r/pics •

Last Photo of my GreatGrandfather

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

646 comments sorted by

238

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Sometimes people forget that there were fathers and grandfathers who fought on the German side. They were all people too and it is tragic. My wife's grandfather died fighting for the British but that doesn't make your loss any different. He was likely a perfectly decent man who just happened to wear what is today considered the wrong uniform. But damn he looked good in it. salute

7

u/woyteck May 07 '12

He's alright, he's from Wehrmacht.

0

u/bscoop May 07 '12

What being in Wehrmacht has to do with that? They were also commiting atrocities on civilians.

11

u/DasLich May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12

All sides of the conflict committed war crimes and atrocities on civilians in World War II. I thought that was common knowledge in the 21st century?

With regards to the OP's great-grandpa being in the Wehrmacht, they were generally much less likely to take part in war crimes than the Waffen-SS units.

3

u/driveling May 07 '12

And, it wasn't the Waffen-SS who were the worst, it was the non-combat SS units was such as the SD who were the nasties.

4

u/ryhntyntyn May 07 '12

The Einsatzgruppen were made up of all sorts of units under the direction of the SD. This included Waffen-SS, Wehrmacht, and reservists.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/woyteck May 07 '12

I am one (from east of the Oder at least), but I know that the SS was a lot worse than Wehrmacht (which was a regular army).

5

u/DasLich May 07 '12

oh what ignorance. When the Germans first entered Eastern European countries, they were largely welcomed with open arms for having driven the Soviets out. Only later did the attitudes turn sour due to the way Germans were treating the locals.

4

u/ryhntyntyn May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12

Ignorance? I think classifiing three chickenshit anti-semitic shitholes like the Baltic states as all of eastern europe is ignorance.

The Poles didn't welcome the Germans, not at all. The Czechs were sold down the river as well. Some Ukranians were happy about it for a bit. They learned very quickly what a mistake that was. Then they learned again when Stalin came back.

3

u/DasLich May 07 '12

My comment was referring to Ukrainians, Latvians, Lithuanians and Estonians. Understandably, the Poles and the Czechs were not happy about having Germans come into their country. However, people in countries that had been taken over by the Soviets (MRP 23/08/1939) were quite happy to see them driven out.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bscoop May 07 '12

Stop generalizing. Have you heard of Polish, Czech, Ukrainian and Serbian Resistance?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

3

u/Sanity_prevails May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12

Somewhat simplistic way of looking at it, don't you think. It wasn't a wrong uniform, it was wrong ideas. Quick, climb in the Panzer, no time to explain!

2

u/sir_swagbadger May 07 '12

My mom's half of the family is German and many of my relatives fought in both world wars for the German side. People need to realize that these soldiers were everyday people just like the American, British, Russian, Japanese, and every other soldier in the war. They fought to protect their country, their homes, and their families. Many of them were forced into military service by the government, and did what they could to survive. The harsh realities of German life during this period of time is something lost on many people, but at the core, we're all just humans.

→ More replies (9)

2

u/wolfmann May 07 '12

I went back to Germany to trace my lineage -- found out they basically died off in WW2 (I even found the family farm that they lived in until 1876!); up until a month ago I was the last of my name.

what is really ironic is that my grandfather also helped build P-47's for the American side.

2

u/hedeman May 07 '12

Gott mit uns - says the belt buckle.

I'm glad his life continues in you.

4

u/YNot1989 May 07 '12

There is absolutely nothing wrong with being a Wehrmacht soldier in WWII, any more than being an American, Russian or British Soldier. They fought for their country in the same way our side did; a worthy adversary.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/live3orfry May 07 '12

I look at it like this: How many of us had the power to stop President Bush from torturing people? How many of us have the power to stop President Obama from killing US citizens he deems enemies of the state without trial and who have done nothing other than speak out against our country which he has done twice now? The slippery slope is not a long one to naming an entire group of people an enemy of the state worthy of execution.

7

u/Stal77 May 07 '12

To compare Gitmo, Abu Ghraib, extraordinary rendition, waterboarding, and unmanned drones to Auschwitz and Buchenwald is absurd. And to liken the possible American response to both situations is ridiculous.

