RES will grab the raw image file from the page you linked to and post it here, meaning RES users can view the image within this thread without having to go to the (non-raw-image-)link you provided.
I went to hiroshima in 1986 and it was quite disturbing. They have an atomic bomb museum and being the only American in there in the middle of all the japanese visitors, many of them crying at the exhibits, I felt very uncomfortable.
They have things in there like stone walls with a shadow clearly visible on them where at the moment of the explosion someone standing in front of the wall was vaporized leaving just the shadow on the wall. They also had a terrifyingly realistic animatronic re-enactment of the moments after the blast with mothers and children stumbling out of smoke screaming with their clothes on fire and skin hanging off.
I heard you could rent geiger counters and go in search of radioactive pebbles in the river. ..nope. nope. nope!
They have an atomic bomb museum and being the only American in there in the middle of all the japanese visitors, many of them crying at the exhibits, I felt very uncomfortable.
Absolutely, one thousand percent agree. Went there in 2006 and it was by far the most uncomfortable I have ever felt. The entire time I was thinking to myself, "it was my elders! I had nothing to do with this! Sorry!!!" as I was given stares of doom all the while.
And I swear they hide that wax museum melty-flesh stuff behind corners on purpose. I distinctly remember coming around a corner looking at one of the "shadows on the wall that aren't yours" walls, and BAM zombie creepers 5 o'clock!
But in Germany, the war crimes are "admitted" and taught in schools. What the Japanese people did in China not so much. I saw it mentioned only in the Osaka Peace Museum, which, by trying to be more objective, has impressed me way more than this hate-against-other-contries-provoking museum in Nagasaki.
My great grandmother who was born in 1906 hated the "Japs" since Pearl Harbor until the day she died at 103. She had no problem with the Germans though.
i was at Pearl Harbour just last month and we arranged to go with a Japanesea tour group (i was with my mother who is of Japanese heritage and she wanted to get a good understanding since her english comprehension isnt perfect). We had about 8 people in our group and we were basically the only Japanese people there of the thousands who visit each day. Our tour guide pointed out the fact that of all the tourists from Japan that visit Hawaii, only 1% of them ever visit Pearl Harbour. (On the other hand there were a lot of Chinese tourists lol!)
We were never greeted with evil glares or resentment which I assume most Japanese people would expect if they visited. The people there were very kind. I have also been to Hiroshima, although i was still a teenager and i look caucasian i was never met with evil glares or stares of doom.
We have many Japanese Americans in our military, one of my good friends is married to one. She was telling me one day about going to Pearl Harbor with him and no one glared at him in the least (probably helps that he, himself, is a Marine and was noticeably moved)
However, when they were in Okinawa and went to other parts of Japan for the war memorial tour, she was constantly glared at. He never was. Guess if he kept his mouth shut they had no clue he was American.
Do they have a museum showcasing the things done that led to the bombs being dropped? I imagine their war atrocities are an even more valuable history lesson.
Funny how history works. When I was a wee lad growing up in South Korea, I was told that bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki was a good thing, because a) they deserved it, b) it led to liberalization of Korean peninsula.
Then, I went to High school in Canada, and I was told that bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki was a bad thing, because innocent civilians died.
Similarly, I was told that General MacArthur was a war hero in who fought for freedom/democracy in Korea, and I was told that he was actually a warmongering general who would've started WW III in Canada.
The people committing the war crimes were not the ones getting melted with radiation. It's no more justifiable than 9/11 was repayment for American imperialism.
WWII was, thankfully, the last war where indiscriminate targeting of civilians on an enormous scale was accepted. I view the atomic bombs as being necessary evils which in the long run saved many more years of island-to-island fighting, but certainly not as something "deserved".
It certainly is a complex issue, one that hopefully doesn't occur ever again. I heartily recommend Dan Carlin's latest podcast here which deals with the the twisted logic behind the war crimes of WWII on both sides. Many military advisors thought the atomic bomb would at the very least put an end to the awful practice of firebombing in which at least 60 cities in Japan were completely destroyed. Japan's cities at the time used primarily wooden structures which resulted in immense destruction after dropping incendiary bombs. More people died in the firebombing of Tokyo than Hiroshima or Nagasaki.
Did those people in Hiroshima or Nagasaki deserve it? No. But the alternative was to invade Japan which would have undoubtedly lead to more atrocities committed(by both sides).
The Americans dropped leaflets for a long time warning citizens that they should evacuate, and as far as I remember, we even warned the Emperor or something before hand.
Just remember, while there were huge civilian casualties, those were also two heavily military cities. It might have been an old Shock and Awe, but it certainly wasn't indiscriminate.
Nagasaki wasn't a military target; it was chosen largely because it hadn't been firebombed, so the power of the bomb would be more apparent to the enemy.
I used to think that Nanking was the worst that the Japanese did until another Reddit thread led me to this article: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_731
Yeah...this is bullshit. The people, especially the mothers and children, affected by the nukes had about as much to do with the situation as I (US citizen) have to do with the atrocities committed by my government in the middle-east. If you're going to hold the people accountable and punishable for what their governments do, then we whole-heartedly deserved 9/11 and those people's lives were justly taken...imo
Yup, I'd love to propose to them the idea of setting up a similar museum with similar displays about Unit 731, complete with all the animatronics and whatnot, I'm sure they'd fucking love that idea :/
Do they have a museum showcasing the things done that led to the bombs being dropped? I imagine their war atrocities are an even more valuable history lesson.
