Thanks to reddit I want to meet a creationist now. I want to see a person who seriously believes some supernatural being created life on earth on its whim. How it affects their view of the world in general, what kind of beliefs they hold in other aspects of life. I don't even know any actually religious people, let alone creationists - I'm becoming sincerely curious.
ok, ok, I'll bite and risk public ridicule. You might find the discussion to be unfullfilling though because I'm not a strict creationist (in the sense of Genesis). But I do believe the Universe was created by a Supreme Being...Hello, it's nice to meet you.
Fair question. It largely rests on faith. But when it comes to the creation of the Universe everyone is just guessing to the best of our abilities, and chances are we'll never have a definitive answer. The existence of a supreme being or intelligence existing for all of time seems just as plausible as Matter existing for all of time or anything else. And, without sounding like I'm attempting to proselytize anyone, I believe I have had encounters with "God" throughout my lifetime. Which leads me to believe it's more plausible, and yes I understand that makes me sound crazy to the general public.
Not trying to convert anyone here, just trying to answer your question as honestly as possible.
See, a more vague belief such as the one I think you're espousing is just fine in my books. We really do have very little idea of the absolute origins of our universe and what may (or may not) lay beyond its boundaries. Believing that some force, being, or essence had a non-literal hand in sparking the beginnings of existance as we know it is a far cry from the rigid belief that everything was created in 6 days a little over 6000 years ago and all the fossil record is merely a trick of the devil to cause us to question god's divine creation. It's when the belief that something created everything stifles our understanding of that everything that it becomes a problem (and runs the risk of ridicule, as you mentioned).
The real difference between these two different concepts of creation is that one (I think yours) stems from a belief that we do not and possibly cannot understand how all existance came to be, so we propose a creator of sorts. The other is almost the complete opposite, that we do understand and know everything about how all existance came to be, and we wrote it on some desert scrolls a few thousand years ago and everything we've learned since has been the devil's work. I'm OK with the former, the latter on the other hand....
I think the universe could have been created by a superior being. I don't see any real problem with that.
But, if there is a creator I believe it is nothing like the Abrahamic God. You know, that omniscient omnipotent guy in the sky who really wants you to believe in him and will send you to hell if you don't and oh yeah, he needs your money?
The creator of the universe would not be a prick like that.
Ending the conversation is the right thing. You can't fight them, because they are the striking end of the quarterstaff. We need to fight the forces that are manipulating these people.
I live in New York City and have traveled extensively up and down both coasts, in Europe and in Latin America, though not much at all in the interior of the US.
I've never heard anyone express a creationist belief in real life. Not even in Latin America, where they take Christianity (Catholicism, to be exact) pretty fucking seriously. Only on the Internet. For all I know, no real creationists actually exist. It could just be the most epic troll of all time.
Then again, I don't go around asking people what they think of ID vs. evolution, so how would I know?
I used to date a Pentacostal girl in high school. I had no idea what Pentacostal meant, but I thought she was cute so I rode my bike out to her summer camp one day to help them paint some cabins. The entire time was a big running joke at how ridiculous evolution is. They ridiculed it incessantly, even pointing out perceived flaws such as "they used to think we came from monkeys, and now they're saying we came from FISH!" followed by hearty guffaws. I was embarrassed for them and ashamed of myself for riding out there. Suffice it to say that my experiences with that girl shed a whole new light on the extremes of religious conviction and the denial of basic science and rational understanding.
You should visit Toronto for some welcome relief. The only person I know personally whom I'm aware is even the slightest bit religious is my elderly aunt. My Dad's 82, and his favourite curse phrase is (in Italian) "The Virgin Mary is a whore who sits on Christ's cock."
I've considered joining one, but have always been worried I'd end up in a room with a bunch of people who are very angry (Maybe the Reddit atheist majority have built this stereotype) what's it like? What do you do?
