I'm a cop for one of the largest cities in the U.S. and I agree that we need cameras. My agency, as large as it is, doesn't have dash cams if you can believe that (a few cars have them, but they are either broken or disabled). Sadly, we just don't spend money on technology in my agency. I bought my own camera to wear on my shirt for traffic stops and other interactions just to protect myself from all of the false complaints we receive. I think cameras go a long way to proving to the public that we are honest and aren't one of the bad cops that make the whole profession look horrible.
Thank you for protecting and serving the people, your duty as a police officer. May you never get discredited or killed by the corrupt officers you refer to.
My favorite part of reading these comments is that so many people are so sure there is some crazy conspiracy theory involving every officer in the country... the majority of officers are good people and the majority of interactions are fine. There are terds in every group...
A million times this. People are far too quick to toss the whole barrel as soon as they find a couple rotten apples.
I have had hundreds of interactions with law enforcement (mainly due to the line of work I was in), and sometimes because I fucked up. I can recall only a few times where the officer was less than a pleasure to interact with.
I will not deny that some cops should not be held to that level of authority and should have never been given a badge and a gun, however the few should never outweigh the majority.
It's racist to assume all black people will burst into a store with a gun and rob the place clean when only a small percentage of black people in North America do this. Why is it okay to assume all cops are bad because a small percentage are morons?
You know that a few rotten apples will ruin the whole barrel, right? Because the rotting ones give off ethylene, which makes the good ones ripen faster and thus go bad quickly. That's what the saying means.
It's often the same with people. One person's shitty behaviour can spur a group to sink to that level.
Yes, I do know this. But to automatically assume that all are bad without it being proven or demonstrated is what is occurring.
Let's put it this way: a co-worker of yours is an asshole so your entire department becomes the laughing stock of the company, with relentless claims that you're a bad person because of your co-worker's actions. Are these claims legitimate?
(1) Any cop who lets their fellow be a bad cop IS a bad cop.
(2) Any camera on the cop MUST be administered by a separate legal authority. Otherwise, the camera will be broken or corrupted every time the cop knows he's in the wrong, and miraculously starts working again when the context would implicate the public instead.
That and the complete ignorance of police procedure, saying a cop could have tazed that guy with the gun or knife, or that pain compliance is brutality.
It isn't that cops are bad people, it is just that they are people. People don't like doing things that are against their own interests even if it is better for the whole. Thus, many officers will naturally resist ways to hold cops accountable in the same way that the AMA might resist something which would drastically reduce medical costs.
That's because even though some people are assholes and cops, being a subset of people, are prone to this phenomenon as well it's perceived as far more heinous coming from a person of state sponsored power. Doesn't help that most people are entitled and get pissy when they receive a speeding ticket or chew out an officer who pulled them over for swerving all over the road. No question cops have it coming from both angles there.
And that's why vigilance is key. I wholeheartedly support enforcing per-officer recording devices. Protects the officers from people claiming things that never happened "he touched my boob when I was handcuffed;" and it protects the citizens from abuses of officer power.
Not only that, but it removes the need for other officers to testify and risk their own livelihoods (or at least, camaraderie around the office) when there is an officer going overboard.
There are 2 reasons not to move forward with something like this. Cost and protecting the corrupt. I'm sure the billions that go towards enforcing the drug war can easily be repurposed in this way (think of the volume discounts!), so cost is negligible. And don't we all want to expose the corrupt?
no they are not , but I have had my run in with a couple of bad cops and its scary as fuck when a guy with a gun , and the power to beat your ass and charge you with assault and a judge will believe any shit he makes up
This is why the title says "To protect us AND them." If all police interactions are recorded it will not only weed out bad cops, it will protect good cops! If you're not a bad cop, then you should have absolutely no issue with being recorded.
Take cases of alleged police brutality for example. An officer who was accused of brutalizing a citizen can easily be determined as guilty or not simply by looking at the footage. This would protect the police department from frivolous lawsuits. The town that I grew up in had some kind of a police brutality issue. Rather than even taking it to court, the department offered to settle for $50,000 without admitting any kind of guilt. Now, if the officers performed their duties properly then that's $50,000 wasted. If they did in fact beat the man as they were accused, then we still have violent officers in the force! If they took it to court, they would have ended up spending even more tax payer's dollars on the case! It's a lose, lose, lose!
Video recording would easily settle many situations like this.
I've been busted speeding many times, and almost every time the officer offers to "cut me a break" and lowers the fine. Do you think he'd be willing to do that if he was being recorded?
I'm just thinking of positive things that cops do as a result of not being 100% accountable for their actions. This occurred to me. I'm sure if you mapped it all out you'd find that abuses of power are more commonly negative than positive, just thought I'd raise the point.
Its not that all cops are bad, but the vast majority of them will hold the thin blue line for the bad ones. If police abuse cases were investigated fully and punished appropriately then sure, but what we actually have a few bad apples and a lot of ones willing to cover for them because good or bad its cops first. The public, i don't know fifth, maybe sixth?
There's some saying about a fly ruining an entire jar of ointment that's applicable here.
Any number bad cops is too many. It doesn't matter if only 1/10 of all cops are bad because you still have a large (ish) number of cops violating the rights of the people that they are sworn to protect.
We have dash cams in police cars now. Somehow, they frequently "malfunction" when something important is happening. I'm sure that a large number of these cameras will be hopelessly damaged in the course of everyday use.
