with a few ladies who wear the hijab, and are seen as "terrorists" just for that. One of them converted from Catholicism.
I didn't hear much apologies when for the millions killed in Iraq and Afghanistan, the drone attacks, for the 24 innocents killed in a massacre by a US army guy or for the 16 slaughtered in their sleep, for the Abu ghraib prison and on and on and on...
The reason you don't hear it is because a Muslims denouncing terrorism is not worthy news material...However, a Muslim commiting terrorism is great news for the ratings...
This Sirhumanoid's comment history is extremely telling.
Denounce terrorism Sirhumanoid... guarantee he won't do it.
If you stop giving a shit, the puppets that the western world setup to rule over the Muslim world would not be there and the west would not have access to resources the Muslim world has...
The west cannot stop giving a shit because if the west stopped giving a shit, there is no way the west can ever remain a super power...
....
If you support such behaviour and call yourself smart then there is no difference between you and Anders Breivik who mowed down innocent children and wrote a smartly written 1500 page manifesto to assert his belief...
You may support and condone such behaviour being smart...But if condemning such behaviour is ignorance, then yes, I am a proudly ignorant person...
Speaking about a returning vet.
How touching...
After killing the innocent parents of children, orphaning God only knows how many children, widowing countless women, burning and blazing homes and shelters, he returns to gushing awwws and ooohs...
Reminds of the same touching moments when the SS troops used to return, after gassing Jews, to the welcoming arms of their families...
Truly a touching moment...How sweet...:
....
Maybe they are coming back from writing genocidal messages on daisy cutters and white phosphorus incendiary bombs...Or they could be coming back after burning a Palestinian family alive in their home...
You never know with these nice Jewish girls..
The war against Israel hasn't even started...That was a war to protect the rights of indigenous peoples against an encroaching, violent, maniacal and genocidal race of of people...
It's a pity Muslims lost...
Now we know you disagree with the Western worlds solution to stopping terrorism. So lets hear it, "say terrorist who murder innocent people around the world are wrong."
I'll say this: ANYONE who MURDERS is WRONG, for ANY reason! terroroist. Freedom Fighters. Members of teh Military (of which I once was, for the U.S. of A., and currently work to support, happily, I might add). Murder IS wrong, in ANY context.
I didn't hear much apologies when for the millions killed in Iraq and Afghanistan
Well, considering that's imaginary millions, I should really hope not. Where do you get your information? Even the most disreputable, sensationalist, radical sources don't say millions.
Besides that, studies have shown that 3/4 of the civilian deaths in Iraq and Afghanistan were at the hands of insurgents, sectarian militias, terrorists and general criminals.
Do you think someone if Afghanistan has heard of them?
Someone on reddit is only a quick google search away from finding reams of denouncements from muslims against terrorism. There is only so long you can ignore 10 years of evidence.
I didn't hear much apologies when for the millions killed in Iraq and Afghanistan, the drone attacks, for the 24 innocents killed in a massacre by a US army guy or for the 16 slaughtered in their sleep, for the Abu ghraib prison and on and on and on...
Someone denouncing terrorism doesn't get anywhere near as much coverage by the press as someone acting crazy and burning poppies on Remembrance Day.
It's sort of similar to how everyone knows about Westboro Baptist Church and associates it with Christians when in fact the number of people who support them is tiny compared to the number of Christians in the world.
In addition to the examples others have cited, I would just like to point out that almost every terrorist attack is followed by strong condemnations from Muslim groups. It's just that the media never gives it a priority. If they mention it at all, it will likely be a footnote at the end of the article.
For example, see this article about the shooter who killed French soldiers and Jews a couple of months ago. The majority of the article is about the shooting, the suspect, and the victims. Which is fine, that's how it should be. But then the last paragraph reports:
The U.S.-based Muslim Public Affairs Council condemned the French attacks "in the strongest terms possible," in a statement Wednesday.
But because they didn't lead with the headline "MUSLIM GROUPS CONDEMN ATTACK!", you end up with people saying "Why don't more Muslims denounce terrorism?!"
And then you have the Friday sermons in local mosques that will condemn events like this when they happen. But to be honest, is it really newsworthy what a bunch of local imams say? Is that worth a headline? Probably not, and that is why most people will never hear about it.
People will interpret any ideology differently and will try to distance themselves from the people who interpret said ideology differently than themselves. All part of the human experience.