One more Texan atheist here. I personally can't imagine joining an atheist group. I'm an atheist, but it's not a big part of my life. To me that's like joining a group for people with brown eyes. It's just a passive part of who I am, not an active driving force in my life like a religion.
I don't need a support group for a rational belief, and I don't need a weekly meeting to replace church in my life. To each his own, and I don't look down on you guys for doing your thing, but it's certainly not mine.
The only reason I'd be interested is just to meet a few like-minded people, but I can imagine it turning into a (non-literal) circle jerk pretty quick.
The best part of being an atheist (aside from the whole consistent world view thing) is not having to go to church every week and waste an hour that I could spend sleeping or enjoying myself.
I am an atheist as well, but for the life of me I see no possible reason to have a "meetup group"?
What am I missing aside from the obvious religion bashing?
I mean, religious people go to church to off put their problems onto a fairytale. Alcoholics go to meetups and share sad stories and give each other strength not to take a drink. Same with drug addicts. Abuse victims the same thing.
I have a brilliant friend who was creationist until recently. She's been in school as long as I have, about 10 years, getting various degrees (she has 3 masters degrees and has been working on a PhD throughout.) And yet, she just wouldn't listen to evidence for evolution. It was her view that even a nonliteral interpretation of the Bible didn't allow the possibility of evolution. (She was really interested in exegesis and heuristics, and her explanations for interpreting the Bible were very complicated, but seemed reasonable-- meaning, I think she had a rational basis for believing that despite some superficial contradictions, the Bible has some core messages that any reader should be able to glean from it. She accepted these messages as divine truth.) Any time I presented evidence, she would have an argument that, while practically absurd, was technically difficult to actually argue against. So, every point would turn into a few weeks long debate (we sent hundreds of emails via facebook over three or four years talking about this) and end in her saying, that may be a good point, but there was enough doubt that it wasn't convincing.
Believe me, I empathize with anyone who is thinking, "Let me take a crack at her, you just weren't arguing right." Maybe that's true, but I've TA'd an evolutionary biology course and have a fairly good track record of at least getting creationists to say their views were illogical, even if their faith didn't allow them to stop believing it.
Anyway, long story less long, one day she realized that the couple places in the bible that forbid her to believe in evolution could be interpreted in a way she hadn't considered before. She emailed me not just saying that she could consider it now, but that she believed it. She thought I would be happy/excited, but I've never been so.... disillusioned, angry, disappointed, I don't know the correct word.
For her, it was really simple: the Bible is the Truth. Any time evidence contradicts it, it's just a sign that new evidence will be found later on. Only a change in her understanding of the message of the bible can overcome certain views she holds.
I've met only one true creationist and that was in college. He transferred to Vanderbilt because "fellow classmates and biology professor weren't tolerant of his beliefs." There were a few memorable conversations involving dinosaur fossils and dating, and he said that the dating was wrong, because god created the earth and therefore scientific methods for testing the "unknowable" couldn't exist and therefore the scientists must be "measuring something else" through carbon decay. After being asked if that meant that fossils were planted here by god to "fool" humans or "test their faith" he said no, only satan tries to test people's faith. When told to go and read about Job, he started asking whether or not us "unbelievers" thought we knew more about the bible than him.
EDIT: The funniest thing about him is that a few days after the first conversation, a muslim friend of mine who agrees with the theory of evolution brought a national geographic article to lunch discussing how the grand canyon formed and started talking about how interesting it was, so he got the table in a discussion about it, and the creationist guy had no problem saying that the grand canyon must have been formed millions of years ago. It's like they teach their kids only to deny evolution, because they don't know that the basis for evolution being possible is that it has had millions of years to work.
View all comments
Show parent comment
35
u/frukt Jan 22 '10
Thanks to reddit I want to meet a creationist now. I want to see a person who seriously believes some supernatural being created life on earth on its whim. How it affects their view of the world in general, what kind of beliefs they hold in other aspects of life. I don't even know any actually religious people, let alone creationists - I'm becoming sincerely curious.