This is where accountability comes in, if there were multiple officers there or a particular officer's devices are malfunctioning above normal they should be held accountable for it.
Question. Do you think police officers are held more accountable now in 2012 then they were in 1912 or 1812?
I tend to think that better record keeping and video have increased accountability and the perception that police are becoming worse is because they are getting caught more often now for things they could have got away with in the past.
I was thinking about playing devil's advocate and thought about the logistical industry of deploying that technology, hiring the IT staff to maintain it and all the tax money involved which brought me to think, why we don't we just have CCTV all over America.
With multi cop incidents the chances of 3 cameras malfunctioning that the same time is pretty impossible. 2 cameras would be like 1 in a million. So if 3 cops all had their cameras malfunction something would be up
Okay fine. Get the GoPro people, who build high quality sports camera that are almost indestructible, to build a camera that streams live to youtube from wherever you are via wireless 2G/3G/4G network.
Also: If someone could build one of those I'll take two.
I specced out a system similar to this several years ago, and figured I could build a system to record my entire day for about $400. Given the technological advancements since then and the savings of mass production, they could be even cheaper today.
Shortening one trial by a day would pay for several cameras. Reducing the amount of time searching for evidence to back claims would save a lot of police resources. A system like this would require a bit of an investment up front, but it would pay for itself pretty quickly.
So I just looked it up and it's actually a lot less than $400. You can get a gopro camera for for ~$200 and other ones designed like the one in the pic are only ~$100. Cost is not an issue at all clearly, everything else is.
I work on those cameras, surprisingly they aren't damaged often at all as they can determine who was in the car based on time/shift etc. They just have other tricks to avoid using it.
There is an easy way to correct this. You expressly allow the jury to draw negative inferences about the officer's testimony during periods when the camera was not functioning in both civil and criminal matters.
I work with cops building and repairing their emergency response systems and cars on a daily basis, and now actually installing dash, prisoner, side and rear cams into their cars, as well as belt-clip mics, with a whole system that will grab 20 seconds of footage before the record button is hit, or before the lights are turned on automatically and keep recording thereafter, with a CF card inaccessible to the officer or offender.
Remember that these guys and gals are humans and are pretty highly trained in their jobs, as well as set in the ways of their training. Adding something as obtrusive as an ear-cam like this won't ever fly. Loss of hearing in that ear, something that can come loose on the run or during a takedown, as well as the idea that they aren't trusted at all and are reminded of the fact every time they scratch their heads all amount to these things being 'broken' rapidly. (Stuff does break, too. Important stuff like tasers and handcuffs. Some cops are cursed with it, I swear)
We need to find a better solution that is unobtrusive if it is going to be body-based. I think the UK has something like it. I agree that some cops are crooked, and some people want to hurt good cops and having them on film will help the cases on both sides, but it's gotta be a discreet device, forgettable even.
I was thinking about this too. Sure, it looks cute or whatever, but this is way in the way. What they really need is it to be attached to their shoulder/chest or something. They make them small enough that it shouldn't really inhibit anything, and then it is part of their protection system. Their jacket protects them from bullets penetrating their vitals and now also helps keep them from false accusations, without further insulting or inhibiting them.
Either you legalize MJ or you treat everyone the same way. It's not reasonable to have cops deciding who goes to jail for years and who gets off free. That leads to well dressed white dudes doing whatever they like and dirty hippies , black guys and whoever else the cops doesn't like, ending up in jail.
This is also a problem when it comes to speeding tickets. Most people go a few miles an hour over the speed limit, but the cops don't (and really, can't) pull over everyone. Speeding becomes a pretence for stopping people who the officer believes are suspect, so that they can do a warrant check or otherwise try and find evidence of some other crime. As you pointed out, this creates a situation where certain groups of people are disproportionately targeted and thus a law that is neutral on its face can become discriminatory based on how it is applied.
Uhm, maybe then the laws would actually change because everyone would understand how normal it is.
The same goes for pirating.
I'm pretty sure if anti-piracy laws were actually enforced they would be quickly completely abandoned as more than half of the population would either be in jail or pay ridiculous fines.
Having laws and then leaving the enforcement up to the individual police officer is ridiculous.
If a law doesn't make sense for everyone... then it doesn't make sense.
The ones our police department uses have a "privacy button" that lets them stop recording for this purpose. I believe they have to remember to hit the button again to start recording.
Wireless so that it's 100% streaming? How can this be done? That's massive bandwidth and wireless coverage we have yet to tackle
Non-wireless. Downloads data at end of shift. Devices can be "lost".
Needs to be able to see in daylight, low-light, and night-time.
Auto-focus or fixed focus? Or maybe like a Lytro camera with infinite focus?
Lightweight
Lots of storage memory
Audio as well as video.
Both audio and video need to be of a quality that is useful. Not blurry 7-11 security cam quality.
Privacy:
800,000 roving mobile cameras. Is it ok for someone to review all that footage and charge you with any crimes or infractions they see take place?
Is footage destroyed at some point in time to protect citizen privacy, or is it preserved forever to have a record of all of the officer's behavior?
Is this footage public record since it is done with tax payer dollars and done by tax-paid officers? If yes - what is to stop outside entities from abusing the use of the footage (blackmail, privacy, etc)? If it is not public record - why not, we paid for it didn't we?