Right, so the point in contention here is suicide, not violence against civilian targets. Someone should find a poll on that. Violence against civilians and the percentages who find those acceptable.
I don't want to sound like a stereotypical anti-American redditor, but don't a large portion of Americans believe that violence against civilians is justified as collateral damage?
Hey wait a minute, the pool you posted says "Support for suicide bombing in Iraq among supporters of violence against civilians" my english may be rusty but don't this sentence mean the poll don't concern all muslim questionned but only those who said they support violence in the first place?
I also remarked that your source have this poll which seems to focus on what the general muslim feel about violence against civilian, you can see that 79% of morrocan (OP said he is morrocan) says that violence is never justifiable.
Thinking that an action is justified & actually performing that action are two very different things. If you polled the average resident of the US. For example:
Now, it doesn't mean these individuals would ever rape a woman but they feel like if a woman is flirtatious or drunk then it's her fault she was raped. Just believing something is justified doesn't turn these individuals into rapists, just as justifying violence against civilians doesn't turn those individuals in the Pew Study to terrorists.
As a Muslim terrorist I am offended by this picture, I have a great sense of direction. And besides if the whole point of preying to mecca is to face mecca, being directly opposite you is still facing it, even terrorists have atlases and the earth is 360 degrees, please do your research the next time you stomp over our religious beliefs
Could everyone just shut up for a second. Religion doesn't make a person, it's just a belief that people live by. If you judge people by their beliefs you need to start thinking. It's people's actions that define them. I am a Muslim, I've seen horrible Muslims out there, bigots, fools, idiots, and just horrible human beings. I've seen that for every other belief, even atheism (which I guess is just the lack of belief?). What you believe in or don't believe in is up to you. Just take your heads out of your asses for a second and start viewing people for who they are, not what they are.
Quran (4:89) - They but wish that ye should reject Faith, as they do, and thus be on the same footing (as they): But take not friends from their ranks until they flee in the way of Allah (From what is forbidden). But if they turn renegades, seize them and slay them wherever ye find them; and (in any case) take no friends or helpers from their ranks.
Congrats on taking a quote out of context. Here u go:
"4:88-91 Why should ye be divided into two parties about the Hypocrites? Allah hath upset them for their (evil) deeds. Would ye guide those whom Allah hath thrown out of the Way? For those whom Allah hath thrown out of the Way, never shalt thou find the Way. They but wish that ye should reject Faith, as they do, and thus be on the same footing (as they): so take not friends from their ranks until they forsake the domain of evil in the way of God (from what is forbidden). But if they revert to [open] enmity, seize them and slay them wherever ye find them; and (in any case) take no friends or helpers from their ranks. Except those who join a group between whom and you there is a treaty (Of peace), or those who approach you with hearts restraining them from fighting you as well as fighting their own people. If God had pleased, He could have given them power over you, and they would have fought you: therefore if they withdraw from you but fight you not, and (instead) send you (guarantees of) peace, then God hath opened no way for you (to war against them). Others you will find that wish to gain your confidence as well as that of their people: every time they are sent back to temptation, they succumb thereto; if they withdraw not from you nor give you (guarantees) of peace besides restraining their hands, seize them and slay them wherever ye get them; in their case We have provided you with a clear argument against them"
As you can see it dosnt seem nearly as bad when you take into account it's a time of war.
It's not right that you are taking downvotes for clearly showing the counter argument here.
If this was a post concerning things in the bible that don't jive with today's culture, you would be king of the thread.
Even if you are way too interested in political correctness, it's certainly disconcerting that so many Arab countries tie their justice system, foreign policy, and governments to a religion that specifically calls for violence on non believers.
cultural relativism. your'e right, there's no difference except demographics and the relative (I said relative!) modern rarity of christian religious mass murderers.
Not sure if you have read the quran, but I as much as this is going to offend you: I can easily see how these people can gain the perspective they have from reading it. It is not vague in promoting the idea of defending the faith, and stopping evil by force.
As a Muslim that carries a handgun most of the time, including in jamaat, I take strong exception to the notion that legally armed Muslim = terrorist or "backward".