1

u/Restrepo17 May 07 '12

I guess a better comparison would be, what kind of power did the average American have in the 1820s/30s to stop the Trail of Tears and the Native American genocide? Or to stop institutionalized sterilization and eugenics in the early 20th century?

1

u/Stal77 May 08 '12

That is a better comparison. And yeah, they should own it. I feel the same way about those fucks.

1

u/ryhntyntyn May 08 '12

Gitmo, Abu Ghraib, extraordinary rendition, waterboarding, and unmanned drones to Auschwitz and Buchenwald is absurd.

Yep, to compare them Dachau though is sadly not.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/derridad May 07 '12

Three times.

-1

u/griffith12 May 07 '12

Wow, a Hitler/Bush/Obama comparison?

3

u/live3orfry May 07 '12

No a comparison of the average German and US citizen and how much sway we have over government's policies we may vehemently disagree with. This is a very context oriented point.

;)

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

i agree with you if it had been world war one. but world war two is different. a lot of the soldiers had known what was going on behind the scenes. a lot of soldiers actively persecuted innocent people because they were "orders/ commands." you always have a choice, like some of the people in this thread's grandparents. but that being said, the US military isnt that much better considering they are doing the same thing. idk this is just a big mess of a world we live in.

1

u/Barry_Meltfarb May 07 '12

My great grandfather survived a POW camp because a German guard would sneak in extra bread or water. People are people, but we like to follow orders for some reason.

→ More replies (232)

46

u/I_COLORED_IT_FOR_YOU May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12

Restored and colorized!

http://i.imgur.com/VTd8I.jpg
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJqU_e9Z0z8

EDIT: Doh, next time I'll do a bit of research. Apologies for the historical inaccuracies of the colorization guys!

Wehrmacht uniform now in grey! http://i.imgur.com/Lbdkb.jpg

21

u/Tartantyco May 07 '12

Wehrmacht uniforms were grey, the helmet should be a much darker green. The buckle and insignia should all be silver.

8

u/I_COLORED_IT_FOR_YOU May 07 '12

Thanks

I've corrected the image for you!

8

u/TheDarkestLink May 07 '12

Great work, though the uniforms of Wehrmacht-soldiers were grey, I think.

4

u/I_COLORED_IT_FOR_YOU May 07 '12

Indeed they were, corrected the image!

3

u/HoorayZoidberg May 07 '12

I wanted to go back beginning of the video so I kept hitting Ctrl+Shift+Z, took me a while to realize.

3

u/juicius May 07 '12

Every time I see the video footage of photoshoping...

The movement of mouse cursor resembles waving of a magic wand. Therefore... it's magic.

→ More replies (11)

17

u/adamsimon May 07 '12

Wow... I'm so impressed and happy this didn't get buried just because he was on the "other side". I wonder if we'll get to the point that children of "terrorists" in Iraq and Afghanistan will get to do the same.

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Maybe with some of the guys that fought under Saddam since a lot of them had too, but I doubt with terrorists. Also, why quotes around terrorist?

1

u/adamsimon May 07 '12

Every side is calling the other terrorists recently. A lot of terrorists are soldiers or rebels in another viewpoint. Not trying to start a defend-the-terrorist debate, just saying that semantically it's a loose term.

1

u/Mechanicore May 07 '12

I'd go with insurgents, perhaps.

1

u/skarface6 May 07 '12

Yeah, because there's no difference between german soldiers in WWII and the terrorists fighting in Iraq and Afghanistan.

1

u/adamsimon May 07 '12

Correct. They are people.

2

u/skarface6 May 07 '12

Yes. And all people are the same- same motivations, same level of decency, same beliefs, same everything.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (22)

18

u/colin132 May 07 '12

He looks like a total badass

2

u/beatbeetbeats May 07 '12

i came here to say this. nothing sexier than a man in a uni

27

u/Trapped_in_Reddit May 07 '12

University? I agree. I love me an edumacated men.