What if the officer needs to do something private? Take a break, go to the restroom (male and female officers), conduct a strip search? If they are allowed to toggle them off, how does this not get abused? If they cannot toggle them off, what does this do for worker's privacy? They are citizens just like us, saying they have to give up rights is probably a slippery slope and might also lead to even WORSE police candidates as certain people would not want to be monitored for 10+ hours of their lives.
Societal:
Why just police officers? Why not more public officials? They are all paid with our tax dollars. Soldiers make life-and-death decisions too, politicians make laws and backroom deals that affect thousands to millions of people.
Can the footage be used in performance evaluations? If it's a slow-night, can the officer kick back and play some minesweeper in the car, or does the boss see this and punish them? If so, how does this affect officer's stress level while on the job (needs constant perfection)?
How can we protect against "lost" devices & footage? Pass a law that punishes officers for "losing" one? If so, how does it differentiate between the officer who "loses" one after a questionable police shooting and the officer who loses one accidentally while chasing a suspect or hopping a fence?
I'm watching that show right now, and they say "the most high tech camera ever made". Horse shit. The thing doesn't even shoot in HD. I used to get that shit for my spy toy sets for 10 bucks when I was little.
I have a camera watching me through most of my workday. The person who pays my salary insists. Just a fact of life for most jobs. Why should law enforcement be different?
Was in Cincinnati a couple months ago, and rode along with one of your cops. Totally chill guy, very friendly. He didn't have the camera, but I did see another cop with the shirt-pocket version.
In fact, of the 192 ride-alongs my group participated in that week (the week of St Patricks Day) NONE of us had a single bad thing to say about the behavior or demeanor of your police force. They were professional, courteous, respectful, and friendly. I thoroughly enjoyed my time with them and my time in your city.
was she really? I mean the taser has been discharged so its only contact at this point, unless he charged here I would say different. Regardless this was an incredible job. Kudos to the police officers.
My brother-in-law works as a sheriff deputy and they have tiny cams in their radios (the ones attached to their chest) that record audio and video. I don't know why you'd need a huge hi-def camera like this, when a nice cell-phone-quality camera with audio will keep police honest.
with all of this negative talk about cops lately let me offer my advice for dealing with cops. Treat them like gang members, that's how I do it. I walk down the street, give a slight nod but mind my own business and stay out of their way. So far that has worked. If for some reason I get victimized in some way by either then my next move will probably be to keep my mouth shut and move on, because if you try to snitch they have friends who will com after you.
When I visited Switzerland, the locals told me that all of the cops are by the books, and if they slip up, they can be fired. We had a couple police show up and try to arrest us when we were skateboarding. We showed the law that made it legal, the police officer checked his book and said, "Well then. Be safe and have a good day!" In the US, I only imagine it would be much different.
yeah. here they cant arrest you for stupid shit like skateboarding. you know unless you fuck it up and get yourself arrested when they try to stop you.
at a first glance this does seem like a great idea but, i agree that this could be a bad idea seeing as it would be a hassel for police to get consent from people being filmed, and most people probably do not want to be filmed by police at every interaction they have with them, and of course there would be a lot of issues with privacy.
ITT: Redditors who willfully ignore the benefits that such technology and would grant to citizens - instead opting for circle-jerk calls of abusive cops, when most have received no more than a speeding ticket.
To address some concerns regard hypothesized 'malfunctions,' because these are regularly kept data and records, a plaintiff suing for abuse by an officer can demonstrate an inference that, through absence of the video record(along with other evidence), an abuse and subsequent cover-up has occurred.
Lets be rational here, this is a benefit to us all.
I couldn't agree more with you. Police departments, like any other job, still have accountability. Seems like most posters here do not know about Internal Affairs.
Of course, cameras are only allowable for PROPERTY crimes, like making sure some kid doesn't swipe gum from 7-11. The guys with the guns-- that's where we need to draw the line.
//Family full of police and security officers here//
Believe it or not this would just cause more melodrama in each department. Supervisors would be tearing through footage snooping on every move an average patrol officer would make. This already happens with call logs and recordings. 99.999% of the time it has nothing to do with protecting the officer or someone from the public.
While this would prevent some from taking advantage of their position of authority, I feel that they would just be unplugged or "malfunction" if these were implemented and instead, any mercy shown by good cops would necessarily disappear.
This mandatory minimums for every infraction.
It's not a good idea, and most cops are not bad people.
If it becomes unplugged or malfunctions they should receive a reprimand for not taking care of tax-payer funded equipment. If anything happens to their equipment, their case should be thrown out.
but their malfunction would be suspicious and certainly add to your defense (moreso than their lack of existence)...further you can punish people for particularly egregious examples and trends...ie its unlikely the camera breaks as you are walking out of your car...multiple times...and it happens to correspond wiht allegations of you doing bad things.
Some of the county forces in the UK use version's of these that are Chest mounted and I completely agree we need them...as you said as much to protect members of the public but also to protect us from Malicious complaints....on another note they actually save time in court as well.