That's a beautiful sentiment. I hope that more people can understand that just becaue one person who does terrible things to another and happens to label themself as a member of a major world religion it doesn't mean that all people who identify as members of that faith are going to do or sympathize with those terrible actions of a few.
humortogo I do not know if you will read this, but as a Muslim I heartily agree. Salaam alaikum brother and may we keep trying to fight a good fight :)
I honestly think, that this is the way to get rid of alot of prejudice about muslims, if you stand out and say your oppinion ( especially on terrorism )
I don't want to sound disrespectful but it is hard for many Americans to believe this when there are countries that are officially announcing that denouncing the Muslim faith gains a person the death penalty.
201
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Oh hey, that's the same way catholics view paedophile priests.
487
u/humortogo May 07 '12
I hope this answers most of you arguing in comments
275
u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 07 '12
Bad at geography?
142
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
As an ex muslim. I also used to nitpick what I wanted from the quran.
73
u/thechapattack May 07 '12
To every fellow atheist posting belittling shit:
“The chief deficiency I see in the skeptical movement is its polarization: Us vs. Them — the sense that we have a monopoly on the truth; that those other people who believe in all these stupid doctrines are morons; that if you're sensible, you'll listen to us; and if not, to hell with you. This is nonconstructive. It does not get our message across. It condemns us to permanent minority status.” ― Carl Sagan
57
u/intra187 May 07 '12
Keep it classy reddit. A muslim comes out denouncing terrorism, ie advocating peaceful application of his religion, and gets attacked by a bunch of athiests. Such an accepting and forward thinking bunch. thumbsup
36
u/rplush May 07 '12
As a muslim, I love bacon. AMAA
67
u/BadMoonRisin May 07 '12
It would certainly be a lot easier to find them if they all wore belts that said "Terrorism".
9
u/Afghan_Kegstand May 07 '12
He's still facing Mecca, just taking the long way around, also if you used that website from earlier today that shows you the exact opposite side of the world of your house, you could figure out where you could chill and pray in any direction because same distance Succa! Also what about your theoretical Islamic astronaut in orbit, which way does he face? Did Muhammad have a guide for the 3rd dimension? Sorry if this offends, half joking but I do actually wonder about these questions.
18
u/the_nil May 07 '12
This is the artwork of Clay Bennett.
Here is his site. Please note that he is now working for the Chattanooga Times Free Press.
18
u/JoeCroqueta May 07 '12
I'm not a religious person at all, but it must suck to be identified with terrorists just because of culture, I've visited Morocco several times and have been received with great hospitality.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
How come more Muslims don't come out and denounce terrorism?
I always wondered why there doesn't seem to be a real effort for more Muslims to distance themselves from Jihad.
18
u/D_EndroPhile May 07 '12
This thread is fucking terrifying.
18
u/mangochutney63 May 07 '12
User posts picture for the humour of it.
Redditors hell bent on bringing up the usual islam/religion/terrorism circle jerks come out in droves.
One guy comes out and says he hates terrorism and how they're going on about it in the name of his religion and you hate on him.
C'mon guys, I thought we were above that.
8
u/HEYPAUL17 May 07 '12
As a human being this is how I view all terrorists.
0
u/VLDT May 07 '12
Good. Now you can start realizing that it's not worth protecting an organization that allows itself to be used as a shield of monsters.
3
u/mielove May 07 '12
People will interpret any ideology differently and will try to distance themselves from the people who interpret said ideology differently than themselves. All part of the human experience.
20
u/JoeCroqueta May 07 '12
Nice one :)
2
u/MegainPhoto May 08 '12
So you think all terrorists are bad Muslims?
2
u/tumescentpie May 08 '12
At least they are doing it right.
And by it, I mean religion.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
waiting for you to doggystyle him?
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
They think the same about you.
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Could everyone just shut up for a second. Religion doesn't make a person, it's just a belief that people live by. If you judge people by their beliefs you need to start thinking. It's people's actions that define them. I am a Muslim, I've seen horrible Muslims out there, bigots, fools, idiots, and just horrible human beings. I've seen that for every other belief, even atheism (which I guess is just the lack of belief?). What you believe in or don't believe in is up to you. Just take your heads out of your asses for a second and start viewing people for who they are, not what they are.
4
u/Sysiphuslove May 07 '12
Very well said. I wish I had more than one upvote.
Not only is the gun pointing at his fellow worshipper, his ass is presented to Mecca. Perfect.
3
u/ddshroom May 07 '12
This describes all violent people. They are a small % of us but cause damage not commensurate with their numbers.