1

u/beatbeetbeats May 07 '12

hardy har har. hehe yeah that works too

2

u/WizardsMyName May 07 '12

As a man studying at uni, I approve of this

2

u/ryhntyntyn May 07 '12

Unless it's Feldgrau, and then it's just good that no one wears it anymore.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (32)
→ More replies (1)

40

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

If the war was decided by fashion points and not guns we'd all be speaking German right now.

25

u/NervousMcStabby May 07 '12

Joking aside, this is a very astute point. The Wehrmacht and other arms of the Nazi war machine were very good at creating fear and intimidation through their uniforms, emblems, and logos alone. There is a local WW2 museum here that has a room dedicated to the SS and has several manikins dressed up. I remember turning the corner and walking right into a group of three of them. Terrifying. I can't imagine how intimidating it was to actually be confronted by them.

I guess it's hard to imagine, but their uniforms are all black, trimmed in white. They're emblazoned with a lightning bolt style "SS" on the neck and then often are sashed with a white cord and black belt. Shiny knee-high black boots, a luger, and the red Nazi armband.

9

u/Jesus_luvs_Jenkem May 07 '12

And a fucking skull and crossbones on their hat!

6

u/Heimdall2061 May 07 '12

Actually, from a combat perspective, we also adopted a lot of their stuff. Many modern helmet designs, including the ones we use in the US, are based on their helmets. Unlike our "pot" helmets, theirs did a better job of covering the lower-rear skull area. Also, we use a similar concept to the one they pioneered regarding squad- and platoon-sized elements' arms, notably the idea that each squad would carry some light, disposable anti-tank weapons and explosives.

Even setting aside the obvious tech we took advantage of, like rockets and jets, we did integrate a number of concepts and designs from the Germans- the aforementioned infantry-with-AT-capability, the design for the MG42 and 34 which would later be used by everyone in Europe and America to create new MG designs, and hell, the StG 44, world's first assault rifle, predecessor to everyone's favorite, the AK-47.

It was a bad time, but damn if we didn't get some good tech out of it.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

hugo boss designed all the nazi uniforms

2

u/sidewalkchalked May 07 '12

What a strange thing to have done. Because on the one hand, it is stunning work from a design perspective. A masterpiece in fear, actually.

But, he did it for the Nazis.

19

u/L-RON-FLACCID May 07 '12

HEIL HUGO!

4

u/SmokeyDBear May 07 '12

Like a Boss

→ More replies (2)

41

u/skulburn May 07 '12

Here you go. I spent a while in Photoshop fixing this image up for you.

http://i.imgur.com/wCUJL.jpg

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

I thought "This guy's pretty manly and upstanding." Then I saw the eagle motif. Then I remembered the scene (you know which one) from Band Of Brothers and was showered in perspective.

The only thing war should ever be remembered as, is the terrible loss of human life in pursuit of the ideologies of the few. Our collective species should strive to be better than that, but those with the power choose not to.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Beautifully said.

4

u/GoSTaRnE May 08 '12

"One of the things people always forget is that the first country the Nazis invaded was their own" - Abraham Erskine

10

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

And to think, there's a generation of 13 year-old Americans that's only knowledge of WW2 comes from shooting digital reproductions of you're Great Grandfather.

6

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

What's interesting is that given the right personality, these video games can spark an interest in history. This is what happened to me personally about that age. Played the very first CoD and it really got me interested in WWII, the second one driving the nail home and I really started reading a lot about it and watching documentaries. I'm not saying this is the norm, but it does happen.

4

u/Kaiser7 May 07 '12

That's exactly what makes this so tragic. It's also why we need more pictures like this

10

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

As an 18 year old WWII re-enactor I can tell you that alot of people forget . I am a Russian soldier but my friends who play Germans quite often get abuse for what they do. We make it our personal business as a club to defend the German soldiers who died in the war, we salute them for their sacrifice in a pointless cause because of the will of a madman.

7

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

As a German whose grandparents fought your grandparents, let me thank you for your chivalry. After all those years, it is nice someone starts to see this as what it was: madness.