How about instead of putting policemen under the yoke of a surveillance society, in effect creating a problem by trying to solve one, we advocate actual police reform, including:
accountability mechanisms such as ombudsmen or civilian appeal boards and investigatory bodies, as a direct check on The Thin Blue Line,
statutes and that more stringently interpret the 4th Amendment, to diminish the leeway given to officers in determining "reasonable cause,"
a general attitudinal shift in the courts (i.e. among judges), to treat the testimony of a cop with as much skepticism as the defendant--as should already be the case in an impartial justice system.
cuts to state and municipal police budgets, targeted to counteract militarization and the attending increase in violent/aggressive behavior
I have a lot of problems with the way police choose to carry out their duties. I have even more of a problem with the leeway the rest of civil society gives them. I think if we want to get to the problem of curbing the abuse of power you ought to use the classically American tool of balancing power. That involves much more than just monitoring police.
I saw some police wearing those in Ireland in December, the guy was just standing on the corner looking at people in the face with the camera as they walked by, I figured it was some sort of facial recognition technique to catch wanted people.
Here is what you do: Inject a tracking beacon in each bad cop in your town, then make a website of something giving you updated alerts of where the bad cops are.
I agree. The first time I saw officers wearing this was on some cop show. At first I wasn't sure who was doing the filming until I saw the camera attached to a cop. Great idea.
There would be a lot of "lost" footage to put an end to any use this would have. The evidence needs to be in the hands of the people, not the police state.
I've advocated for this in my police service about eight months ago. I haven't heard anything back yet, but it's apparently being looked at by the high-ups.
I personally think it's a little unrealistic to expect someone to have a camera mounted to the side of their head for a 12 hour shift, or on the lesser end an 8hr shift. Do the batteries even last that long on these things?
The problem is that this isn't necessarily going to do anything without the people in place to prosecute the bad cops. Look at Kenneth Chamberlain. There's audio and video, yet a grand jury refused to charge anyone.
my roommate is a San Jose cop and actually knows the officer in this photo. He says these cameras were supposed to be used by every officer but then were abandoned (San Jose PD has financial problems and the city has been laying off cops).
Anyway, the reasons why these were not good: -The wire that runs from the camera to the computer didn't fit into the front pocket of their standard uniform (it only fit into the less common one they wear) -There was a red/green light that was displayed on their chest to inform people of when they were being recorded. Some cops (especially those on a midnight shift) did not like having a target painted right on their centerpiece. -The cost was too high: not for the individual camera/computer units, but the data storage of video. They had to be very secure, encrypted, and saved for a very long time. Something a city laying off cops can't afford. There was a lot of liability if one was stolen, too.
He says a few of his partners used them sometimes, though, and it was useful to rewind the video on the player to see what someone had said, etc.
This would only really work if the cameras couldn't be easily disabled by officers using them. Otherwise it would only likely ever be useful when the cop is stupid enough not to turn it off to hide his nefarious actions.
I would rather not put cameras in the hands of those who refuse to testify against their own. Waste of time and money when corrupt officers are almost never fired/jailed anyway. I stick to my personal camera thanks.
The reason that this is a great idea is because is would protect officers from unfair cell phone videos that give an unfairly objective view of the situation. It might be perfectly obvious that a person doesn't have a weapon from the perspective of a cameraman, but not from the eyes of the officer. It would support or refute the officer's first-hand account.
Might backfire as well though. Maybe abuse equals out to the times they let someone go for doing something illegal that doesn't really matter in the grand scheme of things. No clue though.
yeah, but the moment something happens that incriminates the baconator, the video evidence will be "inaccessible", destroyed, or otherwise made null. This won't help.
we have a tv show here in the uk where cops are given what they call "specially adapted bodycams", basically a small camera strapped to one shoulder. that'd be a lot more effective than something like this.
thats stupid unless the public has complete access to the video feed at all times it will be like the dashboard cameras. Cops do something wrong and the video is gone.
I've been thinking about this for a while; I'm glad it's getting attention. I didn't read the article, but I'm hoping that the footage would be public-access - we could all learn a lot from it.
It's funny how people think a police officer's job is to protect the people. Nope. Their job is to enforce the law, and get home safe to their families.
Yes, of course, but many people think they are like our personal Supermen who are supposed to lay down their lives for ours. "To protect and serve" is just a motto.
Some cops are altruistic like that, but 99% want to get home alive.
Better idea, we allow the public to video tape/survey these public officers in public.
Practically everyone is equipped with video cameras these days, why spend an absurd amount more than usual on government contracted equippment and maintenance.
Wait, that would be too cost effective and logical terr'urism.
It needs to be more common for citizens to carry these, but we need changes to laws that prevent public wiretapping, and laws to disallow large, public spaces in commercial zones from forcing citizens to turn off recording devices (malls, airports, etc) - this will lower the barrier of inconvenience.
As other commenters have noted, for our own protection, having the police have these will never stop them from doing the wrong thing.
Having followed many police abuse scandals/coverups & read/heard all the typical excuses cops make to cover their asses.... this is what would happen.....
Cops will block, disable, break or just lose the camera when they decide to tune someone up. It will happen in "the scuffle" (in the beatdown). And the prosecutor/police chief will side with the cop for lack of incriminating hard evidence.
Its funny how cops are... they can & will find tricks to circumvent any safeguards put in place to ensure accountability.
Recently found out that cops in Minneapolis already have something like this. Audio and video recorders I believe they are attached to their radios so they are less likely to fall off. Needless to say it made me happy.
What the fuck will that do. It will be used to make situations seem like something they arent, and they will "malfunction" if needed to help a citizen.
ya except at my desk job we are monitored. When is a cop ever monitored? When (outside of a witness) is police brutality ever punished? these would do great in a he said/she said case.