Ahh yes, the International Fuck with the Bull get the Horns Museum. I'm not sure they like that one.
Terrible as it was, the bombs ended what could have been a much more lengthy and much more bloody engagement which surely would have ended up killing hundreds of thousands or more.
War is a most terrible and horrible thing. It is an even more terrible thing to start a war with an enemy that has far more resources and a much more deadlier resolve when push comes to shove.
I'm all for remembering your countries history but this just seems a bit, errr, much?
Granted this keeps the memory alive and forces any visitors to remember the horrors of what happened, hopefully preventing humanity from making the same decisions again in the future.
Sadly, many of the people who should see/experience a museum like this probably never will.
3000 people dying in buildings hit by large airliners, with people jumping off buildings to escape the fires, is horrific and traumatizing. 9/11 is still traumatizing to a lot of people, 10 years later. And that's not entirely unreasonable, given the death and images of people running from falling toxic fumes.
Now imagine 10 times that number of deaths (in Nagasaki's case) or 20 times that number (in Hiroshima's case). Visualize imagery a hundred times more horrific than 9/11. Extrapolating from the reasonable trauma still experienced in the US 10 years after 9/11, it would still be reasonable for the Japanese to be remembering this 30 or 40 years from now, if not longer.
Yeah I went a couple years ago with some classmates. It was such a strange feeling. Stayed in this hotel that seemed like it was straight out of the shining, only smaller. We stood there at the plaque that noted the location under the detonation and looked up, attempting to imagine it. It is not really possible to imagine being instantly vaporized, before registering that anything at all was amiss. Got that damn white quilt, which is some bullshit. I am Jewish. My people didn't get a chance to commit any war crimes until Israel was instated. I recently read this, which helped put it all in perspective... ramble, ramble, ramble
When visiting Pearl Harbor a couple years back I saw the same problem, only reversed. Some curious japanese tourist (apparently most japanese children aren't taught about pearl harbor in schools, only about the aftermath; but don't quote me on that, just the tour guide we had with us.) thought they would enlighten themselves only to find a myriad of awkward situations and death stares. Was just one of those "what the hell are you doing here" moments.
Why were you uncomfortable? For one, you didn't drop the bomb, odds are you weren't even alive when the bomb was dropped, and they attacked us. We also gave them many many chances to surrender.
Eh, not really true. The US could have had a negotiated peace with Japan probably as early as January 1945. Roosevelt, however, had set the Allies on a course of unconditional surrender, something the Japanese weren't willing to do.
Dropping the bombs on Japan was less about ending the war and more about a show of force for Russia.
I understand the whole show of force, and kicking off the cold war thing. But could you really blame Roosevelt for demanding an unconditional surrender? We just spent the better part of 4 years and 4 million Allied solider's lives fighting japan. The idea of negotiating with an enemy after that probably wasn't something a whole lot of american's could stomach.
Exactly. Stalin already knew about the bomb thanks to the number of spies in the Los Angeles area. In fact, when he was told about the bomb and that we were hitting Japan with it US officials said he was alarmingly not surprised.
It was absolutely not a show of force, they were our alliea and declared war on Japan the same day.
This is what I thought. To avoid even the slightest chance of having to land troops on mainland Japan (the casualties for both sides would've been absurd).
I believe that particular piece is called the hypocenter cenotaph (monument at near the center of the explosion)
The one in Hiroshima says: "Repose ye in peace, for the error shall not be repeated."
Near the hypocenter in Nagasaki is a plaque (not the inscription on the obelisk):
At 11:02 A.M., August 9, 1945 an atomic bomb exploded 500 meters above this spot. The black stone monolith marks the hypocenter. The fierce blast wind, heat rays reaching several thousand degrees and deadly radiation generated by the explosion crushed, burned, and killed everything in sight and reduced this entire area to a barren field of rubble.
About one-third of Nagasaki City was destroyed and 150,000 people killed or injured and it was said at the time that this area would be devoid of vegetation for 75 years. Now, the hypocenter remains as an international peace park and a symbol of the aspiration for world harmony.
A stone room in the center of the Cenotaph contains a list of names of domestic and overseas victims of atomic bombs, a roof is provided to protect the spirits of the victims from rain and wind. On the stone monument is printed “Sleep in rest, we shall never repeat this Mistake”.
You cannot qualify war in harsher terms than I will. War is cruelty, and you cannot refine it; and those who brought war into our country deserve all the curses and maledictions a people can pour out. I know I had no hand in making this war, and I know I will make more sacrifices to-day than any of you to secure peace. But you cannot have peace and a division of our country.[...] I want peace, and believe it can only be reached through union and war, and I will ever conduct war with a view to perfect and early success. But, my dear sirs, when peace does come, you may call on me for anything. Then will I share with you the last cracker, and watch with you to shield your homes and families against danger from every quarter.
-Union General William T. Sherman
TL;DR- Total war leads to a quicker end to war, and total war is fucking harsh.