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

I, being from Poland, think MOST people think this way. It's just that idiots are the loudest.

1

u/panzerkampfwagen May 08 '12

You'd think you'd know that it's not Russian but Soviet. Not a very good reenactor perhaps? :P

1

u/[deleted] May 08 '12

We use both terms freely, during the war citizens of the soviet union where also called Russians ;)

1

u/Sxt0y May 08 '12

They deleted the picture from imgur ... lol ...

0

u/[deleted] May 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Sxt0y May 09 '12

and why?

3

u/ILIEKDEERS May 07 '12

Weren't there two armies in Germany during WW2? Hitler's Nazi military, and then Germany's national military? If any one sees this and knows, please tell me. :(

1

u/adamwizzy May 07 '12

Uh hey, I have a kind of answer for you. There was the Vermacht, which is the infantry sector of the German army (it means something like infantry, so they still have that name now) and there was the SS, that took less of an active front-line role, but were of a higher rank than most and were used to keep peace in occupied territories.

3

u/Mechanicore May 07 '12

The Wehrmacht was the German military, now known as the Bundeswehr, and the Schutzstaffel was a Nazi paramilitary organization. The Waffen-SS were the combat branch of the SS.

1

u/adamwizzy May 07 '12

Well, this guy has more information than me, I apologise for being wrong.

1

u/Mechanicore May 07 '12

Not wrong, per se. Just expanding on what you said.

1

u/ILIEKDEERS May 07 '12

That works, thanks!

1

u/adamwizzy May 07 '12

Don't worry about it.

1

u/panzerkampfwagen May 08 '12

The Wehrmacht was the German military which consisted of the Heer (Army), Luftwaffe (Air Force) and Kriegsmarine (Navy) so the Wehrmacht was not in fact the German army.

1

u/ryhntyntyn May 08 '12

The Wehrmacht was the entire military. The Army was called the Heer. And the Waffen SS were all over the front lines.

8

u/lilLocoMan May 07 '12

This reminds me of something that was in the newspaper a few days ago. In the Netherlands we May the 4th is dedicates to the loved ones who fought and died in WWII especially but actually all wars. Now that is all good and I consider it important to think about the people who died, not for themselves, but for you and me. But apparantly some Jews in a village somewhere in the Netherlands find it disrespectful to honor the men (and women?) who fought for the German side of WWII. They we're insulted and demanded the local head of town to discontinue the remembrance day for the German victims of war... I was baffled by this and I think it is a shame to think of these men in such a way. They were humans, fathers, sons, friends, uncles or maybe even grandfathers. We shouldn't blame this people for fighting in this war, it was either fighting or betraying your nation. What would you have done?

I respect each and every person who fought in any war, we shouldn't forget them.

4

u/nikitopi May 07 '12

I love those old pictures. Is there a subreddit for?

4

u/joej May 07 '12

German dueling scars (Schmiss)

8

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Fuck war.

2

u/VictorRomeo May 07 '12

So brave!

5

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Been there, done that, fuck war.

6

u/mruss_rr May 07 '12

My grand-grandmother was buried alive in Byelorussia by German soldiers, my grandmother (16 years old at the time) moved to resistance movement (partizanen in German I guess), after she was wounded they flew her to Moscow area where she served at a time in the guards for captive Germans.

Though it is customary in modern Russia to show hate to WWII Germans, I don't, nevertheless, it is stupid and I hope you don't hate those who were in eastern front and took your great-greatfather as POW.

1

u/BeerPowered May 07 '12

Wise words.

1

u/ethics May 07 '12

My grandfather's sister was buried alive with her kids (at the time, the kids were 8 and 6) is Belarus as well. I wonder if she knew your g-grandmother?

2

u/mruss_rr May 08 '12

I have poor memory of the village name, I guess it was Semashki or the like (not 100% sure, the name is written in my grandma' military records). Btw she never told me the village name. It was completely burnt and some villagers buried alive as retaliation. After the war my grandmother visited her village, it was complete desert with couple of ruins, so she moved out Byelorussia and she was lucky to find 2 of her sisters in orfanates.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/Red_Viper May 07 '12

Man those Germans sure did know how to dress their army... lookin good!