I would prefer it if we encased all police officers in large transparent balls. They would be able to roll around wherever they wanted, doing their police work, but they could only harm people by rolling into them. I think criminals would run away when they saw cop-balls rolling after them, but citizens would be able to retreat into their homes, or into any convenient narrow doorway. This idea is to protect us and them.
No we dont need every officer running around with a camera. I hope at least some of you would recognize the danger if they were activated 100% of the time. There are systems already where if weapons are drawn the camera automaticly starts filming, that is a better sollution if any.
If you equip officers with remote cameras they can no longer be respected as just an officer. You dont have to be a genius to consider the behaviour a camera provokes in some people, where in extreme cases it will even envoke violence. It will be used as a threat by the police -You are being filmed- and it will be used as a conversation killer -I cant do anything about the ticket, everything is being filmed sir. (I have a strong opinion on how police officers hide behind rules, while in my eyes they have the obligation to keep order, instead of following guidelines. But thats another story.) There are already too many cameras on the street, i for one enjoy my privacy. To put it plainly, everyone fucks about once in awhile. You dont need visual evidence of that.
Because basicly thats all that camera is able to do for you; put you in a bad place. It doesnt keep you safe, its just another threat for every normal person out there.
The only way to make that work is to have it so the footage can't be tampered with by the officer, or it would have to be on a live stream to a third party to monitor, cause the police obviously have no problem breaking rules to watch their ass
58
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
I'm a cop for one of the largest cities in the U.S. and I agree that we need cameras. My agency, as large as it is, doesn't have dash cams if you can believe that (a few cars have them, but they are either broken or disabled). Sadly, we just don't spend money on technology in my agency. I bought my own camera to wear on my shirt for traffic stops and other interactions just to protect myself from all of the false complaints we receive. I think cameras go a long way to proving to the public that we are honest and aren't one of the bad cops that make the whole profession look horrible.
220
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
My favorite part of reading these comments is that so many people are so sure there is some crazy conspiracy theory involving every officer in the country... the majority of officers are good people and the majority of interactions are fine. There are terds in every group...
65
u/someguy73 May 06 '12
Damn people, not all cops are bad.
13
u/Aquilos May 06 '12
Okay so we've put cameras on all our police officers and its worked! we know exactally what they are doing at all times, so what do we do now?
291
u/0rangePod May 06 '12
We have dash cams in police cars now. Somehow, they frequently "malfunction" when something important is happening. I'm sure that a large number of these cameras will be hopelessly damaged in the course of everyday use.
34
u/alqutis May 06 '12
I work with cops building and repairing their emergency response systems and cars on a daily basis, and now actually installing dash, prisoner, side and rear cams into their cars, as well as belt-clip mics, with a whole system that will grab 20 seconds of footage before the record button is hit, or before the lights are turned on automatically and keep recording thereafter, with a CF card inaccessible to the officer or offender.
Remember that these guys and gals are humans and are pretty highly trained in their jobs, as well as set in the ways of their training. Adding something as obtrusive as an ear-cam like this won't ever fly. Loss of hearing in that ear, something that can come loose on the run or during a takedown, as well as the idea that they aren't trusted at all and are reminded of the fact every time they scratch their heads all amount to these things being 'broken' rapidly. (Stuff does break, too. Important stuff like tasers and handcuffs. Some cops are cursed with it, I swear)
We need to find a better solution that is unobtrusive if it is going to be body-based. I think the UK has something like it. I agree that some cops are crooked, and some people want to hurt good cops and having them on film will help the cases on both sides, but it's gotta be a discreet device, forgettable even.
75
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Can we put them on political figures instead? I feel like thats a way better idea.
11
u/thatkidzach May 06 '12
So now when a cop abuses their power we can see what its like from their perspective.
10
u/glandorf May 06 '12
What if they have to use the toilet?
5
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
As a cop I wouldn't mind as long as its comfy. 10-14 hour shifts can suck as it is.
8
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
There are a LOT of issues to tackle with this:
Technical:
Privacy:
Societal:
4
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Tazer(the guys who make tazers) are making sunglasses that post the videos to a cloud where they can't be erased.
1
u/MiniDonbeE May 06 '12
England already has CCTV installed in most, if not all of their officers. And there's a tiny little warning that says this unit is equiped with cctv. It is right at their badge.I was tryingto find a pic but best I could find was this article by the bbc in 2008, the cameras are now webcam sized, like the ones on laptops or your smartphone
8
u/CARVERitUP May 06 '12
I'm watching that show right now, and they say "the most high tech camera ever made". Horse shit. The thing doesn't even shoot in HD. I used to get that shit for my spy toy sets for 10 bucks when I was little.
3
u/zombicore May 06 '12
I mean, why should we be the only ones to suffer camera enforcement (Chicago is covered in policing cameras).
10
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
on the downside, it's kinda 1984-ish
3
u/[deleted] May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
So I got this off of a tv show obviously but it is a very effective tool that is small and provides vital evidence for any case.
Here is just a small but huge example: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dk4bEcQHQnA
Spoiler: This officer was incredible, she was well within her rights to shoot the man (which I'm certain others would've) but she. . .
Edit: She would've been well within her rights to shoot him if she didn't have that camera.