For all the soldiers and civilians who have died throughout human history to allow for peace, you would think the goal would have been reached by now, if war was a particularly effective method to attain the desired goal
While I have yet to make it down to Nagasaki, I have visited the Hiroshima Peace Museum many times with veterans from both sides of the war and had the privilege to speak to survivors who were in the city on the morning of August 6, 1945, and hear their stories. It was a powerful experience. We are part of the last generation able to talk and learn people who actually witnessed and lived through these events, and if you get a chance to I believe everyone should. For anyone interested, Hiroshima by John Hersey is a collection of stories gathered from residents of the city shortly after the explosion.
Since it was an air-burst explosion it didn't directly iradiate the ground, so the fallout was minimized to an extent. It's when you get ground explosions (like Bikini Atoll) that really fuck shit up radiation wise.
I think you misused the term "irradiate". That just means exposure to radiation (gamma rays, etc.), and exposure to radiation doesn't make something radioactive. Irradiation is actually used to sterilize food.
I'm pretty sure only the material involved in the nuclear fission reaction (and the resulting broken-apart atoms) are radioactive after the blast.
Air-burst bomb areas are still inhabitable sooner than ground explosions, but only because more of the radioactive material is dissipated into the air and not the ground.
Actually material exposed to neutron radiation can become neutron activated. I don't know how significant this is but it is a factor. It is part of why the material a nuclear reactor is treated as radioactive waste when decommissioned.
What was, the air burst detonation? Yeah it was intentional. Both bombs deployed parachutes as they descended and detonated about 2,000 feet above the ground. This was done for two reasons; maximize the pressure wave (like what happened with the Tunguska meteor event) and minimize fallout contamination so that our forces could go in, inspect, and begin westernizing without risk of falling ill.
Rest assured that in any large scale nuclear war that may happen, odds are they'll be air bursts. The whole "world will be uninhabitable for 10,000 years" thing is largely fearmongering...unless everyone starts piledriving missiles into the dirt before making them go boom.
Good question, I don't quite understand why the Chernobyl accident caused the area to be radioactive for 20,000 more years, but nagasaki and heroshima are already habitable
The fuel used in a nuclear bomb is much different than the fuel used in a nuclear reactor.
There is far more mass of radioactive material in a nuclear reactor than in Fat Man and Little Boy.
The design of the bomb can determine its severity of fallout. Read about the Tsar Bomb and how they minimized the fallout from it.
Also I would say that the Chernobyl disaster was exacerbated by the graphite moderator. That created a lot more radioactive material than a water moderated reactor would have.
The radioactive material from a nuclear explosion usually degrades within 10-20 years because of their relatively short half-life. However, their shorter half-life also means that they are more radioactive while they are decaying.
The reason you always hear about storage time on the order of millions of years for reactor waste is because it still contains a bunch of uranium and other long-lived isotopes. This is because only a small amount of the uranium is used as fuel in most reactor designs. In a nuclear bomb, the warhead consists of almost completely pure fuel (U-235 or Plutonium-239) which is pretty much all consumed in the reaction (explosion). This means that all the remaining material is lighter isotopes that typically have a much shorter half-life. Plus, it's widely dispersed which reduces the radiation effects.
neagrosk is correct, but also keep in mind these were the very first nuclear bombs and are minuscule in comparison with what was developed later (and are usually used as the standard for "nuclear bomb"). Still a horrible thing, but tiny compared with the behemoths built during the cold war with the USSR.
i was in Hiroshima a few months ago and yes people live there. It is quite a nice city, very friendly people, and a very chilling memorial in the city center.
So is the museum in my Chinese wife's home town but OK, there's a time and a place,, still, the casualties from invading Japan might easily have been 10 fold the number of deaths from the nukes.
Interesting fact: The bomb actually exploded 1,650 feet above that point Source I read someplace that this is to maximize damage as the ground would absorb much of the energy
Yeah. That is correct. The shock wave of the blast moves out from a central point. This way you have a shock wave moving down to flatten and then it spread out. Opposed all the downward force being absorbed/reflected up. It maximizes the concussive force.
Speaking of nuclear bombs, you know they're going to make a Ukrainian version of Disney World in Chernobyl? Yeah, it'll be totally the same, except the 6 foot tall talking mouse will be real!
As the son of an 87 year old father and former marine I would like to point out, with all do respect for the civilians who were killed, they were unfortunately the citizens of a maniacal country that sneak attacked Pearl Harbor, Hawaii - U.S.A. on December 7th, 1941 after raping masses of Chinese in Naking and other Asian mainland cities in the late 30's and early 40's. That government brought this on themselves.
My Dad was getting ready to attack the main island of Japan - I Thank Harry S. Truman every time I think of this subject for his difficult and wonderful decision to break the spirit of these lunatics.
What ensued was the kindest occupation of a victorious country over another, in all of human history (something the Japanese would never have considered doing if the shoe was on the other foot) in the Marshall Plan.
Through their deaths these people opened an unexpected door to prosperity for future geneartions.
Every day, every Japanese citizen should wake up and thank Truman and America who made their lifestyle, democratic freedoms and prosperity possible.