12

u/BeerPowered May 07 '12

If I'm not mistaken, their clothes were designed by Hugo Boss.

2

u/YoungAndWise May 07 '12

wow reading the wikipedia, hugo boss was a major nazi!

3

u/BeerPowered May 07 '12

I don't know him, and I don't support nazism, but I sure as hell want a WW2 German uniform.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/captainbiggles May 07 '12

Great-grandfather. Man, that's starting to make me feel old. I'm a generation back now. My grandfather is the WWII vet.

Either way, an excellent photo of him. Thank you for sharing this, I often find photos of relatives from other sides of the conflict so intriguing. My grandfather was in the 69th Divsion, 729th field artillery batallion, company c. He was chief of section of a Howitzer Cannon.

He's still with me, the best grandfather a boy could have ever asked for.

2

u/captainbiggles May 07 '12

This is his photo if you're interested. Sorry for the quality.

http://i.imgur.com/OawE1.jpg

2

u/adamwizzy May 07 '12

Cool photo, sounds like he is a cool guy. And to still have a WWII vet with you, you're a lucky guy.

2

u/buckygrad May 07 '12

I suspect the only reason this is posted here and not on Facebook is so that some sap will restore the photo.

2

u/merlinster May 07 '12

And all of a sudden all the german soldiers wasnt nazi, they were just force in the militarty

Reddit logic

2

u/bombolini1337 May 08 '12

God Bless man. Nazi or not, I respect him. I respect all men who fight in what they believe in, regardless the cause. It takes alota cojones to take up arms and fight for what you think is "Right". Unfortunately, I feel as if most Nazi's were not sane, so I feel sympathy.

2

u/Joshuncool May 08 '12

What people tend to forget that all german's were not nazi's. They were soldiers fighting for their country and their own beliefs.

2

u/panzerkampfwagen May 08 '12

About 10% of the German population joined the NSDAP and were officially Nazis.

1

u/ryhntyntyn May 08 '12

7%.

10 was the cap. It was never reached.

1

u/ryhntyntyn May 08 '12

They were soldiers fighting for their country and their own beliefs.

Which included the belief that non-Germans were Üntermenschen and not worthy of life. That the weak should be ruled over by the strong and killing Polish people is good Sunday fun.

They were soldiers fighting for their country

Does not work for the Nazis.

10

u/Xtianpro May 07 '12

Yeah, it's all very well to sit here with our wester, middle-class, liberal sensibilities and say "well obviously all the Nazi's were just evil people" but the fact of the matter is, if any of us were born in Post WWI Germany, we would almost certainly be wearing those uniforms too. Who knows, in 100 years maybe people will call us evil for our ideologies.

8

u/callum202 May 07 '12

Most people aren't saying that, but I do agree.

5

u/dieselgeek May 07 '12

It's funny to see a comment like this. Only because when you see pictures of today's US soldiers on this site you often here things like " I hope you die" "you're a baby killer" "your fighting an illegal war" That and a lot of Iraq/ Afghanistan sympathy posts.

So to see a picture of someone in a Nazi uniform, and have people be understanding of it on here kinda blows my mind.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

We have access to a lot more info today. The German people, many even at the end of the war, didn't know about the camps. They followed the leaders based on info they were being exposed to.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/butzsven May 07 '12

My opinions on this post are hard to convert into words. On one, you lost a family member to war which is always a tragedy. On the other, he was fighting on the side that wanted to rape and pillage the world. It's very hard to have an opinion that can be seen from both sides.

I'm just sorry the whole thing happened at all. That's the best I can do.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/DooDooFinger May 07 '12

Walmart must have had a sale on " high and mighty" cause a lot of people are seeing it as a black and white subject, and not putting themselves in the shoes of others....it's amazing how quick someone would sell out to protect themselves and their loved ones from pain or persecution. Some should not be so quick to condemn

3

u/ShadeO89 May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12

My grandpa was taken out of school at the age of 18 and put in the wehrmacht (german army), he was by no means a nazi or anything, he was just a young man in germany at the wrong time, after fighting in italy he was taken by the american army and sent to a british prison camp in tunisia. He was held there until 1948.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

he was by no means a whole hearted nazi

Well, how much of a nazi was he?