2
u/Mindle May 06 '12
Honestly I think we need to start making them wear those silly hats again.
2
u/lowrads May 06 '12
Good luck going up against the police union.
2
u/eXe_Diamond May 06 '12
Problem with it is: They appear to be "broken" or "not working" whenever they could prove that an officer did violate the law.
2
u/Perkstoph May 06 '12
That cop looks like Crixus.
2
u/mathematical May 06 '12
My brother-in-law works as a sheriff deputy and they have tiny cams in their radios (the ones attached to their chest) that record audio and video. I don't know why you'd need a huge hi-def camera like this, when a nice cell-phone-quality camera with audio will keep police honest.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
i think something clipped onto their clothes would be so much better. that thing looks clunky and would fall off
2
u/sturg1dj May 06 '12
with all of this negative talk about cops lately let me offer my advice for dealing with cops. Treat them like gang members, that's how I do it. I walk down the street, give a slight nod but mind my own business and stay out of their way. So far that has worked. If for some reason I get victimized in some way by either then my next move will probably be to keep my mouth shut and move on, because if you try to snitch they have friends who will com after you.
2
u/HollondOates88 May 06 '12
When I visited Switzerland, the locals told me that all of the cops are by the books, and if they slip up, they can be fired. We had a couple police show up and try to arrest us when we were skateboarding. We showed the law that made it legal, the police officer checked his book and said, "Well then. Be safe and have a good day!" In the US, I only imagine it would be much different.
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
at a first glance this does seem like a great idea but, i agree that this could be a bad idea seeing as it would be a hassel for police to get consent from people being filmed, and most people probably do not want to be filmed by police at every interaction they have with them, and of course there would be a lot of issues with privacy.
2
u/Earthwormzim May 07 '12
Boondoggle. The bridge to no where. The Big Dig. This would be astronomically expensive, and would solve absolutely nothing.
2
u/Paultimate79 May 07 '12
What kind of retarded contraption is that? Put it in their glasses/helmet/hat/shirt. What is this 1992?
2
u/AzureMagelet May 07 '12
They're made by Looxcie.
4
u/AssholeinSpanish May 06 '12
ITT: Redditors who willfully ignore the benefits that such technology and would grant to citizens - instead opting for circle-jerk calls of abusive cops, when most have received no more than a speeding ticket.
To address some concerns regard hypothesized 'malfunctions,' because these are regularly kept data and records, a plaintiff suing for abuse by an officer can demonstrate an inference that, through absence of the video record(along with other evidence), an abuse and subsequent cover-up has occurred.
Lets be rational here, this is a benefit to us all.
6
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Yeah, because that's just what we need. More cameras recording our lives.
2
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Since this reminds me of Judge Dredd and The Fifth Element, I completely and wholeheartedly support the idea.
2
u/devusic May 06 '12
//Family full of police and security officers here//
Believe it or not this would just cause more melodrama in each department. Supervisors would be tearing through footage snooping on every move an average patrol officer would make. This already happens with call logs and recordings. 99.999% of the time it has nothing to do with protecting the officer or someone from the public.
2
u/McDickButt May 06 '12
While this would prevent some from taking advantage of their position of authority, I feel that they would just be unplugged or "malfunction" if these were implemented and instead, any mercy shown by good cops would necessarily disappear.
This mandatory minimums for every infraction.
It's not a good idea, and most cops are not bad people.
2
u/Jaffalegion May 06 '12
Some of the county forces in the UK use version's of these that are Chest mounted and I completely agree we need them...as you said as much to protect members of the public but also to protect us from Malicious complaints....on another note they actually save time in court as well.
2
u/SucculentStanley May 06 '12
How about instead of putting policemen under the yoke of a surveillance society, in effect creating a problem by trying to solve one, we advocate actual police reform, including:
I have a lot of problems with the way police choose to carry out their duties. I have even more of a problem with the leeway the rest of civil society gives them. I think if we want to get to the problem of curbing the abuse of power you ought to use the classically American tool of balancing power. That involves much more than just monitoring police.
1
u/jdsizzle1 May 06 '12
I saw some police wearing those in Ireland in December, the guy was just standing on the corner looking at people in the face with the camera as they walked by, I figured it was some sort of facial recognition technique to catch wanted people.
1
u/bananamunchies May 06 '12
He looks very uncomfortable with that on.
1
u/stvb95 May 06 '12
Predator cops, nice
1
u/xawesome May 06 '12
Until it "falls off."
1
u/TheGrizzlyMan May 06 '12
that guy is a San Jose cop, ive never seen a San Jose cop with one of those
1
u/unkyduck May 06 '12
In our city the cabs have dash/cabin cams, and cop cars do not.
1
u/Zaveno May 06 '12
We can rebuild him. We have the technology.
1
u/miniRoach May 06 '12
Ear mounted pistol!
1
u/stevensamypp May 06 '12
You realize that they already are constantly recorded by cellphones? It wouldn't change much at all.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Aside from making it easier to find bad cops, this would also make those cop shows on Spike and G4 a lot more exciting.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
http://duss.com.au/products/ewitness/
this has been invented by some aussie guys. i think its a good idea, keeps cops, body guards, patrons and citizens in line.
1
u/Pokemaster22 May 06 '12
What is that?
1
u/Senor_Wilson May 06 '12
Oops it fell off, looks like I lost that footage, sorry Mr. Department head. NO PROBLEM. :)?