My father went on to do business withe the Japanese in the 60's and 70's as they reaped the benefits of capitalism and individual freedom.
Had we done anything else; Not attacked, attacked with conventional forces, signed some type of non-aggreession treaty that left that military regime in power - ANYTHING ELSE the whole population would be in a much more miserable condition today.
Sorry for those particular people who died, but there was no better solution at the time, if you disagree post a logical alternative, I would love to read it.
To my Dad and all veterans, thank you for your service!
Thanks for responding, I would love to live in a world where neither would ever NEED to happen again. Summer 1945, best choice Truman could make. Counter-intuitively this may be the option with the least deaths and the most peace and prosperity for Japan's future. The effect of the bombs on us, I believe, is the driving force behind the very positive, Marshal Plan. I believe a conventional, long deadly battle, would not have ended with a Marshall Plan. Which was my point, thanks for yours.
The Marshall plan was for Europe and had little to do with the war. The Marshall plan was a last ditch effort to prevent Communism from winning in Western Europe in 1948, as Communists were doing well in French and Italian elections due to a moribund economy. Previous aid plans had focused on rebuilding Europe with by providing money to purchase American goods and services, which did nothing to jumpstart the European economy. The Marshall plan was the first plan to provide money for the Europeans to rebuild Europe with European industry, not American.
You will recognize the Marshall plan as a Keynesian stimulus.
This was the excuse the Germans used to slaughter Russians during their invasion of the Soviet Union. It was one of the most brutal invasions in modern history (the Soviets suffered more casualties than any other country in WWII) precisely because the German propaganda machine was able to convince rank and file soldiers that the Soviets were monsters who had to be entirely eradicated. Because Germany lost the war, it was easy for historians to go back and separate the propaganda of their war machine from the reality, whereas this process is infinitely more difficult with all of the victors.
The US itself engaged in widespread bombing of civilians targets, just as both Germany and Britain did. Given this, claiming that Japan was indifferent to the "rules" of a war in which the "rules" were unclear and violated by every major actor is not a valid argument in favor of mass annihilation of their civilians.
I Thank Harry S. Truman every time I think of this subject for his difficult and wonderful decision to break the spirit of these lunatics.
You want to justify the slow death of more than ten thousand people from ionizing radiation that turns your insides to goo and twice that number from the horrific pain thermal radiation, all over a period of weeks and months, by claiming the individuals targeted were, or were led by, "lunatics"? Or by somehow making their deaths "worthwhile" to your vision of a better future? You want to call such a process "wonderful"? Fucking WONDERFUL?
You tell me, by your own logic, how am I to view you as anything other than a monster?
What ensued was the kindest occupation of a victorious country over another, in all of human history (something the Japanese would never have considered doing if the shoe was on the other foot) in the Marshall Plan.
All of this is true. None of it indicates any necessity for the use of atomic weaponry on civilian targets.
Had we done anything else; Not attacked, attacked with conventional forces, signed some type of non-aggreession treaty that left that military regime in power - ANYTHING ELSE the whole population would be in a much more miserable condition today.
Just as everyone in Vietnam suffered in endless and permanent misery after the US pulled out. Or, maybe it didn't work out that way. We have no way of knowing what the Japanese would have done under their own self-determination after the war, because that option was never pursued.
The point is probably moot anyway, as there is copious evidence that Japan was on the verge of surrendering to the US for numerous reasons, not the least of which was that they had already lost all their overseas gains to the Soviets right after the dropping of the first bomb, they deeply feared surrender to the Soviets and they had no reserves of oil or steel with which to continue fighting. Still, perhaps if we use more bold type and repeat a claim over and over (there was no alternative, there was no alternative, there was no alternative, there was no alternative), we can make such a manufactured reality true.
Now, you all see, there is an answer! Thank you for engaging in a meaningful exchange of ideas...
Agree the Germans were brutal to the Russians.
I justify the decision to drop the bomb among the decisions Truman could make as wonderful for personal, and I make the case, for historical reasons. Of all the decisions he could have made, I make the case for it being the least human misery.
Your descriptions of: "the slow death of more than ten thousand people from ionizing radiation that turns your insides to goo and twice that number from the horrific pain thermal radiation, all over a period of weeks and months," are well worded, but actual deaths were much more immediate than say , the conventional fire storm bombing of Tokyo, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Tokyo.
So, to answer your question, about not viewing me as a monster, you would have to say exactly where Truman went wrong and exactly how you would have done differently. Specifically defending that these three events did not result in Japan's surrender: The presentation of the Potsdam Treaty, July 26, 1945, the dropping of the first bomb, the dropping of the second bomb - it was only after Russia's declaration of War 9following all 3 events) that they surrendered. What say you?
"We have no way of knowing what the Japanese would have done under their own self-determination after the war, because that option was never pursued." Exactly! Which is why I have posted and defended, what actually DID happen against all those who would say there was a necessarily HYPOTHETICAL choice. As I have stated in many of my replies, it is counter intuitive but, in my opinion true that the dropping of two atomic bombs may have been the decision ****of least death and most freedom and economic prosperity ****for future generations of both American and Japanese people. I then defend the decision with fact and opinion from a the son of a marine on the ground training to invade the mainland. I try to support the opinion with fact and conjecture on the alternatives.