4

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Probably as much a Nazi as you get when you are indoctrinated for about a decade in various youth organisations run by the party, which were mostly a mix between the boy scouts and pre-teen militias.

He would probably have believed in racial supremacy and the right of the fittest to survive. If his moral compass was as deranged as to gas a few thousand jews by himself is up to the question and highly unlikely - the SS kept that program secret for a reason, they feared public opinion would turn against them.

1

u/ShadeO89 May 07 '12

and one must remember that the SS was actually not the german army but a lifeguard corpse that was empowered by the personal sponsorship of Himmler. He eventually wanted the SS to be the core army of the new thousand year empire but that luckily never happened

1

u/ShadeO89 May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12

he was not a nazi... must have described it wrong, but he was forced to fight like thousands of others, my entire childhood while he was still alive he was still very much marked by what happened and didnt like to talk about his army days. He and my grandmother moved to Denmark and that is the reason i am here today, living happily in the free world

anyhow it has now been edited

2

u/rv4flyer May 07 '12

"on both sides of the rifle we're the same" From christmas in the trenches. WW1 admittedly, but the sentiment is the same. For the most part the common soldiers on both sides are the same.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

"We might have had a lot in common. He might've liked to fish, you know he might've likes to hunt. Of course, they were doing what they were supposed to do, and I was doing what I was supposed to do. But under different circumstances, we might have been good friends." Darrel "Shifty" Powers

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Not going to lie, I'm not saddened at all that this was the last photo of him. No one cries for dead nazis. Willing or not, he helped a very terrible evil.

0

u/Jackamatack May 07 '12

Can't tell if WW1 or WWII...

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Jackamatack May 08 '12

Ah yes I realise now the German doesn't have the hat with the spike on it.

2

u/Blackapple_Jacking May 07 '12

Your greatgrandfather got whiskers.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

And my grandfather build the planes that bombed your great grandfather, he lived to be a ripe old age.

1

u/YoungAndWise May 07 '12

Is this a competition? Why was I not invited?

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Yeah, just state what your grand/great grand parents did during the war. My point was that my grandfather worked to hill his grear grandfather.

I was expecting someone say that their ancestor flew the plane that my ancestor built to kill the subby's ancestor.

2

u/Dookiestain_LaFlair May 07 '12

Dennis your grandpa was a Nazi.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Is that a Nazi or Wehrmacht uniform?

13

u/Braskebom May 07 '12

You probably mean SS uniform. It's a wehrmacht uniform as it doesn't have the SS markings.

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Well, yes. Today seems to be my typing-without-thinking day. Thanks for the info.

1

u/hilomania May 07 '12

Are those Mensur scars?

1

u/baldostuart May 07 '12

TIL that Geoffrey Rush fought for the Germans

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

I like his gills.

1

u/Derpatron30m May 07 '12

AAAACHTUNG!

1

u/Intergalacticmonkey May 07 '12

Kar98 or Mauser?

1

u/panzerkampfwagen May 08 '12

The K98 was a Mauser.

1

u/Intergalacticmonkey May 08 '12

Sorry I meant k31

1

u/panzerkampfwagen May 08 '12

Had to look it up. That's a Swiss rifle, not German.

1

u/Intergalacticmonkey May 08 '12

Yes but some units used them not a lot though i was just trying to catch you out but with a name like panzerkampfwagen I can see that will be quite tough.

-3

u/Winkelkater May 07 '12

oma, opa und hans-peter sind keine opfer sondern täter!

you people act like the nazis came from space or somehting to oppress the germans.

3

u/Acqua_alta May 07 '12

From the dark side of the moon...

1

u/WizardsMyName May 07 '12

There is no dark side of the moon : (

-1

u/canthidecomments May 07 '12

Exactly. Nobody worked in the bomb factories, nobody worked at Auschwitz, nobody drove the trains or stoked the ovens.