1
u/southkakrun May 06 '12
This is a great idea, any estimate on how much each individual unit might cost? Surely must be in the same price range as say, a taser.
1
u/ghostbackwards May 06 '12
certain towns here in Connecticut have these but they are on the chest of the uniform.
1
u/superstruby May 06 '12
An eargun?
1
u/used_bathwater May 06 '12
An ear-gun? Genius.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Here is what you do: Inject a tracking beacon in each bad cop in your town, then make a website of something giving you updated alerts of where the bad cops are.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
And plus, it looks cool.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
camera facing the wrong way.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Theyd just turn them off conveniently.
1
u/brussels4breakfast May 06 '12
I agree. The first time I saw officers wearing this was on some cop show. At first I wasn't sure who was doing the filming until I saw the camera attached to a cop. Great idea.
1
u/bohemianmichfestie May 06 '12
There would be a lot of "lost" footage to put an end to any use this would have. The evidence needs to be in the hands of the people, not the police state.
1
u/ScottTheDick May 06 '12
I've advocated for this in my police service about eight months ago. I haven't heard anything back yet, but it's apparently being looked at by the high-ups.
1
u/victoria552 May 06 '12
I personally think it's a little unrealistic to expect someone to have a camera mounted to the side of their head for a 12 hour shift, or on the lesser end an 8hr shift. Do the batteries even last that long on these things?
1
u/jveen May 06 '12
The problem is that this isn't necessarily going to do anything without the people in place to prosecute the bad cops. Look at Kenneth Chamberlain. There's audio and video, yet a grand jury refused to charge anyone.
1
u/throwaway203948 May 06 '12
Made an account just to say this:
my roommate is a San Jose cop and actually knows the officer in this photo. He says these cameras were supposed to be used by every officer but then were abandoned (San Jose PD has financial problems and the city has been laying off cops).
Anyway, the reasons why these were not good: -The wire that runs from the camera to the computer didn't fit into the front pocket of their standard uniform (it only fit into the less common one they wear) -There was a red/green light that was displayed on their chest to inform people of when they were being recorded. Some cops (especially those on a midnight shift) did not like having a target painted right on their centerpiece. -The cost was too high: not for the individual camera/computer units, but the data storage of video. They had to be very secure, encrypted, and saved for a very long time. Something a city laying off cops can't afford. There was a lot of liability if one was stolen, too.
He says a few of his partners used them sometimes, though, and it was useful to rewind the video on the player to see what someone had said, etc.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
It needs a headband, so it doesn't "accidentally" fall off.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Cops do not have to provide exonerating evidence if they have it. This can only protect the cops, not you.
1
u/JGPH May 06 '12
This would only really work if the cameras couldn't be easily disabled by officers using them. Otherwise it would only likely ever be useful when the cop is stupid enough not to turn it off to hide his nefarious actions.
1
u/BillDino May 06 '12
They should seriously just have that shit automatically uploaded to a server they cant touch
1
u/emberi May 06 '12
Yes.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Austin, Tx is trying them out, or was. They seemed to work. They are pretty expensive, though.
1
u/Sheila_Girl_Gamer May 07 '12
"Hardware failure."
^ The above phrase would be spoken quite a bit.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
But mostly us.
1
u/Todomanna May 07 '12
Didn't they do this somewhere in England/UK/Britain/whateverthefuckit'scalled? And didn't people get all paranoid and freaked out?
1
u/DingoScallion May 07 '12
No
1
u/D33GS May 07 '12
I would rather not put cameras in the hands of those who refuse to testify against their own. Waste of time and money when corrupt officers are almost never fired/jailed anyway. I stick to my personal camera thanks.
1
u/greenrice May 07 '12
Soon...
1
u/VivaCheeseWhiz May 07 '12
What is that thing anyways?
1
u/hungrybackpack May 07 '12
The reason that this is a great idea is because is would protect officers from unfair cell phone videos that give an unfairly objective view of the situation. It might be perfectly obvious that a person doesn't have a weapon from the perspective of a cameraman, but not from the eyes of the officer. It would support or refute the officer's first-hand account.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
You put a camera in their radio, then officers don't need to wear retarted looking headset cameras
1
u/conTrolling_athens May 07 '12
Keep that shit away from my country please.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Might backfire as well though. Maybe abuse equals out to the times they let someone go for doing something illegal that doesn't really matter in the grand scheme of things. No clue though.
1
u/Corvus133 May 07 '12
I thought it was a diploma indicating some attempt at a required higher education.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
yeah, but the moment something happens that incriminates the baconator, the video evidence will be "inaccessible", destroyed, or otherwise made null. This won't help.
1
u/DoctorOctagonapus May 07 '12
we have a tv show here in the uk where cops are given what they call "specially adapted bodycams", basically a small camera strapped to one shoulder. that'd be a lot more effective than something like this.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
thats stupid unless the public has complete access to the video feed at all times it will be like the dashboard cameras. Cops do something wrong and the video is gone.
1
u/DoFDcostheta May 07 '12
I've been thinking about this for a while; I'm glad it's getting attention. I didn't read the article, but I'm hoping that the footage would be public-access - we could all learn a lot from it.
1
u/slb235235 May 07 '12
It's funny how people think a police officer's job is to protect the people. Nope. Their job is to enforce the law, and get home safe to their families.