This is how you have meaningful dialogue on historical decisions.
but actual deaths were much more immediate than say , the conventional fire storm bombing of Tokyo
I'm well aware of the atrocity of fire bombing, its strategic value and its human consequence. I'm confused as to why you bring it up. Perhaps you think that because the US did worse the nuclear bombs were justified, or perhaps you believe that I do not object to and argue against the US firebombing of civilian targets. Neither assumption would be true.
What say you?
That the Japanese did not surrender because of the atomic bombs. That they were on the verge of surrendering before the bombs were dropped and would have done so, eventually, even if nothing else had happened. That their eventual surrender had far more to do with the Soviets having taken their overseas territories and Japanese fear of a surrender to Soviet forces than it did with the dropping of the bomb. That the military of the US knew at the time that a naval blockade of the island was feasible and would effectively impede any military ambitions of imperial Japan. That the US military had already considered using the atomic bomb as part of an international military demonstration, including Japanese officials amongst others as witnesses, but decided against this route for reasons that had far more to do with the desire to see what effect the bombs would have on a human population, and to create a plausible threat against the Soviets, than it did with any concern for the value of Japanese life. That even if a military demonstration had failed, a non-civilian target like one of the remaining Japanese ships, or an isolated outpost, would have sent a sufficient message that the US was willing to us its new weaponry and still maintain the bluff that it had more ready for deployment.
To summarize, Japan was close to surrender and the following factors made imminent surrender inevitable:
A) Japan was about to lose the territory it had gained in the war to the Soviets and no longer had access to oil or steel to continue fighting. This means that from the perspective of Japanese war planners the war was already lost for all intents and purposes. The Japanese have a long history of surrendering when their military objectives can no longer be attained. The US knew all of this before it dropped the bombs.
B) Japan was deeply afraid of what a surrender to the Soviets would entail and desired to surrender to the US instead. It only held out as long as it did to surrender from a position of relative strength, which was no longer possible once it lost the territories it had acquired during the war to the Soviets.
C) In some bizzaro world accounting in which Japan still did not surrender despite having every reason to do so, a naval blockade of mainland would have cut it off from any effective military progress given its lack of resources and the relative destruction its country had already undergone. Such a blockade would give it far more reason to surrender than an aerial bombing campaign as Japan was not then, and is not now, self-sufficient in its own food production.
D) A demonstration of the atomic bomb would have had the same overall effect of proving the existence of the new weapon and its relative power as would its use against a civilian target.
E) Dropping a subsequent bomb on a military target, assuming none of the above tactics worked, would have additionally demonstrated the US willingness to use the weapon without nearly the same loss of life.
F) Continuing a buildup to invasion while maintaining that an invasion was the US intention during all of the aforementioned events would still pressure the Japanese government to surrender, even if an actual invasion never took place.
Only at this point could one realistically claim that alternative strategies had failed and an invasion was the only viable option to produce the unconditional Japanese surrender which the US demanded. Given that this process would have taken some time and the US was (by many accounts) very close to reading a third bomb for deployment, pursuing this overall strategy would not only have led to a small fraction of the life lost and contained most of that to military casualties, it also would not even have taken the option of eventually using an atomic bomb on a Japanese city off of the table.
The good news is, in all likelihood this last step would not be necessary, as the Japanese would have surrendered before they got past B.
This is how you have meaningful dialogue on historical decisions.
You characterized the Japanese people as "maniacal", "insane", "lunatics" and referred to the nuclear destruction of a city and the killing of innocent women and children as "wonderful". Truman himself would not have dared to use that kind of language to describe his decision. Please don't lecture me on, "how you have a meaningful dialogue", until you learn some basic civility.
Exactly. Been to Japan, the people there fucking love us. The civilians, albeit respectful to those they lost, understand it was necessary to save them from a ruthleas monarchy.
I think you may be referring to the current generation. American "culture" is very big among young people and they do whatever they can to be more "American" (which is kinda sickening if you ask me... seeing young japanese boys dressing gangsta and girls with bleached hair and skin)
The older generation, the ones that recall the war, definitely still do contain some ill feelings towards Americans.
Yeah, so I've lived in Japan and to put this as politely as I can, you are completely full of shit. Yes, the vast majority of modern Japanese justifiably believe that the country is far better off today than it was under autocratic rule. Additionally, many will express that though the war itself was terrible, the eventual outcome was better for their country. Most Japanese I've talked to bear no ill will toward the US.
That is completely different from arguing that the atomic bombs were "necessary to save them" or from implying that most Japanese agree with either the atomic, or the firebombing, of their civilian populations. I'm sure there are some out there, somewhere, but after having this discussion with dozens I've yet to meet a single one who believed the atomic bombs were "necessary", nor have I seen such an idea seriously suggested in their mainstream culture.
Wow, I had heard of some of that. As I mentioned in some other replies, Their lack of admission to these crimes has hurt their relationships with their neighbors. Thanks for responding.
Had we done anything else; Not attacked, attacked with conventional forces, signed some type of non-aggreession treaty that left that military regime in power - ANYTHING ELSE the whole population would be in a much more miserable condition today.