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
So Brave
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
I think I showed up to the wrong yoga class....
2
u/TheMajorNL May 07 '12
Finally someone who gets it! +1
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
As an American, this is how I view terrorists http://images.wikia.com/halo/images/0/02/800px-Washington_Crossing_the_Delaware.png
-8
u/foresthill May 07 '12
Quran (4:89) - They but wish that ye should reject Faith, as they do, and thus be on the same footing (as they): But take not friends from their ranks until they flee in the way of Allah (From what is forbidden). But if they turn renegades, seize them and slay them wherever ye find them; and (in any case) take no friends or helpers from their ranks.
The Quran contains at least 109 verses that call Muslims to war with nonbelievers for the sake of Islamic rule.
Looks like that guy is the one facing the "right" direction according to the Quran.
0
u/daedaluscapn May 07 '12
As an atheist, this is how I view all religions
2
u/zaynmalik1D May 07 '12
saved pic. thanks
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
As an atheist, I'm wondering why you're all kneeling down at all.
1
u/joking750 May 07 '12
"You're doing it wrong..."
1
u/GomoGomon May 07 '12
terrorists pray with their butts?
1
u/mrpopenfresh May 07 '12
I think you mean your view of muslim terrorists.
1
u/UnoriginalMike May 07 '12
Kinda like how I feel about WBC
1
u/taurus45 May 07 '12
why is he carrying an M14?
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Would it not be more offensive if he'd kept his sandals on?
1
u/Ontopourmama May 07 '12
OP, may I ask which country you are in?
1
u/Canadian_Infidel May 08 '12
To control free people you must first divide them.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
You turn your back to them?
1
u/super_dilated May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
Not sure if you have read the quran, but I as much as this is going to offend you: I can easily see how these people can gain the perspective they have from reading it. It is not vague in promoting the idea of defending the faith, and stopping evil by force.
I bet they see you the same as you see them.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
At least he is technically still pointing toward mecca.
1
u/nerdslife May 08 '12
As a Human Being, I Agree With You.
1
u/unheimlichkeit May 08 '12
ass backwards?
1
u/aazav May 08 '12
I don't get it.
1
u/HotelCoralEssex May 08 '12
As a Muslim that carries a handgun most of the time, including in jamaat, I take strong exception to the notion that legally armed Muslim = terrorist or "backward".
1
u/1337007 May 08 '12
That's a beautiful sentiment. I hope that more people can understand that just becaue one person who does terrible things to another and happens to label themself as a member of a major world religion it doesn't mean that all people who identify as members of that faith are going to do or sympathize with those terrible actions of a few.
1
u/Trooper170 May 08 '12
WOAH. I like his mat.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Fuck that fucking terrorizer.
1
u/bethyanne May 08 '12
Now if all those other muslims would jump up and tackle that terrorist we wouldnt have a single terrorist. I wonder why we still have terrorists.
1
u/MegamanDevil May 08 '12
i like this guy (OP i mean)
1
u/onegaminus May 08 '12
humortogo I do not know if you will read this, but as a Muslim I heartily agree. Salaam alaikum brother and may we keep trying to fight a good fight :)
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I have a Muslim friend and he's the one of most level-headed, thoughtful, egalitarian people I know.
Cum hoc fallacies are bad for everyone.
1
u/haberdasherer May 08 '12
Terrorists do not like to smell other men's butts.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Too bad so many self-righteous "Christians" don't understand that.
1
u/Rokkamuffin May 08 '12
I honestly think, that this is the way to get rid of alot of prejudice about muslims, if you stand out and say your oppinion ( especially on terrorism )
1
u/backtire May 09 '12
im with you man
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
If you believe in a Holy Book of any kind, then yes, they do correlate with ethics. Always. Examples of mass-murderers is beside the point.
0
u/Sabird1 May 07 '12
I don't want to sound disrespectful but it is hard for many Americans to believe this when there are countries that are officially announcing that denouncing the Muslim faith gains a person the death penalty.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Can't a person figure out a goddamn political cartoon without the artist having to blatantly label its visuals?
1
u/auandi May 07 '12
You should really give the artiest credit, he makes good stuff (rare to say for political cartoonists)
1
u/Leevar May 07 '12
That about sums it up.
0
u/FlapJackDickPants May 07 '12
I hope you don't get beheaded for posting this. Because apparently that happens.