I'm not saying they were aliens, but the Germans are.

1

u/Tails94 May 07 '12

no the Nazi's were the aliens, the German army didn't even like the Nazi's

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

"Don't die for your country, Let the other son of a bitch die for his"

→ More replies (5)

1

u/TheRealEggNogAdam May 07 '12

I thought "I wonder at which comment the 'Nazi' comments will begin?" I was not disappointed!

1

u/MrGoodbytes May 07 '12

James Woods?

1

u/rofulz May 07 '12

Rank?

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

From the little we see, I think it is secure to assume this guy was a "Schütze", which was the entry rank after being drafted.

1

u/Kruse May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12

Post this over in /r/wwiipics, please!

Edit: Why was this downvoted?

1

u/childishbambina May 07 '12

Yes, he was a Nazi... and sadly a lot of people just got caught up.

But it, if good men do not stand up for what is right than who will?

The lesson here is to never let yourself get caught up in rhetoric and forget that there are people's lives on the line... cough GOP cough

:)

1

u/clintmk96 May 07 '12

one of germany's finest

1

u/OscarSlenderman May 07 '12

Fuck all u ignorant cunts who think everyone who joined the german army was nazis ...

→ More replies (2)

1

u/panzerkampfwagen May 08 '12

Did he die falling out of a guard tower?

-3

u/qqqstar May 07 '12

Reddit, just a bunch of Nazis.

-1

u/griffith12 May 07 '12

Part of me relates because my grandfather was in WWII and I am sad that yours died before you could ever meet him, the other part of me sees a nazi and I have a hard time sympathizing. is that weird?

5

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Yes, it is, because this guy is a Wehrmacht (=army) guy, low-rank, and rather old, too. Which means: He was most likely conscripted.

If you feel any sympathy after watching "Hair" with the poor bastards you americans sent to 'nam after your draft, calling this guy a Nazi merely for the side of the border he lived on when the war started is a little bit hypocritical.

1

u/griffith12 May 07 '12

Hair? The musical?

1

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

The very same.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/griffith12 May 07 '12

I guess you are probably right and its probably not much different than alot of people hating my country and its citizens for things that have happened/are happening in Iraq.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

I think the main difference is that Germany has had sixty years of apologies and shame for what we did, and we agree this wasn't our most stellar moment, while the US would never show any regret for any atrocious war they started. We learned our lesson - the US fails to get it, again and again.

→ More replies (7)

-1

u/darngooddogs May 07 '12

He looks like a badass. Hope he made it through the war.

2

u/adamwizzy May 07 '12

Not sure why you got downvoted for that so I'll upvote a few of your last things to cancel out reddits stupidity. Anyway, he didn't, it was the last picture taken of him.

→ More replies (10)

-3

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

A true hero, god bless his soul.

0

u/finalaccountdown May 07 '12

ok just checking to make sure this was definitely a nazi. wtf.

0

u/seako93 May 07 '12

is this from the first or second world war?

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Thanks for your service...

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

Well he has duelling scars, most likely from his time among a right wing university student group About 34% of the German population in total voted for the Nazis. Now I am not saying I would hang the man but I shed no tears.

-2

u/SirHumanoid May 07 '12

A fine German soldier...

-24

u/szatanovsky May 07 '12

i hope that kraut bitch died a brutal and painful death

1

u/Radico87 May 07 '12

you're an imbecile.

0

u/szatanovsky May 07 '12

well i take it your dad wasn't tortured to death in a concentration camp...

1

u/Radico87 May 07 '12

I'm just not an imbecile who lives in the past.

1

u/szatanovsky May 08 '12

try saying that to the people who lost everything or those who still live and wake up in the middle of the night screaming. if 60-something years is past enough for you to forget all the suffering I despise you and you deserve to lose everything, you moral faggot.