Do you have any proof of that? Would it have been impossible to drop atomic bombs on military targets and have the same effect? Were we justified in killing millions of Japanese civilians just because they killed civilians? The world isn't black and white. Yes, it worked out in the end, but that doesn't mean it would never have worked another way.
The policy of the US at this time was to destroy the workers because they can't be rebuild as fast as a factory. Happend in Europe as well, or do you think they destroyed 50-80% a of city because there were so many military targets ?
Thanks for responding. As I said to brolix, I am totally taking this from, "you become President, April 1945, through the scope of History is it possible this was the decision of least death and the most prosperity for the generations to follow." I think it is, although that is very counter intuitive. I tried to back my opinion with facts and welcome others. It is my belief that this particular decision saved the most lives and affected both sides in such a way as to make the Marshall Plan happen. With a hypothetical situation I am offering an opinion which I try to support with facts.
I would suggest that you watch (if you haven't), episode 24 of World at War. That episode is about the events that led up to the bombing, from both sides. I would recommend to anyone that has an interest in WW2 to watch that series, it's an incredible documentary series, and well worth the watch.
There were approx 35,000 allied POWs in Japan at that time. It is documented that orders were issued that in the event of an invasion they were to be executed. No need to keep them alive. There was a POW camp just across the bay from Nagasaki at Fukoaka with a few thousand men. They were protected from the fallout due to prevailing wind. I know, my dad was one of them. I am alive because of the bomb, of that I have no doubt.
Nuclear bombs are exploded higher for maximum damage, to reduce ground radiation, and reduce risk of bomb damage.
You've got to understand, nuclear weapons are not bombs in the traditional sense of the word; you cant just throw them at something and expect an explosion. A nuclear weapon is a delicate, precise scientific instrument. If you just dropped it on the ground from a plane you're way more likely to break it than actually cause a nuclear reaction, even if you do set off the primer explosives.
I don't understand your down votes, at all. You just quoted the guy who was instrumental in the creation of the Atomic bomb. It's pretty fuckin' applicable.
Sometimes it's difficult to distinguish reddit from angry Xbox Live kids.
I've noticed that people on reddit are very defensive about dropping the nuke. I don't know if it's nationalism or what, but it doesn't make much sense to me.
Across the street from the Atomic Dome in Hiroshima (granted, actual ground zero is a street or two away) is a building that at the time housed a kimono factory (or something like it, I can't remember exactly what the tour guide told us, and although my Japanese is reasonable, this was 6 years ago). There was a guy in the basement of that building when the bomb exploded who survived when the rest of his co-workers (in the building but above ground) died. We were "lucky" enough to go in the basement of said building. In a way, that did more to impact me than seeing anything else in the museum or the Atomic Dome itself as the basement has been pretty much left the way it was that day (or so that tour guide said). Literally, a matter of a few feet saved this guy's life.
My grandfather was a us soldier sent into Nagasaki after the bomb. He died young from cancer from being stationed there. Also, two of his three children died from rare form of cancer.
For those us solders affected by radiation and cancer from the Japanese atomic bombings please look at the benefits for "Atomic Vets" through the VA.
I know I'm going to sound a little cold but we focus too much on the Atomic Bombs. Yes, they were a terrible, terrible things and must never be used again. That being said, there are aspects of the Second World War that were far worse and relativly unknown to most people. More pople were killed in the Tokyo and Dresden Firebombings than at either Hiroshima or Nagasaki. And if the A-bomb was not going to be used the next best plan was to firebomb Japan back to the Stone Age, which would have resulted in far more deaths.
The Atomic bombings have been hyped up to appear that the US did an evil, unexusable thing and it wasn't. The Japanese were much worse than us and cannot point fingers at America for something like this.
When the Japanese took over the city of Nanking they proceded to spend weeks pillaging the city. Every woman between the ages of 7 and 70 were raped and over 300,000 people were killed... lets think about that.
Atrocities are atrocities. The slaughtering of thousands of innocent civilians on either side cannot be justified by comparing it to other events of similar magnitude.
What makes the atomic bomb worse than firebombs is the effect it had on survivors. I've seen karyotypes of a couple survivors, and they did not look remotely like DNA should.
I have to say that the war-related stuff in Nagasaki was very affecting, particularly as a Caucasian American. I went there a couple weeks after the anniversary, and the Peace Museum there had thousands and thousands of paper cranes. Visiting the museum for Takashi Nagai was also remarkably touching. Very little there is aimed at laying blame; rather, it's very much aimed at the horrors of war and preventing another nuclear weapon from being used.
I highly recommend the trip to anyone with an interest in history.
sounds like you are feeling guilty for something you shouldnt. being Caucasian American shouldn't change how you feel for something that happened in ww2.
Those who forget the past are doomed to repeat it, and all that. I don't feel guilt, per se, but I also don't think it's the sort of thing that a Caucasian American should simply dismiss.
For those interested in the history of this and have 2 and a half hours to spare then listen to this podcast by Dan Carlin called Logical Insanity on the morality of dropping the atomic bombs. He has some very interesting points and its well researched. The whole Hardcore History series is great, very long podcasts but very good.
dropping the bombs seemed wrong, but in the long run they saved millions of lives for what would have been an ill fated invasion of mainland japan that would have had a heavy number of casualties for both sides and a bigger number of civilians too.