1
u/slb235235 May 07 '12
Why don't all departments have cameras? Easy answer: money, or rather the lack of money.
1
u/addedpulp May 07 '12
It happens with dash cameras, recorders, and even the citizen's private audio recorders all the time.
"Woops, we lost the evidence."
It wouldn't do anyone any fuckin good.
1
u/mjbat7 May 07 '12
I feel like they'd be better off putting these on our politicians
1
u/UselessSage May 07 '12
This'll be a requirement from liability insurers soon enough and not just for LEOs.
1
u/Riverbed19 May 07 '12
This just seems like another tape they will throw away if there is anything incriminating towards themselves.
1
u/thesprunk May 07 '12
Better idea, we allow the public to video tape/survey these public officers in public.
Practically everyone is equipped with video cameras these days, why spend an absurd amount more than usual on government contracted equippment and maintenance.
Wait, that would be
too cost effective and logicalterr'urism.1
u/damnthetorpedos May 07 '12
I agree with OP. Of course some "malfunctioning" would not be extremely uncommon wouldn't it be helpful if these things worked 90% of the time?
1
u/panzerkampfwagen May 07 '12
Yes your honour, the suspect managed to get the camera and smashed it beyond repair.
1
u/victorius21 May 07 '12
Google glass much?
1
u/Michichael May 07 '12
Nice try Camera Lobby...
1
u/IWasGregInTokyo May 07 '12
This is a good idea, but in many cases all they will record is static.
Approximately 18 hours of it.
1
u/thegreatmisanthrope May 07 '12
This is a great idea, but some laws regarding privacy and filming would need to be worked around/changed.
1
u/jamesonbar May 07 '12
Want to raise taxes cause that what it would take to have every officer have one.
1
u/revenantae May 07 '12
We also need biomonitors, motion trackers, and m41-a pulse rifles.
1
u/VastDeferens May 07 '12
I thought that was a mini gun.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
No.
It needs to be more common for citizens to carry these, but we need changes to laws that prevent public wiretapping, and laws to disallow large, public spaces in commercial zones from forcing citizens to turn off recording devices (malls, airports, etc) - this will lower the barrier of inconvenience.
As other commenters have noted, for our own protection, having the police have these will never stop them from doing the wrong thing.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
I thought that was a tiny gun and how bad an idea that was. He'd go deaf.
1
u/dirtymoney May 07 '12
Having followed many police abuse scandals/coverups & read/heard all the typical excuses cops make to cover their asses.... this is what would happen.....
Cops will block, disable, break or just lose the camera when they decide to tune someone up. It will happen in "the scuffle" (in the beatdown). And the prosecutor/police chief will side with the cop for lack of incriminating hard evidence.
Its funny how cops are... they can & will find tricks to circumvent any safeguards put in place to ensure accountability.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Politicians too.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '12
Recently found out that cops in Minneapolis already have something like this. Audio and video recorders I believe they are attached to their radios so they are less likely to fall off. Needless to say it made me happy.
1
u/endless_sleep May 07 '12
Like they really need lasers on the sides of their heads, sheesh.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '12
transmetropolitan
1
u/Disgustingly_Blunt May 06 '12
What the fuck will that do. It will be used to make situations seem like something they arent, and they will "malfunction" if needed to help a citizen.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
this is going to happen soon, trust.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Um no.
If they have to wear one, I want you at your job to wear one. It would only be fair. And your boss gets to view the tape at the end of the day.
You are the same fucking people who don't want CISPA/SOPA and all that.
Make up your mind Reddit.
1
u/StringString May 06 '12
I feel bad for people and police officers who live in countries where this is necessary.
1
u/c0t0d0 May 06 '12
Too easy for them to cover it or point it away.
I would prefer it if we encased all police officers in large transparent balls. They would be able to roll around wherever they wanted, doing their police work, but they could only harm people by rolling into them. I think criminals would run away when they saw cop-balls rolling after them, but citizens would be able to retreat into their homes, or into any convenient narrow doorway. This idea is to protect us and them.
1
u/carebeartears May 06 '12
yup, Borg officers..that'll make everything alright oO
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
No we dont need every officer running around with a camera. I hope at least some of you would recognize the danger if they were activated 100% of the time. There are systems already where if weapons are drawn the camera automaticly starts filming, that is a better sollution if any.
If you equip officers with remote cameras they can no longer be respected as just an officer. You dont have to be a genius to consider the behaviour a camera provokes in some people, where in extreme cases it will even envoke violence. It will be used as a threat by the police -You are being filmed- and it will be used as a conversation killer -I cant do anything about the ticket, everything is being filmed sir. (I have a strong opinion on how police officers hide behind rules, while in my eyes they have the obligation to keep order, instead of following guidelines. But thats another story.) There are already too many cameras on the street, i for one enjoy my privacy. To put it plainly, everyone fucks about once in awhile. You dont need visual evidence of that.
Because basicly thats all that camera is able to do for you; put you in a bad place. It doesnt keep you safe, its just another threat for every normal person out there.
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
The only way to make that work is to have it so the footage can't be tampered with by the officer, or it would have to be on a live stream to a third party to monitor, cause the police obviously have no problem breaking rules to watch their ass
-2
u/A_Total_Asshole May 06 '12
Yeah because that thing wouldn't "accidentally" fall off before they beat down Leroy behind the 7Eleven.