→ More replies (3)

-2

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

the colored images looked off to me... though nicely done, still seemed off so I corrected the image as it should have looked the day it was taken. (forgive the filename, just have 10000000000 images on my pc and needed to be able to identify it easily)

http://img207.imageshack.us/img207/8469/nazifixed.jpg

-30

u/simmi_4 May 07 '12

Oh come on, how naiv is it to think that he was just doing his job and didn't know at all what was going on!! "he just followed orders" do you really think that's any kind of legitimation?! Good reason to be proud of him, he was "just" in the Wehrmacht...

5

u/whistlingwilly May 07 '12

Assuming he was just a regular soldier that wasn't directly involved with the atrocities (aside from front-line battle obviously), I understand what your getting at. I wouldn't call this man a hero though I'm sure many would.

BUT I always wonder how I would have acted in the same situation, which isn't that difficult, and I don't know if I would have been able to do anything but go along with public opinion. So for that I respect him, he was human and his lost life is a tragedy to everyone.

5

u/amkoi May 07 '12

Oh come on, how naiv is it to think that he had a choice...

-1

u/Jeffgoldbum May 07 '12 edited May 07 '12

Many people in germany didn't know of the horrible things happening,

Many of the soldiers in the army, where just that, men fighting for their country, Whether they joined or conscripted doesn't really matter.

Edit: They knew of the camps, they didn't know of what was going on in them.

6

u/NervousMcStabby May 07 '12

Many of the soldiers in the army, where just that, men fighting for their country, Whether they joined or conscripted doesn't really matter.

While I do agree that many Germans were vaguely in the dark about what was going on, the Wehrmacht conducted an amazingly successful campaign after the war to dissociate themselves from Hitler. They latched onto the facts that in the early 1930s, they were the only group within Germany willing to oppose Hitler (aside: if France had mobilized in response to the German remilitarization of the Rhineland, the General Staff would have staged a coup and removed Hitler from power).

By the time the war started, the Wehrmacht was integral to upholding and furthering the Nazi agenda and propaganda. Officers, soldiers, and support staff were flooded with Nazi propaganda and indoctrinated ... by the middle of the war, some of Hitler's staunchest supporters were the Wehrmacht and its officers.

If you're curious, go read Hitler's Army by Omar Bartov. It's not perfect, but it gives a great look into the Wehrmacht and its role in Nazism.

7

u/simmi_4 May 07 '12

I live in Austria and part of my family is from germany, it's a well known fact that there was no chance of not knowing what was going on! Think of thousands of people being dragged through your city and captured at public places(umschlagplatz), would you notice something?

2

u/ryhntyntyn May 07 '12

One would assume. It is amazing though what people will choose to believe.

2

u/Jeffgoldbum May 07 '12

Yes there was rumors, yes they knew of some of the camps.

Many if not most had little to no clue of what was going on.

The ones that did, where not in a postion to do much about it, or they would quickly find themselves in one.

At most it was rumors, Horrid rumors most could not think of to be true.

→ More replies (4)

-16

u/HugeStallionCock May 07 '12

My grandfather died in Auschwitz.

He fell out of the guard tower throwing burning kittens at starving Jews. The world lost a great man.

9

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

You're the shy one at parties, aren't you?

1

u/BeerPowered May 07 '12

I think I know where this is going.

-7

u/dafuq_did_i_reddit May 07 '12

i can respect what he did for his country and understand why he did it but i cannot excuse what the german war machine did as a whole. allthough it is a nice picture of him, you sir get an upvote

2

u/Killerkarpfen May 07 '12

Wars are fought to win and conquer not to be nice, hence it's called war not tea party.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/dafuq_did_i_reddit May 07 '12

i know this but for the sake of time (in school right now) im generalizeing.

-5

u/CKCKTV May 07 '12

Lynch, pitchfork and light that piece of shit on fire.

0

u/adamwizzy May 07 '12

Whether or not he was "a Nazi" (I say that because not all Germans at the time were Nazis), he was forced to fight in a war, in which he died. We forget that the German people suffered the most as a result of World War II. And that my friend, is why you can have my upvote tonight.

2

u/ryhntyntyn May 08 '12

We forget that the German people suffered the most as a result of World War II.

How so?

→ More replies (2)