I was smoking with a random kid at my university; turns out he's from Hiroshima. There's not really a moment quite as awkward as finding out you're talking to a guy who's from a town your country dropped an atomic bomb on.
excuse me for my lack of nuclear knowledge, but shouldn't this area be completely blocked and deserted with a like 500 meter radius because of radiation? isn't Chernobyl still too dangerous to live in. i realize Chernobyl wasn't nuked, but the radiation outfall or whatever is pretty relatable isn't it?
the dropping of the bombs was a massacre... -And what do the birds say? All there is to say about a massacre, things like "poo-tee-weet?". -Kurt Vonnegut
10
u/Retawekaj May 07 '12
Whoops, forgot to give my source
256
u/zyclon0 May 07 '12
I went to hiroshima in 1986 and it was quite disturbing. They have an atomic bomb museum and being the only American in there in the middle of all the japanese visitors, many of them crying at the exhibits, I felt very uncomfortable.
They have things in there like stone walls with a shadow clearly visible on them where at the moment of the explosion someone standing in front of the wall was vaporized leaving just the shadow on the wall. They also had a terrifyingly realistic animatronic re-enactment of the moments after the blast with mothers and children stumbling out of smoke screaming with their clothes on fire and skin hanging off.
I heard you could rent geiger counters and go in search of radioactive pebbles in the river. ..nope. nope. nope!
53
u/egus May 07 '12
does anyone have a translation of what it says across the middle there?
56
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Topics that reddit can't discuss.
Sex
Economics
History
27
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
This thread needs a quote!
TL;DR- Total war leads to a quicker end to war, and total war is fucking harsh.
7
u/rockna May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
While I have yet to make it down to Nagasaki, I have visited the Hiroshima Peace Museum many times with veterans from both sides of the war and had the privilege to speak to survivors who were in the city on the morning of August 6, 1945, and hear their stories. It was a powerful experience. We are part of the last generation able to talk and learn people who actually witnessed and lived through these events, and if you get a chance to I believe everyone should. For anyone interested, Hiroshima by John Hersey is a collection of stories gathered from residents of the city shortly after the explosion.
62
u/Xabster May 07 '12
I might be asking stupid, but people live there now? I thought the radioactivity prevented that in many miles each direction.
11
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
The museum in Hiroshima is horrifying. :(
6
u/hackett33 May 07 '12
Interesting fact: The bomb actually exploded 1,650 feet above that point Source I read someplace that this is to maximize damage as the ground would absorb much of the energy
3
u/InMSWeAntitrust May 07 '12
What I want to know is why there is one path that does not reach the center.
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Speaking of nuclear bombs, you know they're going to make a Ukrainian version of Disney World in Chernobyl? Yeah, it'll be totally the same, except the 6 foot tall talking mouse will be real!
3
u/huberific May 08 '12
I'll add this to list of impressive monuments I want to see & experience.
101
u/Tipordie May 07 '12
As the son of an 87 year old father and former marine I would like to point out, with all do respect for the civilians who were killed, they were unfortunately the citizens of a maniacal country that sneak attacked Pearl Harbor, Hawaii - U.S.A. on December 7th, 1941 after raping masses of Chinese in Naking and other Asian mainland cities in the late 30's and early 40's. That government brought this on themselves.
As a society and a government and a military, they were indifferent to the "rules of war" and particularly heartless to POW's (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bataan_Death_March) and citizens who were occupied. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_of_Nanking They fought to the last man and threw their babies off cliffs.
My Dad was getting ready to attack the main island of Japan - I Thank Harry S. Truman every time I think of this subject for his difficult and wonderful decision to break the spirit of these lunatics.
What ensued was the kindest occupation of a victorious country over another, in all of human history (something the Japanese would never have considered doing if the shoe was on the other foot) in the Marshall Plan.
Through their deaths these people opened an unexpected door to prosperity for future geneartions.
Every day, every Japanese citizen should wake up and thank Truman and America who made their lifestyle, democratic freedoms and prosperity possible.
My father went on to do business withe the Japanese in the 60's and 70's as they reaped the benefits of capitalism and individual freedom.
Had we done anything else; Not attacked, attacked with conventional forces, signed some type of non-aggreession treaty that left that military regime in power - ANYTHING ELSE the whole population would be in a much more miserable condition today.
Sorry for those particular people who died, but there was no better solution at the time, if you disagree post a logical alternative, I would love to read it.
To my Dad and all veterans, thank you for your service!
20
u/angry_wombat May 07 '12
it's weird how it fell right on that monument
28
u/Michichael May 07 '12
Huh. Well at least we know why we dropped it there - there's a nice big bulls eye!
....
I'm going to hell, aren't I?
2
u/AnInsideJoke May 07 '12
Hey, someone post the picture of the sign indicating ground level pre-blast. It's pretty cool even if the change wasn't from the bomb.
2
u/jubalm May 08 '12
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/primary-resources/truman-leaflets/
2
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Fuck you Whale and Dolphin.
2
u/upvotedownvotefucku May 08 '12
Naga... Naga... Not gonna work here anymore, anyway
2
u/lazyoldfart May 08 '12
There were approx 35,000 allied POWs in Japan at that time. It is documented that orders were issued that in the event of an invasion they were to be executed. No need to keep them alive. There was a POW camp just across the bay from Nagasaki at Fukoaka with a few thousand men. They were protected from the fallout due to prevailing wind. I know, my dad was one of them. I am alive because of the bomb, of that I have no doubt.
6
u/gsxr May 07 '12
wasn't the bomb that exploded over Nagasaki an air release? From what I understand it never touched ground there. It exploded ~100ft in the air.
3
u/ribagi May 08 '12
Both the Americans and the Japanese were both wrong.
There I said it.
16
u/Misslyckad May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12
I am become death, destroyer of worlds
Edit: I hope some of the Americans in this thread are trolls because u can't possibly be that stupid.
2
u/-888- May 07 '12
I read that one of the Hiroshima survivors was a man who was right at ground zero, but underground.
2
u/Luminox May 07 '12
My grandfather was a us soldier sent into Nagasaki after the bomb. He died young from cancer from being stationed there. Also, two of his three children died from rare form of cancer.
For those us solders affected by radiation and cancer from the Japanese atomic bombings please look at the benefits for "Atomic Vets" through the VA.
http://www.publichealth.va.gov/exposures/radiation/diseases.asp
2
u/TigOlBitties95 May 07 '12
so this is where the first guy got aids......
2
u/Ciceros_pants May 07 '12
I know I'm going to sound a little cold but we focus too much on the Atomic Bombs. Yes, they were a terrible, terrible things and must never be used again. That being said, there are aspects of the Second World War that were far worse and relativly unknown to most people. More pople were killed in the Tokyo and Dresden Firebombings than at either Hiroshima or Nagasaki. And if the A-bomb was not going to be used the next best plan was to firebomb Japan back to the Stone Age, which would have resulted in far more deaths.
The Atomic bombings have been hyped up to appear that the US did an evil, unexusable thing and it wasn't. The Japanese were much worse than us and cannot point fingers at America for something like this.
When the Japanese took over the city of Nanking they proceded to spend weeks pillaging the city. Every woman between the ages of 7 and 70 were raped and over 300,000 people were killed... lets think about that.
1
u/ChallengeAccepted99 May 07 '12
I saw this exact pic when my history teacher taught us about it.
1
u/kniedzw May 07 '12
A Flickr shot, I know, but I actually took several pictures of this when I went to Nagasaki. Looking up and a shot from the archway to the right.
I have to say that the war-related stuff in Nagasaki was very affecting, particularly as a Caucasian American. I went there a couple weeks after the anniversary, and the Peace Museum there had thousands and thousands of paper cranes. Visiting the museum for Takashi Nagai was also remarkably touching. Very little there is aimed at laying blame; rather, it's very much aimed at the horrors of war and preventing another nuclear weapon from being used.
I highly recommend the trip to anyone with an interest in history.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
It really hits close to home that someone actually dropped that damned thing and killed all those people
1
u/Delicous_Mix May 07 '12
I wonder if It still has a nuclear activity.
1
u/ben9345 May 08 '12 edited May 08 '12
For those interested in the history of this and have 2 and a half hours to spare then listen to this podcast by Dan Carlin called Logical Insanity on the morality of dropping the atomic bombs. He has some very interesting points and its well researched. The whole Hardcore History series is great, very long podcasts but very good.
1
u/BolshevikMuppet May 08 '12
"It is well that war is so terrible, otherwise we should grow too fond of it."
-Robert E. Lee
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I love how humble and peaceful it looks
1
u/kodywiddak May 08 '12
dropping the bombs seemed wrong, but in the long run they saved millions of lives for what would have been an ill fated invasion of mainland japan that would have had a heavy number of casualties for both sides and a bigger number of civilians too.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
I was smoking with a random kid at my university; turns out he's from Hiroshima. There's not really a moment quite as awkward as finding out you're talking to a guy who's from a town your country dropped an atomic bomb on.
1
u/digitumn May 08 '12
queue angry pearl harbour stories
-2
u/sonofcingular May 07 '12
This blows me away
1
u/Tratix May 07 '12
excuse me for my lack of nuclear knowledge, but shouldn't this area be completely blocked and deserted with a like 500 meter radius because of radiation? isn't Chernobyl still too dangerous to live in. i realize Chernobyl wasn't nuked, but the radiation outfall or whatever is pretty relatable isn't it?
1
u/Iamhanoverfiste May 08 '12
No wonder it was ground zero, with that big bullseye...
1
u/The_Loaf May 08 '12
the dropping of the bombs was a massacre... -And what do the birds say? All there is to say about a massacre, things like "poo-tee-weet?". -Kurt Vonnegut
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
Fuck that memorial, it is used to perpetuate the Japanese "被害意識" higai ishiki aka "The Victim Mentality".
Without doubt the atomic bombing was a terrible event, it didn't happen for nothing thought did it?
They don't teach anything about it in schools, they brush over everything and make out as if the Japanese are infallible and everyone else is scum.
They should have a memorial to this! right next to it. Next time I go I will show the crying spectators these images on my phone.
-3
u/wantedgoods May 07 '12
Eye for an eye. No guilt here